Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:57

CaribouCarafe · 23/01/2024 16:49

Ah interesting! My experience was in England 16 years ago so probably very outdated, can't remember seeing a single graph in pre-GCSE geography!

Edited

We get them to do a project where they gather data (we do a river study and an urban study) and then interpret their data with our S2 classes.

We also do population pyramids where they have to discuss reasons between differences in two pyramids.

We also do cross sections which are pretty difficult to draw and interpret.

IMO it is pretty difficult to teach geography as a non specialist. All my non-geography colleagues agree it’s the hardest to teach of the humanities, since it’s so broad.

Which is why geography graduates are the most employable of all (with the exception of career specific degrees like medicine)

azteccandle · 23/01/2024 16:57

Bellaboo01 · 23/01/2024 16:51

You would be qualified/able to teach in academy's/state secondary schools.

I am sure you would be snapped up.

But, if you think that you wouldn't be able to teach a class then teaching obviously wouldn't be your chosen career.

I am very educated but, teaching isnt my chosen career path.

Edited

Really? My understanding is that you need a PGCE to teach in a school.

redheadsaregreat · 23/01/2024 16:56

C1N1C · 23/01/2024 13:15

I'm curious what people would prefer now that you've raised it...

Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?

The reason I ask is because I've considered teaching in the past (PhD), but I would hate to go through further training. Given the teaching shortage, what are the mum's views?

For what it's worth, in my view there is little added benefit in having a subject teacher with a PhD when teaching school students. Potentially a-level students may gain confidence knowing the person is highly qualified but the level of work relating to a PhD is so far beyond anything that will be taught to a school student that it's like asking if it would help if your driving instructor was an F1 driver.

Beyond a thorough knowledge of the subject, what is required is the capacity to teach and a PhD doesn't confer this

azteccandle · 23/01/2024 16:55

WombatChocolate · 23/01/2024 16:44

It surprises me that it’s news to lots of parents just how bad recruitment and retention is in teaching.

In lots of subjects, many many GCSE students are taught by non-specialists as schools can’t recruit or recruit and keep the staff. Of course it’s not as it should be……complain to your local MP and support campaigners who are pushing for better pay and conditions for teachers and crucially better funding for schools overall. It’s years and years of funding cuts and below inflation pay rises that have meant teaching is less and less attractive.

What I always wonder about, is how bad does it have to get for parents to be fully aware of it or to start to make a serious noise about it?

If you ask your kids, how many lessons a week do they have a supply or replacement teacher, or how often does their main teacher change, many would be surprised by he frequency. It’s just not a question parents ask very often so just don’t know. And it’s so common for most kids that they wouldn’t think to mention it. More and more classes are being ‘delivered’ by TAs ir cover supervisors who give out work set by a teacher….but they can’t explain the concepts, answer questions and adjust the tasks to meet the needs of the class as a teacher would. But that’s what kids are receiving. There’s little interaction and discussion with a qualified person. But people seem to be willing to let it happen. How bad will it get before people say they won’t stand for it?

@WombatChocolate I have one child at school (motivated, achieving), and one at home. Without going into details, I think some parents are already saying they won't stand for it and this is reflected in attendance figures. Many of the children I know who have dropped out of school are being schooled online or through home ed groups.

WillowBarkTree · 23/01/2024 16:54

I was a school governor at a large secondary school in England about 5 years ago. The schools policy was for GCSE or A-Level the teacher had to have degree in subject. For years 7-9 they could teach subjects they had an A-Level in and related to degree. So for example, Chemistry degree would teach chemistry but might also do biology, in year 7-9, history degree might also do rs or geography in same years.

LiftApproaching · 23/01/2024 16:52

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:15

But geography is not an “essay type subject” - it’s actually very skills based; and often teachers of other subjects (be it humanities or elsewhere around the school) often struggle with these skills - such as using contour patterns to identify geographical features.
In terms of the content; I’d actually say a lot of geography sits best in the science faculty rather than the humanities faculty.

I have Maths, physics, chemistry and computer science A-levels at the top grades. I did a medical degree and have postgraduate medical qualifications. The only topic that has ever brought me to tears? Doing contour maps in year seven.

Geography is not easy! My kids doing it at GCSE, brought back many bad memories!

Bunnycat101 · 23/01/2024 16:52

My friend is a physics teacher. He has schools desperate to recruit him- literally getting emails trying to poach him because they are so hard to come by. He’d been based in the state sector but has gone into independent because they were willing to bump up pay significantly. It would be an interesting research project to see degree specialism in the private schools v comps.

redheadsaregreat · 23/01/2024 16:51

BorgQueen · 23/01/2024 13:09

My DD is a Head of Maths and she won’t hire a teacher without a Maths degree. Large academy chain.
Surely it’s complusory for Maths / Science, if it’s not then it bloody well should be.

