Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to want to keep baby things given to me by my sister.

281 replies

Noonesawme · 23/01/2024 10:16

When DS was born, DSis gave us all their baby things including big bits like crib and changing table and loads of clothes. They are adamant they're not having more children so there was never a conversation about needing to give anything back when she gave them to us. I am genuinely very grateful for her giving us all these bits.

DSis has now asked for a lot of these things back to give to her DH's sister who is having her first baby.

I do feel a bit annoyed at this. DS is still young so we haven't decided for sure yet if we want another but it's definitely not off the table and we have put these things away now DS has finished with them (she isn't asking for anything DS is still using, just that he has outgrown, to be fair).
I did say to DSis we were hoping to keep everything ready for if and when we have another and DSis spoke to her sis-in-law who agreed to give anything back if we have a second.
I still feel a bit irritated though. Her sis-in-law is a bit older than me so probably likely to have a second baby not that long after they have this one if they want another (I don't know her at all, just going on what DSis has mentioned) so I can see that we may well end up clashing with needing some of these bits and because it'll be in her house, she'll be the one that gets to keep them. From what I know of her they have a lot more money than DH and I do and could probably much more easily afford to buy all these things if they weren't given them whereas we would really struggle to replace everything we thought we wouldn't have to think about at all.
I know I didn't buy these things myself but they are sentimental also as they were DS's baby things and I just don't really want to give them away and have to hope we get them back.
WIBU to just refuse to give them back?

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 23/01/2024 16:17

JamJar59 · 23/01/2024 16:12

When it comes to sharing baby stuff I don’t think it’s something that even needs to be discussed.

most reasonable people would assume that if items are passed down then there’s a moral obligation to pass it forward or hand it back when they are needed again by the previous owner.

We’ve passed around lots of things and didn’t have to say that it was strictly a loan or if it’s explicitly giving over ownership. Especially in the case of the OP, that’s their SISTER who gave it to her in good faith.

OP is clearly in the wrong.

Why is it suddenly different when it comes to baby stuff?

If it is a loan, then it should be made clear
If you are giving someone something, it then belongs to them

I don't think it makes anyone unreasonable to assume that giving = it now belongs to them.

Noonesawme · 23/01/2024 16:15

ClumsyNinja · 23/01/2024 14:37

YABU, because you’ve already had use of them and you don’t currently need them yourself.

Presumably the items were jointly owned by your BIL and your sister?

Supposing your BIL had given them to his sister first and your sister then wanted to offer them to you but the sister said she wanted to keep hold of them ‘just in case’.

Would you think ‘that’s fair enough, first come, first served’ or would you think she was being a bit selfish…?

This is actually really thought provoking, thank you. I see your point. I would hope that my DSis would advocate for me to have been able to use them as well if they had already given them to someone else and I suppose I have to appreciate that that's likely the situation here with BIL wanting to advocate for his DSis to have them too. I suppose I do just feel a bit worried about parting with them and risking not getting them back as I'd love to see a future child using the same things DS used.

OP posts:
JamJar59 · 23/01/2024 16:12

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/01/2024 15:02

But we don't know how it was presented.

It could've been ''you can use our babies stuff'' but at the same time it could've also been ''You can have these, we're finished with them'' which to me would mean they now belong to OP, not sister.

When it comes to sharing baby stuff I don’t think it’s something that even needs to be discussed.

most reasonable people would assume that if items are passed down then there’s a moral obligation to pass it forward or hand it back when they are needed again by the previous owner.

We’ve passed around lots of things and didn’t have to say that it was strictly a loan or if it’s explicitly giving over ownership. Especially in the case of the OP, that’s their SISTER who gave it to her in good faith.

OP is clearly in the wrong.

Ohnoooooooo · 23/01/2024 15:30

If you have a few sentimental pieces ask her if you can keep them and hand the rest back. You can’t rely on either of you getting pregnant with a 2nd at will. She may only want one child or being older might take longer to get pregnant.

Therealjudgejudy · 23/01/2024 15:05

Sounds like you can't afford a second child anyway...

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/01/2024 15:02

OhmygodDont · 23/01/2024 14:55

Op should have clarified if they were given or on loan.

Id never expect to just be given big ticket items for free forever unless they were actual presents. Presented as presents not just a yeah you can use our babies stuff.

But we don't know how it was presented.

It could've been ''you can use our babies stuff'' but at the same time it could've also been ''You can have these, we're finished with them'' which to me would mean they now belong to OP, not sister.

