Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/01/2024 19:00

I do think there is a lot of naivety on this thread- the idea that all children get qualified teachers at GCSE and A-level is definitely not true!

Yes, to some extent, schools will protect exam years wherever they can- but this really means Y11 first, maybe Y13 second, with Y10 a distant third. And sometimes, especially if a teacher leaves mid year, it's not possible to protect even Y11 classes. A few years ago, I taught a GCSE science class which was a shared group between two teachers (in theory). However, there was no-one to teach the other half of the lessons, so they went through about 5 different teachers (plus multiple cover/supply lessons each term) in that year. It definitely had a huge negative impact on their GCSEs. That same year, two Y10 classes were in the same situation as well.

In order to try and help, my timetable changed multiple times that year- that meant my KS3 groups and my Y12 class had changes too, and in some cases multiple teachers and periods of supply throughout the year.

Many of those students definitely got far lower grades than they otherwise might have done!

I know schools who now make timetable decisions based around how many lessons they can staff, not what's best for each subject. I know schools where class sizes for e.g. triple science or A-level are massive because that's the only way to get all the students to have subject specialists.

For those saying that the lessons or scheme of work etc are provided by a qualified subject specialist- yes, that may be true, but that doesn't help if students have challenges/questions/misconceptions in the classroom AND it also increases the workload of that subject specialist.

If I'm teaching your child in Y11 who didn't have a science teacher last year, you probably want me to have time to put on revision sessions, to mark additional pieces of work, to really plan what I'm doing and tailor it to the gaps that class have... I can't do that if I'm producing KS3 resources for a non-specialist to use at the same time. If I'm teaching your child in Y10, and they don't have a specialist for all their lessons, then all the marking etc for that class falls to me. If I've spent all weekend marking more than "my share" of mocks, then the lesson I plan for the non-specialist to teach is probably not going to be my best work...

None of that is made up, by the way, it's a real situation I've been in.

BTW, they would have got qualified subject specialists at A-level, but a lot of the students in that Y11 class who wanted to do science A-levels ended up not being able to get the grades they needed to study them....

I've now left that school, moved to a school where it was promised I would only teach within specialism, but ended up this year teaching Y12 a niche A-level subject which I'm not qualified in at all. But the qualified teacher of the subject can't cover it, and the other option is an A-level class of 35. I know that I'm doing those students a disservice in lots of ways, but there isn't another option, really. IMO, the school probably shouldn't have run a second class of subject but equally we're the only school that offers it in a 20 mile radius, so that's also a hard decision to make.

I'm not happy about it, by the way, but it's not like there's someone else qualified waiting around to step in and teach that subject on something like a 0.1 timetable spread across 3-4 days a week...

I also think there's a lot of people on this thread acting like having no teachers in an inevitability- but it wasn't this way 5-10 years ago even. If serious action was taken on workload and pay, then we'd recruit, we'd retain more people for longer, and we'd maybe attract some skilled and experienced people back to the profession.

Belinda5 · 23/01/2024 18:56

This is what happens when you downgrade the teaching profession by introducing all sorts of unnecessary beaurocracy, failing to back them up against unreasonable complaints and aggression from parents and pupils and turning the job into one that takes up most of the teacher's free as well as working time.

People leave in droves.

Newbutoldfather · 23/01/2024 18:52

With the exception of medicine, which actually can be life and death, how concerned are you about other professionals having the relevant degree?

Lots of lawyers don’t have law degrees.

converseandjeans · 23/01/2024 18:52

@northlundunmum

The level of cynicism that this is just what it’s like now is deeply depressing.

Well teachers have been warning that there was a crisis for a while. It's more concerning for those with younger children. Those of us in our 50s will be gone & it's unlikely there will be teachers who stay in same school for more than a few years.

It would be really helpful if parents & the press were less critical.

Newbutoldfather · 23/01/2024 18:51

Timetabling is also tricky, especially in the state sector, where each pupil is allocated just over £5,000, aa you can’t afford to be overstaffed, with lots of teachers on light loads.

You can’t get a Geography teacher to just teach a few classes, so teachers with light loads, typically those with only A level subjects like economics and politics, are asked to take these classes.

