Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to work more hours? (Universal Credit)

409 replies

Abneyandteal19 · 23/01/2024 00:00

Hi
Have never claimed benefits before except child benefit as we've always earns over threshold, situation now is....
3DC ages 4 (preschool) 6 and 8.

I work part time professional job management - but job share 15hrs PW. Income £14500

DH professional job in region of £60-65k has never been out of work until now. His contracts ended in Dec. Had a job lined up for Jan- company funding issues have meant they've delayed his start indefinitely. Of course he is desperately searching.

Done all calculations and looks like we are entitled to some UC, so filled in all forms. Have to agree to commitments, DH has to look for work log jobs applied for work coach etc...all fine no problem

But my commitments have come back with I must agree to look for more hours work. I am not sure I can do this... my job is job share split 40/60 so there are no more hours. I have my preschooler everyday I don't work.

Main point is we were just looking for a bit of help for a few months until DH starts and then gets paid for a new job. Chances are he will absolutely get one in next 3 months and then of course will will cease claiming anything and then me working part time will be totally fine again.

It's not that I don't want to work more just not that easy to find something for a few hours a week that will pay more than childcare will cost? Any thoughts/experience? So AIBU not to want to work more hours?

OP posts:
WithACatLikeTread · 23/01/2024 14:42

DaphneMoo · 23/01/2024 14:39

Why can't your husband do agency work while waiting for a full time permanent job? You don't need to work more hours or look for more, just don't claim Universal credit.

Why can't they? They have a loss of income.

DaphneMoo · 23/01/2024 14:39

Why can't your husband do agency work while waiting for a full time permanent job? You don't need to work more hours or look for more, just don't claim Universal credit.

Bromptotoo · 23/01/2024 14:38

@Abneyandteal19 I think, given your earnings, UC will treat you as what they call 'light touch'; see my previous message about the Administrative Earnings Threshold.

Your husband is looking for work and, no doubt, will need to evidence what he is doing. He will have to commit to what he will do. I suspect he'd be allowed some time to explore options in his previous line of work before being leaned on to work at MacDonald's!!

You will need to commit to look for extra work too but I don't think you'll be pressured hard, certainly not immediately. Anything would need to be compatible with the fact you have young kids. I think if you can say you're exploring extra hours at your current employment and putting out feelers that would be enough.

Go to your interviews, explain your circumstances but engage constructively and I think you'll be fine.

If you need expert help speak to Help to Claim, funded by DWP but provided by Citizens Advice, on 0800 144 8 444.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/01/2024 14:38

Katypp · 23/01/2024 14:13

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves could you elaborate on what you mean by "Of course, that includes families where the adults are genuinely unable to find suitable employment"?

I think it's self evident, isn't it?

I am talking about people who are proactively looking for work and open-minded about the kind of work that they would be willing to do but who are unable to find work for whatever reason. It might be short term or it might be long term. And it might be because they lack basic skills (in some cases due to undiagnosed learning difficulties etc), or because they need specific adjustments for disability etc that employers are unable to make. They may be struggling due to factors like racism, ageism, disablism etc. Or it might simply be that they are applying for tons of jobs and narrowly missing out each time for no obvious reason. Obviously, in the longer term, if people are unable to find work over an extended period, then additional support should be offered in the form of training/skills development, interview coaching etc. But the support needs to be available to those who genuinely can't find a job, for whatever reason - not for those who don't fancy looking because it doesn't fit with their lifestyle.

zendeveloper · 23/01/2024 14:37

Bazinga007 · 23/01/2024 14:31

When you are so dependent on one person's salary why on earth does your husband not have income protection insurance?

It would not have paid out in the situation where a fixed term contract finishes at the time that was known and agreed 12 months in advance.

Bazinga007 · 23/01/2024 14:31

When you are so dependent on one person's salary why on earth does your husband not have income protection insurance?

twnety · 23/01/2024 14:30

SmellyKat10 · 23/01/2024 00:37

Hm, I’m not entirely unsympathetic but on balance I do feel like this is pretty poor.

In principle, you CAN work. Your husband could watch the kids. You just don’t want to. That’s not what UC is there for.

