Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)

410 replies

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 00:15

Why the hell are GMB gaslighting women with this stuff?

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

This is an enormous male-bodied person - even larger than the interviewing man!

Post edited by MNHQ

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Boiledbeetle · 23/01/2024 09:01

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:52

Of course they aren’t. I was talking about wider issues such as being forced to use men’s tollets and changing areas. Women shouldn’t be made to feel unsafe by allowing trans women in, but separate spaces should be created so that trans women can have the same security.

I have already said many times that I don’t believe that trans women should be in women’s sports as it’s unfair.

was talking about wider issues such as being forced to use men’s tollets and changing areas. Women shouldn’t be made to feel unsafe by allowing trans women in,

There is no reason why transwomen can't use the mens toilets and changing rooms. Women feel unsafe letting transwomen in because transwomen are men.

Saying "I am a woman" does not stop them being men.

We don't let men in those spaces, so why should we let a special group of men in those spaces?

Zodfa · 23/01/2024 08:59

In this case one suspects "fears for safety" may have as much basis in material reality as "feelings of womanhood".

mamboshirt · 23/01/2024 08:58

Ooops! Was that my comment "Yes he is huge", that is transphobic. It's not . It's the truth. Why on earth are women so feebly letting themselves be walked over by men that ( I promise you) do not give a shit about you? Do you really think William ( Lia) Thomas cares one bit about you, or this Hailey man or whoever. They really don't. So stop caring about them. They are big boys who can look after themselves. Gah!!! Drives me mad.

underneaththeash · 23/01/2024 08:58

FerryTale · 23/01/2024 00:24

Can you get this moved to FWR please?

I'm not sure why he's worried about his safety either...he's massive (and a big cheat).

Boiledbeetle · 23/01/2024 08:56

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:46

It’s possible to strongly disagree with what a person is doing without hating and denigrating the person. You say he’s doing something cruel and wrong - I don’t necessarily disagree - but I think the issue is that we need clear, consistent and fair guidelines and proper categories to accommodate trans women in sport. Many people are weak when presented with an opportunity to succeed. It doesn’t mean he’s evil or cruel or criminal (which would change my feelings on the matter significantly), just taking advantage of an unfair situation.

but I think the issue is that we need clear, consistent and fair guidelines and proper categories to accommodate trans women in sport.

We already have a category for transwomen. It's the mens catergory.

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 08:56

without being deliberately disrespectful

Theres nothing respectful about lying. Thats where we disagree

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 08:56

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:38

sorry, i worded that wrong. I didn't mean that you personally might think that. But i think that it needs to be known more widely. Because a lot of people (despite all the legging and bodycon dress photos that appear in the papers and online) a lot of people simply assume that if someone says they are a trans woman, they have had surgery. (and have a GRC but that is a whole other kettle of fish)

I firmly believe we should all strive to live our best lives. I refuse to believe that anyone who is shitting on women's sport like this sincerely wishes that. They wish THEMSELF to be living their best live, and sod the rest. I would like a show of good faith from trans women (who i have defended vehemently in the past, and will continue to do so under a lot of circumstances) that they are women, understand our struggle to win our own rights and spaces, and to campaign for their own. Then i will believe they are sincere about being a woman.

This golfer is basically saying "yeah, i prob do have an advantage, lolz, but that's not stopping me look at all my luvly money"

Yes, last I saw only 20% had ‘bottom surgery’. 80% didn’t - and who can blame them, it’s very dangerous and requires lifelong care.

DeeLusional · 23/01/2024 08:56

Flickersy · 23/01/2024 00:26

Everyone does know this is going on.

Actually no they don't.

LondonLass91 · 23/01/2024 08:56

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:49

Because we all have a choice about our behaviour. In the words of Michelle Obama.

“When someone is cruel or acts like a bully, you don't stoop to their level. No, our motto is: 'When they go low, we go high'.”

You are deliberately turning this into something it isn't. This male born player should not have taken part in a woman's only golf tournament. It is unfair. Simple as that.

AlisonDonut · 23/01/2024 08:55

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:55

Again, I don’t disagree with you. It’s my opinion that you can fight for women without being deliberately disrespectful. I just don’t feel that one has to copy the behaviour of someone we disagree with in order to ‘win’ the fight.

Men who use female spaces are the ones being 'disrespectful'.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:55

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 08:51

When someone is cruel or acts like a bully, you don't stoop to their level.

Im not 'stooping', I'm stating facts.

Women are missing opportunities and respect to facilitate a cheating, entitled man. Why should anyone facilitate that, in any way?

Again, I don’t disagree with you. It’s my opinion that you can fight for women without being deliberately disrespectful. I just don’t feel that one has to copy the behaviour of someone we disagree with in order to ‘win’ the fight.

OvaHere · 23/01/2024 08:55

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:46

It’s possible to strongly disagree with what a person is doing without hating and denigrating the person. You say he’s doing something cruel and wrong - I don’t necessarily disagree - but I think the issue is that we need clear, consistent and fair guidelines and proper categories to accommodate trans women in sport. Many people are weak when presented with an opportunity to succeed. It doesn’t mean he’s evil or cruel or criminal (which would change my feelings on the matter significantly), just taking advantage of an unfair situation.

Once again calling a man a man is not hate. It's the truth. An important truth in this situation.

What I'm taking from your posts is a need to be seen as a good, kind person who always does the 'right' thing. A man like this would just see an opportunity to use that against you and treat you like a doormat. I can guarantee he would not give even the tiniest fuck about your feelings or the feelings of any other women trying very hard to be kind.

