Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
MistressIggi · 28/01/2024 17:27

And no need to be so rude Zonder to other posters

MistressIggi · 28/01/2024 17:26

Someone with a maths degree from 30 years ago wouldn't be teaching my children without doing the teacher training course, and that would involve time and content that would refresh their skills. Also, presumably, they would actually want to teach that subject. We're not talking here about people with a burning desire to teach some other subject, it's teachers with a space on their timetable being given it.

Zonder · 28/01/2024 17:24

Actually @mumsneedwine I'm quite happy for you not to teach my children.

mumsneedwine · 28/01/2024 17:06

@Zonder when do you suggest I refresh my nearly 40 year old maths skills ? Before or after teaching/planning/marking etc for 60 hours a week ? I already teach Chemistry and GCSE maths. A level maths needs teaching by people who can easily do any problem and explain why. Same as A level chemistry.
Anyone with my A level fancy teaching it ? Because most schools will welcome you with open arms.

Zonder · 28/01/2024 16:57

MistressIggi · 28/01/2024 13:47

I have a maths A level and good teaching skills.
I got the A level over 30 years ago and teach a literacy based subject. Still think I'd do a good job teaching your dc maths?

If you refreshed your knowledge. You clearly had the knowledge and skills once. Would you be happy with someone who got a maths degree 30 years ago and did nothing with it since if they were teaching your children?

mumsneedwine · 28/01/2024 14:18

I got my A in A level maths in 1985. It's not exactly fresh in my memory 😂.

MistressIggi · 28/01/2024 13:47

Zonder · 28/01/2024 10:54

I have A level maths but couldn't explain most of it!

Which goes to show how important the skills of a good teacher are. I'd be shocked if anyone with Maths A level and good teaching skills couldn't teach / explain GCSE level work.

I have a maths A level and good teaching skills.
I got the A level over 30 years ago and teach a literacy based subject. Still think I'd do a good job teaching your dc maths?

mumsneedwine · 28/01/2024 10:58

@Zonder I can do GCSE maths (I have to as we don't have enough maths teachers). But A level is a whole different ball game. All A levels are. I teach A level chemistry but would struggle to do Physics.

Still couldn't teach year 7 Spanish. Unless they want to know how to order a glass of wine

Zonder · 28/01/2024 10:54

I have A level maths but couldn't explain most of it!

Which goes to show how important the skills of a good teacher are. I'd be shocked if anyone with Maths A level and good teaching skills couldn't teach / explain GCSE level work.

mumsneedwine · 28/01/2024 08:47

😂😂 off you go then. Because my PowerPoint on s,p,d levels is quite basic. Lots of drawing required by me (or you, if you're teaching it).

I have A level maths but couldn't explain most of it ! And as for any MFL 🤓.

WearyAuldWumman · 28/01/2024 00:25

noblegiraffe · 27/01/2024 22:09

I can honestly say (no hyperbole here) that I'd be confident walking into any secondary classroom, at any level or subject, and as long as the lesson had been left for me by the teacher, I would have no problem delivering it and dealing with all the very many nuances of teaching.

What? You think you could deliver my A-level further maths lessons because I left you a Dr Frost PowerPoint?

The first thing that came to my mind was Russian - at any level.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 27/01/2024 22:29

noblegiraffe · 27/01/2024 22:09

I can honestly say (no hyperbole here) that I'd be confident walking into any secondary classroom, at any level or subject, and as long as the lesson had been left for me by the teacher, I would have no problem delivering it and dealing with all the very many nuances of teaching.

What? You think you could deliver my A-level further maths lessons because I left you a Dr Frost PowerPoint?

I used to teach textiles.A level included incredibly complex structural items. Complex science about how fibres performed in specific ways, and really detailed production lessons were always good for a laugh. Loads of technical language that’s never heard on a day to day basis.

Could you teach that? Making sure the finish on everything was perfect?

0rangeCrush · 27/01/2024 22:26

noblegiraffe · 27/01/2024 22:09

I can honestly say (no hyperbole here) that I'd be confident walking into any secondary classroom, at any level or subject, and as long as the lesson had been left for me by the teacher, I would have no problem delivering it and dealing with all the very many nuances of teaching.

What? You think you could deliver my A-level further maths lessons because I left you a Dr Frost PowerPoint?

And then be able to get the pupils go and complete air quality sampling, conduct a river study, complete a ricepot, run stats tests, and write a report of their findings.

All from a PowerPoint which you have what … maybe an hour to read over?

Sure Jan GIF
noblegiraffe · 27/01/2024 22:09

I can honestly say (no hyperbole here) that I'd be confident walking into any secondary classroom, at any level or subject, and as long as the lesson had been left for me by the teacher, I would have no problem delivering it and dealing with all the very many nuances of teaching.

What? You think you could deliver my A-level further maths lessons because I left you a Dr Frost PowerPoint?

GinJeanie · 27/01/2024 08:34

Apologies if this has been mentioned before but there's a Facebook group called Exit the Classroom and Thrive which started about two years ago and currently has 151k members. Not all of these people are still teachers but it's still a staggering number. The group has caught the attention of the DfE and some media outlets. If you really want an insight into why your DC's school has a shortage of teachers, I'd join and have a read.
Parents should be furious at the impact this current Government has had the state of schools and the teaching profession.

Also, watch the recent Panorama episode on the condition of school buildings- it's really sobering. I don't think the schools featured are exceptional as our school was built in the 1950s and is in a state. We're often cold in the winter and water regularly gets in.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001vnjc/panorama-britains-crumbling-schools

Your children are being failed and you should be up in arms.

Panorama - Britain's Crumbling Schools

An investigation into the poor state of some of Britain’s school buildings.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001vnjc/panorama-britains-crumbling-schools

fishonabicycle · 27/01/2024 07:56

My daughter studied biomedical science at university, and teaches chemistry and biology at a secondary school. So a related subject, but not a degree in what she actually teaches. I should think that any teacher can cover a year 8 subject as long as the have access to the course work. But obviously not ideal.

OldBeyondMyYears · 27/01/2024 07:53

C1N1C · 23/01/2024 13:15

I'm curious what people would prefer now that you've raised it...

Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?

The reason I ask is because I've considered teaching in the past (PhD), but I would hate to go through further training. Given the teaching shortage, what are the mum's views?

A teacher - hands down!! I am a primary teacher (I did the old 4 year BEd in 1990!) I can honestly say (no hyperbole here) that I'd be confident walking into any secondary classroom, at any level or subject, and as long as the lesson had been left for me by the teacher, I would have no problem delivering it and dealing with all the very many nuances of teaching.

I have taught all primary ages from nursery to Year 6, so not a secondary subject specialist, but I'm 30 years in the job, a deputy head and have seen more changes in education than I can shake a stick at. Teaching is bloody hard work - and yes, there's a recruitment crisis and we are crying out for keen and talented new colleagues, but without the relevant skill set to actually understand the 'how' you'd be crucified on day one. If you really want to do it, make an appointment with your local high school and ask if you can have a look around. Or better still...stand outside the local comp at home time and just watch them as they leave/get on the busses! 😨 Then, if you're still keen, get yourself on Train To Be A Teacher and go from there 👍

Not trying to put you off...but you need to understand the reality of the job.

https://getintoteaching.education.gov.uk/mailinglist/signup/name?gadsource=1&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIqd2Y4Ir9gwMVeZNQBh1fWwRpEAAYASAAEgKLRvDD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

OldBeyondMyYears · 27/01/2024 07:28

My friend teaches geography in a very well known private school in London. She hasn't even for a degree! She started working there 4 years ago as a TA and then the geography teacher left a year later. She was asked to cover the classes whilst they were recruiting - they never did recruit and she's still 'covering' the classes permanently 🤷‍♀️

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 22:43

Ilovecleaning · 26/01/2024 21:57

A bit patronising…

Do tell.

Ilovecleaning · 26/01/2024 21:57

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/01/2024 18:43

Yep, I’m only passionate about the subject I did a degree in.

That’s a shame.

A bit patronising…

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 21:41

MistressIggi · 26/01/2024 21:28

I completely agree with you @0rangeCrush about passion for the subject. Haven't you found though in your own subject a move toward people being asked to teach other things, certainly at BGE level? Say a combined course in your department? I see that in my dc's schools.

Yes!

I have spoken up against it many times. I have flat-out told them I’ll quit if they move to single teacher delivery. Not doing it.

twistyizzy · 26/01/2024 21:33

@0rangeCrush agreed. I want DD to be taught by subject specialists who have a real passion for their subjects, not someone who reads through the slides the day before a lesson. I'm not knocking teachers, I firmly blame the government. Don't our kids deserve to be taught by people who love the subjects they are teaching and who can engage and enthuse their pupils?

MistressIggi · 26/01/2024 21:28

I completely agree with you @0rangeCrush about passion for the subject. Haven't you found though in your own subject a move toward people being asked to teach other things, certainly at BGE level? Say a combined course in your department? I see that in my dc's schools.

0rangeCrush · 26/01/2024 21:18

Zonder · 26/01/2024 20:54

You need a degree to show that you're educated to a certain level. It is also needed for teaching A level in a subject so that again you have studied further than your students in the subject.

So you studied subjects you weren't passionate about. What if someone has a degree in a subject but isn't passionate about it - they just did it to get a qualification? Does that mean they shouldn't teach it either?

Here in Scotland you apply for a PGDE in a specific subject - so I would have only been able to apply to do a PGDE in Geography. I can’t just do a PGDE and then decide on my subject later, if that makes sense. I also can’t side-step into a different subject I am not qualified to teach without doing a whole year of training in that subject (IE achieve NQT again in my second subject) - and I can only do that in a subject that I have enough university credits in. If I wanted to teach; say chemistry; I’d need to look at my academic transcript; see how many relevant credits I had; and then top them up.

In Scotland; you would not pass interview if you couldn’t demonstrate a passion for the subject you intend to teach. Now obviously it isn’t perfect as people can fake it; but all the teachers I spend time with do genuinely love the subject they teach. None of them ended up there by circumstance.

It’s such an alien concept to me tbh; and I do think it’s part of the reason that England is having such a retention crisis. I wouldn’t be happy if I was shoehorned into teaching maths, computing or music.

Mstxxx · 26/01/2024 21:15

Hmm... I don't know the rules around teaching but I would value experience over qualifications personally. Both are good but I would rather be taught something by someone who had years of experience teaching the subject and no degree, than someone with a degree and no experience.

I work in a law firm, I don't have a law degree or even a degree at all, and I manage and train a team of paralegals to do their job who are nearly qualified solicitors and barristers. It's mental and a lot of people don't like it but it happens

But in your case I wouldn't feel entirely happy to be honest if the teacher is saying what they're saying as they don't sound entirely comfortable teaching it!