Edited

I agree with you here, DH will be at home, so no reason OP (or actually DH) could pick up some extra hours doing something...

justasking111 · 23/01/2024 14:30

Abneyandteal19 · 23/01/2024 14:17

Wow a lot of hate for my husband!
We aren't up ourselves at all but he was due to start a job on 15th Jan got told on the 10th he wasn't and has been job searching since.
You really think in that situation your first move should be to apply to McDonalds! Not try to get another similar job?? Of course if after a short while of trying he is unsuccessful he will consider more options.

As previous posters said I'd be happy for UC to say ok- if your husband hasn't found work in 2 months say- then you will be expected to or payment stops. But I now see it won't work like that.

We will see what comes of his interviews and will cancel our claim if he gets offered one. The UC decision is due end of Feb so I guess we just leave it until then and see what they say- fingers crossed we never need it.

Thanks to those offering sensible advice.

It's not hate for your husband at all. But you have a job, he doesn't so he finds work. The default shouldn't be the state.

Oliotya · 23/01/2024 14:26

Abneyandteal19 · 23/01/2024 14:17

Wow a lot of hate for my husband!
We aren't up ourselves at all but he was due to start a job on 15th Jan got told on the 10th he wasn't and has been job searching since.
You really think in that situation your first move should be to apply to McDonalds! Not try to get another similar job?? Of course if after a short while of trying he is unsuccessful he will consider more options.

As previous posters said I'd be happy for UC to say ok- if your husband hasn't found work in 2 months say- then you will be expected to or payment stops. But I now see it won't work like that.

We will see what comes of his interviews and will cancel our claim if he gets offered one. The UC decision is due end of Feb so I guess we just leave it until then and see what they say- fingers crossed we never need it.

Thanks to those offering sensible advice.

I still think looking for more work should be the default rather than applying for benefits. He's already been out of work 6 weeks, end of feb is another 6 weeks away, thats an awful lot of hours that could have been worked.
I resent our taxes being spent supporting 2 capable adults to work half a job between them. Plan better or lower your expectations.
I work evenings and sundays, why can't one of you?

NonPlayerCharacter · 23/01/2024 14:25

BouncingJAS · 23/01/2024 13:08

@MaidOfSteel

Not quite. 54% of the adult population are net tax recipients. They take out more in services vs what they pay in tax.

The cutoff for "net taxpayer" is about £55k/year in the aggregate sense. The higher earners (top 10%) pay 60% of the income taxes so the rest do little. They just end up using services.

For the OP, her SO was not a contractor. He had a fixed term contract (these are usually 12 months). I have seen these type of contracts pop up more and more in the UK as it allows companies to let you go if the financial need arises.

So in the OPs case, her SO simply finished his fixed term contract. He was not fired or made redundant which means he would not be eligible for unemployment benefits (in the general sense).

In this case, this type of problem (time between jobs) is what savings are for. OP needs to increase her hours while her SO looks for work.

And no, the husband should not try to take on lower skilled work. That is actually detrimental in the long-run. But he should temper his expectations for higher paid professional jobs as those are harder to come by now. A lower paying professional job would probably work better right now to tide them over.

And no, the husband should not try to take on lower skilled work. That is actually detrimental in the long-run.

Only if he puts it on his CV as equal relevance to the jobs in his sector. Purely to keep the wolves from the door, it's fine. He could leave it off completely if it looks to dilute his CV. You mustn't lie on your CV but you don't have to include every job you've ever had that's not relevant to the role you're looking for. If they ask at interview what he's doing now, he can tell them while making it clear what he's looking for long term.

TheCompactPussycat · 23/01/2024 14:24

Katypp · 23/01/2024 14:15

And also your definition of what a family who has genuinely fallen on hard times looks like? In my world, the OP would fall into that criteria but I am assuming not in yours

But this isn't about whether she has actually fallen on hard times or not. She sounds like she has.

