Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Blah12345678999 · 23/01/2024 17:36

The schools and teachers can only deal with what they have. They answer to the government essentially not to the kids and parents, the government is the issue.

Blah12345678999 · 23/01/2024 17:35

Also if it’s any reassurance my friend who has a degree in geography and masters in a related specialist geography field was in teaching for a few years but eventually left to go into a more lucrative and less stressful job… It’s a common theme…

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 17:34

Thanks so much for all replies - helpful to read others experiences and perspectives.

The level of cynicism that this is just what it’s like now is deeply depressing.

I do think I’ll talk to the school - not to complain but to just to flag that as a parent I don’t feel this is ideal (recognising the constraints they have) - if they believe parents care about this issue it may prompt them to look again at what they can do with what they have. But do recognise they can’t magic up non-existent teachers.

not sure writing to my (Tory) MP at this point in the political cycle will make a blind bit of difference. Usually I’m all for a bit of political activism. If I get door stepped by the Labour hopeful though I will make a point of the teaching crisis being an issue I very much care about.

OP posts:
Blah12345678999 · 23/01/2024 17:32

CaptainMyCaptain · 23/01/2024 17:28

Teaching wasn't a completely graduate profession in the 70s. You could go to Teacher Training college with 5 O Levels although some asked for a couple of A levels and end up with a CertEd as a teaching qualification. This had ended by about 1980 when you had to have either a degree plus PGCE or a BEd. It wasn't to do with a lack of teachers.

Edited

Just curious were teachers treated with more respect, and was it viewed as a more respected profession in the 70s? I’m amazed when I told people about my experience in teaching that they seemed to think I was ‘crazy’ and talking nonsense, then they seemed more concerned when I was getting more work in supply than I needed due to teachers being off with stress, not enough teachers available etc as they realised this wasn’t a made up issue. I think the media/establishment/government push quite a bad image of ‘lazy’ teachers and unfortunately I think it is generally believed by people until it’s too late and they see the issues 🤷🏻‍♀️

Gia79 · 23/01/2024 17:29

You don’t need a degree as in an undergrad degree to teach a subject. Eg plenty of English teachers have a degree in something like performing arts. Tbh I’ve worked in an academy where an Economics A level class were taught by a RE teacher so they prob won’t get an eyelid about KS3. In fact I’d bet money on it.

CaptainMyCaptain · 23/01/2024 17:28

IvorTheEngineDriver · 23/01/2024 16:13

Back in the 70s I was taught maths by teachers with no degree in the subject. Lack of qualified teachers is nothing new.

Teaching wasn't a completely graduate profession in the 70s. You could go to Teacher Training college with 5 O Levels although some asked for a couple of A levels and end up with a CertEd as a teaching qualification. This had ended by about 1980 when you had to have either a degree plus PGCE or a BEd. It wasn't to do with a lack of teachers.

CaribouCarafe · 23/01/2024 17:26

No problem, although turns out my info on geography was woefully outdated 😅

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 17:25

CaribouCarafe · 23/01/2024 16:38

"The techniques used in the study of history and geography for examples - defining a question, identifying and scrutinising evidence and information to help you answer the question and forming an argument/answer - are much more similar to studying science than music"

Hi OP, you wouldn't believe how well-rounded you have to be in order to do music even at A level let alone degree level.

When I did A level music, it was one of the few courses that still consisted of 6 modules. 2 components of the A level were concerned with being able to research, analyse, and contextualise music scores in relation to the lives and bibliographies of numerous composers and their historical context.

Your child's music teacher would have had to do extensive historical research on composers, performance practices, socio-political context of the composer's life, and on the instrument themselves. I guarantee that they have the skills to be able to teach 8th form history.

What they might not have is some specialist skills related to geography, but to be honest from what I remember from pre-GCSE geography half of it was cultural geography (which is easy to pick up for a reasonably intelligent adult), and the other half is learning about glaciers, water bodies and topology (which might be slightly more difficult for the teacher to pick up but not impossible). I don't remember having to do any data analysis or collection for geography or anything remotely sciencey for it.

