Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my child to be taught by a teacher with a degree in that subject?

561 replies

northlundunmum · 23/01/2024 12:59

My child is in year 8 and in their school
has “Humanities” which is history and geography combined rather than taught separately- not great in my view but ok. However, this year they are being taught by a music teacher. No doubt a very talented musician but according to my child they admit not being very good at teaching history or geography.

I do understand there are teacher shortages and sometimes some teachers will have to cover for others but this seems to be a permanent arrangement at least for this year.

Does anybody know what the DfE / Ofsted rules / guidance are on this? I understand you have to have a degree in a subject in order to train to teach it at secondary level (or at least used to) - does that not extend to actually teaching the subject in school?

Grateful for advice from anyone who knows the law / regulations here as want to approach the school about it and want to be clear what’s reasonable to expect and what they should in fact be doing according to govt policy.

Thank you!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PeloFan91 · 24/01/2024 15:15

To be honest, they’re actually very lucky to have a permanent teacher in the room. Teacher recruitment and retention is in such a state that many won’t even be that lucky. Not that it’s right.

You only need an A Level in a subject to train to teach it and then once you’re qualified they can technically ask you to teach anything.

The teacher probably isn’t very happy about it either, but they’re better with someone who is permanent staff with planned lessons than lots of cover.

Cricketmadmum · 24/01/2024 15:14

I’m not sure it has ever been a requirement to have a subject degree to teach it. Back in the 80s, my (excellent) chemistry teacher actually had a maths degree.

treacletoffee23 · 24/01/2024 15:05

Everyone would like their children taught by subject specialists- although just because you have a Maths Degree it doesn’t mean you can teach
Unfortunately this and previous Governments have de- professionalised Teaching and made it an unattractive career, experienced Teachers are more expensive, and in some schools have been replaced by Classroom Assistants. Until parents and Government start to value the education of our next generations, things will get worse

MummyLK · 24/01/2024 14:57

As a teacher myself (primary trained, now working in a secondary), I completely agree that there should be a teacher who is an 'expert' in the subject teaching it, and I live and work in Scotland where this simply wouldn't be allowed. On the point of history and geography being taught together, I'm okay with. In Scotland in the first few years of secondary school, they're called social subjects and are all taught together. The different disciplines all interlink pretty closely and, if taught by a subject teacher, being taught together could increase understanding of the subject 🙂

CharlotteBog · 24/01/2024 10:31

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/01/2024 22:05

This is sadly really common, and I think it causes kids to disengage with education because they don't have invested class teachers or specialist support.

I also think it has a massive negative impact on behaviour when students bounce from supply teacher to cover lesson and back again- even when they see a permanent class teacher.

Those students will unfortunately also go into Y11 with massive gaps, and even if they get a permanent specialist teacher, it may be too late to address the issues they are facing.

I don't know why, but this made me a bit tearful. My son's school experience (like so many others) has been such a mess.
Year 6 was hard lockdown - so no end of Primary school things and hideous remote learning (primary schools really were not set up for this), no residential etc.
Year 7 was spent socially distancing with masks in school. Year 8 was partly the same. No football, no enjoyable lunches and playtimes.
Year 9 was spent reading how wonderful it was that the school was fully open and how the new yr 7s and 8s could do all the fun stuff.
Strikes meant only the exam year students went in. Year 9s stayed at home.
I was hopeful things would improve in yr 10; that the resources would be directed towards yr10 and yr11.
He has had one trip since year 5 - a day at Thorpe Park.

He is happy enough at school, but education wise, he is disengaged with so many subjects. Supply teachers come in and tell them to 'get on with your work' or 'do page 7-11 in your work book' ie there is no actual teaching.
The correlation in his effort, behaviour and attainment between subjects with stable subject teachers and those with a string of supply teachers is very, very clear.

I do not blame the school or the teachers.

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 10:31

MrsHamlet · 24/01/2024 10:23

Wow. I hope the poster who thinks teaching is just clicking PowerPoints doesn't teach my kids.

I suspect there was an element of irony in there........

We were taught History at both O and A level with a large amount of Powerpoint's granddad the Overhead Projector. The teacher needed to know the subject though, style very much that of a University Lecturer - this was a Grammar School.

I suspect at yr 7/8 level while there's a absolute need to have the skills and aptitudes of a teacher, all that stuff about how kids learn that (used to be?) part of the PGCE, subject knowledge may be no more than being a few pages ahead of the kids.

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2024 10:30

She seems to think that cover lessons are teaching.

At my school cover set needs to not require any specialist subject knowledge because of course a maths teacher can't teach a French lesson if they don't know French. Same for any other subject knowledge.

I'm sure she'll find out when she gets back from maternity leave just exactly how much maths teaching those poor Y7s have had.

CaptainMyCaptain · 24/01/2024 10:27

MrsHamlet · 24/01/2024 10:23

Wow. I hope the poster who thinks teaching is just clicking PowerPoints doesn't teach my kids.