It really isn’t an issue at KS3.

mumsneedwine · 23/01/2024 18:50

And they already are acting as GPs. And last night the government voted, behind closed doors, for the GMC to register them. So v difficult to tell not a real doctor. Not seen that in the press ? Wonder why.

mumsneedwine · 23/01/2024 18:49

@Answersunknown the PA situation is frankly terrifying. 2 years MSc then treating patients ? I want a 10 year trainee proper doctor thanks v much. But our government hate doctors too. People saying, if you don't like it then leave to them too. So they will.

cansu · 23/01/2024 18:47

What do you think is going to happen here? Oh Mrs X thinks there should be a teacher with a geography degree, let's get one. They are using the music teacher because they don't have the funds or the ability to recruit another specialist teacher. This is common. Some teachers can and do teach more than one subject, many are simply obliged to.

converseandjeans · 23/01/2024 18:46

@mumsneedwine

Well you see people said if you don't like the job, then leave. So they did.

Yes I don't think people understand how exhausting it is. Then add in the stress of OFSTED & criticism from all angles.

Yesterday there was a thread about a school taking a ski trip and asking the students to pack lunch. Mum was outraged at the idea & was going to demand to see the risk assessment. No wonder nobody wants to run a trip.

Answersunknown · 23/01/2024 18:45

Most schools have unqualified TA’s acting as teachers.
Soon unqualified PAs will be acting as GPs

Don’t vote Tory

Blah12345678999 · 23/01/2024 18:44

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/01/2024 18:42

It might help encourage the Tories to offer teachers more than the rumoured 1% pay rise this year- which might help keep a few more teachers in the profession. Otherwise, next year, maybe that music teacher has left, and your son is taught by a string of supply teachers etc.

FWIW, I agree it's probably pointless, but for the time it takes to write an email it might be worthwhile.

Less pointless then telling the school what they already know though!

Blah12345678999 · 23/01/2024 18:43

converseandjeans · 23/01/2024 18:41

@noblegiraffe

I’ve been posting about the teacher shortage crisis for years. I do wonder what people thought it meant

Yet Mumsnet still often has threads which complain about teachers. Apparently we have it too easy with all those early finishes & long holidays & don't forget the gold plated pension scheme 🤷🏻‍♀️

I don't think people realise that there really is a recruitment crisis. Not many young staff are staying more than a couple of years. Younger staff also won't go above & beyond for no pay. So all the trips & visits I see going out are older staff.

Just be thankful they have a teacher with them!

Yeap pretty much!! But people won’t believe it… 🤷🏻‍♀️

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/01/2024 18:42

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 17:34

Thanks so much for all replies - helpful to read others experiences and perspectives.

The level of cynicism that this is just what it’s like now is deeply depressing.

I do think I’ll talk to the school - not to complain but to just to flag that as a parent I don’t feel this is ideal (recognising the constraints they have) - if they believe parents care about this issue it may prompt them to look again at what they can do with what they have. But do recognise they can’t magic up non-existent teachers.

not sure writing to my (Tory) MP at this point in the political cycle will make a blind bit of difference. Usually I’m all for a bit of political activism. If I get door stepped by the Labour hopeful though I will make a point of the teaching crisis being an issue I very much care about.

It might help encourage the Tories to offer teachers more than the rumoured 1% pay rise this year- which might help keep a few more teachers in the profession. Otherwise, next year, maybe that music teacher has left, and your son is taught by a string of supply teachers etc.

FWIW, I agree it's probably pointless, but for the time it takes to write an email it might be worthwhile.

converseandjeans · 23/01/2024 18:41

@noblegiraffe

I’ve been posting about the teacher shortage crisis for years. I do wonder what people thought it meant

Yet Mumsnet still often has threads which complain about teachers. Apparently we have it too easy with all those early finishes & long holidays & don't forget the gold plated pension scheme 🤷🏻‍♀️

I don't think people realise that there really is a recruitment crisis. Not many young staff are staying more than a couple of years. Younger staff also won't go above & beyond for no pay. So all the trips & visits I see going out are older staff.

Just be thankful they have a teacher with them!

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/01/2024 18:40

WillowBarkTree · 23/01/2024 16:54

I was a school governor at a large secondary school in England about 5 years ago. The schools policy was for GCSE or A-Level the teacher had to have degree in subject. For years 7-9 they could teach subjects they had an A-Level in and related to degree. So for example, Chemistry degree would teach chemistry but might also do biology, in year 7-9, history degree might also do rs or geography in same years.

I would say this is now massively out of date. As a "science" teacher, I have taught all 3 sciences up to GCSE- one of which I only have a GCSE in myself. I have taught outside my specialism at Level 3 including teaching Y12 in a subject I have no qualifications in at all.

