Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)

410 replies

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 00:15

Why the hell are GMB gaslighting women with this stuff?

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

This is an enormous male-bodied person - even larger than the interviewing man!

Post edited by MNHQ

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:02

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 00:56

I have concerns around trans women in women’s sport but this thread is just dripping with hate. I hope it’s deleted.

please report the hateful posts.
You'll have a job finding them, tbh

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:01

FerryTale · 23/01/2024 00:24

Can you get this moved to FWR please?

Dear MN - please don't. Stop hiding perfectly normal posts where the people who can't see what's happening fear to tread.

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:00

Flickersy · 23/01/2024 00:21

They haven't described him as a woman in that tweet. He is referred to by the interviewer twice as born male.

Unless you think he's lying about the death threats or you think the death threats are somehow acceptable in the circumstances and that's what they're "gaslighting" about?

well they could report that a man who claims to be a trans woman has taken away opportunities from women golfers, and is getting threats. None of those actions is ok.

WickedSerious · 23/01/2024 07:59

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 01:17

Mumsnet’s guidelines re misgendering:

“That said, it’s clear that most trans people find the use of pronouns or names that they or others have consciously rejected, to be hurtful and would therefore struggle to engage in a discussion with those who insist on using them. The same is true of the expression ‘Trans-Identified Male’ or ‘TIM’. Likewise, many feminists are affronted by the term ‘cis’ and ‘terf’, so using these terms will make civil debate less likely. As we’ve said, context is everything – but our moderation team will most likely delete these expressions if we feel they're being used in a deliberately inflammatory way.”

I assume this thread is only still up because fewer mods are around overnight.

Or maybe it's still up because he's a bloke.

FantasticElasticBand · 23/01/2024 07:56

Average (exc big hitters) PGA drive = 300 yds

HD (pre transition) = 250 / 275 yds

Average LPGA = 250 yds

When you hit off a tee, there’s nothing stopping your swing - it’s all club head speed. Very different from hitting off the green / rough.

Also, general fitness / stamina for going around the course.

See also tactical play - which club you’d use to hit which part of the fairway. It’s not always about driving long distances. So if you play tactically - rather than distance, your driving distances reduce = your overall driving averages reduce.

Tactical round play or overall tactical play (see Lia Thomas re speed).

Palladin · 23/01/2024 07:55

This whole farce is so depressing.

literalviolence · 23/01/2024 07:37

In my opinion, any male in women's sports is a cheat and a bigot but even people who show such disregard for others should not get death threats.

hollyhola · 23/01/2024 03:44

I am not anti trans.

I am pro women.

Trans people are more than welcome to live their life as they see authentic to them. Carry on.

But women and their rights must be protected.

Trans women should not be allowed to compete in women's sports or enter spaces where women could be vulnerable such as toilets and changing rooms.

I feel this is very logical and pragmatic and I really cannot understand how things have managed to get this far.

Delphinium20 · 23/01/2024 03:35

”My whole philosophy behind all of this is I don’t believe trans people should be banned from sports, but I do believe there needs to be guidelines in effect," Davidson said.

Such lies. No one, and I mean no one, not even the most conservative states in the US are banning trans people from sports. They are just making them follow THE SAME RULES AS EVERYONE ELSE: play on the team of your sex and no doping.

Delphinium20 · 23/01/2024 03:28

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 00:56

I have concerns around trans women in women’s sport but this thread is just dripping with hate. I hope it’s deleted.

You're right. It's very clear that transwomen hate women and will do anything to ruin their sports opportunities.

Flufferblub · 23/01/2024 03:24

It's just crap. I've heard of trans women winning bike tournaments, swimming, weight lifting and now golf. It's so discouraging for female athletes. Are there trans women in boxing now? Punching the living daylights out of women and then being handed a trophy?

If you're born male, it's baked through every cell. You can change a few things about your appearance on the outside, and you can change your clothes and name to look a bit more female. But you still have the muscle mass, lung capacity and hand strength of a male. It's just a fact. It's just the truth.

If someone digs up human remains in 100s of years, and they test the DNA to see if that person was male or female, it will show up in the DNA. It will never matter what that person might have identified as.

Trans women should just compete against other trans women really.

Do you get trans men competing in men's sports? I don't know really, I haven't heard about that one.

yesmen · 23/01/2024 03:14

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 01:17

Mumsnet’s guidelines re misgendering:

“That said, it’s clear that most trans people find the use of pronouns or names that they or others have consciously rejected, to be hurtful and would therefore struggle to engage in a discussion with those who insist on using them. The same is true of the expression ‘Trans-Identified Male’ or ‘TIM’. Likewise, many feminists are affronted by the term ‘cis’ and ‘terf’, so using these terms will make civil debate less likely. As we’ve said, context is everything – but our moderation team will most likely delete these expressions if we feel they're being used in a deliberately inflammatory way.”

I assume this thread is only still up because fewer mods are around overnight.

#nodebate?

Funny how people can be sticklers for rules when the argument is hard to win.

But sticklers for breaking rules when it comes to redefining women as a class; redefining breast feeding, pregnancy, menstruation, and most accepted terms that describe parts and functions of the female body; redefine womens sports, single sex spaces and so much more.

