Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel guilty I have indoor cats?

113 replies

Mycatlivesindoors · 23/01/2024 10:29

My DS is autistic and was desperate for a ragdoll kitten. They have been described as being great “therapy” cats due to their calm and devoted nature. DS has had a difficult time at secondary school (he’s 12) and he researched ragdolls thoroughly, showing me lots of articles and videos about how lovely they are and how they really help people with their mental health.

I also researched the breed and read how most of them don’t really like going outside as they are quite “lazy” cats and like to spend their time with their owners. More importantly everything I read said they should NEVER go outside as they are too dumb to navigate roads, will let strangers pick them up, get lost etc etc

I bought 2 sibling kittens from a reputable breeder so they would always have a friend, someone to play with. They have lots of toys, we play with them constantly but all they want to do is go outside. It probably doesn’t help that our house layout is such that they are surrounded by glass overlooking the garden. It’s the only thing they see. As a result they both cry and wail to go outside.

After months of listening to them crying and howling by the door I took them outside, supervised. They loved it. I have been taking them out twice a day and they run up and down, watch the birds and generally have a lovely time. However our garden is not cat proof. It means DS and I have to “guard” the areas where they could escape. Last week one of them shot through a tiny hole in the hedge into next doors garden. Luckily we got her back but ever since the two of them spend all their time trying to escape.

I have had quotes from companies to catproof the garden but it is expensive and we are planning to move in the next year or so, so I can’t really justify the expense. I am now wary about taking them out in the garden as it is inevitable they will escape again! I have blocked the hole in the fence but they have now started on a new area in the garden trying to jump the wall.

I feel so guilty about keeping them indoors. But I’ve been told by so many people that if they get out the garden some awful fate will befall them because ragdolls should never be allowed to roam free.

I wish I’d just bought a cat that can go outside now, listening to 2 ragdolls howling at the door all day is so stressful.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Octavia64 · 23/01/2024 12:30

I have three pedigree cats that are often considered indoor cats.

They are very very very stupid.

They all wanted to go out.

They all got lost.

They all now have collars with AirTags so I can go and get them when they get lost (frequently).

However a lot depends on your environment - I am on a very quiet cul de sac in a very quiet housing estate. Very little traffic no foxes etc.

If you are on a main road it's a bit different.

Baldieheid · 23/01/2024 12:29

https://catiospaces.com/catios-cat-enclosures/

Baldieheid · 23/01/2024 12:27

Id sort out a Catio with direct access from a window or door in your situation. Make sure you check it regularly for gaps.

Marmunia106675 · 23/01/2024 12:25

Don't feel bad. We have an indoor cat who is 16. She is terrified of going outside anyway and is timid. She loves her home comforts.

Mooshroo · 23/01/2024 12:24

Protectapet changed my cats life! He’s so happy now. We got the DIY fence brackets and whilst it doesn’t look pretty it’s worth it. Cheaper than an installation service too.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 23/01/2024 12:22

These threads are always polarising. While it's perfectly true that some cats are happy to be indoor cats, others are not, including apparently those belonging to the OP.
Given this, as a minimum I'd suggest you need to provide outside space for them in the form of a catio or cat proofing your garden. Yes it's expensive, but not if considered over the lifetime of your cat.
Ours have always been outdoor cats - personally I think the risk of a short life should be balanced with the animal's quality of life. Having said that all of our previous cats have died of illness/old age rather than accident anyway.

VoleChomper · 23/01/2024 12:21

I do think it sounds depressing for cats when they're kept indoors for their entire existence. But then they're a menace killing so many birds, that maybe it's shit for them but better overall.

PleaseStopEatingMyStuff · 23/01/2024 12:19

I'd 100% keep them home & get a catio. You only have to look at your local Facebook site to see all the desperate people trying to find their much loved cats.

Imnotarestaurant · 23/01/2024 12:10

123sunshine · 23/01/2024 11:05

I think keeping any animal enclosed is cruel. I wouldn’t allow my kids to have pets kept in cages, it’s a miserable existence. Your home's just a giant cage. Cats should be free to roam.

Why stop at cats? Let’s stop keeping dogs on lead and let them roam free. And take down all the fences so that sheep and cows are not caged 🙄

I have two very happy house cats. They have the run of the whole house, and happily stay in the garden. I’ve seen too many cats dead on the side of the road to let them out.

blackpanth · 23/01/2024 11:56

123sunshine · 23/01/2024 11:05

I think keeping any animal enclosed is cruel. I wouldn’t allow my kids to have pets kept in cages, it’s a miserable existence. Your home's just a giant cage. Cats should be free to roam.

Not cruel at all.

blackpanth · 23/01/2024 11:56

Mouse82 · 23/01/2024 11:41

My indoor cat just recently passed away at 22 years old. She was one very happy content cat. Spoiled rotten.

Aww 😸 good age. Definitely one happy kitty

Medsy · 23/01/2024 11:51

YABU to have bought genetically modified animals that have been engineered out of their natural behaviours

BloodandGlitter · 23/01/2024 11:48

Better kept in than out. Protects the cats and wildlife. Harness training is a great idea though and then they can safely explore outdoors.

hoarahloux · 23/01/2024 11:43

123sunshine · 23/01/2024 11:05

I think keeping any animal enclosed is cruel. I wouldn’t allow my kids to have pets kept in cages, it’s a miserable existence. Your home's just a giant cage. Cats should be free to roam.

Why? They aren't wild animals.

Mouse82 · 23/01/2024 11:41

blackpanth · 23/01/2024 10:57

My cats are indoor cats and they're happy!

My indoor cat just recently passed away at 22 years old. She was one very happy content cat. Spoiled rotten.

Tomatina · 23/01/2024 11:14

Every cat is different. I've known some who were happy to spend their life indoors and others who hardly came in. But if a cat obviously wants to go outside, it seems cruel to keep it a prisoner permanently indoors, depriving it of the natural world and unable to freely follow its own instincts.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2024 11:14

123sunshine · Today 11:05
**
I think keeping any animal enclosed is cruel. I wouldn’t allow my kids to have pets kept in cages, it’s a miserable existence. Your home's just a giant cage. Cats should be free to roam”

Which is fine when they’re young and fit. We shall be downsizing from a large family home/gardens to a very good sized flat with a balcony and a terrace. The cats will be able to freely access both but they will be more restricted than they are now.
Only one of them, our ginger boy, is a real roamer, the girls are much more home bodies. He’ll be 12/13 when we permanently move and after hearing of another, incidentally ginger, boy being knocked down and killed very nearby recently, I’m glad he’ll be restricted as he ages. We lost our last boy to the road 14 years ago, aged 19. Don’t want to see another go the same traumatic way.

Overtheatlantic · 23/01/2024 11:08

A catio is a great idea. Give them a place up high where they can sit and watch the birds.

AnnaMagnani · 23/01/2024 11:06

You say they have lots of toys and play with them but do they have stuff they can do by themselves?

I forced a very outdoor cat to be indoors and apart from a few minutes being cross with us everyday he is happy climbing in and out of cupboards and running in and out of his cat tunnel.

He is much more interested in cat furniture (or our furniture) than toys.

Deadringer · 23/01/2024 11:05

My dd puts her cat in a harness on a long rope so she can access every part of the garden but can't escape. She is always supervised so she doesn't get caught in anything. It's not ideal but it works for her.

123sunshine · 23/01/2024 11:05

I think keeping any animal enclosed is cruel. I wouldn’t allow my kids to have pets kept in cages, it’s a miserable existence. Your home's just a giant cage. Cats should be free to roam.

Wooloohooloo · 23/01/2024 11:04

Ragdolls are gorgeous but stupid. My boy is very friendly and walks to up to anyone. He is a bad hunter and has got himself into scrapes even in our house (got a cat toy stuck on his head, sticks his paws into the gas fire when it on etc). He's also quite clumsy for a cat and falls sometimes when jumping onto his cat tree or around the bath 😂 I dread to think how he would fare with cars- he'd probably walk up to moving ones and sit in the middle of the road.

He doesn't seem fussed about going outside but we do have a lead and a harness we take him out on when it's better weather. He enjoys a walk around and a sniff then wants to come back inside.

Snowpaw · 23/01/2024 11:04

My friend has two ragdoll cats and they go outside quite happily in the garden and one explores in the woods at the back of their house. Sometimes they stay out all night / in storms / all weathers and they're absolutely fine. She said one of them explores more than the other - the other one just stays mostly in the garden of its own free will. I think you have to judge it based on your own cats. Allowing them to explore and learn their environment gives quality of life and they won't easily forget where their food and shelter is. I think all animals need sunshine and wind in their faces.

I have adopted a cat and was told to keep it inside for 3 months first to get used to his environment. We managed 6 weeks because he miaowed and yowled and was having a tough time being inside all the time. We let him out gradually, when he was hungry, then fed him when he came back in and by building up that pattern and letting him explore he has gradually worked out his own routine now and he pretty much stays out all night now and sleeps inside all day as he is that exhausted from exploring. He is a very happy, content cat now. His demeanour is much better than when he was cooped up all day.

Floralnomad · 23/01/2024 10:57

My sons Siamese have a catio connected to the house , half of it has a cover so they can go out even if the weather is crap . Do you have lots of enrichment indoors - wall shelves , climbing posts etc . Ours have wall climbing routes , trees , floor to ceiling climbing poles to access the tops of wardrobes etc .

blackpanth · 23/01/2024 10:57

My cats are indoor cats and they're happy!