The problem is that she is utterly unwilling to look for any extra hours herself, or to accept that her DH needs to look for stop-gap work. That isn't 'hard-times', that is just precious and entitled. She simply doesn't want the rules to apply to her.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/01/2024 14:19

Katypp · 23/01/2024 14:10

What's wrong in my opinion is that someone who has been a net contributer should be able to get a little (just a little) extra help to get them paying into the system again.
That's my.opinion and you clearly won't agree but that's life.
I don't agree that the OP's circumstances are the same as someone who has claimed UC for years and is complaining about having to find work, assuming there are no disabilities or illnesses involved.
But as I said, just my opinion

The welfare state was founded on the principle of "from each according to their ability, to each according to their need". Not "to each according to how much they've already put into the pot"

As I said above, I was made redundant myself a few years back after many years of paying higher rate tax etc. It wouldn't have occurred to me that I should get "extra" for having paid in over the years because I didn't actually need it.

Yes, our finances took a hit. Yes, we had to dip into our savings and cut back on expenditure. Yes, I ended up taking a job for a while that I wouldn't have usually contemplated taking in order to be able to pay the bills. However, I fully expected to have to do everything in my capability to support myself and my family , because that's surely a normal expectation - why on earth would I expect the taxpayer to stump up for stuff that I'm capable of doing for myself? I would far prefer that those limited taxpayer funds to go towards the people who genuinely can't manage without state support.

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 14:19

evilharpy · 23/01/2024 14:13

I was also going to ask about contribution-based JSA. Is that not an option for people who have been on FTCs? My husband was made redundant at the start of last year and went through the process to claim JSA (although he found a new job quickly enough before the claim was finalised so he never received anything). I was only working about 27 hours at the time but it's not means tested so there was no requirement for me to increase my hours.

Yes, anyone can claim if their contract comes to an end or if they are made redundant etc, and there are no income barriers either. You can only claim it for a short while and it’s not much at all.

Abneyandteal19 · 23/01/2024 14:17

Wow a lot of hate for my husband!
We aren't up ourselves at all but he was due to start a job on 15th Jan got told on the 10th he wasn't and has been job searching since.
You really think in that situation your first move should be to apply to McDonalds! Not try to get another similar job?? Of course if after a short while of trying he is unsuccessful he will consider more options.

As previous posters said I'd be happy for UC to say ok- if your husband hasn't found work in 2 months say- then you will be expected to or payment stops. But I now see it won't work like that.

We will see what comes of his interviews and will cancel our claim if he gets offered one. The UC decision is due end of Feb so I guess we just leave it until then and see what they say- fingers crossed we never need it.

Thanks to those offering sensible advice.

OP posts:
Bromptotoo · 23/01/2024 14:15

A teacher working 30 hours per week would not be entitled to UC, even if their partner was out of work

That's nonsense.

It will depend on circumstances. As set out in OP and assuming they're not renting I guess they'd get around £700/month.

Katypp · 23/01/2024 14:15

And also your definition of what a family who has genuinely fallen on hard times looks like? In my world, the OP would fall into that criteria but I am assuming not in yours

Menapausemum1974 · 23/01/2024 14:13

Spot on, easy to be nasty when you’re hiding behind a screen I suppose!
the system isn’t fit for purpose and the rules can verge on the ridiculous and impossible. If there was a bit of flexibility this family would likely be back on their feet, earning a good salary, contributing a larger then average amount of tax and likely never need help again, instead the rules ( and some posters) would rather send him off to a minimum wage job which would definitely interfere with his ability to secure a post at his previous level ( minimum paid jobs are hardly likely to offer much perks/ flexibility) and have the family dependent on benefits for a much longer period, all the while massively reducing his ability to pay into the tax system! 🤦‍♀️🤷‍♀️

evilharpy · 23/01/2024 14:13

I was also going to ask about contribution-based JSA. Is that not an option for people who have been on FTCs? My husband was made redundant at the start of last year and went through the process to claim JSA (although he found a new job quickly enough before the claim was finalised so he never received anything). I was only working about 27 hours at the time but it's not means tested so there was no requirement for me to increase my hours.

Katypp · 23/01/2024 14:13

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves could you elaborate on what you mean by "Of course, that includes families where the adults are genuinely unable to find suitable employment"?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/01/2024 14:11

It's laughable that posters like @AmethystSparkles are suggesting that it's only far right posters telling the OP that it's reasonable to expect her to look for work.