I'll give her the benefit of the doubt and assume she was talking about prepared cover lessons not all lessons.

MrsHamlet · 24/01/2024 10:23

Wow. I hope the poster who thinks teaching is just clicking PowerPoints doesn't teach my kids.

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2024 10:13

Yes I could and do- it's mostly just PowerPoint clicking!

Blimey, do you think maths teaching is mostly just PowerPoint clicking or is it only humanities teachers you're insulting here?

Stressedoutforever · 24/01/2024 10:06

noblegiraffe · 23/01/2024 18:17

Just about any decent teacher with a degree, regardless of subject, could teach a humanities subject to a year 8.

A maths teacher couldn't.

Yes I could and do- it's mostly just PowerPoint clicking! A good teacher can stand in front of a class and teach (that's why we all do cover..)

I have an economics degree but teach maths, only up to GCSE as we don't have a sixth form. I'm due to return from maternity leave soon and since September my classes have all been taught by whoever is avaliable. One class of year 7s has 5 different teachers over the two week timetable including PE, art and science but not a single maths teacher.

noblegiraffe · 24/01/2024 10:00

And the real problem with all of this is it's not going to get any better, and it is definitely about to get a lot worse.

The government missed its secondary teacher training target for September 2023 by fifty percent.

Job adverts going out now are going to be unfilled for September because there won't be the ECTs to take them up. The number of vacancies is set to increase, the workload caused by a lack of subject specialists will increase.

And this in turn will cause more teachers to quit.

Those figures are locked in.

Kigali78 · 24/01/2024 09:00

My degree is psychology and my PGCE is in teaching ks2&3 science.

As well as those subjects, I’ve taught (and examined) sociology at A level, philosophy and ethics (a level) health and social care (level 3) child development, GCSE, TOK (IB), geography (ks3) EPQ (level 3/AS)

Teaching outside your specialism is very common!

WombatChocolate · 24/01/2024 08:49

ThanksItHasPockets · 23/01/2024 23:07

Independent schools are leaving the teachers’ pension scheme in their droves, making the remuneration package much less appealing. The independent sector is rapidly losing its cushion against the national staffing crisis.

I agree. Independent schools will be losing the small cushion they have. Teaching in all settings looks increasingly bleak as a career option, or certainly as a long term one. I’d imagine they will continue to struggle to recruit trainees but some will also ways sign-up due to a desire to make a difference. However, the reality of working in chronically under-funded schools and excessive workloads will mean few stay long.

I imagine that those with children just starting school now, might see quite a different kind of teaching and schooling by the time they leave education. The government just isn’t willing to pay and fund what is required to resource schools and pay proper qualified professionals.

Blah12345678999 · 23/01/2024 23:33

I think the government needs to address the teaching issue, this is the reality. I didn’t want to leave but I just found out everything bad about the profession was true and more. One retired teacher told me if there weren’t school holidays you would die, and I remembered thinking: Christ, I believe you. I think it’s probably a sign it’s not the place to spend your life working in sadly. If I could afford to volunteer just to teach (only teaching, non of the bureaucracy etc) I’d do it though so maybe one day I’ll be able to pay it back that way! My qualifications don’t expire (they stopped the time limit on that due to the crisis) so if the education sector improves dramatically I’d think about
going back then!

ThanksItHasPockets · 23/01/2024 23:18

Blah12345678999 · 23/01/2024 23:07

Yeah, I did a career change into teaching, it was reasonably ‘easy’ in that they were wanting to recruit teachers. I managed to get a non-qualified teacher salary along with my fees all paid for, but I knew during the course I couldn’t do teaching as a profession as it wasn’t good and I didn’t want to end up having a nervous breakdown which was the only career trajectory I could see happening in teaching sadly 😔 , lots of other people from my course who got the salary and fees paid for have also left or gone private or abroad, the package came to £30k for each of us, I believe government money… Well spent eh 🤷🏻‍♀️ maybe the ones who paid for the PGCE etc stayed on longer… On the positive side by doing the course I got exposed to another much more lucrative and less stressful career which I’ve stayed in ever since!

Edited

You could always pay it back 🤷🏻‍♀️. I imagine they take cheques.

Blah12345678999 · 23/01/2024 23:07

RotundCheese · 23/01/2024 21:09

I know several PhDs/former post-docs who now teach at secondary. PCGE is only a year, and you get a good bursary - it's an easier road than most career changes.

Yeah, I did a career change into teaching, it was reasonably ‘easy’ in that they were wanting to recruit teachers. I managed to get a non-qualified teacher salary along with my fees all paid for, but I knew during the course I couldn’t do teaching as a profession as it wasn’t good and I didn’t want to end up having a nervous breakdown which was the only career trajectory I could see happening in teaching sadly 😔 , lots of other people from my course who got the salary and fees paid for have also left or gone private or abroad, the package came to £30k for each of us, I believe government money… Well spent eh 🤷🏻‍♀️ maybe the ones who paid for the PGCE etc stayed on longer… On the positive side by doing the course I got exposed to another much more lucrative and less stressful career which I’ve stayed in ever since!

