Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Bluevelvetsofa · 23/01/2024 13:27

The most ineffective teacher I ever worked with was the most highly qualified. He had a PhD and clearly was proficient in his subject, but simply couldn’t teach it. I’d prefer someone who has the ability to manage a classroom, follow the lesson plan and develop a positive relationship with the students.

Ace56 · 23/01/2024 13:24

C1N1C · 23/01/2024 13:15

I'm curious what people would prefer now that you've raised it...

Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?

The reason I ask is because I've considered teaching in the past (PhD), but I would hate to go through further training. Given the teaching shortage, what are the mum's views?

Someone with zero teaching qualifications or experience will probably not be able to teach, no matter how much knowledge they have. You need to know how to pitch things in the right way, how to adapt to different levels of children, how to keep their attention and most importantly these days, behaviour management!!

If you’ve had no experience in a classroom your behaviour management will be awful. This is a BIG part of teacher training which you learn in stages and through observation of other teachers. I’m an ex teacher btw.

Sleepthief · 23/01/2024 13:24

I'd rather have a qualified, permanent music teacher teaching Humanities to my child, if that is their timetabled teacher for the year, presumably with departmental/head of department support and schemes of work, than a series of supply or cover teachers who could be different every day🤷‍♀️

fedupandstuck · 23/01/2024 13:24

There's no requirement other than in a directly maintained school for teachers to have QTS. Subject wise, theoretically a teacher can be asked to teach any subject, if there is a shortage of specialists. An academy or a private school can hire anyone at all.

I would think they've been unable to hire a specialist and are making do with whatever staff have the timetabled capacity to teach those lessons.

There is little point complaining to the school as they will be well aware of the staffing issues. Write to your MP about education, befriend any out of work geography teachers you come across and big up the school to them?? Not sure what else you can do.

JudgeJ · 23/01/2024 13:23

In my long teaching career, started in 1970, I have taught the majority of subjects except Music and Drama, other than when covering for an absent colleague. My subject is Maths, to A level, but at various times I was timetabled for all kinds of things to fill gaps in the timetable, I recall keeping a couple of pages ahead of the class when teaching Technical Drawing in my first job. It's not new to have to use teachers from other subjects though I do understand it's worse now. I got a really good report from an HMI when doing a spell in a Reception class for our Mathematics display, the Head was delighted.

ProfessorPeppy · 23/01/2024 13:22

I teach a small amount of KS3 French, because I have a ‘A’ at French A-level. My degree is in music (Oxford) and I have a masters in psychology.

The alternative is a supply teacher fluent in the target language who struggles to maintain order and whose classes are chaotic and dangerous.

Sometimes schools have to make choices based on who can actually teach.

Comefromaway · 23/01/2024 13:21

I can't really comment on Geography but most people with music degrees have had to study a fair amount of history as part of their degree.

IgnoranceNotOk · 23/01/2024 13:21

I hope you backed the teachers when they were on strike OP.

At the rate teachers are leaving you’ll be lucky to have an English or Maths specialist teaching them the core subjects.

It’s in a very sorry state and who knows how many years it’ll take to solve it.
Geography is probably the least of the school’s worries sadly.

Previousreligion · 23/01/2024 13:21

C1N1C · 23/01/2024 13:15

I'm curious what people would prefer now that you've raised it...

Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?

The reason I ask is because I've considered teaching in the past (PhD), but I would hate to go through further training. Given the teaching shortage, what are the mum's views?

Personally the latter but it's a generalisation. The highest qualified teachers I had in terms of PhDs etc were definitely not always the best teachers (in fact were often poor as they struggled to explain things simply and understand why the pupils didn't understand concepts that were easy for them).

DominiqueBernard · 23/01/2024 13:20

You're not wrong, OP, but you are a little naïve (I mean that in the nicest possible way.) If your child is at an academy, their teacher can be literally anyone and certainly don't need to have QTS or a PGCE.

Your concerns are entirely valid. If lots of parents / citizens share these concerns and take action such as writing to their M.P., support teaching unions' strikes (for example, in France most parents don't send their children to school on strike / industrial action days, to show their solidarity), then perhaps there will be some improvement.