OhmygodDont · 23/01/2024 14:55

CecilyP · 23/01/2024 14:45

Except OP wasn’t even aware she was ‘borrowing’ as her DSis didn’t make that clear.

Op should have clarified if they were given or on loan.

Id never expect to just be given big ticket items for free forever unless they were actual presents. Presented as presents not just a yeah you can use our babies stuff.

ChangeAgain2 · 23/01/2024 14:52

@Noonesawme I'd consider this a miscommunication between you and Dsis. DSis clearly still views the items as hers and on loan to you. Now she wants to pass then on to DSIL. You, however, view them as yours and consider them as a gift. Somewhere along the line there's been a miscommunication or misunderstanding. Stuff isn't worth falling out over. I'd give them back and be thankful you had the free use of them. If future it's worth clarifying before accepting stuff.

I give loads of stuff to my SIL. I always tell her that I've sorted out a load of stuff for my niece. I told her to keep what she wants and pass on the rest. I don't want anything back. I've been very clear.

OhmygodDont · 23/01/2024 14:52

Defaultsettings · 23/01/2024 14:46

A sentimental changing table?

Remember dear that day you was changing ds just here on this table and he just exploded covering you in shit 🥹 then peed all over the clean nappy about to go on too 🥲

😂

Defaultsettings · 23/01/2024 14:46

A sentimental changing table?

ChatGPTwrotemyhomework · 23/01/2024 14:46

@Noonesawme I chose YABU, but I've reconsidered when I thought of it as asking for a gift back.

My dad was given some dining chairs by his sibling. A few YEARS later, sibling asked for them back! So it was what? Free storage for my stuff I don't want cluttering up my own house? You can use it but only as long as I decide I don't need it! Don't need to say this of course... it's obviously understood... Hmm

What's your relationship with your sister like generally? I think you should give the stuff back since it's already been promised elsewhere, but mention you're disappointed she didn't say previously that it wasn't a gift.

CecilyP · 23/01/2024 14:45

OhmygodDont · 23/01/2024 14:37

Yabu you where given things for free to use, now the person who purchased them wants to let another family also use her baby things for free.

If you wanted items that where yours, you should have purchased rather than borrowing.

Except OP wasn’t even aware she was ‘borrowing’ as her DSis didn’t make that clear.

CecilyP · 23/01/2024 14:44

ClumsyNinja · 23/01/2024 14:37

YABU, because you’ve already had use of them and you don’t currently need them yourself.

Presumably the items were jointly owned by your BIL and your sister?

Supposing your BIL had given them to his sister first and your sister then wanted to offer them to you but the sister said she wanted to keep hold of them ‘just in case’.

Would you think ‘that’s fair enough, first come, first served’ or would you think she was being a bit selfish…?

I don’t know why you wouldn’t think that! If your sister had already given all her stuff away to her SIL, you wouldn’t really expect her to promise it to you. And certainly not without asking her SIL first!

steff13 · 23/01/2024 14:38

DrySherry · 23/01/2024 14:31

"whereas we would really struggle to replace everything"

You clearly can't afford another child if the cost of replacing a crib, a changing table and some clothes is something your worrying about. Accept that - and give them to someone who can make good use of them. Otherwise you make yourself look a bit selfish imo

I was actually thinking this but I didn't want to say it because it seemed mean.

OhmygodDont · 23/01/2024 14:37

Yabu you where given things for free to use, now the person who purchased them wants to let another family also use her baby things for free.

If you wanted items that where yours, you should have purchased rather than borrowing.

ClumsyNinja · 23/01/2024 14:37

YABU, because you’ve already had use of them and you don’t currently need them yourself.

Presumably the items were jointly owned by your BIL and your sister?

Supposing your BIL had given them to his sister first and your sister then wanted to offer them to you but the sister said she wanted to keep hold of them ‘just in case’.

Would you think ‘that’s fair enough, first come, first served’ or would you think she was being a bit selfish…?

steff13 · 23/01/2024 14:35

Noonesawme · 23/01/2024 13:13

Thank you! This is my thought process. I did not buy them but I do consider them mine. My DSis never said there was a possibility she would want them back to pass on, she just gave them to us and I assumed they would be ours to use for all our children, however many that may end up to be.
I'm not trying to make judgements of her sis-in-law either, I was just explaining my thought process as to why I'm worried there's a possibility we won't get them back. I don't know her! Met her very briefly at DSis' wedding years ago but that's it, it's not really about her, it's about my DSis' and BIL suddenly asking for a gift they gave back which I'm upset about.