Often to, fill timetable gaps, people are teaching subjects to KS3 which they may have no qualifications in, and equally you have people teaching KS4 who may have only done a degree in the subject myself.

I do think Covid etc has changed a lot- things were definitely better 5 years ago, although in most schools most science teachers definitely taught all 3 sciences to GCSE.

noblegiraffe · 23/01/2024 18:38

If you have a shit geography teacher in KS3 you're not going to get anyone taking it for GCSE.

Newbutoldfather · 23/01/2024 18:36

@noblegiraffe ,

I’ve not heard that, no. Not sure where I would sit there. Where would Physics teachers go? A subject that (at least at A level) is half Maths anyway.

It is the ‘sage on the stage’ vs ‘the guide on the side’ debate. I am probably too much the former when I teach Physics (or Maths) but I try and become the latter when I am teaching enrichment (mix of humanities) or PSHE.

Ultimately, in Year 8, they are learning to be curious and how to think rather than laying down a large body of knowledge. It all gets retaught at GCSE anyway.

clarepetal · 23/01/2024 18:32

The school I work at is an academy. This happens a lot. Despite this, it's a great school and rated outstanding.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/01/2024 18:30

WearyAuldWumman · 23/01/2024 14:53

That might be true for England, but not for Scotland. (I agree - not necessarily relevant to this thread.)

However, in Scotland if a school cannot obtain a properly qualified teacher for a subject we are allowed to use a non-specialist until such time as we can find a subject specialist. (Certainly not ideal.) A specialist has to set the work for a non-specialist.

The rule here for secondary ed is that you are required to have a degree and that you must have studied your specialism at uni for at least two years. (You can also add to your qualifications later, via post-grad certificates.)

I'm qualified to teach three subjects - two that I studied at uni and one that I did as a post-grad.

To be fair in most schools in England, this does usually only happen because the school can't recruit. The difference is, perhaps, that even "nice" schools in average or maybe affluent towns can struggle to recruit for a particular vacancy for literally years. It's not usually SLT doing it for a laugh, or a teacher deciding to have a stab at something random just for fun.

Sometimes it's also done to fill awkward gaps on the timetable, e.g. you've got an ECT in geography this year, so there's one class they can't teach for this year only, but next year they can up their hours. It's very difficult to find someone in England to take on 0.1/0.2.

The work is normally set by a specialist, but this just puts additional work on specialist teachers, and leads to them leaving, making the problem worse. The bigger issue IMO is also marking- if assessments aren't marked by a specialist, then often key points are missed and students come through the year with misconceptions and gaps that take a long time to sort out!

I do agree it would be better to have official rules around this, but schools aren't usually doing it for fun.

CaptainMyCaptain · 23/01/2024 18:29

mumsneedwine · 23/01/2024 18:21

Well you see people said if you don't like the job, then leave. So they did.

This.

noblegiraffe · 23/01/2024 18:27

Newbutoldfather · 23/01/2024 18:21

@noblegiraffe ,

Depends on the Maths teacher.

I was (maybe am still, but not working this year) a Physics teacher, and I have taught loads of bits and pieces when I wasn’t fully loaded.

And I prepared carefully, mastered my brief and the lessons were effective (yes, that is my assessment, but I am quite harsh on myself). It really isn’t hard.

Have you ever heard the suggestion that maths teachers should have different INSET sessions to the rest of the teachers because what is useful for most staff is largely a waste of time for maths?

Yeah, so we don't need to get kids to write extended pieces of writing. We don't need to facilitate debates. We don't need to do textual analyses. I don't even really know what PPE paragraphs are. Sentence starters? Not relevant. Improving your writing? Not relevant.

So I'd be a shit humanities teacher. Now I could obviously have extensive training to get up to speed, but schools don't have the time or money for that sort of thing so you are just dropped into it.

StragglyTinsel · 23/01/2024 18:27

There’s probably a fair bit of history in your average music degree, I’d guess.

The music teacher may actually have a degree that meets the criteria for entry to a history PGCE anyway.

sharptoothlemonshark · 23/01/2024 18:26

Very few maths teachers have maths degrees in my experience. You could earn a lot of money with a maths degree, teaching is not an attractive alternative

StragglyTinsel · 23/01/2024 18:25

noblegiraffe · 23/01/2024 18:17

Just about any decent teacher with a degree, regardless of subject, could teach a humanities subject to a year 8.

A maths teacher couldn't.

Some of them probably could.

But they would probably be a long way down the list for asking, given that the education system isn’t exactly awash with maths teachers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread