Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)

410 replies

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 00:15

Why the hell are GMB gaslighting women with this stuff?

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

This is an enormous male-bodied person - even larger than the interviewing man!

Post edited by MNHQ

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 09:54

I notice that 'it's only a game' is only ever trotted out with regards to women's sports. Everyone seems on board with men's sports as an industry worth billions of dollars.

EasternStandard · 23/01/2024 09:54

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 23/01/2024 09:50

Hopes and dreams about playing golf? It's only a game!

And can be people’s livelihoods like any professional sport

Does that only matter when it’s a male? Why?

ChishiyaBat · 23/01/2024 09:53

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 23/01/2024 09:50

Hopes and dreams about playing golf? It's only a game!

It's only a game? People spend money, hours of their life training to be able to compete!

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 09:53

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 23/01/2024 09:50

Hopes and dreams about playing golf? It's only a game!

It isn't only a game. That is to play into the hands of people like ParkRun.

It is a serious sport, that people train for, spend their life training and getting better. And given the prize money available on the professional circuit, it is well worth being good at.

ArabellaScott · 23/01/2024 09:52

Hopes and dreams about playing golf? It's only a game!

Some people are professional sports people, and this is their career.

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 09:51

Hopes and dreams about playing golf? It's only a game!

Tell that to the man taking women's opportunities then

ChishiyaBat · 23/01/2024 09:51

Isn't it just @bluebunny1

@OvaHere Oh no it would be so unladylike to be disrespectful wouldn't it!

Men do not belong in female spaces and sports doesn't matter how many unnecessary surgeries they have, they are still men!

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 09:51

My own belief system is led by reality. My statements are led by this and unless you are saying my speech should be compelled to reflect someone else's belief system that is in direct conflict with my own I can call this person a man.

The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command 1984

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 23/01/2024 09:50

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 00:59

How is it dripping with hate?

I disagree that males should be able to cheat their way into taking women’s spaces in sports competitions or as in this case - win them entirely! And “I’M’” hateful?

Its not hateful to women to take away their hopes and dreams, hard work and chances to win?

Hopes and dreams about playing golf? It's only a game!

willingtolearn · 23/01/2024 09:47

I am glad to see the polling results.

As to 'misgendering' I am not an adherent of the transideology belief system. Misgendering is a made up word to me.

My own belief system is led by reality. My statements are led by this and unless you are saying my speech should be compelled to reflect someone else's belief system that is in direct conflict with my own I can call this person a man.

LondonLass91 · 23/01/2024 09:47

As much as you have Sharron Davies, Martina, Daily Thompson etc stating that this is unfair, you then have Tom Daley and Gary Lineker saying that trans women are women and as such, it is unfair to exclude them from women only sport. And I cannot understand how they can possibly think that? How on earth can these sport men not understand how unfair women find it?

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 09:46

StragglyTinsel · 23/01/2024 09:30

I think you need to actually look beyond the rhetoric of ‘trans excluding’ and think here.

What makes you think anyone you put in the TERF category is against female people competing in female sports or being in female spaces?

Trans men are female - even if they don’t want to be.

Arguing that people should use the correct provision according to their biological sex is only ‘trans excluding’ if you believe trans people should have the right to decide they are the exception to this and use the opposite sex provision. Even then, the point is not excluding or hating trans people. It’s simply the principle that people have a right to single sex provision in circumstances where it makes a difference.

Just so i can be clear before i get indignant.

Are you telling me to think about what i said right before you paraphrase what i said. Or are you just emphasising what i said and agreeing with it?

Jovacknockowitch · 23/01/2024 09:45

FerryTale · 23/01/2024 00:24

Can you get this moved to FWR please?

Why?

ArabellaScott · 23/01/2024 09:45

Just noting. GMB have updated their Tweet. (my bold)

Original:

'Hailey Davidson reveals she’s received a number of anti-trans messages - including death threats - since becoming the first-ever transgender player to win a female field event. She also accepts some trans athletes do have an advantage when playing against women in sports'

Update:

'Exclusive: Hailey Davidson reveals she’s received a number of anti-trans messages - including death threats - since becoming the first-ever transgender player to win a female field event. She also accepts some trans athletes do have an advantage in women’s sports.'

I have screenshots saved.

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 09:44

AlisonDonut · 23/01/2024 09:28

If women who took testosterone measured at even half the same levels as men who lower theirs [and say they are women], they would be banned from competition.

I was just thinking about this. I grew up in the 70s and 80s so i well remember the DDR female athletes, and i have read about their later troubles and early deaths.

But theoretically, if there is an agreed lower threshold for testosterone for TW in sport, and women were allowed to raise their testosterone levels (from pre- or onset- of puberty i guess) to the same level what would the outcome be? Would the playing field be somewhat levelled (although height, leg and arm length etc may not be affected in the girls/women?)

Not that anyone should be taking testosterone to prove this. Again we saw what happened to those girls/women in the DDR. It was obscene.

TempleOfBloom · 23/01/2024 09:43

I think GMB know exactly what they are doing here, which is highlighting the absurdity and unfairness. They probably got the interview on the ticket of allowing the golfer to be plaintif about death threats, but managed to emphasise the bulk, get the golfer to agree that it is unfair etc.

