Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)

410 replies

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 00:15

Why the hell are GMB gaslighting women with this stuff?

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

This is an enormous male-bodied person - even larger than the interviewing man!

Post edited by MNHQ

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
YetAnotherSpartacus · 23/01/2024 09:32

Cheat and thief of women's prizes.

LondonLass91 · 23/01/2024 09:32

megletthesecond · 23/01/2024 09:24

GMB know exactly what they're doing. Now everyone can see what a cheat Hailey is.

That's a good point.

Brainworm · 23/01/2024 09:31

This thread is about fairness in sport and whether natal males should be able to compete in single sex competitions for natal females.

The issues at hand are: should competitions be single sex in the first place and if so, under what circumstances (if any) should natal males be able to compete in them.

I find accusations of transphobia, hate and discussions about pronouns deflect from the substantive points that ultimately boils down to inclusion versus fairness.

I believe that you can be non hateful and have a preference for either.

I do struggle with anyone who suggests single sex competition is important for fairness for females, but also argue to include some natal males in the female category on the basis of inclusion.

A final note, determining access to single sex categories by natal sex, does not impose exclusion on anyone. People may self exclude by choice, as they don't want to compete with their natal sex, but this isn't 'banning them'.

StragglyTinsel · 23/01/2024 09:30

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 08:42

(as an aside: I'm not terfy because i don't want trans women in women's sports. If they're not having testosterone, I'm happy for trans men to be in women's sports, and generally in women's spaces. I am therefore trans inclusive)

I think you need to actually look beyond the rhetoric of ‘trans excluding’ and think here.

What makes you think anyone you put in the TERF category is against female people competing in female sports or being in female spaces?

Trans men are female - even if they don’t want to be.

Arguing that people should use the correct provision according to their biological sex is only ‘trans excluding’ if you believe trans people should have the right to decide they are the exception to this and use the opposite sex provision. Even then, the point is not excluding or hating trans people. It’s simply the principle that people have a right to single sex provision in circumstances where it makes a difference.

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 09:30

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 09:19

Gosh yes - i absolutely do not think it should be anything like approaching a requirement to have any surgery for any circumstances. This is one thing that i am very very firm about. Top, bottom, or whatever surgeries that are possible are something that i really don't think anyone should be even encouraged to have, let alone mandated. I have seen far to many reports and articles about the ones that haven't gone right, or haven't turned out how the person thought it would. I really do want people to be happy and satisfied in their lives.

But it really isn't widely known about how few have surgery.

It’s a very grim picture when you fall down the rabbit hole of bottom surgery. I don’t think trans people should be having this to feel validated. Then again nothing to me would visage a man becoming a woman.

What I DO advocate for is men being able to express themselves in whatever way they like without the labels. Wanna wear a skirt and lipstick? Great! Go for it! MORE breaking down gender stereotypes please. Just don’t claim it makes you female

WickedSerious · 23/01/2024 09:29

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 09:06

I didn’t say women should let trans women in. I specifically said that trans women should have their own spaces but you missed that bit of the quote. It is well documented that trans women are also not safe around men and I don’t want anyone to feel unsafe.

If these men are having problems with other men they should take it up with those other men.

It's not up to women to sort it out.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 23/01/2024 09:28

CatMadam · 23/01/2024 08:29

God god transphobes are boring.

Good god YOU are boring. At least have a crack at explaining what transphobia you see. Posters like you just embarrass yourself. You pop up, shout transphobia with NOTHING to back it up, maybe a wee 'oh have a look the FWR board' and then you slope off never to appear again.

Have a day off.

AlisonDonut · 23/01/2024 09:28

If women who took testosterone measured at even half the same levels as men who lower theirs [and say they are women], they would be banned from competition.

MadamVastra · 23/01/2024 09:26

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 08:19

I’d argue that one should be respectful of everyone. I don’t agree with trans women in women’s sport. I would have that discussion all day long. I just can’t see what being rude and nasty brings to the argument. If a person was called Fred but asked me to call them John I would just do it because it matters to them. If a person is born male but wants to be female, that in itself doesn’t hurt me but it matters to them so why would I not respect that?

Yes there are huge issues around this that need to be sorted out but this should be done via rational debate and discussion. Being deliberately hurtful helps no one. And I’d say that on both sides of the argument.

So you agree to call them whatever they want because it matters to them - yet what matters to women is overridden?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 23/01/2024 09:25

hollyhola · 23/01/2024 03:44

I am not anti trans.

I am pro women.

Trans people are more than welcome to live their life as they see authentic to them. Carry on.

But women and their rights must be protected.

Trans women should not be allowed to compete in women's sports or enter spaces where women could be vulnerable such as toilets and changing rooms.

I feel this is very logical and pragmatic and I really cannot understand how things have managed to get this far.

Boggles my mind that people don't seem to understand this, or if they do can still find ways to defend it. Slow hand clap for the women willing to prioritise the feelings of men over women. All make blanket statements like 'all trans women are harmless'.

Well done you.

megletthesecond · 23/01/2024 09:24

GMB know exactly what they're doing. Now everyone can see what a cheat Hailey is.

SnackQueen · 23/01/2024 09:24

I'm so sick of this shit.

