Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Male born person wins women’s golf tournament and is now “worried about his safety” - interviewed by GMB (Title edited by MNHQ)

410 replies

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 00:15

Why the hell are GMB gaslighting women with this stuff?

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

This is an enormous male-bodied person - even larger than the interviewing man!

Post edited by MNHQ

https://twitter.com/GMB/status/1749329378352275568

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
11
pickledandpuzzled · 27/01/2024 15:16

Chichimcgee · 26/01/2024 21:03

Why is it always men causing such fuss. There’s a gorgeous woman on Fb called big sexy, she’s often mistaken for a man and she says that’s fine because she knows how she looks, she’s been yelled at in a public loo and had to explain that she’s a woman but understands why it must have been a shock thinking there was a man in the women’s loo - she’s so lovely and understanding and self aware. Then you see a video of a man with stubble having a fit over someone calling him ‘he’ crying over pronouns and misgendering him and poor him etc its attention seeking to an extreme

Just FYI. Searching for Big Sexy on FB is probably not wise.
<not me honest >

endinthefrownz · 27/01/2024 14:55

willingtolearn · 23/01/2024 09:47

I am glad to see the polling results.

As to 'misgendering' I am not an adherent of the transideology belief system. Misgendering is a made up word to me.

My own belief system is led by reality. My statements are led by this and unless you are saying my speech should be compelled to reflect someone else's belief system that is in direct conflict with my own I can call this person a man.

This....

endinthefrownz · 27/01/2024 14:52

https://www.shewon.org/

She Won. This website is dedicated to archiving the achievements of female athletes who were displaced by males in women’s sporting events and other types of competitions expressly for women. One day soon we hope their accomplishments will be formally recognized.

She Won banner: Selina Soule and Alanna Miller; picture attributed to Alliance Defending Freedom

List of Female Athletes by Sport | She Won

This website is dedicated to archiving the achievements of female athletes who were displaced by males in women’s sporting events.

https://www.shewon.org/

OneMorePlant · 27/01/2024 00:40

Chichimcgee · 26/01/2024 21:03

Why is it always men causing such fuss. There’s a gorgeous woman on Fb called big sexy, she’s often mistaken for a man and she says that’s fine because she knows how she looks, she’s been yelled at in a public loo and had to explain that she’s a woman but understands why it must have been a shock thinking there was a man in the women’s loo - she’s so lovely and understanding and self aware. Then you see a video of a man with stubble having a fit over someone calling him ‘he’ crying over pronouns and misgendering him and poor him etc its attention seeking to an extreme

Because men are the weaker sex. 😁

Ofcourseshecan · 26/01/2024 21:24

Brewdug · 23/01/2024 00:52

Why?

Because we’re horrid and hurting men’s feelings and should be chased out of the biggest talk forum before we corrupt anyone else.

Chichimcgee · 26/01/2024 21:03

Why is it always men causing such fuss. There’s a gorgeous woman on Fb called big sexy, she’s often mistaken for a man and she says that’s fine because she knows how she looks, she’s been yelled at in a public loo and had to explain that she’s a woman but understands why it must have been a shock thinking there was a man in the women’s loo - she’s so lovely and understanding and self aware. Then you see a video of a man with stubble having a fit over someone calling him ‘he’ crying over pronouns and misgendering him and poor him etc its attention seeking to an extreme

Chichimcgee · 26/01/2024 20:59

I think if an archaeologist can dig your bones up in hundreds of years and say 100% that’s a man’s skeleton, it doesn’t matter what hormones/surgery/whatever you have, you are always going to be a man and have the advantages of that.

Helleofabore · 26/01/2024 20:39

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 01:30

That is not what she says. I don’t know enough about the science to know whether I agree with her or not, but at least engage with what she’s actually saying (that pre-surgery and years of hormone treatment, she would have had an advantage):

”My whole philosophy behind all of this is I don’t believe trans people should be banned from sports, but I do believe there needs to be guidelines in effect," Davidson said. "Going back even four years ago or even before I had surgery, I definitely had an advantage. I would 100% agree with that.

"But the difference is now that years have gone on, three years after surgery, my physical capabilities now compared to back then are night and day. So again, honestly, I 100% agree that men do have advantages. Say you get a trans person on hormones for a year or no surgery nothing… of course, for the most part, yeah they’re gonna have an advantage."

I suggest that you really do more reading of the studies on this topic before posting someone who is basically ignoring the evidence and is spreading misinformation.

The advantages are still present. The bones don’t shrink, the lungs don’t shrink, the veins don’t shrink, the muscles may change, but how much of that is because these make people choose ‘shape’ over ‘strength and fitness’. It is now suggested by sports scientists and developmental biologists that these male athletes could regain their performance if they changed their training

So, either way, these male athletes have chosen to take steps to limit their own performance. What other athletes are rewarded in competing with a protected sports category that they have no fucking right to claim because they have taken steps to limit their performance? If a male athlete has lost their testes to cancer, do they get to compete as a female also?

Why is this special group of male people allowed to make this choice yet be allowed to compete in a protected category that they have no right to claim. It is NOT a ‘woman’s’ Sports category. It is a female sports category.

There is no logic in this inclusion when you start to scrutinise this. It relies on the lie that these male people have become ‘women’ to make this even sound reasonable. But they are not ‘women’. They are male. Not female. Never to be female.

It is a myth that they can wind back their physical advantage. It has been proven with studies. And it was never true. Yet discussion of this issue is constantly framed as hate and ‘disgusting’ if it points out the truth. I am happy to post you links to read.

And yet, the constant demand to repeat the lie that a male has become a female or that they are weak now so should compete, just because that is kind, is what has harmed women and girls in their sports. How fucking kind is that? How fucking kind is it to scold women and girls for stating the truth and that this inclusion of male people in female sports categories is harming women and girls.

And no one is banning these male people from sport. They can compete with other male people. They choose not to .

TheKeatingFive · 26/01/2024 19:40

The whole TRA narrative is fuelled by drama and falsehoods that have no basis in reality.

Trans people are banned from sports

Trans people are being literally genocided

The other side deny Transpeople's existence

Trans suicides are sky high, fuelled by hate crimes

JKR is a hate filled, transphobic bigot

The GC movement are literally nazis

Absolutely none of this is true. Yet there are people who arent paying very much attention who fall for the hyperbole

StragglyTinsel · 26/01/2024 19:19

No one is banning transwomen from sport. They’re just saying they don’t get to compete in the female category.

This is the same logic whereby not getting what you want supposedly equates to ‘erasure’ or denying the existence of’ of whether utter catastrophising is the order of the TRA day.

People need to stop taking the catastrophic language at face value and actually think. Transwomen can compete in sport. Just in the male category. Or in the new third categories some sports are offering. They don’t want this so TRAd shout very loudly about how they transwomen are being banned from sport entirely and other hyperbolic bullshit.

It’s deeply irritating.

Numberfish · 26/01/2024 19:07

Overcooker · 23/01/2024 01:30

That is not what she says. I don’t know enough about the science to know whether I agree with her or not, but at least engage with what she’s actually saying (that pre-surgery and years of hormone treatment, she would have had an advantage):

”My whole philosophy behind all of this is I don’t believe trans people should be banned from sports, but I do believe there needs to be guidelines in effect," Davidson said. "Going back even four years ago or even before I had surgery, I definitely had an advantage. I would 100% agree with that.

"But the difference is now that years have gone on, three years after surgery, my physical capabilities now compared to back then are night and day. So again, honestly, I 100% agree that men do have advantages. Say you get a trans person on hormones for a year or no surgery nothing… of course, for the most part, yeah they’re gonna have an advantage."

You cannot possibly be going to pretend that an adult man loses his thigh length, tendon thickness, muscle ratio, etc. etc. after four years of taking ‘hormones’.

Your kind of post is why people cry gaslighting. What you are claiming is so obviously untrue that it’s laughable. Men and transwomen should stay out of women’s sports and spaces. There is absolutely nothing whatever stopping them having their own category. Except their desire to cheat.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 26/01/2024 12:11

*The only reason any of this bullshit has got as far as it has is because it's men.

