Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel guilty I have indoor cats?

113 replies

Mycatlivesindoors · 23/01/2024 10:29

My DS is autistic and was desperate for a ragdoll kitten. They have been described as being great “therapy” cats due to their calm and devoted nature. DS has had a difficult time at secondary school (he’s 12) and he researched ragdolls thoroughly, showing me lots of articles and videos about how lovely they are and how they really help people with their mental health.

I also researched the breed and read how most of them don’t really like going outside as they are quite “lazy” cats and like to spend their time with their owners. More importantly everything I read said they should NEVER go outside as they are too dumb to navigate roads, will let strangers pick them up, get lost etc etc

I bought 2 sibling kittens from a reputable breeder so they would always have a friend, someone to play with. They have lots of toys, we play with them constantly but all they want to do is go outside. It probably doesn’t help that our house layout is such that they are surrounded by glass overlooking the garden. It’s the only thing they see. As a result they both cry and wail to go outside.

After months of listening to them crying and howling by the door I took them outside, supervised. They loved it. I have been taking them out twice a day and they run up and down, watch the birds and generally have a lovely time. However our garden is not cat proof. It means DS and I have to “guard” the areas where they could escape. Last week one of them shot through a tiny hole in the hedge into next doors garden. Luckily we got her back but ever since the two of them spend all their time trying to escape.

I have had quotes from companies to catproof the garden but it is expensive and we are planning to move in the next year or so, so I can’t really justify the expense. I am now wary about taking them out in the garden as it is inevitable they will escape again! I have blocked the hole in the fence but they have now started on a new area in the garden trying to jump the wall.

I feel so guilty about keeping them indoors. But I’ve been told by so many people that if they get out the garden some awful fate will befall them because ragdolls should never be allowed to roam free.

I wish I’d just bought a cat that can go outside now, listening to 2 ragdolls howling at the door all day is so stressful.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
Canthave2manycats · 24/01/2024 22:48

123sunshine · 24/01/2024 21:04

Not that’s it’s any of your business but my house backs on to fields, as did my previous property. My cat roams free in the fields My cat isn’t pooing in neighbours gardens. Cat litter trays are absolutely rank in the home.
We will have to agree to disagree, I believe cats should be free to roam. All cats I’ve owned have hated being trapped indoors. I wouldn’t own a cat and live in a busy dangerous road putting my cat In Danger.

Cat trays are only rank if you don't keep them scrupulously clean.

It's all well cats being free to roam and in an ideal world - yes. I see appeals daily for missing cats. I also see daily notifications of cats having been killed on the roads. My first two cats as an adult were sister kittens, and we kept them in from the start, so it was what they were used to.

I then acquired two more, that had been used to getting out, so we kept that up. The next DCat was a stray and moved gradually into the house, eventually full-time when he was old and blind in one eye.

As I said upthread, my current three are happy as larry indoors, and I am so glad.

orangeblosssom · 24/01/2024 21:36

Minimum85percentCocoa · 24/01/2024 16:16

Cat tax here (would love to see yours)

So cute!

123sunshine · 24/01/2024 21:04

Createausername1970 · 24/01/2024 17:51

As long as you go round your neighbours' gardens and pick up your cat's poo.

Free roaming domestic pets can be a nuisance. I had indoor cats, they were litter mates and both died after reaching 19 and 20. Our vet was all in favour of indoor cats. She said she had to patch up or put down so many after they were run over or ingested stuff they found in random gardens.

Not that’s it’s any of your business but my house backs on to fields, as did my previous property. My cat roams free in the fields My cat isn’t pooing in neighbours gardens. Cat litter trays are absolutely rank in the home.
We will have to agree to disagree, I believe cats should be free to roam. All cats I’ve owned have hated being trapped indoors. I wouldn’t own a cat and live in a busy dangerous road putting my cat In Danger.

Cincinnatus · 24/01/2024 21:03

Much better than letting it shit in other people’s gardens and murdering wildlife.

