Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend’s comment

64 replies

Skyiscrying · 23/01/2024 12:55

Feeling a bit meh about a comment a friend made to me. She is a parent to one school age child and was saying about how hard things are with said child in terms of school runs, things for school, dress up days, clubs, homework etc. I said I understand how hard it all is. She said I couldn’t understand and despite me explaining the following, she said I don’t have kids and I couldn’t possibly understand.

I don’t have kids, but I am a nanny. My nanny kids are both in KS1 and their parents are 2 paediatric junior doctors in a hospital who work very long hours. This is absolutely no judgement as they do a vital job, but they take over about an hour before bed time and I will have the kids all sorted out ready for some quality time without them needing to do anything else. Within the day I do school runs, pick ups, go back and forth to their clubs, bath the children, cook their tea and prepare any snacks, battling with them to do the home work and reading everyday, get them dressed for bed and do the evenings dishes. I also take on the things the parents don’t have the time for, preparing costumes (their school has SO many ‘dress like X’ days), preparing activities etc. Any of you with multiple children will understand what it’s like trying to do homework with one child and the other is having a tantrum, wanting something else or just generally needing attention.

I don’t get home till 7.30pm and then I have to feed myself and do all the necessary things to run my own house. AIBU to think she’s ignorant to how much work my job is? No they aren’t my kids but I spend more time with them than anyone else I know and I’m doing everything but bed times. I don’t get to have lazy days either as it’s what I’m paid to do, there’s no leaving dishes till the morning or just watching a film for the evening and calling it a day.

It’s not the first time people with children have told me have told me I don’t understand what it’s like to have kids. I’ve cared for children longer than any of my friends have had them.

OP posts:
Skyiscrying · 23/01/2024 13:36

BIinkii · 23/01/2024 13:14

You have a good idea, you don't know totally. I think the best comment in this situation from you would be "its hard enough for me I imagine it's harder for you as I switch off, you dont".

Edited

I took on a family members young child for 2 years as their parents were unable to care for them. The family thought I would be best qualified to take this on. All the washing, tantrums, bed times etc. is that good enough for you?

OP posts:
SweetBirdsong · 23/01/2024 13:36

I am with your friend. You may be a nanny, but it is in NO WAY like having children of your own. She's right. YABU.

s4usagefingers · 23/01/2024 13:35

I used to be a nanny and now have a baby of my own. Whilst nannying is an extra challenge in some ways (having to always go the extra mile because you are being paid to educate and take care, be constantly switched on, bite your tongue when it’s none of your business etc.) it really isn’t the same as being a parent.

Being a parent is more emotionally, physically, mentally draining as you are so much more invested in this child than you are your charges. Also the responsibility level is just so much higher when it is your own. A nanny is ‘help’. I’ve no doubt you work extremely hard and often people don’t realise how difficult a job it can be but it is difficult in a different way.

noooooooo · 23/01/2024 13:32

I got pulled up by a friend for saying ‘it’s different for parents’ - he said it was dismissive. I assumed he and his wife were CFBC and now I know not, so I just don’t say this stuff in case it offends.

I do still (secretly) think unless you’re a parent you don’t understand the particular pressure (obviously non-parents can have valuable insights into raising kids and do experience many pressures of their own).

CharmedCult · 23/01/2024 13:27

You do it as a job. You get to go home and leave it all behind afterwards.

I don’t get to have lazy days

Yes you do, on the days you’re not working.

Riverlee · 23/01/2024 13:23

The initial comment by your friend was just a letting off steam comment and nothing more and probably didn’t deserve any further comment.

However, after explaining your situation, she should have realised that you do have a fair idea of what school runs etc all involve and not pulled the ‘I’m a parent, you’re not’ top trump card.

BIinkii · 23/01/2024 13:20

IamnotSethRogan · 23/01/2024 13:17

I think it's best to sometimes let friends say this sort of thing, and understand that it is cathartic for them to say it.

It sounds like all op said was "Oh yeah I know what you mean" which sounds pretty non committal and not trying to make it a competition.

No, OP said I understand how hard it all is.

IamnotSethRogan · 23/01/2024 13:17

I think it's best to sometimes let friends say this sort of thing, and understand that it is cathartic for them to say it.

It sounds like all op said was "Oh yeah I know what you mean" which sounds pretty non committal and not trying to make it a competition.

BIinkii · 23/01/2024 13:14

You have a good idea, you don't know totally. I think the best comment in this situation from you would be "its hard enough for me I imagine it's harder for you as I switch off, you dont".

CoffeeMachineNewbie · 23/01/2024 13:14

I think you have a great understanding of the work involved in kids.

But imagine picking up another job on top of that.

I have 2 KS1 kids and i have to do all those things you do, as well as work another FT job into the mix and do the bedtime hour and admin to run a home.

As do many parents. I think that's all your friend was getting at.

applepiesain · 23/01/2024 13:13

I think it's best to sometimes let friends say this sort of thing, and understand that it is cathartic for them to say it.
In this sort of situation, your relationship as friends takes precedent to who is "right" on a given topic.
Obviously there could very well be issues where a disagreement is more important to one of you than your friendship, possibly fundamental moral differences let's say, but it's not the case here.

In answer to your question. Yes and no. Yes, you have a fair idea in practical terms, but No because when the children are not your children you don't have the emotional energy/overwhelming sense of responsibility for a lifetime/ worry/overhaul of your own childhood and relationship with your parents/ love/hurt/ that goes along with raising them and this can take up a load of extra energy.

Skyiscrying · 23/01/2024 13:09

BIinkii · 23/01/2024 12:58

But you get to leave and go home at night. Your friend is 24/7. What about weekends? It's definitely not a competition.

I’m not saying it’s the same level. I’m annoyed that she says I don’t understand what it’s like to do all of the child related running around. I work weekends too.

Im not making it a competition.

OP posts:
Zanatdy · 23/01/2024 12:59

Well I think you have a good idea

BIinkii · 23/01/2024 12:58

But you get to leave and go home at night. Your friend is 24/7. What about weekends? It's definitely not a competition.