Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Traumatic event, my child won't talk about it

38 replies

Rosemary1981 · 23/01/2024 12:09

We were at a friends house last week and her husband had a major heart attack.

Unfortunately the children saw it all, thankfully he is in hospital doing well but not quite out the woods yet.

We are doing all we can to be supportive, and offering practical help with shopping, and meals ect, as well as emotional support to them all.

Unfortunately my own child won't talk about it, child is under 8 and just keeps saying "I'm fine".

I am still very shaken up about it myself, so I can't imagine what it must have all looked like for a child. I am worried.

We are all very close friends, I asked my child if they wanted to make a get well card, in a hope they might have questions or to open up a conversation but they said they didn't want to.

This is very unusual for my child. I'm not sure what I'm looking for here. I guess I just need to hold on a little and keep a very close eye, I feel like they are in shock and have shut down.

Has anyone been through similar and can offer advice thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ohtowinthelottery · 23/01/2024 17:00

I saw my friend get knocked over by a van around the age of 10. She was running for the school bus (we were at Middle School and caught a public service bus the 3 miles home). I witnessed her lying on the road not moving. The ambulance came and took her off the hospital. I got the bus home, walked into the house, burst into tears and blubbed to my mother what had happened. She picked up the phone and rang the hospital who reported that my friend was alive and now conscious. (Good old days before data protection/GDPR).
She thankfully survived with no lasting ill effects. I wouldn't say it traumatised me. Upset for a while - yes. Still remember it like it was yesterday. Even pointed out the spot where it happened to my DH on a visit to my home town. But I've never lost any sleep over it.

ginasevern · 23/01/2024 16:56

If you keep pushing this I think you will traumatise your child. Children see things in black and white. Their minds are not as complex as adults. We'd be thinking about the potentially widowed wife, how she would pay the mortgage, deal with the children and a million other things. A child will see someone ill drop to the floor and get taken to hospital. Upsetting yes. Traumatising, no. Besides, you can't wrap them in cotton wool.

When I was six my father had a massive heart attack which I witnessed. The only thing I really remember is him collapsing, all hell breaking loose and me being taken in my pyjamas to sleep with a neighbour. I slept in the same room as my best friend next door that night and we giggled the night away.

notlucreziaborgia · 23/01/2024 14:37

It may not have been at all traumatizing for him, and he’s not talking about it because there’s nothing to talk about.

Two people can have the same experience and have vastly different reactions to it. What will traumatize one person won’t even register with someone else, and that’s normal human variation.

It can be incredibly frustrating to have someone basically disregard you, project upon you what they believe you should be thinking/feeling, and accuse you of kidding yourself/burying your real feelings because they can’t comprehend that an entirely different person isn’t the same as them. Ime it also means that in the event that something does happen that bothers you, that they’re going to be the last person you’d trust to respect and support you.

Stompythedinosaur · 23/01/2024 14:30

Things that age don't process through talking, they process through play.

I wouldn't push it, give them time.

SKG231 · 23/01/2024 14:03

Children see and think about things alot differently to adults. To us we are thinking oh gosh he could have died, what will life be like for him now, how will they pay the mortgage etc.

but to your child this man was poorly, went to hospital and is now going to be ok.

SophieinParis · 23/01/2024 13:56

They’re fine! Don’t project!
The world of adults is often quite distant to children. A grown up got ill, went to hospital, grown up is now fine

CharlotteMakepeace · 23/01/2024 13:50

Children don't have the same comprehension that adults do.

Stop trying to inflict trauma and drama on your child when there is none.

You were upset and still are as you understand that he could have died and you. Will have thoughts about him, his wife and children and your own mortality etc.

Your child probably saw it as an inconvenience that you had to go home early.

VampireWeekday · 23/01/2024 13:41

As a child I watched someone we knew (older man) fall over and smack his head on the pavement, blood everywhere, ambulance called. My friend who was with me was very shook up, I wasn't at all. In my head he had been taken care of in hospital and so was absolutely fine.

BananasInThreePieceSuits · 23/01/2024 13:39

You are ascribing adult emotions and feelings to a child and trying to push them to talk about something that probably hasn’t bothered them.

Please just drop it.

