Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)

410 replies

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 00:15

Why the hell are GMB gaslighting women with this stuff?

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

This is an enormous male-bodied person - even larger than the interviewing man!

Post edited by MNHQ

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:33

OvaHere · 23/01/2024 08:24

Calling men, men and using male pronouns for a man is not rude and nasty. It's reality. A reality that is very important for women to uphold when these same men are shitting on us from a great height.

Just because we've been gaslit and propagandised to internalise that calling a man he is a terrible thing to do doesn't mean it is. That's just how they want us to feel in order to prevent us adequately fighting back.

I don’t disagree that the issues in women’s sports are huge and beer to be tackled urgently. I just don’t see why we can’t tackle these issues without being deliberately hurtful and disregarding the feelings of others. I don’t agree with men competing in women’s sports at all and I will fight against this in any way I can as I feel it’s unfair. But I think that can be achieved while still being respectful of others.

I take huge offence at trans women referring to ma as a ‘terf’. But how can I expect someone else to be respectful of my feelings if I don’t care about theirs. We’re all people at the end of the day.

MorningSunshineSparkles · 23/01/2024 08:32

Absolutely agree they shouldn’t have ever been allowed in women’s sports. Absolutely don’t agree they should be receiving any kind of death threats or hate. By all means voice your displeasure in him being allowed to play in a woman’s tournament but take it up with the people that decided it was ok. Directing hate at anyone is not ok.

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:32

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:24

I don’t think the thread should be deleted as discussion is valid. However I also don’t believe that there isn’t deliberate misgendering of an actual person happening here.

Your opinion is valid. As is mine. As is that of the golfer who this discussion is based on. I just think we should be able to express our opinions without being deliberately hateful. On all sides.

if you have an issue with individual posts, report them.

Misgendering isn't illegal. Wishing "terfs to die in a fat fire" apparently equally not.

And look, there is at least one post in this thread that says "cutting off a penis doesn't make that person a woman" (paraphrased). There is STILL an assumption on many people's part that trans women, or trans identified males, all have surgery. This is a misconception that, when pointed out, leads to TRAs screeching "you're obsessed with our genitals". But it is a legitimate worry, especially of women and the parents of girls and young women in particular, that people with a penis shouldn't be around their half- or unclothed girls. If their assumption is "oh they're trans, no penis" - then they need to be informed. And only by leaving discussions like this in the general mainstream board (the one with all the traffic) are some of those people going to get the message.

Alongside the lesson about how women/girls are losing out on team and podium places, scholarships and prize money. Not to mention the lack of privacy and dignity.

And also the "wah, they want trans women banned from sport" needs to be countered. If you are a man play in the men's competition. If you are a woman play in the woman's competition. If you are a trans woman play in the men's or campaign for trans women's categories. If you are a trans man - difficult. If you're taking testosterone? play in the men's or campaign for trans men's categories. It should be noted that women campaigned long and hard for their own categories. That thing with the Boston marathon is within living memory, FFS. I would have thought trans women, if they think they are women, would show a bit of sisterly solidarity. Knowing how it is to be most marginalised and all that.

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 08:31

CatMadam · 23/01/2024 08:29

God god transphobes are boring.

IKR - why aren’t these women just staying quiet and knitting or asking about laundry or something. Fucking bitches actually giving a shit about rampant misogyny, SNOOZE!!

OvaHere · 23/01/2024 08:31

CatMadam · 23/01/2024 08:29

God god transphobes are boring.

I know, right? We could all be doing something better with our time like cheating other people in sport. I guess that's more exciting.

CatMadam · 23/01/2024 08:29

God god transphobes are boring.

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 08:28

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:07

I do think there are issues arising from trans women competing in women’s sports. However one can have discussions about this while remaining respectful and considerate of the feelings of others. Deliberately misgendering a person is wrong. The othering you are engaging in is even worse. It costs nothing to be kind.

I will never ever personally be pushed into pretending a very obvious bloke is anything other than that.

Id love just someone to answer “What is a woman?”. I feel if we had an answer to that that isn’t the biological definition and isn’t a circular argument (“A woman is someone who says they’re a woman”) I’d be more open to understanding the trans ideology. I’ve been asking 10 years and never had an answer.

pickledandpuzzled · 23/01/2024 08:28

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 01:30

That is not what she says. I don’t know enough about the science to know whether I agree with her or not, but at least engage with what she’s actually saying (that pre-surgery and years of hormone treatment, she would have had an advantage):

”My whole philosophy behind all of this is I don’t believe trans people should be banned from sports, but I do believe there needs to be guidelines in effect," Davidson said. "Going back even four years ago or even before I had surgery, I definitely had an advantage. I would 100% agree with that.