Brefugee · 23/01/2024 09:24

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 09:06

I didn’t say women should let trans women in. I specifically said that trans women should have their own spaces but you missed that bit of the quote. It is well documented that trans women are also not safe around men and I don’t want anyone to feel unsafe.

Is it well documented? It is very well documented that effeminite gay men aren't totally safe in men's toilets. I don't see (to be fair, i also don't search them out) reports or statistics about TW in men's toilets.

I want people to feel safe. Be safe. But the answer to "i don't feel safe in the men's" isn't "use the women's" it is: educate men not to make people unsafe, and campaign for 3rd spaces (I'm on board with that)

and to remind everyone (waves at the monitors) my first post said that i don't think TW should enter women's sport categories. And i don't think anyone should receive threats.

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 09:23

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 09:03

I wholeheartedly disagree. I couldn’t really care less if you or anyone thinks that I’m doing the right thing. I, however do need to know that. I’m not treated like a doormat and as evidenced on this thread I do speak my mind. I’m far from perfect - I do have a temper at times and don’t always practice what I preach. But I choose to try and do right by people. And if someone wants me to call them she or they or whatever, that in itself doesn’t hurt me so I choose to do it. If you choose not to that’s your prerogative.

I guess if you want to call a man a woman then you do you.

The rest of us will speak the truth and know we’re not hateful for doing so.

OP posts:
CountZacular · 23/01/2024 09:23

@SchoolQuestionnaire

Where is it well documented that TW are at risk in men’s spaces? People say this but I feel like if TW were really at a specific risk above and beyond other men on a regular basis, Pink News would be having a field day reporting on the stories.

Have you ever wondered about the claims? We do known, however, that the risk to women rises significantly when toilets and changing spaces are unisex - which they are if TW are in them.

I know you said you advocate for their own spaces but they don’t want them. They’re only interested in the validation they get from using women’s space (note validation, not safety - because if it was safety they’d be happy just to have their own spaces).

bluebunny1 · 23/01/2024 09:22

The problem is that women’s event organizers can’t simply say no to these participants, because they are worried about being sued. The transgender community’s legal support is extremely well funded, super organized and receives lots of donations.

IcakethereforeIam · 23/01/2024 09:20

I don't wish him any harm, no-one should be threatened. That is not acceptable. But no matter the surgery, or the hormones, women are not just men with low testosterone. Ridiculous that it has to be said.

LondonLass91 · 23/01/2024 09:20

In response to the CEO of the golfing body, who has stated that they will carry out testosterone testing..I think Carilyn Johnson's response sums up the problems with this, below.

Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)
Brefugee · 23/01/2024 09:19

KarenNotAKaren · 23/01/2024 08:56

Yes, last I saw only 20% had ‘bottom surgery’. 80% didn’t - and who can blame them, it’s very dangerous and requires lifelong care.

Gosh yes - i absolutely do not think it should be anything like approaching a requirement to have any surgery for any circumstances. This is one thing that i am very very firm about. Top, bottom, or whatever surgeries that are possible are something that i really don't think anyone should be even encouraged to have, let alone mandated. I have seen far to many reports and articles about the ones that haven't gone right, or haven't turned out how the person thought it would. I really do want people to be happy and satisfied in their lives.

But it really isn't widely known about how few have surgery.

lola8345 · 23/01/2024 09:18

It really doesn't matter how safe trans women are. As documented by the swimmer (thomas) He strutted his naked arse, with his penis out on display in the women's changing room.
I can't imagine any women being happy with that.
All the years women had to fight for their rights!!

OchonAgusOchonOh · 23/01/2024 09:18

WhamBamThankU · 23/01/2024 09:12

He's not even trying to look like a woman.

Ah really now. Did you not notice the very feminine earrings?

ArabellaScott · 23/01/2024 09:18

bluebunny1 · 23/01/2024 09:17

If this continues there will simply be no women’s sport at all, because no sane woman is going to compete against a biological man. Already there are cases of women pulling out of footballs etc to protect themselves.

you are right OP, this is crazy.

We already have women quitting their sports because there is no point.

See the very brave Lynn Pinches conceding her title and refusing to play pool with a male opponent.

Unicorntearsofgin · 23/01/2024 09:18

Of course this is ludicrous. Any adult male or female are welcome to dress and express themselves however they please. No issue with that. However there are differences between the sexes that no amount of pretending can change.

Sport should be separated by sex with an open category in my mind.

Women’s sports and opportunities are not for males no matter how nice they are and how they identify.

bluebunny1 · 23/01/2024 09:17

If this continues there will simply be no women’s sport at all, because no sane woman is going to compete against a biological man. Already there are cases of women pulling out of footballs etc to protect themselves.

you are right OP, this is crazy.

Boiledbeetle · 23/01/2024 09:16

SchoolQuestionnaire · 23/01/2024 09:08

See this I don’t understand. I completely get the not wanting trans women competing against women and it is unfair. They have a competitive advantage. I can’t for the life of me understand why you would be opposed to trans women having their own category. It doesn’t hurt you, and means they can still compete and have a fair crack.

I'm not against it. But they are!

Swipe left for the next trending thread