This (and others who posted about the string component of history in music) is very reassuring thank you!

OP posts:
AllProperTeaIsTheft · 23/01/2024 17:23

For gcse and A level years I would expect teachers to hold a degree in that subject. For the first few years of secondary, I wouldn’t.

The thing is, you can expect what you like, but if they can't find a teacher, they can't find a teacher. It's not as if schools want to be putting non-subject specialists in front of classes. Why would they, unless they had no choice?

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 17:14

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 23/01/2024 17:00

Which is why geography graduates are the most employable of all (with the exception of career specific degrees like medicine)

Isnt it history that’s meant to be the most employable? It was when ds did his degree 9 years ago.

It wasn’t when I did my degree in 09-13, nor was it about a year ago when I looked it up last. It’s because geography is far more varied and transferable than history.

cakecoffeecakecoffee · 23/01/2024 17:14

Yabu.

because many teachers have completely unrelated degrees and a PGCE. They have teaching skills and a curriculum to follow.

in a field where there are staff shortages I’d just be bloody relieved they’ve got a teacher. DD in Y4 is on her 6th teacher of this academic year!

WillowBarkTree · 23/01/2024 17:13

@noblegiraffe that doesn’t surprise me at all. I was trying more to emphasis even 5 years ago (pre Covid) children being taught subjects by a teacher without a degree in that subject for Years 7-9 was policy - not out of the ordinary. We never had a music teacher teaching humanities but I would have felt that would have fallen within policy if they had done the subject for A-level.

Blah12345678999 · 23/01/2024 17:11

ActDottie · 23/01/2024 16:06

As long as they’re not teaching A Level and they have Geography A level I wouldn’t mind too much. I’d be annoyed though if they were an a level teacher without a degree in the subject. I agree though the teacher shouldn’t be admitting they’re not very good at teaching geography!

Well it might help bring home just how bad the teaching situation is and that it’s not about teachers being ‘lazy’ and ‘work shy’ 🙄 if anything I think the teachers have completely the opposite problem!

DwightDFlysenhower · 23/01/2024 17:10

Also just to say, if you employ a tutor for your child, check they're qualifed. Most aren't. And those that are are say qualified for secondary and claiming it's ok to teach Year 6 maths. They know nothing about primary maths and the exam process at all.

I used to tutor for entrance exams when I was at university. No teaching qualifications, but I had sat them myself. I was good at explaining verbal and non-verbal reasoning which was more than a lot of the other (qualified teacher) tutors could do! Fair enough really, it isn't something they'd ever done.

Off topic

It depends what you're looking for in a tutor I think. I know I couldn't tutor GCSE because I don't know the syllabus. A lot of the time though, the children I tutored really just needed one-to-one as an opportunity to talk through questions, and learn exam technique. It was more about a confidence boost that they felt they were going into the exam well-prepared and would perform their best.

tokesqueen · 23/01/2024 17:09

My son's year 11 second set maths class in an outstanding secondary was being covered by a librarian at one point two years ago.

noblegiraffe · 23/01/2024 17:05

WillowBarkTree · 23/01/2024 16:54

I was a school governor at a large secondary school in England about 5 years ago. The schools policy was for GCSE or A-Level the teacher had to have degree in subject. For years 7-9 they could teach subjects they had an A-Level in and related to degree. So for example, Chemistry degree would teach chemistry but might also do biology, in year 7-9, history degree might also do rs or geography in same years.

I have to say that even schools experience of 5 years ago is woefully out of date.

Teacher supply was a problem before covid, it has absolutely crashed since.

Here's how recruitment has been going against target of trainees needed in recent years (purple is trainees who started training in 2023 so will be starting teaching in 2024, yellow is trainees who started teaching in 2023).

E.g. they only recruited 50% of the secondary trainees needed last year. They overrecruited in PE - 181% of target, but only managed to get 17% of the Physics target.