I had to laugh though. Having to keep alert when out at night? Clearly the first time the golfer has ever felt vulnerable when out at night…that’s being a woman for you!

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 09:42

OchonAgusOchonOh · 23/01/2024 09:39

I completely agree.

The only way to look/behave like a woman is to be one. If something (sport, prisons, refuges, changing facilities, prizes) are categorised as women's/men's then they should be restricted to actual women/men.

Yep. I also think people who think TW competing is fine should ask themselves: why are sports segregated by sex on the first place?

thedankness · 23/01/2024 09:40

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 09:08

See this I don’t understand. I completely get the not wanting trans women competing against women and it is unfair. They have a competitive advantage. I can’t for the life of me understand why you would be opposed to trans women having their own category. It doesn’t hurt you, and means they can still compete and have a fair crack.

An extra category for transwomen just gives men another category in which to compete and win medals, when women's sport already does not have parity with men's in terms of funding, coverage etc. So it's not fair unless you also have a category for transmen. The problem with that is you're creating a category where doping (taking testosterone) is allowed. You're also creating two far smaller pools of competitors, thus increasing the likelihood of winning. You're doing this based on identity alone, as there is no way to meaningfully distinguish between "genuine trans" (whatever that means) and someone identifying into the trans category in order to increase their likelihood of success. The caveat is that they have to alter their body in harmful ways, either by taking cross-sex hormones or drugs to reduce their hormones.

I think this would be a real slippery slope in terms of athletes being encouraged/forced into altering their bodies to enter the trans category, which is highly unethical. We have already seen this with Caster Semenya - a male athlete with a DSD. Men with DSDs are scouted because they are guaranteed medals if they compete in the women's category. This is obviously unfair on women athletes, but it is also exploiting the male athletes in usually poorer countries who will suffer the health consequences of lowering their testosterone.

At the end of the day not everyone has the ability to compete in elite sport, whether down to genetics, choice or a combination of both. If you choose to make alterations to your body that doesn't necessarily give you the right to your own category of sport. Trans people are not a third group of people; they are men and women with varying body modifications. They should compete in an open category with men, and there should be a female-only category.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 23/01/2024 09:39

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 09:33

to be fair i often don't look/dress/act like a (stereotype) woman. right now I'm wearing big socks, tracksuit bottoms, a metal band t-shirt and a hoody that my DCs bought for DH but he doesn't wear so i do (from the men's department of a clothes shop)

I am wearing no make up, i have short hair, no jewellery and no nailvarnish.

A person with gender dysphoria may never ever do that because part of their dysphoria is focused on the stereotype. The people who use Malaga airport definitely won't dress like me today because reasons.

That isn't an issue for me. The issue is biological men in places biological men shouldn't be. Including a women's golf competition.

I completely agree.

The only way to look/behave like a woman is to be one. If something (sport, prisons, refuges, changing facilities, prizes) are categorised as women's/men's then they should be restricted to actual women/men.

lola8345 · 23/01/2024 09:38

GMB have highlighted this, I don't follow golf, I would have no idea about this.
I guess they turned comments off, so that they wouldn't have to pull the article, due to accusations of hate.
I don't think they were supporting the golfer at all. It's a very clever way to highlight injustice.

bluebunny1 · 23/01/2024 09:36

ChishiyaBat · 23/01/2024 09:34

I am just leaving this here so you can see how many women are being robbed of their rightful wins, dignity and places/scholarships etc. it's sickening!

https://www.shewon.org/

This is shocking

OvaHere · 23/01/2024 09:35

ChishiyaBat · 23/01/2024 09:34

I am just leaving this here so you can see how many women are being robbed of their rightful wins, dignity and places/scholarships etc. it's sickening!

https://www.shewon.org/

But we mustn't be disrespectful. That would truly be terrible.

LondonLass91 · 23/01/2024 09:35

I wonder why they did turn off comments, why does it matter to them if people think this is unfair? Do they usually turn of comments, or just for this issue 🤐

ChishiyaBat · 23/01/2024 09:34

I am just leaving this here so you can see how many women are being robbed of their rightful wins, dignity and places/scholarships etc. it's sickening!

https://www.shewon.org/

She Won banner: Selina Soule and Alanna Miller; picture attributed to Alliance Defending Freedom

List of Female Athletes by Sport | She Won

This website is dedicated to archiving the achievements of female athletes who were displaced by males in women’s sporting events.

https://www.shewon.org/

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 09:33

OchonAgusOchonOh · 23/01/2024 09:18

Ah really now. Did you not notice the very feminine earrings?

to be fair i often don't look/dress/act like a (stereotype) woman. right now I'm wearing big socks, tracksuit bottoms, a metal band t-shirt and a hoody that my DCs bought for DH but he doesn't wear so i do (from the men's department of a clothes shop)

I am wearing no make up, i have short hair, no jewellery and no nailvarnish.

A person with gender dysphoria may never ever do that because part of their dysphoria is focused on the stereotype. The people who use Malaga airport definitely won't dress like me today because reasons.

That isn't an issue for me. The issue is biological men in places biological men shouldn't be. Including a women's golf competition.