Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel guilty I have indoor cats?

113 replies

Mycatlivesindoors · 23/01/2024 10:29

My DS is autistic and was desperate for a ragdoll kitten. They have been described as being great “therapy” cats due to their calm and devoted nature. DS has had a difficult time at secondary school (he’s 12) and he researched ragdolls thoroughly, showing me lots of articles and videos about how lovely they are and how they really help people with their mental health.

I also researched the breed and read how most of them don’t really like going outside as they are quite “lazy” cats and like to spend their time with their owners. More importantly everything I read said they should NEVER go outside as they are too dumb to navigate roads, will let strangers pick them up, get lost etc etc

I bought 2 sibling kittens from a reputable breeder so they would always have a friend, someone to play with. They have lots of toys, we play with them constantly but all they want to do is go outside. It probably doesn’t help that our house layout is such that they are surrounded by glass overlooking the garden. It’s the only thing they see. As a result they both cry and wail to go outside.

After months of listening to them crying and howling by the door I took them outside, supervised. They loved it. I have been taking them out twice a day and they run up and down, watch the birds and generally have a lovely time. However our garden is not cat proof. It means DS and I have to “guard” the areas where they could escape. Last week one of them shot through a tiny hole in the hedge into next doors garden. Luckily we got her back but ever since the two of them spend all their time trying to escape.

I have had quotes from companies to catproof the garden but it is expensive and we are planning to move in the next year or so, so I can’t really justify the expense. I am now wary about taking them out in the garden as it is inevitable they will escape again! I have blocked the hole in the fence but they have now started on a new area in the garden trying to jump the wall.

I feel so guilty about keeping them indoors. But I’ve been told by so many people that if they get out the garden some awful fate will befall them because ragdolls should never be allowed to roam free.

I wish I’d just bought a cat that can go outside now, listening to 2 ragdolls howling at the door all day is so stressful.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Canthave2manycats · 24/01/2024 16:24

Daisies12 · 23/01/2024 14:26

Why can they not just go out the garden, where they want? That's normal for cats. Give them collar/tags and microchips. Cruel to make them stay in.

I think my cats missed that memo.

GodspeedJune · 24/01/2024 16:22

Yabu to feel guilty. I don’t want to be graphic but have you ever helped a cat that has been hit by a car? It’s absolutely shocking and brutal, and I wouldn’t knowingly let any of my pets die that way.

Don’t listen to anyone who doesn’t have ragdoll experience. My parents have two and when they are approached by a dog they roll over. They would be torn to shreds outside.

SKG231 · 24/01/2024 16:16

I don’t agree with keeping cats trapped in a house against their will. I think they should always have a choice. If they want to be lazy home cats then great but it should be their choice.

Minimum85percentCocoa · 24/01/2024 16:16

Cat tax here (would love to see yours)

To feel guilty I have indoor cats?
To feel guilty I have indoor cats?
To feel guilty I have indoor cats?
Minimum85percentCocoa · 24/01/2024 16:13

I do think some previous posters don’t understand the difference between a rag doll and a ‘standard’ cat. I have a similar breed - a Birman - which I think rag dolls might originate from (these are not a modern, ‘genetically modified’ breed but an ancient one that has been preserved). Normal cat sensibilities don’t apply! My kitten currently loves escaping over the garden wall but it’s not safe for her to be out alone. She loves a walk on the harness and lead and I’m about to cat proof our small yard so she can be out there without me having to watch her like a hawk (still won’t be unsupervised). I think part of it is adolescence as she’s 9 months old, my last Birman didn’t want to venture out.

i had similar worries to you and posted a thread in the litter tray where I got great advice. I have also done wider research and have made the decision not to allow her to roam alone. They’re too trusting, not street wise and liable to be stolen. I chose this breed because of household allergies but I wouldn’t judge any one’s reasons for having one. My brother also adopted one who was allowed to roam for 10 years, but got into lots of scrapes during this time which ultimately resulted in a front leg amputation (this injury happened prior to my brother adopting him). Although this cat was a bit miffed to be kept in at first he is happy now.

An indoor cat will require more play, enrichment, exercise, company etc than an outdoor cat, but if you get this right they are on the whole very happy as house cats. There are good indoor options for climbing using shelves/ladders etc on the walls.

Google some diy options for cat proofing. As long as they’re not too determined you can often knock something up using shelf brackets and mesh netting. Also I am looking into growing spiky plants up the walls to further put her off trying to scale them.

