Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
CaribouCarafe · 23/01/2024 16:38

"The techniques used in the study of history and geography for examples - defining a question, identifying and scrutinising evidence and information to help you answer the question and forming an argument/answer - are much more similar to studying science than music"

Hi OP, you wouldn't believe how well-rounded you have to be in order to do music even at A level let alone degree level.

When I did A level music, it was one of the few courses that still consisted of 6 modules. 2 components of the A level were concerned with being able to research, analyse, and contextualise music scores in relation to the lives and bibliographies of numerous composers and their historical context.

Your child's music teacher would have had to do extensive historical research on composers, performance practices, socio-political context of the composer's life, and on the instrument themselves. I guarantee that they have the skills to be able to teach 8th form history.

What they might not have is some specialist skills related to geography, but to be honest from what I remember from pre-GCSE geography half of it was cultural geography (which is easy to pick up for a reasonably intelligent adult), and the other half is learning about glaciers, water bodies and topology (which might be slightly more difficult for the teacher to pick up but not impossible). I don't remember having to do any data analysis or collection for geography or anything remotely sciencey for it.

lieselotte · 23/01/2024 16:34

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:07

What do you mean by “subjects like that”?

Looks like Michael Gove has joined the chat. Only STEM subjects matter (and English).

lieselotte · 23/01/2024 16:31

The techniques used in the study of history and geography for examples - defining a question, identifying and scrutinising evidence and information to help you answer the question and forming an argument/answer - are much more similar to studying science than music

Says who? Have you studied music yourself? I only did GCSE but I saw some of the things my university flatmates who studied music did, and the transferable skills were valuable. It's not just playing instruments.

2mummies1baby · 23/01/2024 16:30

BorgQueen · 23/01/2024 13:09

My DD is a Head of Maths and she won’t hire a teacher without a Maths degree. Large academy chain.
Surely it’s complusory for Maths / Science, if it’s not then it bloody well should be.

I cannot tell you how many secondary school Maths teachers in my local area don't have a Maths degree. It's appalling. I am the only primary school teacher I know with a Maths degree.

Unfortunately, teaching is very low paid compared to many other jobs for which a Maths degree qualifies someone.

lieselotte · 23/01/2024 16:30

OP from my experience with my son, Y8 is the year schools don't care about, and my ds is at university now, so the recruitment crisis wasn't so bad back then.

Y7 - trying to get the kids into good habits
Y9 - GCSEs looming, want kids to do their subjects so make more effort
Y10 and 11 - GCSE years

Y8 - doesn't matter so they get the cover teachers etc

Not right, but nothing new.

The music teacher might be better than s/he thinks, and maybe they've got an A level in history or geography.

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:30

ExtremelyJoyous · 23/01/2024 16:17

Yes I understand how it works.. thanks for the lecture though.

Then it is surely disingenuous to call your friend a “geography teacher” who teaches modern studies when the fact is that she is in fact a modern studies teacher who teaches modern studies.

StragglyTinsel · 23/01/2024 16:30

Winter3000 · 23/01/2024 13:11

Complete horses**t.

Have you looked at academic geographers do?

I say this as someone with a PhD in geography that gets the response ‘how is that geography?’ any time it comes up. Most of the geographers I know have similar experiences.

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 16:27

responding to @C1N1C’s question “Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?”

I think teaching is a specialism that one needs to learn how to do well and continually improve in so personally would favour a qualified teacher over knowledge of the subject matter. However the key thing being taught at this stage (I think) is not the subject matter itself it’s the techniques used in the study of that subject. So an under of those are important and more transferable between some subjects than others. The techniques used in the study of history and geography for examples - defining a question, identifying and scrutinising evidence and information to help you answer the question and forming an argument/answer - are much more similar to studying science than music.

OP posts:
junebirthdaygirl · 23/01/2024 16:24

I am a Primary teacher so teach history and Geography up to the end of Primary which in lreland would be year 8. I could easily progress to teaching either at Secondary level early years . I think it's the teaching bit that's important. I wouldn't take on Science as it never appealed to me but could do Maths too for a year or two. I know this as l have tutored kids and love Maths and especially love explaining it. . So the important thing is: can they teach and are they bringing the subjects alive? Some wizards at a subject are awful teachers.

elliejjtiny · 23/01/2024 16:21

I can't remember exactly what the qualification is but I know there are a few teachers at my dc secondary school who are qualified to teach their specialist subject to year 10 and 11 but can teach any subject to year 7-9.

DwightDFlysenhower · 23/01/2024 16:19

You've a reasonable chance of a degree educated biologist.

My degree educated biologist relative is currently teaching maths, while biology is taught by a PE graduate!

She's very fed up, because the other teacher can't run practicals so she's doing that. Oh she's teaching Y7 music once a week because she can read music and teach them the instruments of an orchestra because she plays in one... (I think they only have a part time music teacher and couldn't timetable it any other way.)

