Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to work more hours? (Universal Credit)

409 replies

Abneyandteal19 · 23/01/2024 00:00

Hi
Have never claimed benefits before except child benefit as we've always earns over threshold, situation now is....
3DC ages 4 (preschool) 6 and 8.

I work part time professional job management - but job share 15hrs PW. Income £14500

DH professional job in region of £60-65k has never been out of work until now. His contracts ended in Dec. Had a job lined up for Jan- company funding issues have meant they've delayed his start indefinitely. Of course he is desperately searching.

Done all calculations and looks like we are entitled to some UC, so filled in all forms. Have to agree to commitments, DH has to look for work log jobs applied for work coach etc...all fine no problem

But my commitments have come back with I must agree to look for more hours work. I am not sure I can do this... my job is job share split 40/60 so there are no more hours. I have my preschooler everyday I don't work.

Main point is we were just looking for a bit of help for a few months until DH starts and then gets paid for a new job. Chances are he will absolutely get one in next 3 months and then of course will will cease claiming anything and then me working part time will be totally fine again.

It's not that I don't want to work more just not that easy to find something for a few hours a week that will pay more than childcare will cost? Any thoughts/experience? So AIBU not to want to work more hours?

OP posts:
Menapausemum1974 · 24/01/2024 15:58

Babyroobs · 24/01/2024 15:26

Well maybe they were cautious and sensible about taking on a mortgage with insecure earnings ? they probably knew that in the worst case scenario UC pays help with rent but not a mortgage ! And sometimes you know babies aren't always planned, not saying this is the case here but it happens. I don't understand why their approach blows your mind so much, it 's not exactly as if they are long term benefit recipients and chose to keep having kids like some people do who have never had a job !

She never said she rented , she specifically said they were using savings to pay the mortgage. People are not even reading the facts now! 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

Menapausemum1974 · 24/01/2024 15:55

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 14:22

The pandemic was 2020-2021! That makes not having secured employment (with a large family) and no savings even more bizarre, not less. You do know we are in 2024 right?

Yes thank you I am aware we are in 2024, however they may have had to use all their savings during the pandemic period and have struggled to replace them. As for “ secure” employment I have worked in the charity sector for over 20 years, this is always contracts due to the way the funding works, luckily despite being made redundant a couple of times I have managed to not be out of work but it’s the way things work in many sectors.

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 15:46

@Babyroobs @lookwhatyoudidthere lives in London which, so far as most of us are concerned is another planet. Although, that said, Northampton siffers from a London pay effect s it's commutable.

They also seem to think £100k is in the way of a 'modest income'.

As an SEO in the Civil Service in LB Westminster my max 10years ago was £41k. I don't think it's hit £50k even now. My FTE in current role is about £26k.

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 15:40

Babyroobs · 24/01/2024 15:26

Well maybe they were cautious and sensible about taking on a mortgage with insecure earnings ? they probably knew that in the worst case scenario UC pays help with rent but not a mortgage ! And sometimes you know babies aren't always planned, not saying this is the case here but it happens. I don't understand why their approach blows your mind so much, it 's not exactly as if they are long term benefit recipients and chose to keep having kids like some people do who have never had a job !

@Babyroobs A house in an asset that you can sell if things go wrong. You also have control over your payments (and payment holidays if necessary) so as to manage your largest out going cost which is generally either mortgage or rent. Rent is rising sharply at the moment, as buy-to-let landlords recharge the interest rate rises to their tenants, so renting represents a total lack of control over your costs (you don't decide them as a tenant, neither do you decide the renewal rate each year). Babies of course can surprise and delight you in equal measure, many of the London parents I know get themselves into a position where they can financially control and manage the outcome, or else take precautions.

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 15:34

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 15:28

This is how far off piste this thread has gone.

I did not say the OP was paying rent, I don't think she is.

My point was that an ordinary couple, both working in say retail, with a joint income of maybe £45-£50k - gross - and renting as as many have to, should be able to have children.

Edited

I think I misunderstood your previous post, which said 'private let'? I hadn't realised this was a hypothetical, retail-working couple.

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 15:28

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 15:20

@Bromptotoo I missed that they were renting. This just gets more and more bizarre the more I find out about it. The approach literally blows my mind: lets see how many kids we can fit into our rental (for which we have no control over rising costs) and couple this with no savings to cover the unforeseen. If I was in rentals with 3 kids, I would be rather urgently considering my return to work FT or else how to up-skill to change my lot in life.

This is how far off piste this thread has gone.

I did not say the OP was paying rent, I don't think she is.

My point was that an ordinary couple, both working in say retail, with a joint income of maybe £45-£50k - gross - and renting as as many have to, should be able to have children.

Babyroobs · 24/01/2024 15:26

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 15:20

@Bromptotoo I missed that they were renting. This just gets more and more bizarre the more I find out about it. The approach literally blows my mind: lets see how many kids we can fit into our rental (for which we have no control over rising costs) and couple this with no savings to cover the unforeseen. If I was in rentals with 3 kids, I would be rather urgently considering my return to work FT or else how to up-skill to change my lot in life.

Well maybe they were cautious and sensible about taking on a mortgage with insecure earnings ? they probably knew that in the worst case scenario UC pays help with rent but not a mortgage ! And sometimes you know babies aren't always planned, not saying this is the case here but it happens. I don't understand why their approach blows your mind so much, it 's not exactly as if they are long term benefit recipients and chose to keep having kids like some people do who have never had a job !

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 15:20

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 14:01

How, in the name of all that is holy, do you save on 2*min wage and in a private let?

Is it only the well off who can breed?

@Bromptotoo I missed that they were renting. This just gets more and more bizarre the more I find out about it. The approach literally blows my mind: lets see how many kids we can fit into our rental (for which we have no control over rising costs) and couple this with no savings to cover the unforeseen. If I was in rentals with 3 kids, I would be rather urgently considering my return to work FT or else how to up-skill to change my lot in life.

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 15:01

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 14:22

@lookwhatyoudidthere so far as I can tell the OP's husband was on a salary sufficient to pay Higher Rate Tax and she was on £14,500. Joint income nearly £80k. A job that was expected to continue - for me and many others life on back to back fixed term contracts is a norm as it is in many sectors - until funding failed. At that point hubby is unemployed.

If you cannot afford 3 kids on a combined income of c£80k heaven help the rest of us.

We only had two but managed a girl and then a boy two years apart. Might have been different if we'd had two of the same sex and wanted to try for a girl (or boy).

@Bromptotoo If OP's husband earned 65k pre tax, he's only just made the threshold for higher rate of tax, which is £50,271 - £125,140. So £14,729 of his pay would be subject to 40% higher rate. After tax this would be take home pay of £45,738 (assuming no pension deductions). OP's take home would be £13,502, that makes a total family income of £59,240, if you were divide this amongst a family of 5 to show your potential spend per human that would be £11,848. I'm no financial whizz, but that sounds super tight to me?

We are based in London, where people are struggling to meet their mortgage payments on higher incomes (I'm talking over 100k take home), due to interest rates and rising costs. I at a total loss as to how people can afford to pay their mortgages and have large families? 80k (which isn't the OP's income in any event) for a family of 5 simply wouldn't cut it round our way, unless you were prepared to dress in rags and eat beans in perpetuity.

Unsurprisingly, London birthrates are falling through the floor, the barriers are too high and we all work too hard (long hours and commutes coupled with high expectations placed on us by businesses). why bother if all we are doing is topping up the less ambitious workers, or those who don't work at all, in other parts of the UK? It would be interesting to know the economic effect of Londoner saying 'nah - you're alright - I think I'll work 15 hours too'.

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 14:22

Menapausemum1974 · 24/01/2024 14:17

Your forgetting a pandemic that no one was
prepared for. OP already said they took a big hit because of this, most probably why they now don’t have much saved. Sure they will take this into consideration going forward but they won’t be alone in not planning for such a massive upheaval

The pandemic was 2020-2021! That makes not having secured employment (with a large family) and no savings even more bizarre, not less. You do know we are in 2024 right?

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 14:22

@lookwhatyoudidthere so far as I can tell the OP's husband was on a salary sufficient to pay Higher Rate Tax and she was on £14,500. Joint income nearly £80k. A job that was expected to continue - for me and many others life on back to back fixed term contracts is a norm as it is in many sectors - until funding failed. At that point hubby is unemployed.

If you cannot afford 3 kids on a combined income of c£80k heaven help the rest of us.

We only had two but managed a girl and then a boy two years apart. Might have been different if we'd had two of the same sex and wanted to try for a girl (or boy).

Menapausemum1974 · 24/01/2024 14:17

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 14:07

Yeah I do get that, my query is: why in holy hell have 3 kids? Knowing that this is the financial landscape you are operating in? Close your eyes and hope for the best? Expect other tax payers to pay your way? There isn't a perfect solution, only choices.

Your forgetting a pandemic that no one was
prepared for. OP already said they took a big hit because of this, most probably why they now don’t have much saved. Sure they will take this into consideration going forward but they won’t be alone in not planning for such a massive upheaval

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 14:07

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 14:01

How, in the name of all that is holy, do you save on 2*min wage and in a private let?

Is it only the well off who can breed?

Yeah I do get that, my query is: why in holy hell have 3 kids? Knowing that this is the financial landscape you are operating in? Close your eyes and hope for the best? Expect other tax payers to pay your way? There isn't a perfect solution, only choices.

HollaHolla · 24/01/2024 14:03

0rangeCrush · 23/01/2024 14:19

Yes, anyone can claim if their contract comes to an end or if they are made redundant etc, and there are no income barriers either. You can only claim it for a short while and it’s not much at all.

I was coming on to say about this. It's really not much - I think it was £145 a fortnight, at the beginning of this year. I claimed it for 12 weeks, without much question; I just had to show I was applying for work in my field. (My advisor was sensible enough to see that there was no point in making me take a job as an Amazon delivery driver, for example - I have a PhD, and work in Higher Education.) I would then have had to take something else, if I didn't get something within the first 12 weeks. I was starting to apply for hospitality jobs - which I've done before - when I got my current role. So, I think I got the JSA for 15 weeks in total. Wasn't eligible for anything else, as am single, childless, and have a mortgage....

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 14:01

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 13:34

@OCDmama I think what you’re failing to grasp is people in temporary employment and large families to support need a safety net, and that my friend is called savings, not benefits. You are of course entitled to your opinion, as am I.

How, in the name of all that is holy, do you save on 2*min wage and in a private let?

Is it only the well off who can breed?

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 13:38

OCDmama · 24/01/2024 13:29

@lookwhatyoudidthere no I understand. I worked contracts for years before I was lucky enough to land a permanent role. What you don't seem to grasp is that not everyone chooses to work contracts. Sometimes that's the nature of the business. Some permanent roles can be rare.

@Oliotya I worked as a HCA. It certainly wasn't a case of interview/straight to work. There's the matter of DBS checks that need to be done, and basic training before starting work with clients.

Having a large family is a choice not a duty or a right. Taking contracts is a choice also, life is full of them, what responsible adults do is take calculated risks and cut their cloth to suit their budget. You seem to be of a mindset that people are entitled to saddle themselves with more responsibility than they can afford to and then revert to the state for help. This is partly why schools and healthcare is so underfunded- because many are taking from system and not giving enough back.

lookwhatyoudidthere · 24/01/2024 13:34

OCDmama · 24/01/2024 13:29

@lookwhatyoudidthere no I understand. I worked contracts for years before I was lucky enough to land a permanent role. What you don't seem to grasp is that not everyone chooses to work contracts. Sometimes that's the nature of the business. Some permanent roles can be rare.

@Oliotya I worked as a HCA. It certainly wasn't a case of interview/straight to work. There's the matter of DBS checks that need to be done, and basic training before starting work with clients.

@OCDmama I think what you’re failing to grasp is people in temporary employment and large families to support need a safety net, and that my friend is called savings, not benefits. You are of course entitled to your opinion, as am I.

Oliotya · 24/01/2024 13:30

OCDmama · 24/01/2024 13:29

@lookwhatyoudidthere no I understand. I worked contracts for years before I was lucky enough to land a permanent role. What you don't seem to grasp is that not everyone chooses to work contracts. Sometimes that's the nature of the business. Some permanent roles can be rare.

@Oliotya I worked as a HCA. It certainly wasn't a case of interview/straight to work. There's the matter of DBS checks that need to be done, and basic training before starting work with clients.