Canthave2manycats · 24/01/2024 15:53

Imnotarestaurant · 23/01/2024 12:10

Why stop at cats? Let’s stop keeping dogs on lead and let them roam free. And take down all the fences so that sheep and cows are not caged 🙄

I have two very happy house cats. They have the run of the whole house, and happily stay in the garden. I’ve seen too many cats dead on the side of the road to let them out.

I couldn't agree more.

I have 3 rescue cats. All three of them were used to being out. None of them has ever looked to go out. One had been a stray in a city centre, one had been neglected and left out in all weathers (now if she gets a drip of water when you're washing your hands, she takes off like a split streak!), and the newest one had fields to roam in. I have a cat flap that's microchip operated and I had fully expected them to want out, but they know when they've got it good!

I'd have got a catio otherwise.

fleurneige · 24/01/2024 15:29

Personally I would never have a cat if it had to be indoor. Unless I adopted an older one from refuge which has always been an indoor one.

bawbells · 24/01/2024 15:27

I think if it makes you feel guilty then deep down you know what's the right thing to do.

Kwam31 · 24/01/2024 15:26

ragdoll!!

Kwam31 · 24/01/2024 15:26

Neighbours of mine have a tattoo and he's walked on a harness and lead, they're out twice a day walking as you would a dog, very sociable happy cat.

Floralnomad · 24/01/2024 13:51

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 24/01/2024 13:05

I accept that, although Ragdolls are more prone to PKD and HCM than moggies due to inbreeding and a Royal Veterinary College report reports that the average lifespan of a Ragdoll is 10.1 years against 14.0 years for a crossbreed (moggy).
But even ignoring that, I stated above removing any sense of self protection.. This was the line specifically referring to Ragdolls.

I’m amazed that the average lifespan of a Ragdoll is only 10 yrs . My mum had a very well bred one ( champion showing lines) that had 2 bowel resections as a 16 week old kitten for volvulus , was allergic to everything and he made it to 16 and eventually died because his thyroid medication gave him acute liver failure .

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 24/01/2024 13:05

Wooloohooloo · 24/01/2024 12:53

@Grumpyoldpersonwithcats Ragdolls really don't have any physical traits which cause them any pain or discomfort. Persians have breathing difficulties but Ragdolls don't. They're just very fluffy.

I accept that, although Ragdolls are more prone to PKD and HCM than moggies due to inbreeding and a Royal Veterinary College report reports that the average lifespan of a Ragdoll is 10.1 years against 14.0 years for a crossbreed (moggy).
But even ignoring that, I stated above removing any sense of self protection.. This was the line specifically referring to Ragdolls.

Wooloohooloo · 24/01/2024 12:53

@Grumpyoldpersonwithcats Ragdolls really don't have any physical traits which cause them any pain or discomfort. Persians have breathing difficulties but Ragdolls don't. They're just very fluffy.

MrsSkylerWhite · 24/01/2024 11:31

NonComplainingDay · Yesterday 13:46
**
"I would rather hunt in the wild than eat in captivity."
It's not natural for cats to be kept inside,.how do you think they manage in the wild as ferrels etc?”

Cats are the only wild animals that domesticated themselves by ingratiating themselves with humans and developing symbiotic relationships that offered them food and protection in households.

Most ferals live sickly, short, miserable and hungry lives.

catscalledbeanz · 24/01/2024 00:14

Are you playing within them properly? Indoor cats need stimulation. Daily. Different toys, different engagement. It's challenging and should take up an hour every day in fits. They need to hunt and kill. Play can replicate that. They don't need to go outside if you offer the mental stimulation through play that they need. But most indoor cat owners fail to do this.

Astridastro · 23/01/2024 23:50

One of my cats thinks he is a dog, so he goes outside in the garden with the dog for a pee then comes straight back in. He doesn’t do a pee (he has a litter tray, he just poddles about after the dog. In the Summer if we are out in the garden he will come out but he won’t go out alone. He howls to get back in the minute the door is closed.

Tumbleweed101 · 23/01/2024 23:46

I’ve got a barn kitten. She’s now 11yr and pretty much lives outside all year. The only time she makes a fuss to come inside is in the winter, when she is of course welcome to
come in. The rest of the time she prefers to be out. Even in winter if she is still in when we go to bed she soon starts crying to go out. She likes to come and sit with us in the summer in the garden and share our bbqs. She sleeps in our caravan most of the time as it has a window that doesn’t fully shut.

I know rag dolls are different from farm bred moggies but I’d still want to find a way to get them outside safely.

laclochette · 23/01/2024 23:45

First of all it's worth underscoring that cat breeds are much less well established than eg dog breeds, and much less distinct from each other genetically, so there is a lot less that you can say about any given cat's personality/behaviour based on breed than people often think - and than breeders make out! There are dim and docile Ragdolls, but also there are sharper-witted and more active ones. Breeds are really just cats with specific physical appearance traits.

