Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
RiderofRohan · 23/01/2024 15:57

Teachers are treated terribly and the pay is even worse. Kids are rude (sometimes violent), parents are demanding, headteachers are often unsupportive.

My mum was a talented maths teacher (with several maths degrees) and 30+ years of experience. She loved teaching but was treated badly throughout her career. Despite being severely disabled, she was expected to adhere to covid 'bubbles' with no reasonable adjustments made for her poor mobility. Expected to walk up and down a huge school, do stairs, etc. That was the last straw and she took early retirement as a result.

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 15:56

ExtremelyJoyous · 23/01/2024 15:46

I don’t think it’s that important at year 8 tbh. Maybe A levels but even then surely as long as they know the exam syllabus it’s fine?

I’m in Scotland and my geography teacher friend mostly teaches modern studies and criminology now! She will also cover for history and RE but didn’t do either in school or uni.

You will find that in fact, your geography teacher friend is also a modern studies teacher. She has done this by gaining the perquisite university credits to apply to be a probationer teacher in modern studies; and then undertaking enough hours and observed lessons in modern studies to achieve full registration as a modern studies teacher.

The “teaching history and RE” is a red herring. She doesn’t actually teach them. She merely facilitates lessons planned by others in her free periods. She has no planning, marking etc to do.

Notellinganyone · 23/01/2024 15:52

@ExtremelyJoyous - it’s really not fine. V difficult to impart real love of a subject if all you know is the syllabus and the syllabus doesn’t tell you how to teach. Makes the focus on narrow box ticking exams all the greater.

punchdrunkdove · 23/01/2024 15:52

I think it would be best to have a qualified teacher with a degree in the subject they are teaching, I am sure it was the norm when I was at school but teaching is now famously one of the most least desired jobs. I was asked recently if I'd ever considered going into teaching and I just laughed, not because I don't respect teachers but honestly why would anyone choose to be put through the wringer like that!

Notellinganyone · 23/01/2024 15:50

@VickyEadieofThigh -thats not true for PGCE courses but TeachFirst has slightly different requirements. Sadly specialism in Secondary schools has now waned for the many reasons people have cited. In my school m big Independent day school, all teachers have degrees, many doctorates, in the subjects they teach which is widening the inequality gap.

AInightingale · 23/01/2024 15:49

The best history teacher I ever had was an out-of-work actor who had an English degree! He was absolutely brilliant, brought the subject to life by mimicking the figures he was teaching about (did a storming Richard III) and was miles better than our regular teacher. Though it's obviously not ideal as the subject gets more advanced, but for years 8 and 9 it's surely fine.

Oblomov23 · 23/01/2024 15:49

Interesting. At GCSE the Business teacher is an RE teacher. You say it only matters at A'level? Hmm. Not sure I agree.

drspouse · 23/01/2024 15:47

my mother was a Maths teacher in the state sector for many years. She even taught in a young offenders institution at one stage and did not struggle to manage behaviour so I guess at least some of this is down to aptitude rather than being taught how to do it.

Mine was also a Maths teacher in the state sector but has a tendency to take things personally so didn't have as much luck with classroom behaviour. However, she went on teach excluded children 1:1 and reportedly got excellent results from them so appears to have had an excellent aptitude for some behavioural issues.

ExtremelyJoyous · 23/01/2024 15:46

I don’t think it’s that important at year 8 tbh. Maybe A levels but even then surely as long as they know the exam syllabus it’s fine?

I’m in Scotland and my geography teacher friend mostly teaches modern studies and criminology now! She will also cover for history and RE but didn’t do either in school or uni.

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 23/01/2024 15:46

In an ideal world then yes all subject teachers would have a degree in their subject. The reality is that teachers are overworked and underpaid and treated like shit by the government. Be grateful your kid has a teacher willing to teach the subject at all.

GreyhpundGirl · 23/01/2024 15:45

I'm a secondary teacher- there are no rules about it. I'm HoD and have had non-specialists teach my subject. It's my job to support them. Please contact your MP- there has been a recruitment and retention crisis for years, currently only about 50% of training places have been taken up. Younger teachers leave within 5 years, and there's a critical mass reaching retirement age. Be thankful they have a. qualified teacher in front of them, rather than a succession of supply.

Snowdropsareontheirway · 23/01/2024 15:42

C1N1C · 23/01/2024 13:15

I'm curious what people would prefer now that you've raised it...

Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?

The reason I ask is because I've considered teaching in the past (PhD), but I would hate to go through further training. Given the teaching shortage, what are the mum's views?

I’m a parent and an ex teacher. I would want someone with QTS.

BonjourCrisette · 23/01/2024 15:41

C1N1C · 23/01/2024 13:15

I'm curious what people would prefer now that you've raised it...

Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?

The reason I ask is because I've considered teaching in the past (PhD), but I would hate to go through further training. Given the teaching shortage, what are the mum's views?

You might get on well in an independent school. My daughter seems to have lots of people with PhDs teaching her and I am fairly sure they don't all have PGCEs. I don't think they are struggling with motivation or crowd control etc as it's quite selective.

