Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have said no to this? (BF extended family)

133 replies

cocunut · 23/01/2024 09:16

I’ve been with my boyfriend for nearly two years, both late 20s, no kids.

My BF’s parents are separated and I met his mum and her extended family late last year, and also saw them at the Christmas just gone. However, I’ve only met his dad in passing and have wanted to meet him properly for ages but we haven’t managed to arrange something yet.

In December, my BF asked me over text if I was free a weekend in January (this weekend coming) to go to Wales (!!!) to meet his dad with his partner and his extended family. For context, we both live in SE England, a 10 min drive from each other and about the same to his dad’s. I responded “that’s a nice idea, let’s talk about it”, which he took as a yes and booked hotel rooms, organised the family etc. When we eventually got to talk about it and I explained I didn’t have anybody to look after my pets (horses and dogs) he wasn’t happy as he’d already booked it - to which I told him I technically didn’t even agree!!

We met up last night and he’s quite disappointed that I can’t go but he understands etc. Now I feel bad and am considering asking my DM to look after my horses so I can go for a night. My only qualm is that I was away for 3 nights over new year with BF and horses were absolutely terribly behaved for DM and a nightmare!!

I dont understand why we can’t meet up locally as his dad lives less than 20 minutes from me. I understand he wants me to meet his stepmum and their family but it’s just not convenient for me to go away for a weekend in January and leave my animals with poor DM (who is perfectly capable but in her late 50s and works full time).

AIBU to have said no; am I being unfair on BF who has booked it? Or is he BU for booking it without me explicitly saying I could come??

OP posts:
whatsitcalledwhen · 23/01/2024 09:44

FWIW I think your boyfriend was wrong to assume that you had agreed to it based on what you said.

I also don't think you should automatically be expected to leave your horses for a weekend if you don't feel comfortable doing so.

And I wasn't being a dick, I think that for people who have a real affinity with their animals and are committed to their upkeep with ones like horses, their partners need to be on the same page or they aren't compatible as they take up so much leisure time. So if he doesn't understand that then yes I think it could be an issue longer term.

Doesn't mean one party is right / wrong, just not on the same page on something likely to be a long term issue.

hellojelly · 23/01/2024 09:44

cocunut · 23/01/2024 09:19

Hahaha, I should’ve known I’d attract animal haters on this post! We’ve been away dozens of times over the past two summers - he knows I can’t do winter getaways as it’s so much extra work this time of year.
Would your response have been different if I substituted horses in this post for kids…? You’d get flamed if you said this re. a woman with kids…

If you know you can't ever do winter getaways why did you not say "sorry I can't" rather than "nice idea let's talk about it?"

twnety · 23/01/2024 09:45

cocunut · 23/01/2024 09:19

Hahaha, I should’ve known I’d attract animal haters on this post! We’ve been away dozens of times over the past two summers - he knows I can’t do winter getaways as it’s so much extra work this time of year.
Would your response have been different if I substituted horses in this post for kids…? You’d get flamed if you said this re. a woman with kids…

i didnt read that as an animal hater, but I agree.

I dont have a dog, partly because I'm not a dog person, but mainly because I can go away at a drop of a hat, and ask neighbours to feed cats (I feed their cats when they're away but they put their dog in kennels)

MeMyBooksAndMyCats · 23/01/2024 09:45

Why didn't he arrange it when his step mum was down closer to you two?

YANBU, horses are hard work in the winter he can't just expect you to down tools and go. Basically like having kids horses!

cocunut · 23/01/2024 09:46

@hellojelly I didn’t want to come off as just saying “no” because I didn’t want to appear like I wasn’t making an effort. I was going to suggest doing it at another time and didn’t know he’d already booked it! I should definitely have been clearer and given a firm no

OP posts:
Crispsandwichrock · 23/01/2024 09:47

cocunut · 23/01/2024 09:30

@BananasInThreePieceSuits personally I wouldn’t take my child on a 4 hour drive to go for a night away with people they’d never met before, which would involve a lot of drinking and being in the pub till late, then in a hotel with my BF of 2 years but you do you 🤔

This is such a rude response.
I would have thought the plan meant your bf was getting very serious about you and wanted this meet to happen - maybe a proposal on the cards? Or he just loves his family and wants you to like them too

mindutopia · 23/01/2024 09:47

I have horses. They are a pain. But if I need to go somewhere, I hire a groom to look after them for a few days to give me time away. It's just one of those things you have to sort out when you have horses really, or else you'd never go anywhere.

cocunut · 23/01/2024 09:49

@Crispsandwichrock definitely no proposal hahaha, neither of us want to get married, but I didn’t look at it from that angle so thank you!

OP posts:
whatsitcalledwhen · 23/01/2024 09:49

And finding someone reliable sooner rather than later to take care of your horses if you do have to go away somewhere in future / are otherwise unable to look after them for a few days is a good shout so you have their details on hand and the pressure isn't on you and your mum if she isn't the right person to do it or they need someone more than experienced and confident with horses that have a tendency to be naughty when you aren't there.

hellojelly · 23/01/2024 09:49

cocunut · 23/01/2024 09:46

@hellojelly I didn’t want to come off as just saying “no” because I didn’t want to appear like I wasn’t making an effort. I was going to suggest doing it at another time and didn’t know he’d already booked it! I should definitely have been clearer and given a firm no

But you said he didn't book it until after your "that's nice, let's talk about it" comment. So he's obviously taken it as a yes. I can see why he's annoyed. You knew you couldn't go as soon as he mentioned it and didn't just tell him straight. Would have taken two seconds to say "I can't at the minute but why don't we find a weekend in April" or similar.

MySugarBabyLove · 23/01/2024 09:51

At the end of the day assuming the horses were there before the BF was, he knew the score with regards to how often the OP can leave them.

Owning horses isn’t like owning a dog or a cat which you can send to kennels or get someone to come in and feed, they need far more involved care, and I speak as someone who doesn’t have any, but which most people presumably know?

Saying “let’s talk about it” should have been just that. You should have sat down and have a discussion about the practicalities, whether you could in fact get someone to look after the horses before he actually just booked it.

And if the dad only lives 20 minutes away then it seems he’s doing this deliberately to cause issues.

Now he’ll probably start saying you put your horses above him even though there were perfectly practical alternatives which don’t involve anyone putting themselves out.

StockpotSoup · 23/01/2024 09:51

It sounds like communication problems in general. He shouldn’t have assumed “Let’s talk about it” meant “Let’s book it”. But maybe you’ve also assumed he gets that it isn’t that easy to just ask your mom to “pop in” to sort out the horses. I think you’re being harsh calling people on this thread “animal haters”, but the responses you got do demonstrate that most people don’t understand the level of responsibility involved. I think you need a proper discussion to set expectations.

KT8282 · 23/01/2024 09:52

What I find odd is your BF knows you have animals and would need to confirm petsitters before agreeing to anything. ‘Let’s talk about it’ should therefore have been obviously non-committal. When I still had my doggo, my then BF (now DH) would have asked about my dog’s arrangements (out of politeness/for conversation) if we were going somewhere the dog couldn’t come. Horses are far more like children than most other pets in terms of being high maintenance so your BF needs to always consider this if he wants to date a horsey gal!

gannett · 23/01/2024 09:52

Communication issue on both your parts. You gave an ambiguous answer and I can see why he took it as a yes, but he should also have double checked.

In fact the oddest thing is that he texted you the potential plan in December, you said "let's talk about it" but a month later neither of you have revisited it? If I had been you in that scenario, I'd have started seeing whether you could find anyone to look after your animals, tell him that's what you were waiting on, then give a definitive yes/no as and when. If I had been him, I'd have chased you for a definitive answer after a week or so.

You're not being unreasonable to not want to leave your animals but tbh meeting his dad is one of those non-negotiable things that you'll have to do at some point and it's best if you start on a good foot.

cocunut · 23/01/2024 09:55

@gannett youre absolutely right and I think if I’d actually wanted to go deep down I would’ve made the arrangements quickly. Secretly all I felt was dread when he told me and I think I was subconsciously hoping he’d forget about it…

OP posts:
ThatBoyFromEastTennessee · 23/01/2024 09:57

You gave an ambiguous answer and I can see why he took it as a yes, but he should also have double checked.

Really? How does saying something sounds nice but asking to talk about it mean yes?

cocunut · 23/01/2024 10:03

FWIW he’s met my mum, dad and brother and tried to bring this up last night. However it is different as my parents are 20 minutes from him, still together, and I haven’t done the whole extended family thing as they are all 200+ miles away. He seems to think as he has “made an effort” with my family that I am not reciprocating (he hasn’t said this explicitly but I think that’s what he is thinking), I should do the same: however he has literally ZERO responsibilities outside of work and I haven’t asked him to sit in a car for 4 hours!

OP posts:
gannett · 23/01/2024 10:03

cocunut · 23/01/2024 09:55

@gannett youre absolutely right and I think if I’d actually wanted to go deep down I would’ve made the arrangements quickly. Secretly all I felt was dread when he told me and I think I was subconsciously hoping he’d forget about it…

I've definitely done the whole ostrich thing in the past when it's come to things I don't want to do. Never works out well, as I'm sure you don't need us to tell you any more!

Gazelda · 23/01/2024 10:16

I'm sensing that there's more of an obstacle for you than the animal care.

You mention the long drive several times. Meeting new people. These seem to make you feel uncomfortable.

He was an idiot to go ahead and book before having a face to face chat. But equally, you were vague and you need to let him know that the distance and meeting new people is also a challenge for you.

You're not being completely honest with him by blaming it on him for not considering your animal care responsibilities when the reality is that there's more issues that he doesn't know about.

cocunut · 23/01/2024 10:21

@Gazelda you’re right - we both drive but I am not comfortable driving at all for more than an hour at a time, but I get (mild) car sick as a passenger and just don’t enjoy long drives. I also worry that we will carpool with his dad and they will share the driving; I’m not sure I would feel happy in a car for that long when I don’t really know his dad very well.
It’s also just sooo far away! If it was closer to home I’d drive myself there (so I couldn’t have too much to drink and potentially make a fool of myself!) and could make my excuses and drive myself back so I didn’t have to stay for longer if I didn’t want to.

OP posts:
JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 23/01/2024 10:23

Get recommendations for a local freelance groom and ask your Mum to check/supervise/support.

This is less of an imposition on your Mum but you have peace of mind the first time you use a freelance groom.

It is really important to have someone trustworthy available for holiday/emergency cover if you have horses. Treat this as a good opportunity to trial someone in a low risk situation.

whatsitcalledwhen · 23/01/2024 10:25

cocunut · 23/01/2024 10:21

@Gazelda you’re right - we both drive but I am not comfortable driving at all for more than an hour at a time, but I get (mild) car sick as a passenger and just don’t enjoy long drives. I also worry that we will carpool with his dad and they will share the driving; I’m not sure I would feel happy in a car for that long when I don’t really know his dad very well.
It’s also just sooo far away! If it was closer to home I’d drive myself there (so I couldn’t have too much to drink and potentially make a fool of myself!) and could make my excuses and drive myself back so I didn’t have to stay for longer if I didn’t want to.

Doesn't your boyfriend know all this already though? Or can't you tell him straight that these are the reasons? Have you done that now?

It sounds like you could do with clearer communication all round from both sides.

cocunut · 23/01/2024 10:27

I feel like using those reasons would come across so much worse than saying sorry I can’t due to the horses! I could technically “get over” the drive and the new people and I’d be fine. But the horses are a solid reason not to go (and are the main reason anyway).

OP posts:
cocunut · 23/01/2024 10:29

Tbh I feel like for the first time meeting people he’s really put me in quite a high pressure situation! I think he should have been a bit more considerate that I might prefer to meet in a local pub for lunch or dinner and go home afterwards before giving me a baptism of fire with the extended family!!

OP posts:
Sunnydays0101 · 23/01/2024 10:35

I think you are being very contrary about this. It’s pretty normal for couples your age without kids to go away for weekends, be free and spontaneous. If your DP’s family lived four hours away full-time, you’d be travelling to meet them at some stage. A lovely idea, let’s talk about it showed no reluctance, negativity or unwillingness. I’d say it’s pretty boring that your life has to revolve around a few horses.