Schools are definitely struggling at the moment.

Anisette · 23/01/2024 16:18

TheNanny24 · 23/01/2024 13:13

Be glad to have a warm body in front of the class.
Be even more grateful if they are a qualified, permanent teacher.
Thank your lucky stars if they actually have a degree in the subject!

Why?

I'm really surprised that so many people are saying that OP is unreasonable, presumably because of the teacher shortage. Why do we accept that so meekly? Do we not feel that our country and our schools should be run in such a way that teaching is an attractive profession and good teachers don't leave?

You can bet that the likes of Sunak, Johnson, Rees-Mogg etc were never taught by anyone other than teachers with degrees in the relevant subjects. Why should we accept lower standards from them for our children?

ExtremelyJoyous · 23/01/2024 16:17

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 15:56

You will find that in fact, your geography teacher friend is also a modern studies teacher. She has done this by gaining the perquisite university credits to apply to be a probationer teacher in modern studies; and then undertaking enough hours and observed lessons in modern studies to achieve full registration as a modern studies teacher.

The “teaching history and RE” is a red herring. She doesn’t actually teach them. She merely facilitates lessons planned by others in her free periods. She has no planning, marking etc to do.

Yes I understand how it works.. thanks for the lecture though.

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:15

Comefromaway · 23/01/2024 16:12

I assume the poster means a humanities subject that shares a lot of skills and where a history teacher might very well have a degree in politics or philosophy or a similar essay/humanities type subject.

But geography is not an “essay type subject” - it’s actually very skills based; and often teachers of other subjects (be it humanities or elsewhere around the school) often struggle with these skills - such as using contour patterns to identify geographical features.
In terms of the content; I’d actually say a lot of geography sits best in the science faculty rather than the humanities faculty.

IvorTheEngineDriver · 23/01/2024 16:13

Back in the 70s I was taught maths by teachers with no degree in the subject. Lack of qualified teachers is nothing new.

Comefromaway · 23/01/2024 16:12

I assume the poster means a humanities subject that shares a lot of skills and where a history teacher might very well have a degree in politics or philosophy or a similar essay/humanities type subject.

Isitreallythough · 23/01/2024 16:11

Unfortunate but not very surprising. I know Hist/Geog/RE teachers in particular are commonly roped into teaching one another’s subjects

MissersMercer · 23/01/2024 16:11

Voted yabu as this happens all the time. My friend teachers the whole class alone at least once a week and she's just a TA with no qualifications at all. She hates it, it is not in her job description at all. Headteacher say she can put in a claim for more pay on the days she pretends to be a teacher.

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:07

ManchesterLu · 23/01/2024 16:07

YABU. Anyone can look at a syllabus and teach it, so if they're qualified to teach, it's fine.

I wouldn't even expect a subject specific degree at GCSE to be honest for subjects like that.

What do you mean by “subjects like that”?

ManchesterLu · 23/01/2024 16:07

YABU. Anyone can look at a syllabus and teach it, so if they're qualified to teach, it's fine.

I wouldn't even expect a subject specific degree at GCSE to be honest for subjects like that.

Wetblanket78 · 23/01/2024 16:07

The work will be set by humanities teacher the teacher though I'm not sure about marking. When I was in year 8 we were often taught by a student teacher. We know the work was set by head of Humanities because he would often say Mr Jones has set this work for you.

ActDottie · 23/01/2024 16:06

As long as they’re not teaching A Level and they have Geography A level I wouldn’t mind too much. I’d be annoyed though if they were an a level teacher without a degree in the subject. I agree though the teacher shouldn’t be admitting they’re not very good at teaching geography!

NewYearSameShizzle · 23/01/2024 16:02

My son is doing his GCSEs this year, he didn't have a science teacher all last year. I'd love for there to be specialist teachers for each subject but it appears as though it just isn't possible right now. By all means speak to the school but I would have thought they would be using specialist teachers, if they had them.

LevelledPeach · 23/01/2024 16:00

I'm a head of science.

It's increasingly common for science teachers to have a degree in PE, sports science, or sports coaching.

Good luck finding any physics teachers with a degree in physics, or chemistry with a chemistry degree.
You've a reasonable chance of a degree educated biologist.

There's been a huge increase in the number of unqualified teachers in secondary schools, too.

There's now a lot of routes into teaching, meaning that, increasingly, teachers don't hold a PGCE, either.

It's a mess, alright.

DanceMumTaxi · 23/01/2024 15:58

This situation is very common and is happening in most schools. My school has lots of people teaching outside their specialism. Some don’t even have a GCSE in the subject being taught let alone a degree. Eg technology teacher doing maths, language teacher doing RE and PE teacher doing Geography plus more. In my school it’s a consequence of having absolutely no money, but in other schools it’ll be because they just can’t find teachers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread