Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)

410 replies

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 00:15

Why the hell are GMB gaslighting women with this stuff?

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

This is an enormous male-bodied person - even larger than the interviewing man!

Post edited by MNHQ

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Boiledbeetle · 26/01/2024 07:41

SchoolQuestionnaire · 26/01/2024 07:26

I agree. I’ve said a number of times that I don’t think trans women should have access to women’s spaces.

But it's not just the women's spaces. it's the being expected to deny the reality in front of our eyes and pretend that Dave in accounts really is a woman now. Why does Dave get to insist we all call him she when talking about him if he's not there?

Why do I have to respect that Dave apparently is now a woman and address him as such and have to put in the mental energy to correct myself every time I speak to him and address him as Davina, despite working with him for 20 years as Dave, when he is showing no respect whatsoever for women by insisting I do that? Why am I seen as the bad person for refusing to collude with Daves mistaken belief that he is a woman?

Where's the respect for me, as a woman, that Dave 's insistence that after 50 years of being male he is suddenly a woman and as such should be treated as one?

Why does Dave's feelings take precedent over my feelings?

Respect is a two way street. I'm perfectly happy to respect Dave. I'll respect Dave's choices in how he wishes to live his life, he can wear what he wants, call himself what he wants, live how he wants, but when Dave tries to gaslight me into agreeing with him that he's a woman then I shall respond with the same level of respect that he is showing to me, an actual woman.

pickledandpuzzled · 26/01/2024 07:37

I see where you are coming from, @SchoolQuestionnaire and am not hostile towards trans identifying people. I am concerned about children and I am concerned about certain situations- single sex spaces, seats and so on.

You mentioned convicted criminals should lose certain courtesies- if we have to wait for the conviction to correctly sex them then the survivors would be expected to refer to her attacker as a woman- she. That’s never acceptable to me, whether the offence was a punch or rape.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 26/01/2024 07:26

Boiledbeetle · 26/01/2024 07:15

Oh I get that, but I'm at a loss as to why this particular group of men should be treated any different from the rest of the men.

Why is assumed that on Monday Dave in accounts is a man and of course Dave is not going to be welcome in women's toilets, changing rooms, prisons, and sports etc. But on Tuesday when Dave comes into work, maybe wearing some makeup and a skirt, maybe still in his shirt and tie with his full beard, and utters the four words "I am a woman" we are supposed to suddenly change our speech, respect his pronouns, accept he's a woman and discuss how painful his periods are with him whilst we wait in the queue for the women's toilets.

What happened between Monday 5pm and Tuesday 9am that makes Dave extra extra special, and different from the rest of the men in the office and suddenly gives Dave access to women only stuff?

I agree. I’ve said a number of times that I don’t think trans women should have access to women’s spaces.

Boiledbeetle · 26/01/2024 07:15

SchoolQuestionnaire · 26/01/2024 06:43

I’m sorry if it came across that I’m telling you or anyone how to behave as that is not the case at all. I’m simply explaining my own thoughts.

Oh I get that, but I'm at a loss as to why this particular group of men should be treated any different from the rest of the men.

Why is assumed that on Monday Dave in accounts is a man and of course Dave is not going to be welcome in women's toilets, changing rooms, prisons, and sports etc. But on Tuesday when Dave comes into work, maybe wearing some makeup and a skirt, maybe still in his shirt and tie with his full beard, and utters the four words "I am a woman" we are supposed to suddenly change our speech, respect his pronouns, accept he's a woman and discuss how painful his periods are with him whilst we wait in the queue for the women's toilets.

What happened between Monday 5pm and Tuesday 9am that makes Dave extra extra special, and different from the rest of the men in the office and suddenly gives Dave access to women only stuff?

SchoolQuestionnaire · 26/01/2024 06:43

Boiledbeetle · 26/01/2024 06:40

With respect, you have no idea what trans women do or don’t experience because you aren’t one

And transwomen have no bloody clue whatsoever what women experience because they aren't one. They are men.

I'm still not getting why I should ever be respectful of any man who thinks it's OK to trample all over women's boundaries

I just feel that there is room for compromise between ‘twaw so we must all share space with women and anyone who doesn’t agree is a terf and should die’ and ‘trans women are not women so I give no shits about their security at all and they can just fuck off’.

Go and read the threads about the ERCC tribunal and see how far you move towards the they can just fuck off stage by the end

I’m sorry if it came across that I’m telling you or anyone how to behave as that is not the case at all. I’m simply explaining my own thoughts.