ThanksItHasPockets · 23/01/2024 23:07

WombatChocolate · 23/01/2024 22:23

Many independent schools struggle to recruit and retain teachers too. The amount of teachers available, especially some subjects is in massive decline.

That said, most independent schools have more classes taught by subject specialists and see a lower turn-over of staff. Those that pay more clearly attract staff, plus the longer holidays and generally better behaviour and resourcing makes it more attractive, even if the hours can be extremely long. But then, this is hardly surprising is it?

Teachers might be motivated to teach and make a difference, but it’s not surprising that places that pay better and have better conditions might attract them. People who can pay think the specialist teachers and continuity make a difference. Few children in the state sector will get through their GCSEs with the same set of teachers they started out with.

It does feel like we are going back towards a Victorian system, of a small number of teachers, and then ‘monitors’ who back then were teenagers supervising the class, but today are increasingly TAs or cover supervisors. Given that the government is only prepared to fund schools to the level that fewer teachers can be attracted and afforded, that will be the future.

Definitely ask your children - how many lessons had a cover teacher this week or today. Ask how many changes if teacher have they had this year. Ask if their teacher teaches lots of subjects and if they teach A Level in the subject they are teaching them.

Independent schools are leaving the teachers’ pension scheme in their droves, making the remuneration package much less appealing. The independent sector is rapidly losing its cushion against the national staffing crisis.

Passingthethyme · 23/01/2024 22:26

That would annoy me greatly! But I'm guessing that's the best they can get, very depressing if this is the future

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 23/01/2024 22:25

My DC's school appears to be able to, though I assume it is unusual as they make a point of telling us that all the Science departments are fully staffed by specialist teachers

My school too. No problem recruiting well-qualified teachers in all subjects. But it's an excellent girls' grammar school (the onmy one in the area), so no mystery there. Whereas my Y11 ds has had lessons in the main hall with multiple other classes in the last few weeks due to teacher shortages/absence/lack of available supply teachers.

WombatChocolate · 23/01/2024 22:23

Many independent schools struggle to recruit and retain teachers too. The amount of teachers available, especially some subjects is in massive decline.

That said, most independent schools have more classes taught by subject specialists and see a lower turn-over of staff. Those that pay more clearly attract staff, plus the longer holidays and generally better behaviour and resourcing makes it more attractive, even if the hours can be extremely long. But then, this is hardly surprising is it?

Teachers might be motivated to teach and make a difference, but it’s not surprising that places that pay better and have better conditions might attract them. People who can pay think the specialist teachers and continuity make a difference. Few children in the state sector will get through their GCSEs with the same set of teachers they started out with.

It does feel like we are going back towards a Victorian system, of a small number of teachers, and then ‘monitors’ who back then were teenagers supervising the class, but today are increasingly TAs or cover supervisors. Given that the government is only prepared to fund schools to the level that fewer teachers can be attracted and afforded, that will be the future.

Definitely ask your children - how many lessons had a cover teacher this week or today. Ask how many changes if teacher have they had this year. Ask if their teacher teaches lots of subjects and if they teach A Level in the subject they are teaching them.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 23/01/2024 22:05

CharlotteBog · 23/01/2024 20:40

Out of 5 lessons today, my son had supply teachers for 4 of them. He's year 10.

This is sadly really common, and I think it causes kids to disengage with education because they don't have invested class teachers or specialist support.

I also think it has a massive negative impact on behaviour when students bounce from supply teacher to cover lesson and back again- even when they see a permanent class teacher.

Those students will unfortunately also go into Y11 with massive gaps, and even if they get a permanent specialist teacher, it may be too late to address the issues they are facing.

RotundCheese · 23/01/2024 21:09

C1N1C · 23/01/2024 13:15

I'm curious what people would prefer now that you've raised it...

Would you (as parents) prefer a highly qualified person (e.g. a PhD) with zero teaching experience/qualifications... or someone like the OP mentioned, a qualified teacher with 'some' knowledge of the subject?

The reason I ask is because I've considered teaching in the past (PhD), but I would hate to go through further training. Given the teaching shortage, what are the mum's views?

I know several PhDs/former post-docs who now teach at secondary. PCGE is only a year, and you get a good bursary - it's an easier road than most career changes.

CharlotteBog · 23/01/2024 20:40

Out of 5 lessons today, my son had supply teachers for 4 of them. He's year 10.

Shinyandnew1 · 23/01/2024 20:04

l very rarely had a substitute teacher and my teachers seemed knowledgeable in their subjects 15 years ago

I wonder what’s been happening over the last 14 years…