So what does she do if she is short two maths teachers and a physics teacher and there are no qualified teachers with maths or physics degrees applying for the roles? That's the issue schools are having. Your dd can want all she wants but if there isn't anyone applying she and every school in the country will have little choice but to take what's on offer.

Bellaboo01 · 23/01/2024 16:51

azteccandle · 23/01/2024 16:46

Thanks @Bellaboo01 . As a PhD qualified subject specialist (and former university lecturer), I have been approached by private schools to teach - but would not be qualified to teach in a state secondary.

Having said that, I know that I wouldn't last 5 minutes in a state secondary as I doubt I would be able to control a class or deal with the range of abilities.

Edited

You would be qualified/able to teach in academy's/state secondary schools.

I am sure you would be snapped up.

But, if you think that you wouldn't be able to teach a class then teaching obviously wouldn't be your chosen career.

I am very educated but, teaching isnt my chosen career path.

ExtremelyJoyous · 23/01/2024 16:50

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:30

Then it is surely disingenuous to call your friend a “geography teacher” who teaches modern studies when the fact is that she is in fact a modern studies teacher who teaches modern studies.

This year she is teaching higher geography, Nat5 and higher modern studies and Nat 5 criminology 🤗 social geography is her preferred subject and she only taught that in another school so that’s why I call her a geography teacher.

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:49

Bellaboo01 · 23/01/2024 16:43

I would as a parent prefer a highly qualified person.

As a teacher, I disagree with this too.

I was at uni with people who were way more qualified than me; and many of them were awful at teaching.

What we need is people who are qualified in a subject AND qualified as a teacher AND are effective at actually implementing the theory.

MBL · 23/01/2024 16:49

Agree a degree in the subject being taught is ideal however some related degrees are definitely OK. During lockdown I listened to quite a few maths classes taught by someone with an economics degree. He was excellent both in content, style and group management (though I suppose this might be different when not online).
I don't think he teaches A level maths though.

ThanksItHasPockets · 23/01/2024 16:49

BorgQueen · 23/01/2024 13:09

My DD is a Head of Maths and she won’t hire a teacher without a Maths degree. Large academy chain.
Surely it’s complusory for Maths / Science, if it’s not then it bloody well should be.

That is an unusually hard line and quite short-sighted, I’m sorry to say. There are many talented mathematicians who choose to study degrees with significant mathematical content but not purely maths. Your DD’s criterion is stricter than the PGCE admissions tutors at UCL and Cambridge!

CaribouCarafe · 23/01/2024 16:49

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:46

(In Scotland at least) you need to do data gathering and analysis for geography. You also need to interpret fairly complex graphs such as hydrographs. You mention knowing about “water bodies” - you need to do the water cycle; which is taught in science also (but we go into more detail in geography as we also look at the human side of it)

Ah interesting! My experience was in England 16 years ago so probably very outdated, can't remember seeing a single graph in pre-GCSE geography!

azteccandle · 23/01/2024 16:46

Bellaboo01 · 23/01/2024 16:43

I would as a parent prefer a highly qualified person.

Thanks @Bellaboo01 . As a PhD qualified subject specialist (and former university lecturer), I have been approached by private schools to teach - but would not be qualified to teach in a state secondary.

Having said that, I know that I wouldn't last 5 minutes in a state secondary as I doubt I would be able to control a class or deal with the range of abilities.

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:46

CaribouCarafe · 23/01/2024 16:38

"The techniques used in the study of history and geography for examples - defining a question, identifying and scrutinising evidence and information to help you answer the question and forming an argument/answer - are much more similar to studying science than music"

Hi OP, you wouldn't believe how well-rounded you have to be in order to do music even at A level let alone degree level.

When I did A level music, it was one of the few courses that still consisted of 6 modules. 2 components of the A level were concerned with being able to research, analyse, and contextualise music scores in relation to the lives and bibliographies of numerous composers and their historical context.

Your child's music teacher would have had to do extensive historical research on composers, performance practices, socio-political context of the composer's life, and on the instrument themselves. I guarantee that they have the skills to be able to teach 8th form history.

What they might not have is some specialist skills related to geography, but to be honest from what I remember from pre-GCSE geography half of it was cultural geography (which is easy to pick up for a reasonably intelligent adult), and the other half is learning about glaciers, water bodies and topology (which might be slightly more difficult for the teacher to pick up but not impossible). I don't remember having to do any data analysis or collection for geography or anything remotely sciencey for it.

(In Scotland at least) you need to do data gathering and analysis for geography. You also need to interpret fairly complex graphs such as hydrographs. You mention knowing about “water bodies” - you need to do the water cycle; which is taught in science also (but we go into more detail in geography as we also look at the human side of it)

WombatChocolate · 23/01/2024 16:44

It surprises me that it’s news to lots of parents just how bad recruitment and retention is in teaching.

