Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel guilty I have indoor cats?

113 replies

Mycatlivesindoors · 23/01/2024 10:29

My DS is autistic and was desperate for a ragdoll kitten. They have been described as being great “therapy” cats due to their calm and devoted nature. DS has had a difficult time at secondary school (he’s 12) and he researched ragdolls thoroughly, showing me lots of articles and videos about how lovely they are and how they really help people with their mental health.

I also researched the breed and read how most of them don’t really like going outside as they are quite “lazy” cats and like to spend their time with their owners. More importantly everything I read said they should NEVER go outside as they are too dumb to navigate roads, will let strangers pick them up, get lost etc etc

I bought 2 sibling kittens from a reputable breeder so they would always have a friend, someone to play with. They have lots of toys, we play with them constantly but all they want to do is go outside. It probably doesn’t help that our house layout is such that they are surrounded by glass overlooking the garden. It’s the only thing they see. As a result they both cry and wail to go outside.

After months of listening to them crying and howling by the door I took them outside, supervised. They loved it. I have been taking them out twice a day and they run up and down, watch the birds and generally have a lovely time. However our garden is not cat proof. It means DS and I have to “guard” the areas where they could escape. Last week one of them shot through a tiny hole in the hedge into next doors garden. Luckily we got her back but ever since the two of them spend all their time trying to escape.

I have had quotes from companies to catproof the garden but it is expensive and we are planning to move in the next year or so, so I can’t really justify the expense. I am now wary about taking them out in the garden as it is inevitable they will escape again! I have blocked the hole in the fence but they have now started on a new area in the garden trying to jump the wall.

I feel so guilty about keeping them indoors. But I’ve been told by so many people that if they get out the garden some awful fate will befall them because ragdolls should never be allowed to roam free.

I wish I’d just bought a cat that can go outside now, listening to 2 ragdolls howling at the door all day is so stressful.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
forrestgreen · 23/01/2024 18:04

What about a good cat harness for raffles with extendable leads

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 23/01/2024 17:03

rainymays · 23/01/2024 13:26

They should have been genetically modified more so they're suitable as indoor cats and can manage on a lead imo, as should all cats. The day cats come with the expected cost of cat proofing and harness training will be a very good day for cats, wildlife, and cat owners neighbours. I have a number of pedigree cats and none have cried to be out of their cat proofed garden, and any who did would not be bred from.

This post sums up why I have never, and will never have a pedigree cat.

So called professional breeders have done huge damage to generations of cats (and of course dogs) by deliberately in-breeding them to create genetic abnormalities like deformed skulls, curly or no fur, deformed ears and limbs, and removing any sense of self protection. This is done purely for the benefit of owners who want something that looks cute on TikTok. It certainly isn't for the animal's benefit.
I think the world would be a better place were most of these 'breeds' banned.

At least my 'vermin' / 'hideous cats' haven't been bred by idiots to shorten their lives, and cause lifelong health problems.

rainymays · 23/01/2024 15:45

Medsy · 23/01/2024 13:36

You have ornaments

What a horrible thing to say, I didn't say you have vermin. My cats can do tricks, they cuddle with me most of the day, they love their toys and cat trees and playing with each other I love them like they are family and just because they're nice to look at does not make them an ornament. They're beautiful to look at, but I'd be just as happy to have a hideous cat who acted the same as a purebred.

Daisies12 · 23/01/2024 14:26

Why can they not just go out the garden, where they want? That's normal for cats. Give them collar/tags and microchips. Cruel to make them stay in.

IamfeelingHappy · 23/01/2024 14:23

We have M/F ragdolls who were inside until they were about 4 years old and we moved - the neighborhood cats had been visiting the new garden and our male ragdoll was very distressed and peeing all over our sofas and floors near the garden. He kept getting stress induced cystitis and the vet explained this is very dangerous in male cats, as due to their uretha going through a bone, things can get backed up and their kidneys can explode. The vet recommended the cats have access to the garden, which they do now 24/7 (we have cat doors linked to the chip in their necks).
Our female cat stays mostly indoors with the occasion visit to the garden. Our male cat spent several years practically living outside under bushes but he's now become more of an inside cat of his own choice. He never goes out the front of the house but we suspect he goes over a fence to a neighbours as he comes back looking like he has been lovingly brushed most days.
Ragdolls are very smart cats - they can be trained to fetch like dogs. They are just not very street smart - and there is a concern they will get hit by a car or a stranger will just pick them up because they go floppy around people.
But I came to the conclusion our cats are so much happier being able to go outside. We would be devastated if something happened to them, but their quality of live being made to stay indoors when they wanted to go outside was something we had to consider.

crummyusername · 23/01/2024 13:47

I have 2 indoor cats. The catio has been great. Also super important I think is indoor places for them to play - they love being high up - I have a large cat tree and am setting up some cat wall shelves - I think that makes a huge difference to them, as cats love being high up and able to climb.

NonComplainingDay · 23/01/2024 13:46

"I would rather hunt in the wild than eat in captivity."
It's not natural for cats to be kept inside,.how do you think they manage in the wild as ferrels etc?
I wish people wouldn't buy cats that they then keep imprisoned for the rest of their lives, it's so cruel. Just get a rescue moggy.

slore · 23/01/2024 13:45

Get a catio, and cat leads. Ragdolls are typically very amenable to wearing harnesses and being walked like dogs. (The one worry would be aggressive dogs like XL bullies attacking them).