"But the difference is now that years have gone on, three years after surgery, my physical capabilities now compared to back then are night and day. So again, honestly, I 100% agree that men do have advantages. Say you get a trans person on hormones for a year or no surgery nothing… of course, for the most part, yeah they’re gonna have an advantage."

I have a bridge I can sell you…

While they’re not the strong fit man they were before, they still have advantages over women.
Men get that advantage at puberty as they grow and through socialisation. It’s why we have women’s categories. No amount of transition intervention makes them shrink or changes the stability of their hips, their limb ratio etc.

Can I ask, when you say ‘dripping with hate’ which bits do you mean? I see anger, and uncompromising language. I don’t see hate. To me, saying ‘That transwoman has male advantage, he’s a cheat’, is not hate. It’s clear language.

OvaHere · 23/01/2024 08:24

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:19

I’d argue that one should be respectful of everyone. I don’t agree with trans women in women’s sport. I would have that discussion all day long. I just can’t see what being rude and nasty brings to the argument. If a person was called Fred but asked me to call them John I would just do it because it matters to them. If a person is born male but wants to be female, that in itself doesn’t hurt me but it matters to them so why would I not respect that?

Yes there are huge issues around this that need to be sorted out but this should be done via rational debate and discussion. Being deliberately hurtful helps no one. And I’d say that on both sides of the argument.

Calling men, men and using male pronouns for a man is not rude and nasty. It's reality. A reality that is very important for women to uphold when these same men are shitting on us from a great height.

Just because we've been gaslit and propagandised to internalise that calling a man he is a terrible thing to do doesn't mean it is. That's just how they want us to feel in order to prevent us adequately fighting back.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:24

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:10

i agree that in person, standing opposite them or referring to them (say at work) in the 3rd person it would be impolite to "misgender" them. By calling a trans woman "he" for eg.

But talking about someone fairly abstractly (trans women are men) - meh. They are. That is the single qualification to be a trans woman. So as long as the rest of the statements aren't against guidelines, i fail to see how it is wrong. It is impolite at worst. Truthful (much as people don't like the truth) at worst.

And i think it would be wrong for MN to move or delete this, because as we know, there are STILL people who see "trans woman" written and think "oh yes that's a woman who wants to be a man" because they only read vague articles,and want to #BeKind.

I don’t think the thread should be deleted as discussion is valid. However I also don’t believe that there isn’t deliberate misgendering of an actual person happening here.

Your opinion is valid. As is mine. As is that of the golfer who this discussion is based on. I just think we should be able to express our opinions without being deliberately hateful. On all sides.

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 08:19

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 01:30

That is not what she says. I don’t know enough about the science to know whether I agree with her or not, but at least engage with what she’s actually saying (that pre-surgery and years of hormone treatment, she would have had an advantage):

”My whole philosophy behind all of this is I don’t believe trans people should be banned from sports, but I do believe there needs to be guidelines in effect," Davidson said. "Going back even four years ago or even before I had surgery, I definitely had an advantage. I would 100% agree with that.

"But the difference is now that years have gone on, three years after surgery, my physical capabilities now compared to back then are night and day. So again, honestly, I 100% agree that men do have advantages. Say you get a trans person on hormones for a year or no surgery nothing… of course, for the most part, yeah they’re gonna have an advantage."

@Overcooker can you explain which part of this confuses you or is progressive? Cutting a penis off does not make the rest of you a woman

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:19

OvaHere · 23/01/2024 08:09

Erm it's cost women everything. Calling men 'she' in order to 'be kind' is why this bullshit has flourished in the first place.

Why do we have to be respectful of these men?

I’d argue that one should be respectful of everyone. I don’t agree with trans women in women’s sport. I would have that discussion all day long. I just can’t see what being rude and nasty brings to the argument. If a person was called Fred but asked me to call them John I would just do it because it matters to them. If a person is born male but wants to be female, that in itself doesn’t hurt me but it matters to them so why would I not respect that?

Yes there are huge issues around this that need to be sorted out but this should be done via rational debate and discussion. Being deliberately hurtful helps no one. And I’d say that on both sides of the argument.

Cincinnatus · 23/01/2024 08:18

A man dominating women’s sports?! I’m shocked.

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 08:18

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 01:30

That is not what she says. I don’t know enough about the science to know whether I agree with her or not, but at least engage with what she’s actually saying (that pre-surgery and years of hormone treatment, she would have had an advantage):

”My whole philosophy behind all of this is I don’t believe trans people should be banned from sports, but I do believe there needs to be guidelines in effect," Davidson said. "Going back even four years ago or even before I had surgery, I definitely had an advantage. I would 100% agree with that.

"But the difference is now that years have gone on, three years after surgery, my physical capabilities now compared to back then are night and day. So again, honestly, I 100% agree that men do have advantages. Say you get a trans person on hormones for a year or no surgery nothing… of course, for the most part, yeah they’re gonna have an advantage."

There is NO science to “Pre transition yes I had an advantage but since then depsite the fact my size, bones and muscle mass have not change, I have put on lipstick and changed my name so obviously that makes my skills all girly and me and the 8 stone woman are totally the same.”

so no I will not listen to him. and I will ever not be convinced that this BS isn’t the most regressive thing we’ve seen in modern times

Bargello · 23/01/2024 08:18

Death threats are never right, nobody should live in that sort of fear whatever the situation. Let's just make that very clear.

However, this person is male, and should not be competing against women.

Dantedisciple · 23/01/2024 08:17

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 00:24

They refer to him as “she” multiple times.

He is a cheat who should stay out of women’s sports. It’s very simple

He's not a cheat if the rules allow it, but I agree he should stay out of women's sport.

newyearnewknees · 23/01/2024 08:17

The amount of posters jumping on this thread to berate the OP and anyone that agrees with them is sickening.

This is why I don't want to compete in my sport any more. One of my few pleasures in life taken away from me by men.

literalviolence · 23/01/2024 08:15

OvaHere · 23/01/2024 08:09

Erm it's cost women everything. Calling men 'she' in order to 'be kind' is why this bullshit has flourished in the first place.

Why do we have to be respectful of these men?

Exactly and IMHO, any male demanding to be called she is committing an act of oppression. We need to be able to stand up against such male violence. Pronouns are sex not identity based.

EasternStandard · 23/01/2024 08:14

Op I’m with the majority vote yanbu

Males shouldn’t have this advantage in female sports

Theinnocenteyeballsinthesky · 23/01/2024 08:11

Women’s sports are for women. Men belong in men’s sports . We want our fucking stuff back!

Theinnocenteyeballsinthesky · 23/01/2024 08:11

Useful info about men v women performance in sport. How are we even in a place where people think men in women’s sports is ok?

Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)
Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)
Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:10

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:07

I do think there are issues arising from trans women competing in women’s sports. However one can have discussions about this while remaining respectful and considerate of the feelings of others. Deliberately misgendering a person is wrong. The othering you are engaging in is even worse. It costs nothing to be kind.

i agree that in person, standing opposite them or referring to them (say at work) in the 3rd person it would be impolite to "misgender" them. By calling a trans woman "he" for eg.

But talking about someone fairly abstractly (trans women are men) - meh. They are. That is the single qualification to be a trans woman. So as long as the rest of the statements aren't against guidelines, i fail to see how it is wrong. It is impolite at worst. Truthful (much as people don't like the truth) at worst.

And i think it would be wrong for MN to move or delete this, because as we know, there are STILL people who see "trans woman" written and think "oh yes that's a woman who wants to be a man" because they only read vague articles,and want to #BeKind.

OvaHere · 23/01/2024 08:09

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:07

I do think there are issues arising from trans women competing in women’s sports. However one can have discussions about this while remaining respectful and considerate of the feelings of others. Deliberately misgendering a person is wrong. The othering you are engaging in is even worse. It costs nothing to be kind.

Erm it's cost women everything. Calling men 'she' in order to 'be kind' is why this bullshit has flourished in the first place.

Why do we have to be respectful of these men?

SecondChancesAtLife · 23/01/2024 08:07

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 00:56

I have concerns around trans women in women’s sport but this thread is just dripping with hate. I hope it’s deleted.

Absolute bollocks. Nothing hateful about it.

People are simply stating facts.

I can’t understand anyone (but especially women) who don’t get worked up about this.

Handmaidens.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:07

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 01:15

Im interested in other views actually but quite shocked that anyone could think this is ok.

You’re ok with it?

I do think there are issues arising from trans women competing in women’s sports. However one can have discussions about this while remaining respectful and considerate of the feelings of others. Deliberately misgendering a person is wrong. The othering you are engaging in is even worse. It costs nothing to be kind.

Swipe left for the next trending thread