Klcak · 23/01/2024 13:35

For a young child, and I suppose your child is on the cusp of youngness/decent understanding, I would probably make quite light of it and this is possible because it wasn't fatal and the friend's dh is improving. I agree that your child may well be completely fine - he hasn't got the understanding of an adult and you can just tell him X is doing well and don't press him anymore. Certainly don't let him see any of your trauma from it - be more breezy about it. It shouldn't affect him day to day as it isn't a member of his own household/class etc that he sees all the time.

TortillaChipAddict · 23/01/2024 13:28

My daughter witnessed her younger sister having seizures two years ago, she was four at the time she witnessed them. It was traumatic for her, especially because of the panic the first time it happened as we initially thought her younger sister was dead, and the waiting for the ambulance and seeing how stressed we were about it. The next one was also fairly traumatic and unexpected. She didn’t want to talk about it initially, then went through a phase of asking the same questions repeatedly about the incidents, often ones that wouldn’t occur to me to ask. She had some counselling at school which helped a lot but is still quite on edge and anxious when she thinks her sister is unwell, as the seizures were febrile. Although I was older, a teenager, my family went through a difficult time and everybody just said oh kids are resilient, she will be fine. I wasn’t, but I think it would have been a lot easier if I had know there was somebody to talk to about it if I needed it.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 23/01/2024 13:12

Stressfordays · 23/01/2024 12:13

At under 8, I can well imagine it is very black and white for them. The person got poorly, went to hospital and are now ok. They may well 'be fine'. I'd leave them to it and let them come to you if needs be. But keep making a lot out of it won't help, especially if they have just taken it in their stride. Children are very resilient.

This. He may very well be fine. As adults, we think about what the outcome might have been, but children don't.

bobomomo · 23/01/2024 13:08

Kids can be affected by things we don't realise are a big deal (dead animal on the road) yet seem indifferent to serious illness, it's not always logical to us. Remember as far as your child is concerned, the friend was ill, went to hospital and the drs have fixed him - you know it's a lot more complex but your child doesn't understand the nuances of heart damage following heart attacks!

Just answer questions but I wouldn't overly worry

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2024 13:05

I'd just clarify that children are more likely to be traumatised by the kind of illness / injury we're talking about in this thread if it happens to their parents (or other primary caregiver).

Primary caregivers are so central to the identify and psychological safety of children that frankly a lot could happen to other people, even siblings, without it being felt as a major trauma but things that impact their parents or their relationship with their parents have a significantly amplified impact.

That's why, for example, if a child has a sibling with a serious illness and they happen to grow up with some mental health issues as a result, it will usually be because they felt less important / less of a priority to their parents than the ill sibling as opposed to any kind of trauma from witnessing the sibling's illness/treatment.

It seems quite self-absorbed on the face of it but it's because we're so strongly wired as children that our survival depends on our bond with our parents.

See also; why any form of abandonment, any perceived emotional neglect/harsh criticism, etc by parents can lead to quite significant and long lasting mental health impacts which can (sometimes) seem out of proportion with the severity the adults at that time feel it should have.

ShortColdandGrey · 23/01/2024 12:58

Give them a while to process. Our beloved pet died at the beginning of December and our almost 8 year old didn't want to talk about it and kept asking me why I was crying. They have now broken down a few times over the loss and last night were very upset. I think they just need a wee while to process it themselves and when they are ready the floodgates open.

lola8345 · 23/01/2024 12:57

My ex saw similar at that age. It made him decide to become a doctor.
She might be fine, she might need some time to process.

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2024 12:56

Just as an interesting point it's also why childhood trauma is so damaging in adulthood.

Children aren't able to process things that happen to them in the same way and so any significant trauma gets stored in the subconscious / a different area of the brain.

I believe there are MRI scans that show that childhood memories are stored in a different structure/area but would have to look this up to confirm.

The prevailing theory is that it's more 'embedded' in the subconscious and influences much more of our mental health, behaviour and thinking patterns than going through a similar level of trauma would as an adult.

It's also harder to treat and (usually) requires a fair amount of therapy - because being subconscious there's a serious amount of work to even become aware of how it's impacted you, let alone to change it.

(By trauma here I mean more significant trauma than this incident and usually things related to primary caregivers as that's what is important to children far beyond anything else).