Perfect28 · 23/01/2024 13:19

PP make very good points but I'm confused as to what you want the school to do if they can't hire a specialist?

Ace56 · 23/01/2024 13:19

As pp have said, if your child is in a state school at the moment she’s lucky to have a permanent qualified teacher at all. They are having a major recruitment and retention crisis, and quite frankly humanities will be way down the list of subjects they care about.

Previousreligion · 23/01/2024 13:18

I feel mixed feelings.

My best teacher ever had a degree in Education, not the subject she taught, but was incredibly talented.

I don't have a maths degree but I did A Level and a degree with a pretty challenging maths component. If I was a qualified teacher I'm sure I could apply the same skills to teach maths to year 8s.

But I would be concerned in other cases.

Busyhedgehog · 23/01/2024 13:18

In theory, if you have QTS, you can teach anything the school is happy for you to teach. You just specialise in a subject and age range.

LoreleiG · 23/01/2024 13:17

If the school was short I’d be happy with a qualified teacher that knew how to teach set course materials. Especially in year 8. Maybe they have an A Level in the subject? At my school it was common for teachers to teach their A Level language as well as their degree one, for example.

VickyEadieofThigh · 23/01/2024 13:17

In England at least, it's incorrect to say that you must have a degree in the subject to be able to train to teach it. You don't even need an A level in it.

Itslegitimatesalvage · 23/01/2024 13:16

The odd thing is, psychology has a huge amount of maths in! So she actually should be able to do all of it. It’s her rather than the psychology degree that’s the issue.

Itslegitimatesalvage · 23/01/2024 13:15

My son is in first year of high school and his maths teacher has a degree in psychology. I’ve already had to email the head of
maths twice because she has “corrected” his homework equations, but she is doing it wrong and he is doing right (because I’m teaching him). They don’t have anyone else to take the class so the head of maths is having to show her how to do the things she has gaps of knowledge in, and I have to check what he is doing to make sure she has taught the correct stuff. It’s really not good.

C1N1C · 23/01/2024 13:15

I'm curious what people would prefer now that you've raised it...

Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?

The reason I ask is because I've considered teaching in the past (PhD), but I would hate to go through further training. Given the teaching shortage, what are the mum's views?

eggsandbaconeveryday · 23/01/2024 13:15

Are you aware that in some schools they can't attract qualified teachers so have unqualified staff in place , even at GCSE level ? My friend started off as a technician covering food tech but for the last 2 school years the school she is employed by has her covering classes in the department , which includes writing lesson plans and marking not just delivering the lessons each day. The school pay her as an unqualified teacher but have just put out another advert for the role for a qualified teacher , offering almost 10k more than they are paying my friend. They haven't had any interest so far ! The state of our schools is just appalling.

luckylavender · 23/01/2024 13:13

BorgQueen · 23/01/2024 13:09

My DD is a Head of Maths and she won’t hire a teacher without a Maths degree. Large academy chain.
Surely it’s complusory for Maths / Science, if it’s not then it bloody well should be.

She's lucky she can still find maths teachers. Isn't it the biggest shortage?

TwinFireSigns · 23/01/2024 13:13

BorgQueen · 23/01/2024 13:09

My DD is a Head of Maths and she won’t hire a teacher without a Maths degree. Large academy chain.
Surely it’s complusory for Maths / Science, if it’s not then it bloody well should be.

There just aren't enough people with Maths and Science degrees who want to teach anymore. It's been building a long time. I doubt any HoD wants to employ a non-specialist Maths or Science teacher but in a lot of schools they get zero applications for any vacancies. It might vary by location but it's a widespread problem that is only growing.

TheNanny24 · 23/01/2024 13:13

Be glad to have a warm body in front of the class.
Be even more grateful if they are a qualified, permanent teacher.
Thank your lucky stars if they actually have a degree in the subject!

Winter3000 · 23/01/2024 13:11

StragglyTinsel · 23/01/2024 13:06

If it makes you feel better, the overlap between school geography and degree level geography is so slight that it probably doesn’t matter. It’s like two totally different subjects with the same name. 🤣

Complete horses**t.

Winter3000 · 23/01/2024 13:10

You're lucky there's a teacher at all.
Teachers are leaving in their droves.
It's the most thankless job going.