Incidentally, they only met 27% of the target for music so that music teacher may well be needed back to teach music at some point.

Those extremely low numbers of trainees means that when job adverts start going out for September, many of them will be unfilled.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?
RatatouillePie · 23/01/2024 17:02

I teach in a secondary school, and I disagree that you need a degree to teach a subject.

I've seen many awful degree qualified teachers, but I've also seen many amazing teachers with no relevant degree who have interest and enthusiasm in a subject.

I don't have a degree in my subject. It's a relevant degree and overlaps in many areas, but not at all in others. Does that make me a bad teacher? I have the best GCSE results, got amazing A Level results, and when I run the revision session I get 4 times the amount of kids turning up!

I might not be the highest qualified in my department, but I am very good at explaining things to kids, and happy to learn as I go along!

A permanent teacher is much better than a temporary one!

One year we had find a "warm body" to put in front of the kids!

Bellaboo01 · 23/01/2024 17:00

azteccandle · 23/01/2024 16:57

Really? My understanding is that you need a PGCE to teach in a school.

Nope (unfortunately)!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 23/01/2024 17:00

Which is why geography graduates are the most employable of all (with the exception of career specific degrees like medicine)

Isnt it history that’s meant to be the most employable? It was when ds did his degree 9 years ago.

LiftApproaching · 23/01/2024 17:00

My third child has left home to go to university. Our girls went to a large London private school and we were extremely lucky. They were taught by phenomenal subject teachers. The teachers all had degrees in their subjects.

The only exception was one maths teacher in recent years who was recruited from an IT job. He was clearly very bright, but had only taught adults. He was phenomenally bad at teaching children of school age. He even got annoyed with them asking questions about maths. He left after a year and said teaching was not for him.

I would love my kids to be taught by people who really were passionate about teaching. I would be appalling at teaching children, which is why I don’t teach.

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 16:59

LiftApproaching · 23/01/2024 16:52

I have Maths, physics, chemistry and computer science A-levels at the top grades. I did a medical degree and have postgraduate medical qualifications. The only topic that has ever brought me to tears? Doing contour maps in year seven.

Geography is not easy! My kids doing it at GCSE, brought back many bad memories!

Haha!

Id say it’s easy to do geography badly, but difficult to do it right!

I personally found geography easy - but I recognise that it isn’t actually easy; I’m just good at it!

redheadsaregreat · 23/01/2024 16:59

Itslegitimatesalvage · 23/01/2024 13:16

The odd thing is, psychology has a huge amount of maths in! So she actually should be able to do all of it. It’s her rather than the psychology degree that’s the issue.

Psychology has some maths in it but only a narrow sphere of maths. Maths is not one topic. You will need graphs, algebra and statistics. wouldn't be using advanced calculus or trigonometry

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 23/01/2024 16:59

Itslegitimatesalvage · 23/01/2024 13:15

My son is in first year of high school and his maths teacher has a degree in psychology. I’ve already had to email the head of
maths twice because she has “corrected” his homework equations, but she is doing it wrong and he is doing right (because I’m teaching him). They don’t have anyone else to take the class so the head of maths is having to show her how to do the things she has gaps of knowledge in, and I have to check what he is doing to make sure she has taught the correct stuff. It’s really not good.

I’m sure that made her happy.

Teachers are running to keep up. It’s not her fault she got shoved in front of a class with little knowledge of the subject.

I once had to teach electronics. I knew fa, had to wing it all the time. It was awful. And l had to spend ages learning it for 2 lessons a week. My priorities were my exam classes. So instead of spending the 5 hours trying to learn electronics which is what it needed for the 2 lower school classes,l spent an hour, and looked after my 11 periodexam classes instead.

DwightDFlysenhower · 23/01/2024 16:58

Geography depends doesn't it? At my university at any rate it could be a BA or a BSc.

I had friends who did quite a lot that would cross over with anthropology and international studies, while others did things that linked more into meteorology and computer modelling topography. Both did quite a lot of statistics, but in very different ways.