QuestionableMouse · 24/01/2024 21:02

Better indoor cats than dead cats. I've had to pick up more than I ever want to after they've been hit on the road.

Somatosensational · 24/01/2024 21:01

Mine is obsessed with a balled up pair of winter socks. He carries them around with him miaowing.

His latest obsession is a spiral of (uncooked) pasta which he loves chasing and batting about.

Somatosensational · 24/01/2024 20:58

Fluffyfleece · 24/01/2024 17:45

My friend is quite sorted, her smallish garden is enclosed by stone walls too high for the cats to climb so they can be outside safely

This is my dream home.

MadKittenWoman · 24/01/2024 20:55

Our ragdoll / Birman cross went out, as do the ragdoll brothers across the road. They aren't as stupid as made out; they aren't supposed to hunt or fight, but ours did both.

We've had many cats over the years, mostly fancy rather than moggy, and they've all lived full and happy, and more importantly independent lives doing what cats do, patrolling their territory, making friends and enemies, intimidating the local foxes, sunbathing, climbing, etc. Would you like to spend the rest of your days locked in your house?

MadCatLady27 · 24/01/2024 19:54

WaterHound · 24/01/2024 18:13

Mine has a collection of soft toys that he carries around with him obsessively.

Mine loves "ratty" (toy rat) and will carry him around, howling, proudly telling everyone about her "kill"

It's rather realistic, I was sat on the loo the other day looked down and got a massive fright as I thought it was a live rat!

Current obsessions are the far too small Amazon box (despite having access to anywhere she wants), the yellow laundry skip (as above) and the bathroom. Anyone who goes in there is generally accompanied whether they wish to be or not! She purrs away

MadCatLady27 · 24/01/2024 19:06

I follow a couple of ragdoll owners on Instagram - Bruno the Ragdoll for example, and he walks beautifully on his harness and goes on all sorts of adventures with his owner - she's now got a 2nd and walks them together.

I'd be too worried about something happening and then getting loose

Zanatdy · 24/01/2024 18:15

There’s also a gorgeous Birman cross in our neighbourhood - it’s one of the most gorgeous cats I’ve ever seen. Guy upstairs feeds them and so we see a lot of them. I’ve become very fond of them both. I do worry about them and the road

WaterHound · 24/01/2024 18:13

Mine has a collection of soft toys that he carries around with him obsessively.

Zanatdy · 24/01/2024 18:12

There’s a gorgeous rag doll in my neighbourhood and it’s pretty good by the road. It’s not a main road but I’ve seen her check before crossing.

MadCatLady27 · 24/01/2024 18:10

Here's mine 😍 I'm mega obsessed with her and my phone is full of photos of her 😍

Does anyone else who has them find they get "obsessions"?

To feel guilty I have indoor cats?
To feel guilty I have indoor cats?
WaterHound · 24/01/2024 18:09

Minimum85percentCocoa · 24/01/2024 16:13

I do think some previous posters don’t understand the difference between a rag doll and a ‘standard’ cat. I have a similar breed - a Birman - which I think rag dolls might originate from (these are not a modern, ‘genetically modified’ breed but an ancient one that has been preserved). Normal cat sensibilities don’t apply! My kitten currently loves escaping over the garden wall but it’s not safe for her to be out alone. She loves a walk on the harness and lead and I’m about to cat proof our small yard so she can be out there without me having to watch her like a hawk (still won’t be unsupervised). I think part of it is adolescence as she’s 9 months old, my last Birman didn’t want to venture out.

i had similar worries to you and posted a thread in the litter tray where I got great advice. I have also done wider research and have made the decision not to allow her to roam alone. They’re too trusting, not street wise and liable to be stolen. I chose this breed because of household allergies but I wouldn’t judge any one’s reasons for having one. My brother also adopted one who was allowed to roam for 10 years, but got into lots of scrapes during this time which ultimately resulted in a front leg amputation (this injury happened prior to my brother adopting him). Although this cat was a bit miffed to be kept in at first he is happy now.

An indoor cat will require more play, enrichment, exercise, company etc than an outdoor cat, but if you get this right they are on the whole very happy as house cats. There are good indoor options for climbing using shelves/ladders etc on the walls.

Google some diy options for cat proofing. As long as they’re not too determined you can often knock something up using shelf brackets and mesh netting. Also I am looking into growing spiky plants up the walls to further put her off trying to scale them.

I agree with all of this. I have two indoor cats, one of which is a raggy and the other a Persian. They do not have any sense at all. They are very happy.

We also have two outdoor cats who would be distressed to be kept inside - these are moggies and love their outside time.

Createausername1970 · 24/01/2024 17:51

123sunshine · 23/01/2024 11:05

I think keeping any animal enclosed is cruel. I wouldn’t allow my kids to have pets kept in cages, it’s a miserable existence. Your home's just a giant cage. Cats should be free to roam.

As long as you go round your neighbours' gardens and pick up your cat's poo.

Free roaming domestic pets can be a nuisance. I had indoor cats, they were litter mates and both died after reaching 19 and 20. Our vet was all in favour of indoor cats. She said she had to patch up or put down so many after they were run over or ingested stuff they found in random gardens.

jennylamb1 · 24/01/2024 17:51

Agreed, we must have photos! Grin

KindleGirlie · 24/01/2024 17:46

I’m disgusted by this thread. Talk of not one but two gorgeous ragdolls and there’s no photos 😱

Ibizafun · 24/01/2024 17:45

The system is called Freedom Fence.

Fluffyfleece · 24/01/2024 17:45

My friend is quite sorted, her smallish garden is enclosed by stone walls too high for the cats to climb so they can be outside safely

MadCatLady27 · 24/01/2024 17:42

Ragdolls shouldn't go out unaccompanied as they have no sense of danger.

I have a ragdoll and DH a BSH and both are indoor cats. They have plenty of enrichment through toys, windows to look out of, us chatting to them, and playing together - they often race round the house together!

In the summer they come out with us on their harnesses into the garden, we use "cat walking jackets" as they are much more secure than a harness.

Please please don't let yours out unaccompanied, they are so vulnerable to being stolen, or knocked down by a car as they're so trusting and don't sense danger. I'd far rather they were safe

You ARE however being unreasonable for not posting photos! My absolute favourite breed I'm BESOTTED with mine she's such a character ❤️

Somatosensational · 24/01/2024 17:38

Ibizafun · 24/01/2024 16:32

How big is your garden? We have an invisible wire running round at the top and bottom of our hedges. The cats wear special collars when they go out and if they try and get out the garden, they hear a high pitched sound which warns them off before they get a nasty "tingle".

The system is endorsed by Cat's Protection and is used by farmers to keep their livestock in. My cats never get a shock as after a couple of times they understood.

It's a good compromise.

What is this system called? I've never heard of it before but am intrigued.

@Minimum85percentCocoa Your Birman is beautiful!

LindsayLaing · 24/01/2024 16:52

I love cats and have had many over the years. I feel quite strongly that they should be allowed outside. I always think how life would be if I spent 15 years inside never smelling fresh air or feeling grass on my feet. Yes there are risks in everything but none of us would ever do anything if we thought like that. Tracker collars are great as you can see where they are.

Ibizafun · 24/01/2024 16:32

How big is your garden? We have an invisible wire running round at the top and bottom of our hedges. The cats wear special collars when they go out and if they try and get out the garden, they hear a high pitched sound which warns them off before they get a nasty "tingle".

The system is endorsed by Cat's Protection and is used by farmers to keep their livestock in. My cats never get a shock as after a couple of times they understood.

It's a good compromise.

SKG231 · 24/01/2024 16:28

pay the money and cat proof the garden. If you had the money for an expensive breed of cat, and two of them then you should dig a little deeper in your pockets to give them the best quality of life you can and let them be able to be out in the garden safely.