Not much redefining of men going on though is there? No rules being broken there. Balls are still balls...

LilyBartsHatShop · 23/01/2024 03:14

BobbyBiscuits · 23/01/2024 02:19

@Morwenscapacioussleeves Crikey does it? I thought that was a pretty mainstream opinion as it's obviously unfair in sport. I guess I am that then.
Haha. I like to think I'm tolerant (unless PMsing).
I've never actually ever met a trans woman. I wonder how many on here have?

Back when I was footloose and fancy free I hung out in what I would have called alternative circles (I guess nowadays they'd be called queer?). I knew several trans women. I remember joking with a friend about how all the males in our group were waxed smooth as dolphins, and all the females (myself included) were hairy as yetis. It would never have occurred to me to think of trans women as female people who belonged in women's sports, or any women's groups, really.

Gowlett · 23/01/2024 03:13

Trans notwithstanding… Work away, it’s your body.
But when it comes to sport (etc) we’re just talking about physical advantage. It’s not fair. It’s dangerous. It’s needless.

mamboshirt · 23/01/2024 03:07

He is huge . Yes. What is the point of a female sports category? If you can answer that question then you know this is all kinds of wrong.

yesmen · 23/01/2024 03:06

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 01:58

So is the hate coming from the women golfers who voted to amend the LPGA constitution to allow transwomen to compete?

On first glance your point seems like a good one - the women themsleves agreed to it.

However, we know from the swimming and athletics debacle in the States that the agreement from the women was coersion, they were threatened with loss of scholarship and much more besides.

Furthermore, most decent men would not pull a stunt like this. This says an awfull lot about the ones who do.

Geppili · 23/01/2024 03:01

This is so shocking! She is huge! Ridiculous.

BobbyBiscuits · 23/01/2024 02:54

@Chichimcgee Thanks for sharing that. Yeah, I'm not surprised you feel a bit anti if the trans women you met were like that. I'd find that pretty (very) uncomfortable.. it sounds like attention seeking big time. I used to know some really camp men like that but just gay, not trans or even cross dressing.
My f to m trans family member is lovely (maybe I'm biased) but I do worry for them as 'choosing' to be a man is a whole massive can of worms. They take testosterone, I just hope they don't regret they had their boobs chopped off (parents paid for surgery). This person is over 21, and they do seem a lot happier since they transitioned. So I do have mixed feelings about the whole thing.

thinslicedham · 23/01/2024 02:50

This person acknowledges that someone born male will generally have a physical advantage over someone born female, yet still pretends (?) not to understand why there would be objections and backlash to a male competing against a female...

Maybe you can just live your life without formally competing against others, like most people do. These people know it's unfair; they just don't give a shit about fairness. It's more important for them to win or at least force everyone to pretend that they're special, stunning, and brave.

Chichimcgee · 23/01/2024 02:36

BobbyBiscuits · 23/01/2024 02:22

@Chichimcgee As I said I am fully against trans women in female sport. I've never even met a trans woman before. I've also sadly been brutally abused by men, not while they were dressed as a woman though. I certainly don't mean any disrespect to you or any other posters.

Edited

I’ve met a couple of trans men and a couple of women.
The female to male people I’ve met have been nice, you wouldn’t know they were trans, they just act like decent people and live their life.
The male to female people I’ve met have been awful, very much a caricature of what a man thinks a woman is. Immediately aggressive ‘I’m trans if you have a problem with that we’re going to have an issue’ very intense and uncomfortable to be honest.
that’s just my experience and a total of about 5 people isn’t much to go off but it was definitely a stark difference in behaviours.

TheSlantedOwl · 23/01/2024 02:23

This thread isn’t ’dripping with hate’ - it’s full of justifiable anger.

The stupidity and entitlement which led this man to cheat deserves anger.

BobbyBiscuits · 23/01/2024 02:22

@Chichimcgee As I said I am fully against trans women in female sport. I've never even met a trans woman before. I've also sadly been brutally abused by men, not while they were dressed as a woman though. I certainly don't mean any disrespect to you or any other posters.

BobbyBiscuits · 23/01/2024 02:19

@Morwenscapacioussleeves Crikey does it? I thought that was a pretty mainstream opinion as it's obviously unfair in sport. I guess I am that then.
Haha. I like to think I'm tolerant (unless PMsing).
I've never actually ever met a trans woman. I wonder how many on here have?

Chichimcgee · 23/01/2024 02:19

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 01:58

So is the hate coming from the women golfers who voted to amend the LPGA constitution to allow transwomen to compete?

As if they had a choice?! Anyone who speaks up for women’s rights risks being called names at best and risks being in fear of their life at worse.

LilyBartsHatShop · 23/01/2024 02:16

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 01:58

So is the hate coming from the women golfers who voted to amend the LPGA constitution to allow transwomen to compete?

Quite possibly, now that they're reaping what they've (naively, kindly, and behaving in exactly the way females are socialised to behave) sown.
If, by "hateful", you mean "bloody pissed off that women aren't allowed nice things all to themselves, ever."

Swipe left for the next trending thread