Boiledbeetle · 26/01/2024 06:40

With respect, you have no idea what trans women do or don’t experience because you aren’t one

And transwomen have no bloody clue whatsoever what women experience because they aren't one. They are men.

I'm still not getting why I should ever be respectful of any man who thinks it's OK to trample all over women's boundaries

I just feel that there is room for compromise between ‘twaw so we must all share space with women and anyone who doesn’t agree is a terf and should die’ and ‘trans women are not women so I give no shits about their security at all and they can just fuck off’.

Go and read the threads about the ERCC tribunal and see how far you move towards the they can just fuck off stage by the end

SchoolQuestionnaire · 26/01/2024 06:23

SoreAndTired1 · 26/01/2024 04:57

Where is it 'well documented'? There has never been one publicised assault on a transwoman in the mens. Not one documented case. Believe me if there was, they'd rub it in our faces and never let us forget. Indeed and in fact, on the contrary. Gay men and even some transwomen have said transwomen never get any hassle in the mens, the most they get is a smirk. They are safe in the mens room. So please stop lying.

Also, just on your 'misgendering' nonsense, it hurts women, especially RAPE SURVIVORS who have to testify in court and call her rapist 'she'. It gaslights women into denying our experiences and what we see with our own eyes. Mis-sexing, and yes, that is what you are doing, mis-sexing hurts women. So please stop mis-sexing men.

Please be assured that I have no skin in this game and don’t need to lie. I’m just on a forum taking part in a reasonable discussion.

With respect, you have no idea what trans women do or don’t experience because you aren’t one. Feelings understandably run high around this issue but I can’t understand the lack of flexibility on both sides of this discussion. I just feel that there is room for compromise between ‘twaw so we must all share space with women and anyone who doesn’t agree is a terf and should die’ and ‘trans women are not women so I give no shits about their security at all and they can just fuck off’.

I maintain that I don’t think there is anything wrong with trans women having their own spaces (separate to women). I also still believe that the vast majority of trans women don’t want to hurt anyone and don’t deserve the vitriol they face. With that in mind I choose to refer to someone in the terms they prefer as a mark of respect. While there are some exceptions I don’t agree that for the most part it hurts anyone.

Re the issue of rape victims I understand that some men are taking advantage of this entire shitshow to gain access to women to harm them. I wholeheartedly agree that convicted criminals should lose all rights re how they are described. I also agree that a woman is biologically incapable of rape so shouldn’t be described in this way. I don’t know how to balance this as I don’t have all the answers here. This is why it’s important to have these discussions.

https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/transgender-teens-restricted-bathroom-access-sexual-assault/

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/oct/05/record-rise-hate-crimes-transgender-people-reported-england-and-wales

Transgender teens with restricted bathroom access at higher risk of sexual assault

Transgender and gender-nonbinary teens face greater risk of sexual assault in schools that prevent them from using bathrooms or locker rooms consistent with their gender identity, according to a re…

https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/transgender-teens-restricted-bathroom-access-sexual-assault/

SoreAndTired1 · 26/01/2024 06:17

autisticat · 23/01/2024 23:08

This thread is disgusting, and as @Overcooker said, dripping with hate. It’s clear, as usual, that many of you have never met a trans woman and don’t know what you’re talking about.

@autisticat Being outraged at a man cheating women out of spot isn't 'hate' you misogynist. Wake up to yourself. Your ignorance is sad. It's clear you have never met a transwoman.

SoreAndTired1 · 26/01/2024 06:06

Dantedisciple · 23/01/2024 19:54

I don't think it is pandering to the men of this world I think it is pandering to the law of the UK.
Have you ever met a man who is in favour of men or male born persons competing in women's sport?

Not met, but know of male sports officials that are in favour of it, unfortunately. One an ex-olympic gold medalist himself.

SoreAndTired1 · 26/01/2024 04:57

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 09:06

I didn’t say women should let trans women in. I specifically said that trans women should have their own spaces but you missed that bit of the quote. It is well documented that trans women are also not safe around men and I don’t want anyone to feel unsafe.

Where is it 'well documented'? There has never been one publicised assault on a transwoman in the mens. Not one documented case. Believe me if there was, they'd rub it in our faces and never let us forget. Indeed and in fact, on the contrary. Gay men and even some transwomen have said transwomen never get any hassle in the mens, the most they get is a smirk. They are safe in the mens room. So please stop lying.

