Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)

410 replies

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 00:15

Why the hell are GMB gaslighting women with this stuff?

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

This is an enormous male-bodied person - even larger than the interviewing man!

Post edited by MNHQ

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
StillStuckInTheShed · 23/01/2024 08:47

It's astonishing how warped our world is today. All this crap about men choosing to be women and visa versa. Misgendering. Cis. Terf.

It's all a load of bollocks.

A man cannot, under any circumstances, become a woman simply because he 'feels like it' he can pump all the hormones into his bloodstream he likes, he can have surgery to give him breasts and female genitals. He still won't ever be a woman.

FACT.

All this gender shit needs to stop. You're born either male or female and it cant be changed.

and while I'm at it...They refers to more than one, therefore is plural, should never have been used in reference for an individual who doesn't feel like they want to be referred to as their biological sex. It's ridiculous.

MyOodieIsAGoooodie · 23/01/2024 08:47

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 00:56

I have concerns around trans women in women’s sport but this thread is just dripping with hate. I hope it’s deleted.

Agree 100%.

TW in women spaces/sports requires serious and urgent discussion but to call using pronouns of choice as “gaslighting women” is hyperbolic, especially in an article where “born male” is used. Helps no one. Same behaviour as TRAs.

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:46

LondonLass91 · 23/01/2024 08:40

It is really awful isn't it. We are just being thrown under the bus. A woman has just lost out on a record, sponsorship opportunities, and the chance to inspire girls who would otherwise not enter this male dominated sport. Yet GMB focus on him? And talk about his hurt feelings. Awful.

tbh i would, in this golfer's shoes, have been much more circumspect about going public with all this.

I do sometimes wonder if this golfer (and the Spanish soldier, the Canadian teacher with the massive prosthetic boobs) are doing 2 things. 1. taking the money, going for a payoff for breaking equality legislation, unfair dismissal etc and 2. trying to highlight, through their ridiculous actions, where blind acceptance and #BeKind get us?

in the golfer's shoes, i wouldn't have entered the competion to be fair, i would be regretting going public and being ridiculed and shining a spotlight on myself in particular, and the rules about trans women in golf in general.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:46

OvaHere · 23/01/2024 08:37

Why are you so worried about the feelings of men who deliberately do things that cause harm to women - such as this man?

Do you worry about disrespecting the feelings of all men who do harm to women or just the ones who have a special identity?

Serious question because I can't fathom why his feelings matter to you so much given you seem to accept he is a man doing something cruel and wrong to women.

It’s possible to strongly disagree with what a person is doing without hating and denigrating the person. You say he’s doing something cruel and wrong - I don’t necessarily disagree - but I think the issue is that we need clear, consistent and fair guidelines and proper categories to accommodate trans women in sport. Many people are weak when presented with an opportunity to succeed. It doesn’t mean he’s evil or cruel or criminal (which would change my feelings on the matter significantly), just taking advantage of an unfair situation.

LondonLass91 · 23/01/2024 08:45

I note they have turned comments off...now why would that be?

Never mind, Billy Bragg should be along soon to call us all 'terfs' for thinking this is unfair, you can usually count on him.

DeeLusional · 23/01/2024 08:45

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:33

I don’t disagree that the issues in women’s sports are huge and beer to be tackled urgently. I just don’t see why we can’t tackle these issues without being deliberately hurtful and disregarding the feelings of others. I don’t agree with men competing in women’s sports at all and I will fight against this in any way I can as I feel it’s unfair. But I think that can be achieved while still being respectful of others.

I take huge offence at trans women referring to ma as a ‘terf’. But how can I expect someone else to be respectful of my feelings if I don’t care about theirs. We’re all people at the end of the day.

I have no problem being called a TERF - "trans-exclusionary"....yes definitely,
Terfs want to exclude blokes in wigs and frocks from women's sports and safe spaces. "Radical feminist" .... as a 2nd gen radical feminist I have no problem with the appellation. The only problem is finding a company that will print "TERF AND PROUD" on a t-shirt.

WickedSerious · 23/01/2024 08:45

CatMadam · 23/01/2024 08:29

God god transphobes are boring.

What are 'transphobes'?

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 08:44

But I also believe that the vast majority of trans women don’t want to hurt anyone and don’t deserve to be spoken about without any thought to their feelings

Well let's take the man in question here. Has he been thinking of the feelings, respect, safety and opportunities of the women he's denying here? Uh ... no.

So why all the concern for his feelings from you?

SapphireSeptember · 23/01/2024 08:44

Wait, back up. Gwen Stefani is a terf? I had no idea! 😍

Spendonsend · 23/01/2024 08:43

I vaguely remember there is something very specific about womens elbows and golf ability, which wont have been impacted by surgery of hormones.

LondonLass91 · 23/01/2024 08:43

MorningSunshineSparkles · 23/01/2024 08:32

Absolutely agree they shouldn’t have ever been allowed in women’s sports. Absolutely don’t agree they should be receiving any kind of death threats or hate. By all means voice your displeasure in him being allowed to play in a woman’s tournament but take it up with the people that decided it was ok. Directing hate at anyone is not ok.