In lots of subjects, many many GCSE students are taught by non-specialists as schools can’t recruit or recruit and keep the staff. Of course it’s not as it should be……complain to your local MP and support campaigners who are pushing for better pay and conditions for teachers and crucially better funding for schools overall. It’s years and years of funding cuts and below inflation pay rises that have meant teaching is less and less attractive.

What I always wonder about, is how bad does it have to get for parents to be fully aware of it or to start to make a serious noise about it?

If you ask your kids, how many lessons a week do they have a supply or replacement teacher, or how often does their main teacher change, many would be surprised by he frequency. It’s just not a question parents ask very often so just don’t know. And it’s so common for most kids that they wouldn’t think to mention it. More and more classes are being ‘delivered’ by TAs ir cover supervisors who give out work set by a teacher….but they can’t explain the concepts, answer questions and adjust the tasks to meet the needs of the class as a teacher would. But that’s what kids are receiving. There’s little interaction and discussion with a qualified person. But people seem to be willing to let it happen. How bad will it get before people say they won’t stand for it?

Beamur · 23/01/2024 16:44

A friend of mine is a teacher and does a lot of private tutoring too. She only actually teaches her degree subject some of the time. Currently teaching a science subject to an A level class (and really enjoying it) - not her degree subject. But she is a good and engaging educator and good at learning.

azteccandle · 23/01/2024 16:44

I assume this is a state school - in which case YA being a bit U.

My DC is taking GCSEs this year. In one subject they had supply teachers up until Christmas and finally have a subject specialist. In another subject they have just lost their specialist teacher and have a non-specialist teacher instead. Both are humanities.

I considered retraining as a secondary teacher a while back and one of the reasons I didn't was that I would have to teach across chemistry, biology and physics ie. "sciences" rather than just my degree (and PhD) subject. I suspect humanities is going the same way.

Bellaboo01 · 23/01/2024 16:43

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 16:27

responding to @C1N1C’s question “Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?”

I think teaching is a specialism that one needs to learn how to do well and continually improve in so personally would favour a qualified teacher over knowledge of the subject matter. However the key thing being taught at this stage (I think) is not the subject matter itself it’s the techniques used in the study of that subject. So an under of those are important and more transferable between some subjects than others. The techniques used in the study of history and geography for examples - defining a question, identifying and scrutinising evidence and information to help you answer the question and forming an argument/answer - are much more similar to studying science than music.

Edited

I would as a parent prefer a highly qualified person.

brightyellowflower · 23/01/2024 16:43

Also just to say, if you employ a tutor for your child, check they're qualifed. Most aren't. And those that are are say qualified for secondary and claiming it's ok to teach Year 6 maths. They know nothing about primary maths and the exam process at all. Or they're teaching GCSE History and have a primary teaching qualification!

You'd be amazed how many people think it's ok to teach something just because they got an A* in it!

EnjoyTheMushrooms · 23/01/2024 16:40

ha, even at university you’re not always taught by somebody with a degree in that subject… (I was surprised to learn this!)

wronginalltherightways · 23/01/2024 16:39

Well, society reaps what it sows, frankly.

Treat teachers like crap. Talk about teachers like crap. Pay teachers like crap. Expect teachers to make up for all the crappy parenting going on and waste time teaching skills past generations learned at home. Treat schools like crap (massively underfund them) leaving them without basic resources like books, pencils and glue sticks half the time. Try to get teachers to fund their own classroom resources when that happens. Cut support staff, leaving even more things that teachers need to sort. Mainstream children who need support without said support. Fail to support teachers when children behave terribly. Fail to support teachers when parents back their poorly behaved children. Blame teachers for poor student behaviour, even though the leadership teams don't have a solution or provide any support.

The list goes on.

Cue parents complaining that teachers are only in it for the long holidays and that their children's teachers aren't qualified to actually teach their subjects ... because they can't get anyone to do it any more.

Whenever our local schools list job openings, we essentially have to take what we can get, assuming anyone applies. Depressing as hell. I've lost count of the number of teachers and teaching assistants I know who have left schools behind entirely and now do other things.

brightyellowflower · 23/01/2024 16:38

YANBU but I know someone who didn't even have any science GCSE's at all - and has now been made head of science.

My mum is fuming! (ex teacher, now retired)

Workworkandmoreworknow · 23/01/2024 16:38

Stop voting Tory. Listen to the many, many cries of teaches about the current state of education (and how it is only going to get worse). Shout loudly and make education an election issue that the powers that be are going to have to address.

Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?The reason I ask is because I've considered teaching in the past (PhD), but I would hate to go through further training. Given the teaching shortage, what are the mum's views?

FFS. Seriously. What mums want is a qualified professional with a degree in the subject they are teaching. It shouldn't be 'either/or'. It should always be both.

Why not go the whole hog and stick 18 year olds in front of classes?