Our neighbour had an adorable ragdoll, she spent almost all of her time outdoors (mainly in our garden) and she was a prolific hunter. She was very confident and friendly, but quite savvy. I've known cats with so little common sense it wasn't safe for them to be outdoors, but she wasn't one of them.

Protection for wildlife is one benefit of having indoor cats, as is preventing them being hit by cars, which is a risk for all cats that go outside.

Medsy · 23/01/2024 13:36

rainymays · 23/01/2024 13:26

They should have been genetically modified more so they're suitable as indoor cats and can manage on a lead imo, as should all cats. The day cats come with the expected cost of cat proofing and harness training will be a very good day for cats, wildlife, and cat owners neighbours. I have a number of pedigree cats and none have cried to be out of their cat proofed garden, and any who did would not be bred from.

You have ornaments

Sloelydoesit · 23/01/2024 13:35

One of mine who likes to wander wears a GPS tracker and a flashing light at night in case he wanders near a road.
He's already a few lives down after being hit by a car in November

rainymays · 23/01/2024 13:26

Medsy · 23/01/2024 11:51

YABU to have bought genetically modified animals that have been engineered out of their natural behaviours

They should have been genetically modified more so they're suitable as indoor cats and can manage on a lead imo, as should all cats. The day cats come with the expected cost of cat proofing and harness training will be a very good day for cats, wildlife, and cat owners neighbours. I have a number of pedigree cats and none have cried to be out of their cat proofed garden, and any who did would not be bred from.

Riapia · 23/01/2024 13:10

No cat tax payment ?
Very slack.

Muchof · 23/01/2024 12:57

Toomuch44 · 23/01/2024 10:41

Either way, it's worth getting them micro chipped. Many people are genuine and would help them relocate their owner if they were found.

I can't say what the right thing is for ragdolls, but we've always taken the risk and let ours out as we believe they should have the best quality life possible whilst living alongside us.

Not just worth it, it has just or is about to become law.

usernother · 23/01/2024 12:55

@Merula Best for the cat to get hit by a car? What about what's best for our decimated wildlife?

Might not get hit by a car. The wildlife will cope if the cat kills some.

Alargeoneplease89 · 23/01/2024 12:54

usernother · 23/01/2024 12:48

Let them out. It's cruel not to. At least you're thinking of what's best for the cats.

Unless you know the breed, you won't understand.... its like letting a puppy / toddler out alone

Merula · 23/01/2024 12:52

usernother · 23/01/2024 12:48

Let them out. It's cruel not to. At least you're thinking of what's best for the cats.

Best for the cat to get hit by a car? What about what's best for our decimated wildlife?

Somatosensational · 23/01/2024 12:52

I have a very daft British shorthair cat who in no way is suited to a life outdoors. He's clumsy, falls off the bath and sofa and the other week he banged his head on my desk when he got excited. He's allowed on my second floor balcony under close supervision. It has tall glass sides so nowhere he can squeeze through, and doesn't really have a ledge to land on. He's never tried to jump up.

He likes to sniff the plants and poke his nose in cobwebs, and on a warm day he'll sometimes lie on the chair for a bit but the vast majority of times he wants to come in after a few minutes or not go out at all. He's very timid and follows me everywhere, so I don't think wandering off appeals to him.

He has lots of toys, places to jump and hide and gets lots of playtime and attention from me. He seems very happy.

I think it does really depend on the cat. I specifically went for his breed because they're suited to an indoor life, and I didn't want to keep a high energy/adventurous cat indoors.

Alargeoneplease89 · 23/01/2024 12:52

You need to decide if they are in or outdoors - they don't understand being both.

No one knows your area or cats ability, some ragdolls go out and others don't. Mine doesn't but would love to - made the mistake of taking him for walks which resulted in cysitis as he didn't understand why he couldn't access the outside area constantly but if he did go out alone it would be like letting your toddler out.

usernother · 23/01/2024 12:48

Let them out. It's cruel not to. At least you're thinking of what's best for the cats.

SantaBarbaraMonica · 23/01/2024 12:46

My Ragdolls roam free as they wish. We are fairly remote but they’re well able to mouse and battle crows and climb on the ridge line of the shed.

Theonewiththecandles · 23/01/2024 12:45

I have a ragdoll and true to his breed he’s a complete idiot. He’s generally happy as a house cat but does sometimes make a dash for the door if he’s not supervised. We take him out on a harness and lead in the garden when it’s sunny and he loves it and only wants to go outside when it’s nice. When it’s cold and rainy he would prefer to be in our bed with the electric blanket running.

Lennon80 · 23/01/2024 12:42

I’d just let them out - my cat only comes in to sleep.

bobomomo · 23/01/2024 12:40

Walk them on leads?

PheobeBebe · 23/01/2024 12:37

When our cat was a kitten we put a harness on him and attached the dog retractable long line. It allowed him to play in the garden without us having to follow him round everywhere. Thankfully it was summer so we could just sit on a chair and relax in the sunshine! Could you set up something similar?

TripleDaisySummer · 23/01/2024 12:36

We made a DIY catio - wasn't expensive but DH can do some basic DIY. You can buy some though I think they are pricy.

Also harnesses - we walk them out on harness took a while to get used to them but they did.

We've also put in cat shelves round entire kitchen dinner room accesses via a cat pole - platforms and scratching posts that goes to ceiling and they jump off that to shelves and beds high up on wall.