Deliaskis · 23/01/2024 12:55

I agree with others your child may not be traumatised by it at all....for some it's quite matter of fact - person was ill, ambulance came, person in hospital, person gets better. Children don't think through all of the ramifications and the what ifs that we do.

I don't think you need to keep asking, just keep it light, and respond factually if your child has questions.

ohtowinthelottery · 23/01/2024 12:53

As others have said, children take it more at face value than adults. Adult got ill, ambulance arrived, adult went to hospital, adult getting treatment. They don't understand the wider implications of the illness.

My DS grew up seeing his DSis having many prolonged seizures and being carted off to the hospital on a blue light. On a few occasions he had to come with us in the ambulance as no-one around to have him - so he also witnessed the emergency care in resus! He has never been traumatised by it. One of the neighbour's DCs once remarked 'oh look, there's little lottery's ambulance ' to his parent and then carried on playing.

Thehamsterthatcametotea · 23/01/2024 12:53

I think that it’s important to be led by your child. Don’t place any expectations of how she should and shouldn’t react. She might be fine but not in a few months. She might not be fine but not want to talk about it yet.

Don’t hide your feelings about your experience, it won’t hurt her to know that Mummy was scared.

BluJanuary · 23/01/2024 12:50

Might not be a 'big thing' to such a small child. They probably are wondering if it should be, with the way you're acting.

SarcasmAndCoffee · 23/01/2024 12:49

something similar happened with my (then 6 year old) dc. There was a gang related stabbing outside our house and dc saw the aftermath as we arrived just after it had happened on the way home from school, There was blood all over the pavement, splattered up the walls and he saw the victim being put into the ambulance. It was very traumatic and as soon as we realised what was happening i turned dc away so he didn’t keep watching. Dc saw the knife which had been left.

it took him a while to talk about it and I just told him I’m here when he’s ready and eventually we spoke and I answered all his questions honestly. He’s luckily not suffered any long term trauma from it. We speak very openly which is important in these situations.

just reassure dc that your there whenever they are ready to talk but don’t push. Glad the person is recovering

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 23/01/2024 12:49

My kid (6) has experienced a number of losses - we lost three grandparents in a relatively short space of time. At the time of each she seemed fine. It's come out in bits and bobs over time. There hasn't been a major breakdown or reaction but moments of sadness. Sometimes with me, sometimes at school. I would tip school off, and be open to talking about it if your kid brings it up, but I wouldn't force it. Watch and wait sounds right!

wheresmymojo · 23/01/2024 12:46

KreedKafer · 23/01/2024 12:21

If if helps, when I was 9 I witnessed my own father drop to the floor and have a major seizure, and I was also fine as soon as I knew he was alive and doing well.

The last thing I’d have wanted would be people trying to get me to keep talking about it, really. Yes it was frightening and awful while it was happening, but I didn’t want or need to dwell on it once he was recovered.

I think some people - both kids and adults - do just prefer to process most of their feelings quietly by themselves. The important thing is that your child knows they can talk to you if they want to. So I wouldn’t push it and I wouldn’t worry about it. If they want to talk, they’ll do it when they’re ready, and if they don’t, that’s fine.

Yep. My Granddad had a heart attack in front of me when I was about the same age.

I calmly flicked to the page of my Brownies guide book on first aid. Gave him some aspirin while my Nan called the ambulance.

Didn't feel shaken by it at all. Often younger children can be a bit more like animals - they tend to live in the present moment.

You're shaken because you're relating it to 'what ifs' and perhaps people in your own life and how short life can be, how it can change in a blink of an eye, how his wife/children would be now if it had been fatal. None of that is in the 'present moment' and so probably isn't crossing his mind.

IMO one of the reasons teenage years are often so emotionally raw is that it's when our brain starts to live outside the present moment more so we have an adjustment period of ruminating on past mistakes and being anxious about the future because we didn't experience those kind of thoughts and feelings before then.

EverleighMay · 23/01/2024 12:44

When I was 8 my teacher dropped down dead in the classroom, or so we thought at the time, he had actually just fainted and turned out that it was the start of a leukemia journey, we never seen him again and all assumed he was dead!

Some kids were screaming but others including me just left the grown ups to deal with it and got on with our day.

Your child is probably not as affected as adults will be, I would suggest business as usual if they aren't giving cause for concern.

Swipe left for the next trending thread