If it was transmen (so women) leading the charge; demanding access to all male spaces, demanding language changed to accommodate them, trying to get men arrested in front of their kids for their 'violent rhetoric' online (aka misgendering), rocking up at male only counselling, invading prostate cancer groups on facebook and kicking off if they weren't centered and validated. Getting actual prostate cancer patients booted off the group for bigotry if they question it, no matter how politely. Demanding validation in sport (although winning and dominating the competition would be a sticking point).

It wouldn't have got anywhere. The men would have collectively told them to fuck off, ignored cries of 'but muh gender!!!" and bollocks to compromising. And indeed off those women would have fucked, tails between legs.

But when it's MEN and their gender identity, everyone falls over themselves to pander and validate. They aren't told to fuck off, and if they are, oh those evil, nasty women! What bigots! What hate! Don't they know you're the most womanly woman who has ever womaned?

The other men look on and because it involves effort and sticking their necks out to defend women they shrug their shoulders and walk off. Not their problem. The misogynists rub their hands with glee, they can't believe they finally get to stick it to the women and be seen as progressive heroes for doing it.

They don't want compromise. And the only compromise would be third unisex spaces, and open categories.

Such a category was indeed launched recently (think it was in swimming) and not a single transwoman entered because they didn't want it. They want womenscategories to dominate in, and women have to be there as validation props. How else are they going to get their gender euphoria? (aka boner*

Please save this before it is deleted.

Panterus · 26/01/2024 11:55

HermioneKipper · 23/01/2024 01:05

They can dress up and call themselves whatever they want but males don’t belong in women’s spaces or sports.

And kids shouldn’t be making life altering decisions at a very young age.

otherwise everyone can crack on.

Yeah I don't agree with this anymore.

I think we've had to say that they can dress as they want and pretend to be who they want because otherwise we'll be accused of being bit**es (or insert other gendered slur) or hysterical. Or worse still we might not look feminine enough or come across as aggressive (heaven forfend).

But now I think if someone wanted to appropriate blackness they would be met with a wave of hatred, if someone wanted to pretend to be Jewish it would be deeply frowned upon. Can you imagine for a second a golfer turning up blacked up?

Someone got told off for wanting to be called Nonna on here this week and not having Italian connections!

So why, are we all dancing round defending every other groups seemingly sacrosanct right to not be appropriated or offended but not women's? Why? Because society has been told they can shit all over women for eons and we will still be the ones picking up the pieces and doing the grunt work.

I don't think men should be portraying womanhood at all. I think it should be met with outright vocal condemnation. I think men role-playing womanhood should be publicly derided. They should be sacked and deplatformed. If I saw someone blacked up, you can be damn sure I would voice my concern and so would many others.

And no this should not be in FWR. This concerns all women and I'm sick of male posters and their aunt Lydia shills coming on here and trying to shut women up, put them in the FWR naughty corner or told we are terfs.

This issue needs to be highlighted regularly because women's rights are snatched away without a backwards glance, just a smug smirk from the men that drive it.

Look at America. Reproductive rights are gone and the Supreme Court will look at making divorce more difficult soon so women cannot leave.

Look at this guy here, he doesn't give a damn about the women he is stealing from. He fully admits he has an advantage. He just doesn't care and he knows he will get away with it because other men and the women who crave the attention of those men will be complicit in helping him fuck women over just one more time.

It's time we called out misogyny just like we call out rasicm. It is after all just as bad.

It's time we called men like this out. Womanhood is unique to women. Those that are born girls and reach adulthood. If you think blackface was wrong but you think this is okay, you need to ask yourself why. Why do you think women deserve less? Why is it okay to steal our identities, our sports and our safe spaces?

It's not.

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 26/01/2024 11:51

The only reason any of this bullshit has got as far as it has is because it's men.

If it was transmen (so women) leading the charge; demanding access to all male spaces, demanding language changed to accommodate them, trying to get men arrested in front of their kids for their 'violent rhetoric' online (aka misgendering), rocking up at male only counselling, invading prostate cancer groups on facebook and kicking off if they weren't centered and validated. Getting actual prostate cancer patients booted off the group for bigotry if they question it, no matter how politely. Demanding validation in sport (although winning and dominating the competition would be a sticking point).