FWIW my mother was a Maths teacher in the state sector for many years. She even taught in a young offenders institution at one stage and did not struggle to manage behaviour so I guess at least some of this is down to aptitude rather than being taught how to do it. When she went into teaching in the 70s a PGCE was not necessary, just a degree in the subject you wanted to teach.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 23/01/2024 15:40

drspouse · 23/01/2024 15:29

A music teacher with a degree in music will know a LOT of history. YABVU.

Not necessarily. A headteacher told me once that their music teacher wouldn't present facts on musical history on a school trip because she "didn't learn history ". Ffs.

titchy · 23/01/2024 15:34

Oh your poor naive thing. Most schools are now academies - they don't even have to have qualified teachers anymore, let alone ones with degrees in the right subject.

Justpontificating · 23/01/2024 15:31

It’s not right although i do agree the exam years are more important and should definitely be taught by a teacher with a degree in the relevant subject.

However no one wants to teach these days.
Huge class sizes, bad behaviour and low wages make it no longer an attractive job. Teachers are no longer given the respect they deserve by students and yes even some parents.

We need to teach parents to discipline their kids and show respect and make class sizes smaller. Research has shown class sizes of no more than 22 to have a better outcome for students.

A friends son with a degree in Maths lasted one year in a secondary state academy and left. ( he was teaching all years ). He said students didn’t care about the work, didn’t do homework or in some cases work in the class, were aggressive, rude and basically impossible to teach. It was no more than crowd control.

He took a job at a private school teaching up to and including GCSE ( not Alevel until he has more experience). With small class sizes and strict discipline he has said it’s ‘a different world’. He pay is less, his hours much longer including Saturdays ( longer holidays though) but he doesn’t care.

So smaller classes and more discipline for starters might draw teachers back.

fleurneige · 23/01/2024 15:30

Most teaching Degrees require the study of two subjects. How do you know the music teacher does not have a qualification in humanities/history/geography?

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 15:30

For those who are going on about “of course you can’t have subject specialists with degrees teaching your kid, there is a recruitment crisis!”

Maybe consider that if you revalued the profession - IE insisting that your teachers are qualified to honours/masters level in a relevant discipline as well as postgraduate/combined teaching degree, and then paying them appropriately, the RIGHT candidates would be recruited; and a lot of the issues would resolve.

In Scotland, unpromoted teachers earn £48k. They are contracted to work 35 hours and don’t need to do any more. There is no recruitment or retention crisis, well not to the extent there is in England anyway. There are no unqualified teachers, and every teacher has a degree alongside their teaching qualification.

drspouse · 23/01/2024 15:29

A music teacher with a degree in music will know a LOT of history. YABVU.

Bluevelvetsofa · 23/01/2024 15:27

I was a SENCo and assistant head teacher. As well as that, including safeguarding and responsibility for LAC, I managed two departments and have taught Functional Skills, RE, Option Support and English. Always to fill gaps in the timetable and it was often necessary too take lessons at short notice.

Of course, the ideal would be a specialist in the subject, who has the ability to engage the students, teach to their strengths, adjust the content for more and less able. I’d settle for someone who could get the best out of them, even if they weren’t a specialist.

gardenfoundry · 23/01/2024 15:25

"...according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography."

The teacher should never had said that, or even anything remotely close to it. it undermines their ability to teach.

I think it's bonkers that you - in most cases - have to hold a degree to become a teacher, even if said degree is in a useless subject. As university becomes more and more difficult to attend due to cost, the approach needs to be changed.

Mumof2teens79 · 23/01/2024 15:24

BorgQueen · 23/01/2024 13:09

My DD is a Head of Maths and she won’t hire a teacher without a Maths degree. Large academy chain.
Surely it’s complusory for Maths / Science, if it’s not then it bloody well should be.

Does she not have a shortage of math teachers then?
DDs school have vacancies for maths teachers....they may well only hire those with maths degrees...in the mean time teachers from other departments are timetabled to fill the gaps so it's a counter productive rule.
Better a maths teacher with no degree than an English teacher teaching maths

Mumof2teens79 · 23/01/2024 15:21

You don't have to have a degree in a subject to teach at secondary AFAIK...and never have.
My parents were teachers and didn't have degrees.

It would be ideal to be taught be a specialist. But u would rather have a specialist geography teacher without a geography degree, than music teacher who happens to have a geography degree teaching geography.

leftoverss · 23/01/2024 15:21

Meh, we didn't have a Humanities teacher for a year during GCSEs as she had cancer and I still got an A. This was at a crappy comprehensive that was rated 'Requires Improvement'.

C1N1C · 23/01/2024 15:20

Aaron95 · 23/01/2024 14:24

I have a degree in Chemistry. What I studied at university has absolutely zero relevance to what you learn for GCSE or A-Level.

I would be more concerned that they are being taught by someone qualified in teaching. We seem to forget that teaching children is a highly valuble skill and not an easy one to learn and put into practice.

I agree... I'm in a similar field.

This is where I think schools fail, but in reality, it's not their fault. There's 'what is needed to pass' vs. 'what is actually useful'.

I remember a lecturer telling us "you need to know the different amino acids, what they look like, their chemistry etc... you need them to pass your exam... but in reality, I'd just look them up in a book".

School is more about memory than useful skills sadly...

Swipe left for the next trending thread