This is part of why we are in this mess.

AlisonDonut · 23/01/2024 08:54

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:52

Of course they aren’t. I was talking about wider issues such as being forced to use men’s tollets and changing areas. Women shouldn’t be made to feel unsafe by allowing trans women in, but separate spaces should be created so that trans women can have the same security.

I have already said many times that I don’t believe that trans women should be in women’s sports as it’s unfair.

Trans women aka men already have spaces, called 'the gents' or 'male changing rooms'.

They wouldn't use seperate spaces. They are after the ones the women are in.

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 08:53

It needs laughter and sunlight. Which is a good cure for lots of things.

Exactly. Not mangling of reality on the name of 'kindness' (to men, because it's all extremely unkind to women)

DeeLusional · 23/01/2024 08:53

Flickersy · 23/01/2024 00:21

They haven't described him as a woman in that tweet. He is referred to by the interviewer twice as born male.

Unless you think he's lying about the death threats or you think the death threats are somehow acceptable in the circumstances and that's what they're "gaslighting" about?

I would never condone death threats, but they are quick to complain when the boot is on the foot, it's usially GC WOMEN who receive rape and death threats and lose their jobs and their competitions.

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:52

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 08:47

It’s possible to strongly disagree with what a person is doing without hating and denigrating the person.

It's not 'hating and denigrating ' to say he's a man. It is just fact.

the hyperbolic language is laughable. Saying TWAM is "genocide" and "literal violence"

Everything short of "oh yes you are a real biological woman and way better than us cis women who are ugly and useless" is "transphobia"

It needs laughter and sunlight. Which is a good cure for lots of things.

Again for clarity: biological people should have their own sporting categories. If trans people want to do sport, they either go with biology or campaign for their own categories. Where's the petition, I'll sign and share.

AlisonDonut · 23/01/2024 08:52

Teentaxidriver · 23/01/2024 08:47

Berefugee - do you understand the life long benefits of male puberty? Biological males have no place in women’s sport.

Brefugee said this:

(as an aside: I'm not terfy because i don't want trans women in women's sports. If they're not having testosterone, I'm happy for trans men to be in women's sports, and generally in women's spaces. I am therefore trans inclusive)

'Trans men' are females. They have not had lifelong benefits of male puberty, what with being female.

The people who had male puberty are males, often called 'trans women'.

This is confusing so many of us decided a long time ago to stop calling anyone trans as it is part of the misinformation that leads people to be even more confused.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:52

AlisonDonut · 23/01/2024 08:48

Men aren't 'unsafe' by being kept out of women's sports.

Do you care about the hurt felt by women and girls who have spent their whole lives training, just to lose to a man who decided he was a woman last week?

Of course they aren’t. I was talking about wider issues such as being forced to use men’s tollets and changing areas. Women shouldn’t be made to feel unsafe by allowing trans women in, but separate spaces should be created so that trans women can have the same security.

I have already said many times that I don’t believe that trans women should be in women’s sports as it’s unfair.

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 08:51

When someone is cruel or acts like a bully, you don't stoop to their level.

Im not 'stooping', I'm stating facts.

Women are missing opportunities and respect to facilitate a cheating, entitled man. Why should anyone facilitate that, in any way?

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:50

Teentaxidriver · 23/01/2024 08:47

Berefugee - do you understand the life long benefits of male puberty? Biological males have no place in women’s sport.

you appear to be mistaking me for someone who thinks trans women should be allowed to be in women's sport.

I have taken part, in my sadly long gone youth, in sports at county level. The sport i used to do is getting pretty TWAW i think. I'd be at the barricades if i were still participating.

LondonLass91 · 23/01/2024 08:50

MyOodieIsAGoooodie · 23/01/2024 08:47

Agree 100%.

TW in women spaces/sports requires serious and urgent discussion but to call using pronouns of choice as “gaslighting women” is hyperbolic, especially in an article where “born male” is used. Helps no one. Same behaviour as TRAs.

Same behaviour as TRAs..really? REALLY?.

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:49

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 08:44

But I also believe that the vast majority of trans women don’t want to hurt anyone and don’t deserve to be spoken about without any thought to their feelings

Well let's take the man in question here. Has he been thinking of the feelings, respect, safety and opportunities of the women he's denying here? Uh ... no.

So why all the concern for his feelings from you?

Because we all have a choice about our behaviour. In the words of Michelle Obama.

“When someone is cruel or acts like a bully, you don't stoop to their level. No, our motto is: 'When they go low, we go high'.”

AlisonDonut · 23/01/2024 08:48

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:41

I don’t disagree with anything that you are saying. There are huge issues that need to be resolved. Women need to feel safe, trans women also need to feel safe and that doesn’t need to happen by disregarding women’s feelings. But I also believe that the vast majority of trans women don’t want to hurt anyone and don’t deserve to be spoken about without any thought to their feelings.

Misgendering may not be illegal but if you can choose not to hurt someone why on earth would you. And that goes for the nastiness on the trans side too.

Men aren't 'unsafe' by being kept out of women's sports.

Do you care about the hurt felt by women and girls who have spent their whole lives training, just to lose to a man who decided he was a woman last week?

Teentaxidriver · 23/01/2024 08:47

Berefugee - do you understand the life long benefits of male puberty? Biological males have no place in women’s sport.

TheKeatingFive · 23/01/2024 08:47

It’s possible to strongly disagree with what a person is doing without hating and denigrating the person.

It's not 'hating and denigrating ' to say he's a man. It is just fact.

Swipe left for the next trending thread