It wouldn't have got anywhere. The men would have collectively told them to fuck off, ignored cries of 'but muh gender!!!" and bollocks to compromising. And indeed off those women would have fucked, tails between legs.

But when it's MEN and their gender identity, everyone falls over themselves to pander and validate. They aren't told to fuck off, and if they are, oh those evil, nasty women! What bigots! What hate! Don't they know you're the most womanly woman who has ever womaned?

The other men look on and because it involves effort and sticking their necks out to defend women they shrug their shoulders and walk off. Not their problem. The misogynists rub their hands with glee, they can't believe they finally get to stick it to the women and be seen as progressive heroes for doing it.

They don't want compromise. And the only compromise would be third unisex spaces, and open categories.

Such a category was indeed launched recently (think it was in swimming) and not a single transwoman entered because they didn't want it. They want womens categories to dominate in, and women have to be there as validation props. How else are they going to get their gender euphoria? (aka boner).

TheKeatingFive · 26/01/2024 11:10

Claiming to be a medical doctor has the potential to cause immediate harm, as would Reverend or Admiral, because those terms imply specific knowledge or experience that pretenders wont have - that's why some titles are protected terms.

I'm not sure that applies universally. What about being a 'sister' as in nun? Or academic doctor of medieval history?

The general point is that we don't go around letting people claim they are things they aren't. For lots of reasons, but one of them being the very basic idea that words have to have clearly defined meanings to be useful.

anyolddinosaur · 26/01/2024 10:40

@TheKeatingFive Claiming to be a medical doctor has the potential to cause immediate harm, as would Reverend or Admiral, because those terms imply specific knowledge or experience that pretenders wont have - that's why some titles are protected terms.

For those claiming to be something else the prospect of harm to others is less obvious or immediate but we still dont go along with it because we believe such people are ill and therefore need help.

I am sad for those who can not accept themselves as they are and feel the need to pretend to be something they are not but I dont support them inflicting harm on other people.

TheKeatingFive · 26/01/2024 10:17

If I claimed to be God or Napoleon or Princess Kate I'd be accepted as mentally ill and no-one would tell me I really was God or Napoleon or Kate - what's the difference with a man claiming to be a woman?

Equally, if I demanded to be known as a 'Doctor' or a 'Reverend' or an 'Admiral' then I wouldn't be accommodated in that.

Not because it would hurt anyone, but because words mean something and assigning them willy-nilly breaks down those meanings and causes confusion and ambiguity.

Reality matters - bottom line

EasternStandard · 26/01/2024 09:58

Ereshkigalangcleg · 26/01/2024 09:54

With respect, you have no idea what trans women do or don’t experience because you aren’t one.

And the same applies to males who claim to be women. They don't know what women do or don't experience because they aren't one.

Yes this is very easily flipped

Can we then agree men have no idea what it is to be a woman as they are not one.

StragglyTinsel · 26/01/2024 09:57

Ereshkigalangcleg · 26/01/2024 09:54

With respect, you have no idea what trans women do or don’t experience because you aren’t one.

And the same applies to males who claim to be women. They don't know what women do or don't experience because they aren't one.

There is considerable irony in the ‘lived experience’ claims made in and around the concept of transgender.

But our ‘lived experience’ as biologically female people simply does not count. Does it? 🙄

Ereshkigalangcleg · 26/01/2024 09:54

With respect, you have no idea what trans women do or don’t experience because you aren’t one.

And the same applies to males who claim to be women. They don't know what women do or don't experience because they aren't one.

anyolddinosaur · 26/01/2024 09:45

@SchoolQuestionnaire Lets start with where we agree - no-one should receive death threats. No-one should be assaulted.

Then where we may disagree - no-one should receive threats of rape for saying no to men. No-one should risk losing their job for speaking the truth. No-one should lose scholarships, funding prizes to a cheat, yet a lot of women are doing so https://www.shewon.org/ A man claiming to be a woman has no real understanding of what it means to be a woman and whatever is going on in their head does not make them a woman. It is not a "hate crime" to misgender someone, roll your eyes at them or tell them they are not the sex they claim. It is not "literal violence" to disagree with someone's perception of themself.

I can have sympathy for those men who for some reason hate and want to change their body without saying they are a woman or prioritising their needs over my own and especially over those of girls (letting adult males into changing rooms with young girls).