I second all the recommendations for a catio and for harness training. I personally wouldn't let a cat free-roam, it's risky for them, and I'd find it too anxiety inducing. (It's so funny to me that of all the pets, cats are the only ones that have somehow secured the right to roam freely without their owners - classic cat! Nobody would let their dog, hamster etc explore alone.)

Mycatlivesindoors · 23/01/2024 23:43

tadpoles oh that sounds lovely, what a lucky ragdoll you have!

I took mine out in the garden again today, and played ball with them which they love! I’ve ordered some cat tunnels and a tent which will hopefully entertain them in the garden for a bit!

Because of the layout of the house (on a hill with steps down to garden) we can’t have a catio but I am so amazed by the ones I looked at online. What a great idea.

Looking to move this year so will either see about professionally cat proofing new garden or getting a catio. Thankyou for the ideas!

Im totally in love with my ragdolls and wouldn’t be without them. They adore each other and I’m watching them both thoroughly groom each other before they jump up on the bed to sleep with me!

OP posts:
TadpolesInPool · 23/01/2024 23:35

I had to check I hadn't written the OP! My DS was the same: researching and presenting me with a list of reasons why we should get a ragdoll (we lived in a flat). Including helping calm his anxiety!

Well, we cracked and got a ragdoll in the December. Then unexpectedly moved overseas the next summer, to a place where we just cannot keep the cat inside (very hot, doors always open, we spend half our time outside...).

Anyway, our ragdoll has adapted really well! He LOVES going outside. At first he was in loads of fights with other cats (no serious injuries, just 2 bites) and he was rubbish at defending his territory. However within a few months he got the hang of it. Now hardly any cats come near our garden because he defends it properly. Except our neighbour's cat - they appear to have made friends and miaow at each other and will lie down near each other.

There are loads of dogs loose here which was a huge worry. At first our cat was very unsuspecting and got chased a couple of times. Now he is much more dog smart and hasn't had a problem in over a year. There are a couple of dogs who use out garden as a thoroughfare (impossible to block) but cat stays out of the way and is fine.

Other people- he ll go to our guests but not to anyone outside our house.

Cars - we're not on a main road and he's learnt to be wary of our cars on our drive.

Wildlife - unfortunately he has gotten very good at catching lizards. He definitely has learnt - his instincts seem to have really been fine tuned since coming here.

He used to wander quite far and once went missing for 36 hours after a cat fight but that was only 3 months after we moved here. Most the time he sleeps in our garden, or in the house whilst I'm working.

For the past 12 months he's come home between 5 and 5.30pm like clockwork. He's shut in overnight.

I do think his life will probably be shorter because he goes out. But he loves it so much that I'm glad we moved and didn't keep him in a flat.

Fluffywhitecloudsinthesky · 23/01/2024 19:15

I let my ragdoll out in the garden, they like to potter about, but won't go massively away from me (except from stupidity and then cry to come back). After about 20 min, they just walk in the house. I keep an eye on them outside. I also have a catio and a cat tree.

Lots of people don't let their cats roam, I have a friend with a rescue, again, she cat-proofed her garden and the cat comes back in after being outside for a bit.

I live on a busy road with buses on it, so having a roaming cat is not a possibility, it would just get squished.

blackpanth · 23/01/2024 19:10

NonComplainingDay · 23/01/2024 13:46

"I would rather hunt in the wild than eat in captivity."
It's not natural for cats to be kept inside,.how do you think they manage in the wild as ferrels etc?
I wish people wouldn't buy cats that they then keep imprisoned for the rest of their lives, it's so cruel. Just get a rescue moggy.

Again my cats are happy as indoor cats

blackpanth · 23/01/2024 19:10

Daisies12 · 23/01/2024 14:26

Why can they not just go out the garden, where they want? That's normal for cats. Give them collar/tags and microchips. Cruel to make them stay in.

It really isn't cruel

Medsy · 23/01/2024 18:33

rainymays · 23/01/2024 15:45

What a horrible thing to say, I didn't say you have vermin. My cats can do tricks, they cuddle with me most of the day, they love their toys and cat trees and playing with each other I love them like they are family and just because they're nice to look at does not make them an ornament. They're beautiful to look at, but I'd be just as happy to have a hideous cat who acted the same as a purebred.

But the natural point of a cat is to be a predator and exercise self-protection.
In the case of ragdolls, they can't be predators as they don't go outside, and they have been genetically modified to have zero self-protection sense.
I mean what the hell?