I'm very much on the left of the political spectrum, but I believe that the benefits system should be there for those who are genuinely in need, e.g. due to sickness, disability, caring for disabled family members etc. Of course, that includes families where the adults are genuinely unable to find suitable employment. Personally, I would make the system much more generous for those who have genuinely fallen on hard times, so that we don't have people having to rely on food banks or choosing between eating and heating etc.

However, we will never have a hope in hell of funding a welfare state that effectively looks after the people who genuinely need help if people who are perfectly capable of work expect the state to fund their personal lifestyle choices simply because they've paid a bit of tax and feel entitled to it.

Katypp · 23/01/2024 14:10

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/01/2024 14:02

I do agree with a pp who said that -rather like pensions- contributions into the system should be taken into account for a limited period to help people get back on their feet.

Isn't this what contribution-based JSA is about? As far as I know, it doesn't take household income or savings into account.

I presume that the OP's dh would be entitled to this if he has been contributing, but that they want to claim UC on top of this because it isn't enough?

UC is based on household income, and there is a reasonable expectation that all capable adults in the household should be actively seeking work to qualify. What's wrong with that, exactly?

What's wrong in my opinion is that someone who has been a net contributer should be able to get a little (just a little) extra help to get them paying into the system again.
That's my.opinion and you clearly won't agree but that's life.
I don't agree that the OP's circumstances are the same as someone who has claimed UC for years and is complaining about having to find work, assuming there are no disabilities or illnesses involved.
But as I said, just my opinion

justasking111 · 23/01/2024 14:09

My sons partner did a degree in marketing no jobs.So she's doing hospitality. Zero hours. She's worked there right through university running this franchise for an absent boss. Last month she had a work accident damaged knee so was off. She's asked for extra hours next month to make up her wages. He said no because she should be finding a job relevant to her degree. Like she hasn't been trying. He's rarely there, she does orders, staff rotas, juggling staff no shows.

He's a lazy bastard but so are many bosses who coast.

If OPs husband is up his backside exaggerating his importance. Wake up @Abneyandteal19

EvelynKatie · 23/01/2024 14:03

AmethystSparkles · 23/01/2024 12:23

You’ve activated the Mumsnet far right conservative bots OP.

They like to make it as difficult as possible for you to claim benefits so that you won’t claim them. My friend has had two heart attacks and he’s being treated despicably. They probably hope he’ll die of stress so that they save money.

Just make an attempt to look for work. If you get a job then deal with it at that time. I bet all the people claiming that you’re committing fraud are still using tax-avoiding companies such as Amazon.

I don't think it's 'far right' at all to suggest to someone who was a higher rate tax payer on a 60k job should have had the sense to plan ahead when taking a 12 month contract without savings to fill any gaps in employment, and then demand the state supports them during that gap, and are shocked they have to follow the same rules everyone else does!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/01/2024 14:02

Katypp · 23/01/2024 13:56

I don't understand most of the responses to this poster, which I assume are either driven by envy or just sheer unpleasantness for the sake of it.
Yes, the OP will have to abide by the same rules as everyone else, but I do agree with a pp who said that -rather like pensions- contributions into the system should be taken into account for a limited period to help people get back on their feet. After all, it's families like this who pay for UC in the first place.
The obvious solution to me would be for the DH to look for any full-time work he can and look for a better job at the same time. Many of us do that.
It is a mystery to me though that whenever anyone posts about people claiming UC they're accused of benefits basing with all sorts of astonishing justifications given as to why they should be allowed to do so indefinitely, yet when a couple who have paid into the system for 18+ years need a helping hand, they are met with derision and contempt. As I said, I can only assume it's envy.

I do agree with a pp who said that -rather like pensions- contributions into the system should be taken into account for a limited period to help people get back on their feet.

Isn't this what contribution-based JSA is about? As far as I know, it doesn't take household income or savings into account.

I presume that the OP's dh would be entitled to this if he has been contributing, but that they want to claim UC on top of this because it isn't enough?

UC is based on household income, and there is a reasonable expectation that all capable adults in the household should be actively seeking work to qualify. What's wrong with that, exactly?

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 14:01

justasking111 · 23/01/2024 13:58

You don't like part time teachers do you?

A teacher working 30 hours per week would not be entitled to UC, even if their partner was out of work.