Well if you don't get them back then you're going to have to figure something else out. You're being selfish to keep them when someone else can use them. You have to get rid of your babies things eventually so forming an emotional attachment to them was a little bit odd.

DrySherry · 23/01/2024 14:31

"whereas we would really struggle to replace everything"

You clearly can't afford another child if the cost of replacing a crib, a changing table and some clothes is something your worrying about. Accept that - and give them to someone who can make good use of them. Otherwise you make yourself look a bit selfish imo

CecilyP · 23/01/2024 14:28

StBrides · 23/01/2024 14:16

I disagree. I get what people are saying & usually I agree with the majority on posts likes these. But a few things:

  1. the sil appears to be financially able to look after themselves, there's no real 'need' here
  2. the op is expecting to get further use out of them in hoping for another baby = this is totally valid reason for keeping them
  3. once you give something away you have no right to ask for it back just because

I don't think the op is being selfish at all. I think her sister is being selfish, unreasonable and is putting the op in an unfairly difficult position.

I think asking for stuff back, especially larger items, is fine. Promising things to another couple before even asking OP for them back, not so fine. As a PP said, DSis is definitely wanting to play lady bountiful!

TellMeWhoTheVillainsAre · 23/01/2024 14:23

You got them for free. You were very lucky your sister had them to give to you. If she didn't, you would have bought them or been gifted them. You are not using them now and your sister knows you are not using them. You've benefitted from the kindness of your sister, who seems like a lovely woman but now you're being grabby and wanting to keep them, not use them, but not let anyone else use them either.

There's always free baby stuff going around! There's always friends and families who have barely used items that they are happy to pass on.

Take a leaf out of your sister's book, and share.

sunnydayhereandnow · 23/01/2024 14:21

It's really unreasonable to not pass the things back to Dsis for her SIL especially if she has already promised you can have them back if you have another child! If your DS is already really young and has outgrown the things, then the chances there will be overlap with someone pregnant now are minimal. Like others said, in the worst case scenario you can buy baby stuff secondhand at minimal cost. Also clothes are frequently not even relevant the next time round - what if next time your baby is a DD or in the opposite season? Be the good person and help everyone to save the planet from production of even more heaps of baby stuff that gets used for a few months then clogs up storage space. Keep one or two outfits you loved, and the rest is for photos, not storage.

StBrides · 23/01/2024 14:16

InTheRainOnATrain · 23/01/2024 11:24

I think you’re missing the point? Yes the stuff is OP’s now and yes legally she could keep it hoarded in the attic but there’s someone else in the extended family that would benefit and legal ownership doesn’t change the fact that it’s pretty selfish to not help others as you were helped yourself. Also, she’s risking a falling out with her sister, which just isn’t worth it over some second hand baby bits. Finally, and this one might appeal more to OP, the sister has an older child and they keep on good terms there might be a lot more hand-me-downs to come from small stuff like clothes to big ticket stuff like outgrown toys and bikes.

I disagree. I get what people are saying & usually I agree with the majority on posts likes these. But a few things:

  1. the sil appears to be financially able to look after themselves, there's no real 'need' here
  2. the op is expecting to get further use out of them in hoping for another baby = this is totally valid reason for keeping them
  3. once you give something away you have no right to ask for it back just because

I don't think the op is being selfish at all. I think her sister is being selfish, unreasonable and is putting the op in an unfairly difficult position.

NotARealWookiie · 23/01/2024 14:14

Hmmm. She shouldn’t really have given them to you and then ask for them back. It is totally normal to pass bits like this around but it does help to clarify the arrangements from the offset.

I would suggest just handing the bits over and saying that you would like them back for your next DS. Babies use many items for an only couple of months and then they grow out of them so the chances of you both needing them at the same time are very slim.

minipie · 23/01/2024 14:13

Quite apart from the morality here, refusing to share would be a very sure way to ensure your sister never hands you down any of her child’s stuff in future- outgrown clothes, bikes, toys etc.

CecilyP · 23/01/2024 14:13

kisstheblarney · 23/01/2024 13:42

Surely the onus is on OP to infirm if it's a loan or a gift?

I suppose this thread could be a useful reminder to others to make clear whether things are a gift or a loan.

Swipe left for the next trending thread