If I claimed to be God or Napoleon or Princess Kate I'd be accepted as mentally ill and no-one would tell me I really was God or Napoleon or Kate - what's the difference with a man claiming to be a woman?

TheKeatingFive · 26/01/2024 09:34

We all KNOW that transwomen are men. Because we know that mammals can't change sex. I trust we are all educated enough to agree on that.

So why are we being pressurised to lie about it?

As a courtesy? But surely the whole point of a courtesy is that it has to be freely given. A compelled courtesy is totalitarian.

Personally, I am immensely concerned that what may have been offered as a courtesy is now being enshrined in law. We have biological truths contradicted in law. That is proper Orwellian territory and extremely sinister.

But ultimately 'trans women are women' acts more like a religious mantra. Just like bread being 'the body of Christ'. Demonstrably false, but people repeat it to indicate their faith and the tribe they belong to.

I don't want to belong to a science-denying tribe that the TRAs are advocating. If that makes me 'transphobic' I will just wear that badge with pride. I believe in material reality.

SoreAndTired1 · 26/01/2024 09:16

SchoolQuestionnaire · 26/01/2024 06:23

Please be assured that I have no skin in this game and don’t need to lie. I’m just on a forum taking part in a reasonable discussion.

With respect, you have no idea what trans women do or don’t experience because you aren’t one. Feelings understandably run high around this issue but I can’t understand the lack of flexibility on both sides of this discussion. I just feel that there is room for compromise between ‘twaw so we must all share space with women and anyone who doesn’t agree is a terf and should die’ and ‘trans women are not women so I give no shits about their security at all and they can just fuck off’.

I maintain that I don’t think there is anything wrong with trans women having their own spaces (separate to women). I also still believe that the vast majority of trans women don’t want to hurt anyone and don’t deserve the vitriol they face. With that in mind I choose to refer to someone in the terms they prefer as a mark of respect. While there are some exceptions I don’t agree that for the most part it hurts anyone.

Re the issue of rape victims I understand that some men are taking advantage of this entire shitshow to gain access to women to harm them. I wholeheartedly agree that convicted criminals should lose all rights re how they are described. I also agree that a woman is biologically incapable of rape so shouldn’t be described in this way. I don’t know how to balance this as I don’t have all the answers here. This is why it’s important to have these discussions.

https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/news/hsph-in-the-news/transgender-teens-restricted-bathroom-access-sexual-assault/

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/oct/05/record-rise-hate-crimes-transgender-people-reported-england-and-wales

Harvard is completely captured and believes saying Trans Women are men is a 'hate crime'. Many of these incidents are self-reported. A graph once showed 'Strange looks' counted as a 'hate crime'. So excuse me if I don't buy it. A woman saying NO to transwomen is counted as a 'hate crime'.
Likewise with the assaults. Transwomen are known for assaulting women and girls 5 times greater the rate of 'cis' men. I do not buy that a transgirl (boy, so can defend themselves) is at greater risk of sexual assault than an actual girl is. This is just gaslighting at this point, and it's absolutely disgusting. https://fairplayforwomen.com/criminality/

Study suggests that transwomen exhibit a male pattern of criminality • Fair Play For Women

When looking at ANY CRIMES committed by all trans people there is a slightly higher risk of crime compared to the general population.

https://fairplayforwomen.com/criminality

pickledandpuzzled · 26/01/2024 08:58

I would judge Dave for his misogyny. I would avoid his parody of womanhood.

I would also find Dave alarming to be around. The latter statement is tricky because it’s similar to unacceptable racist statements. Though it’s his behaviour which is triggering my spidey senses, so maybe it’s justified. It’s his choice to do those things that make other people uncomfortable.

TheKeatingFive · 26/01/2024 08:46

and ‘trans women are not women so I give no shits about their security at all

It is not acceptable for anyone to be in danger.

But boiling it down, these people are men, in danger from other men (your position), in men's spaces.

So why is this being served up to women as their issue to deal with? I am not responsible for the behaviour of some men and neither do I feel I should be used as a shield to protect other men from that.

Why are women being harangued here, not the man making these spaces unsafe to begin with?