I very much doubt he had received death threata from any women. It's not really our MO is it? Likely from men, not women. I'd quite like to see these death threats. I wonder if they are on the same scale as JK Rowling? Unlikely.

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:42

(as an aside: I'm not terfy because i don't want trans women in women's sports. If they're not having testosterone, I'm happy for trans men to be in women's sports, and generally in women's spaces. I am therefore trans inclusive)

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:41

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:32

if you have an issue with individual posts, report them.

Misgendering isn't illegal. Wishing "terfs to die in a fat fire" apparently equally not.

And look, there is at least one post in this thread that says "cutting off a penis doesn't make that person a woman" (paraphrased). There is STILL an assumption on many people's part that trans women, or trans identified males, all have surgery. This is a misconception that, when pointed out, leads to TRAs screeching "you're obsessed with our genitals". But it is a legitimate worry, especially of women and the parents of girls and young women in particular, that people with a penis shouldn't be around their half- or unclothed girls. If their assumption is "oh they're trans, no penis" - then they need to be informed. And only by leaving discussions like this in the general mainstream board (the one with all the traffic) are some of those people going to get the message.

Alongside the lesson about how women/girls are losing out on team and podium places, scholarships and prize money. Not to mention the lack of privacy and dignity.

And also the "wah, they want trans women banned from sport" needs to be countered. If you are a man play in the men's competition. If you are a woman play in the woman's competition. If you are a trans woman play in the men's or campaign for trans women's categories. If you are a trans man - difficult. If you're taking testosterone? play in the men's or campaign for trans men's categories. It should be noted that women campaigned long and hard for their own categories. That thing with the Boston marathon is within living memory, FFS. I would have thought trans women, if they think they are women, would show a bit of sisterly solidarity. Knowing how it is to be most marginalised and all that.

I don’t disagree with anything that you are saying. There are huge issues that need to be resolved. Women need to feel safe, trans women also need to feel safe and that doesn’t need to happen by disregarding women’s feelings. But I also believe that the vast majority of trans women don’t want to hurt anyone and don’t deserve to be spoken about without any thought to their feelings.

Misgendering may not be illegal but if you can choose not to hurt someone why on earth would you. And that goes for the nastiness on the trans side too.

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 08:40

Deliberately misgendering a person is wrong

Misgendering is a nonsense concept. I've never used pronouns in relation to 'gender'.

It correctly sexing.

viques · 23/01/2024 08:40

You would be hard put not to misgender him if you met him in a coffee shop wouldn’t you . That’s probably another thing he wouldn’t understand.

StragglyTinsel · 23/01/2024 08:40

AlisonDonut · 23/01/2024 08:34

I hate to tell you but not wanting males in female sports or refuges is pretty TERFy. That makes you a TERF.

The denial is strong.

It’s amazing how effective the TERFs are evil people who want to harm poor trans people online messaging has been in ensuring that people don’t actually listen to what people challenging the TRA agenda are actually saying. So many people who simply don’t understand that their own position is aligned with the objectors not the activists.

It’s all divide and conquer. Hide the fact that the vast majority of people think biological sex matters in certain circumstances : sports, refuges, dignity in hospital wards or prison placements, and so on. Have them violently agreeing with each other but think they’re fighting a ‘culture war’. Just bullshit.

LondonLass91 · 23/01/2024 08:40

It is really awful isn't it. We are just being thrown under the bus. A woman has just lost out on a record, sponsorship opportunities, and the chance to inspire girls who would otherwise not enter this male dominated sport. Yet GMB focus on him? And talk about his hurt feelings. Awful.

ClumsyNinja · 23/01/2024 08:40

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 00:56

I have concerns around trans women in women’s sport but this thread is just dripping with hate. I hope it’s deleted.

Why should it be deleted?

Do you think cheating is acceptable if it’s done by someone who claims they’re transgender?

I hate all MEN who openly cheat especially as it’s nearly always women who are fucked over by cheating men.

Do you honestly believe that these men taking part and winning women’s sporting events are genuinely Trans, because I don’t.

DeeLusional · 23/01/2024 08:38

Justwrong68 · 23/01/2024 00:24

To even entertain the idea of him competing against women and then reporting it like it's normal behaviour is gaslighting everyone.

It's only "gaslighting" if it makes you doubt the truth. NO ONE doubts that this is a man.

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:38

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 08:33

I made the penis comment based on the fact the golfer in questioned claimed if a man has surgery then he no longer poses a threat or and advantage. I’m assuming he meant bottom surgery

sorry, i worded that wrong. I didn't mean that you personally might think that. But i think that it needs to be known more widely. Because a lot of people (despite all the legging and bodycon dress photos that appear in the papers and online) a lot of people simply assume that if someone says they are a trans woman, they have had surgery. (and have a GRC but that is a whole other kettle of fish)

I firmly believe we should all strive to live our best lives. I refuse to believe that anyone who is shitting on women's sport like this sincerely wishes that. They wish THEMSELF to be living their best live, and sod the rest. I would like a show of good faith from trans women (who i have defended vehemently in the past, and will continue to do so under a lot of circumstances) that they are women, understand our struggle to win our own rights and spaces, and to campaign for their own. Then i will believe they are sincere about being a woman.

This golfer is basically saying "yeah, i prob do have an advantage, lolz, but that's not stopping me look at all my luvly money"

OvaHere · 23/01/2024 08:37

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:33

I don’t disagree that the issues in women’s sports are huge and beer to be tackled urgently. I just don’t see why we can’t tackle these issues without being deliberately hurtful and disregarding the feelings of others. I don’t agree with men competing in women’s sports at all and I will fight against this in any way I can as I feel it’s unfair. But I think that can be achieved while still being respectful of others.

I take huge offence at trans women referring to ma as a ‘terf’. But how can I expect someone else to be respectful of my feelings if I don’t care about theirs. We’re all people at the end of the day.

Why are you so worried about the feelings of men who deliberately do things that cause harm to women - such as this man?

Do you worry about disrespecting the feelings of all men who do harm to women or just the ones who have a special identity?

Serious question because I can't fathom why his feelings matter to you so much given you seem to accept he is a man doing something cruel and wrong to women.

StragglyTinsel · 23/01/2024 08:34

Reading that tweet… other than using ‘preferred pronouns’ (which adds to the overall rhetorical effect), it feels pretty unsupportive of this golfer.

The first sentence is that the transgender golfer ‘says she fears for her safety’. Not ‘fears for her safety’ but ‘says’ it. Thats not the same thing and will be deliberate.

Thats followed up with the information that the triggering event was winning a place on a tour designed to promote growth opportunities for female players. This is not a female player (as the first word in the sentence makes clear) so the sentence is really saying ‘biologically male golfer claims they are unsafe after taking opportunities away from female golfers’.

The next sentence amplifies this by explaining that there are accusations that ‘she has an unfair advantage’ and the reasons given is ‘she can hit a ball further than a female born player’. It doesn’t outright say ‘because “she” is male’ but may as well do.

I do agree that it is depressing how many people are quite happy to give away opportunities for female players in the name of ‘kindness’ (to males who say they’re women).

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 08:34

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:33

I don’t disagree that the issues in women’s sports are huge and beer to be tackled urgently. I just don’t see why we can’t tackle these issues without being deliberately hurtful and disregarding the feelings of others. I don’t agree with men competing in women’s sports at all and I will fight against this in any way I can as I feel it’s unfair. But I think that can be achieved while still being respectful of others.

I take huge offence at trans women referring to ma as a ‘terf’. But how can I expect someone else to be respectful of my feelings if I don’t care about theirs. We’re all people at the end of the day.

Why should you care about theirs when they don’t care about yours or any woman’s feelings?

Im done pandering and simpering towards men. I’ve spent nearly 40 years being told that’s what I have to do in order to keep them on side. Fuck that.

AlisonDonut · 23/01/2024 08:34

BobbyBiscuits · 23/01/2024 01:01

Trans women in women's sport is something I disagree with. Trans women in women's refuges (unless in a seperate part, of course they should have refuge) also. I have a trans family member (F to M). I believe in live and let live, I'm a feminist and I'm not threatened by trans women. This thread is just gonna be uber Terfy no doubt like Gwen Stefani.

I hate to tell you but not wanting males in female sports or refuges is pretty TERFy. That makes you a TERF.

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 08:33

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:32

if you have an issue with individual posts, report them.

Misgendering isn't illegal. Wishing "terfs to die in a fat fire" apparently equally not.

And look, there is at least one post in this thread that says "cutting off a penis doesn't make that person a woman" (paraphrased). There is STILL an assumption on many people's part that trans women, or trans identified males, all have surgery. This is a misconception that, when pointed out, leads to TRAs screeching "you're obsessed with our genitals". But it is a legitimate worry, especially of women and the parents of girls and young women in particular, that people with a penis shouldn't be around their half- or unclothed girls. If their assumption is "oh they're trans, no penis" - then they need to be informed. And only by leaving discussions like this in the general mainstream board (the one with all the traffic) are some of those people going to get the message.

Alongside the lesson about how women/girls are losing out on team and podium places, scholarships and prize money. Not to mention the lack of privacy and dignity.

And also the "wah, they want trans women banned from sport" needs to be countered. If you are a man play in the men's competition. If you are a woman play in the woman's competition. If you are a trans woman play in the men's or campaign for trans women's categories. If you are a trans man - difficult. If you're taking testosterone? play in the men's or campaign for trans men's categories. It should be noted that women campaigned long and hard for their own categories. That thing with the Boston marathon is within living memory, FFS. I would have thought trans women, if they think they are women, would show a bit of sisterly solidarity. Knowing how it is to be most marginalised and all that.

I made the penis comment based on the fact the golfer in questioned claimed if a man has surgery then he no longer poses a threat or and advantage. I’m assuming he meant bottom surgery

Swipe left for the next trending thread