Also, just on your 'misgendering' nonsense, it hurts women, especially RAPE SURVIVORS who have to testify in court and call her rapist 'she'. It gaslights women into denying our experiences and what we see with our own eyes. Mis-sexing, and yes, that is what you are doing, mis-sexing hurts women. So please stop mis-sexing men.

DeeLusional · 25/01/2024 13:45

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 25/01/2024 10:04

They got ratioed to hell and back for that post, started hiding replies and eventually turned off replying all together. People aren't playing pretend anymore.

Professor Jo Phoenix has this week won a case againt the Open University, who was hounded from her job for basically saying sex matters and sometimes it's more important than identity. Someone compared her to a 'racist uncle' for that.

But also this week, we've had people who work for a rape crisis centre stand up and say they will not confirm the sex of a worker assigned to a victim. They will only say 'no men work here'. Their CEO is male, no GRC, who took the role in spite of the exemptions applied which meant the role was supposed to be female only.

This is not a big secret btw, women know. But 'no men work here'. Gaslighting rape victims ffs. A witness went as far to say this person was a biological woman 🤯

That 50 year old bloke, swimming and changing with young girls makes me sick. Felt attacked apparently when parents held up towels to protect their daughters, and instead of sending him packing the powers that be banned the parents. He's a pervert and I'll bloody well call him one.

We have a way to go on getting our stuff back.

The CEO of the Edinburgh Rape Crisis centre admitted to doing 4 counselling sessions a week despite having no relevant training or qualifications (his quals are in Hotel Management) and said he did the sessions "to keep it fun". Fun. Rape and Trauma counselling is FUN to him. Still no news of him being sacked though.

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 25/01/2024 10:04

They got ratioed to hell and back for that post, started hiding replies and eventually turned off replying all together. People aren't playing pretend anymore.

Professor Jo Phoenix has this week won a case againt the Open University, who was hounded from her job for basically saying sex matters and sometimes it's more important than identity. Someone compared her to a 'racist uncle' for that.

But also this week, we've had people who work for a rape crisis centre stand up and say they will not confirm the sex of a worker assigned to a victim. They will only say 'no men work here'. Their CEO is male, no GRC, who took the role in spite of the exemptions applied which meant the role was supposed to be female only.

This is not a big secret btw, women know. But 'no men work here'. Gaslighting rape victims ffs. A witness went as far to say this person was a biological woman 🤯

That 50 year old bloke, swimming and changing with young girls makes me sick. Felt attacked apparently when parents held up towels to protect their daughters, and instead of sending him packing the powers that be banned the parents. He's a pervert and I'll bloody well call him one.

We have a way to go on getting our stuff back.

literalviolence · 25/01/2024 09:09

Personally I hate males in women's sports and I hate that some sections of society support that. I won't be shamed for hating injustice and misogyny. Every single person who says TWAW is dripping hatebl for women.

pickledandpuzzled · 24/01/2024 17:05

Indignant is a good word.

There’s another thread underway where women are getting scolded for pushing back.

It’s not dripping with hate to raise a concern about a situation.

It’s not transphobic to recognise that a 50yr old man shouldn’t be changing and swimming with teenage girls, and that a middle aged trans woman winning a golf tournament has displaced one of the women for who the competition was set up.

Women are cross, indignant and are past couching their opinions in soft appeasing terms.

Verv · 24/01/2024 17:04

Another mediocre man muscling in on women's sports.
Eventually the penny will drop with the public that there's money to be made from their shiny new "identities" and they'll be viewed as nothing more than second rate grifters.

viques · 24/01/2024 16:59

autisticat · 23/01/2024 23:08

This thread is disgusting, and as @Overcooker said, dripping with hate. It’s clear, as usual, that many of you have never met a trans woman and don’t know what you’re talking about.

“Dripping with hate”?

I don’t think so, it is however full of indignant women who have been patient and forbearing for a long time , have had that thrown back in their faces with death and rape threats a thousand times , and are now standing up for their legal rights and are pushing back against ridiculous, inaccurate statements and ‘ beliefs’ that have no basis in science, reinforce outdated stereotypes about human behaviour, aim to reduce women’s freedoms, safety and dignity , and in this instance and other similar cases , enable cheating in order to steal women’s sporting success, ambitions, sponsorship, records and monetary gains.

Hate no. Anger yes.

Delphinium20 · 24/01/2024 16:38

I don't think anyone who is a competent adult believes this. Yes, some kids are confused, some people with mental health delusions may believe it, yes, some vulnerable adults with neurodivergence may possibly believe it (or are simply confused by the definitions of words), but no one truly believes that TWAW. When they say TWAW they are saying that they want to pretend that TWAW in order to allow TW to do what they want regarding women's spaces. It's a bullying tactic.

However, I don't think it's always bullying. Similar to saying (but not exactly), "I don't see color" when discussing racism. OBVIOUSLY, people can see the differences between a Black person and a white person. Sometimes "I don't see color" has good intentions behind it that really mean, "I don't judge you based on your skin/race." But, pretending not to see race has pitfalls.

Sometimes, when a person says, "Oh, I see so and so as a woman" they are attempting a similar good intention. They want to be kind or nice or non-confrontational or a good person. But, they haven't thought this through re: policies and real life issues. When they say, "I consider this TW a real woman" they don't ever mean it in a literal sense.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 24/01/2024 15:34

bawbells · 24/01/2024 15:31

He's not a trans woman is he. A man cannot turn into a woman. A woman cannot turn into a man.

He is a transwoman. In the same way a seahorse is not a type of horse, a transwoman is not a type of woman.

In fact, the only thing every transwoman has in common with every other transwoman is that they are all a type of man.

bawbells · 24/01/2024 15:31

He's not a trans woman is he. A man cannot turn into a woman. A woman cannot turn into a man.

lola8345 · 24/01/2024 15:28

If my 13 year old daughter had been a changing room with that 50 year old, they would have needed to shoot me. like hell is that acceptable.

The fire alarm would have been activated in the first instance then yes everyone would have heard my views on the wrongs of 'them" competing in a girls category and changing with them.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 24/01/2024 12:48

It's quite complicated

This old chestnut again.

There is fuck all complicated about it. Or any situation that involves men who claim to have a 'gender identity' demanding access to anything meant for women.

Doesn't matter if they've taken estrogen or what they wear. They are not a type of woman and they are certainly not female.

The very reason they have been allowed to compete in women's sports is because they are men. They demanded full access and were handed it without question, mostly by other men.

Actual women's feelings, safety or fairness were never even considered.
It's almost like they know exactly what a woman is after all. Funny that.

pickledandpuzzled · 24/01/2024 12:36

Universalsnail · 24/01/2024 09:20

Trans women arguably have some advantage in some sports and not others. It's quite complicated, is very sport dependent and also extent of transition treatment dependent for some sports.

I have no idea if golf is one of those sports.

But it doesn't matter because this person is legally considered a she and was legally allowed to play golf in the womens category. If people have an issue with this they need to take it up with the people who set the regulations about golf, not send this individual death threats for being trans and having the audacity for playing a sport they love in the category they are allowed to compete in. Petition to have the regulations of who is allowed to compete changed if you wish but attaching the individual isn't ok.

Edited

There’s a 50yr old male born competing in the girls over 13s race. I mean he’s over 13 but doesn’t meet the category in any other way.

It’s legal because it’s in Canada.

‘Legal’ doesn’t mean ‘right’. Particularly as he’s changing with the girls and doesn’t like their parents using towels to shield them.

A pervert is still a pervert, even when they haven’t broken the law.

When someone wins by finding a loophole in the regs, the regs are rewritten to prevent it happening again. It is still cheating the first time though.

Helleofabore · 24/01/2024 12:15

autisticat · 23/01/2024 23:08

This thread is disgusting, and as @Overcooker said, dripping with hate. It’s clear, as usual, that many of you have never met a trans woman and don’t know what you’re talking about.

On the contrary. Many of the posters on this thread are very knowledgable. Why is it relevant that someone has to have 'met' a male with a trans identity to have knowledge about the advantages that male people have? The advantages that are not reduced with testosterone suppression.

I think it is you who appear to not know what you are talking about.

HermioneKipper · 24/01/2024 12:10

I can’t understand why people are trying to pretend there’s no differences between men and women.

We all know that men are bigger and stronger than women, faster and can hit further/faster.

The bloke in question is extremely tall, broad and clearly hugely powerful. A few years of taking cross sex hormones doesn’t reduce his lung capacity or size does it?!

Are people being wilfully stupid and disingenuous on purpose? They can’t actually believe this nonsense can they??

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 24/01/2024 10:15

There is nothing to stop this person competing in the appropriate sex category. Only someone who wants to take advantage would not do so. Or someone seeking validation.

Exactly

Swipe left for the next trending thread