I said "induction" didn't I?

OCDmama · 24/01/2024 13:29

@lookwhatyoudidthere no I understand. I worked contracts for years before I was lucky enough to land a permanent role. What you don't seem to grasp is that not everyone chooses to work contracts. Sometimes that's the nature of the business. Some permanent roles can be rare.

@Oliotya I worked as a HCA. It certainly wasn't a case of interview/straight to work. There's the matter of DBS checks that need to be done, and basic training before starting work with clients.

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 11:32

LakieLady · 23/01/2024 15:27

You're right about them making it as difficult as possible, @AmethystSparkles .

Earlier today, I had an email from a client who was well enough to work (and did work) and now isn't. They tried to submit a FIT note to their work coach yesterday, and they refused it, telling them that they could only accept a FIT note if it was for a different health condition.

They have 2 main health problems, both of them are fluctuating in nature. This cannot be right, surely? There are loads of health conditions that vary massively in how severe they are from time to time.

Anyway, the bottom line is that UC comes with conditions, which claimants can accept and comply with or not. If they don't comply, and don't have a good reason for not complying, they can be sanctioned. That sanction can be challenged on the grounds that it's unreasonable, but challenges can take forever (a year or more if it has to go to a tribunal).

I don't agree with it, and I like it even less. It is particularly hard on people with MH conditions, ASDs and mild learning difficulties. But it's what people voted for.

@LakieLady if you want an answer to your question above you might get some useful help if you repost in Cost of Living which is where most benefit related questions fetch up.

Bromptotoo · 24/01/2024 09:57

@lookwhatyoudidthere said Contractors (as a PP mentioned) aren’t actually eligible for UC as they are not counted as full time, you aren’t FT unless you have a FT contract and have passed your probation period.

If you're the sort of contractor who has their own business and offers their services through it that may be the case.

If, as I am, you're on a series of fixed term contracts which are hopefully back to back but depend on outside funding and on PAYE then you're an employee - or possibly a worker. In either of those cases if the contract ends and there's no new role/contract you're out of work and can claim UC (or NS JSA if you've got the right NI contributions).

As I understood the OP's posts her DH was in the latter category.

Long term 'tenured' employment of the type I had in the Civil Service from 1978 to 2013 is a bit of a luxury now.

bobomomo · 23/01/2024 21:17

It's fine to take uc, it's there for situations like op's but the condition is they both urgently seek full time employment, nothing wrong with that. Take the money, get job hunting, hopefully he will find work before you op

Starzinsky · 23/01/2024 21:12

If he finds another job quickly then great but part-time working is a luxury even with kids, and definitely not reasonable on benefits.

Kalevala · 23/01/2024 20:59

Oliotya · 23/01/2024 20:43

I recently gave up stacking shelves for a job in social care. I interviewed on a Thursday, started induction on Monday. It is that easy if you're willing to work. You tailor the cv to suit the job you're applying for, obviously. Nobody should think themselves above applying for anything going - snobbery and wishful thinking shouldn't be what welfare is for.

I agree. I've never had to wait more than a few days from contact with the employer to starting work. Some haven't looked at a cv, preferring a chat followed by a paid day trial. If you are willing to work and a fast learner, then it's not difficult. I've done all kinds of jobs.

lookwhatyoudidthere · 23/01/2024 20:46

OCDmama · 23/01/2024 20:08

@lookwhatyoudidthere@Hmmmmaybe

Wow holier than thou. And so ignorant.

Lots of people work 'contract' jobs. Lots of roles are only for 12/18/23 months. Because that's how a lot of businesses budget at the moment. They don't want to commit to employing permanently, or beyond those months. Lots of people work contract to contract because that's the way of it. What do you think a maternity leave post is as an example?

And they have three children. That's the situation. I'm not sure how raging at them for that helps - should OP sell the kids??

And all the 'pick up more hours at your current job' commenters - again, many businesses have such tight budgets they cannot afford to pay more hours. I'm not sure where you're all working that has unlimited budgets with permanent contracts?

@Oliotya no, it's not that easy to just get a job. Recruiting costs money - they'll take a look at the CVs, realise it's a stop gap and not take OPs husband on. They'd make a loss themselves through HR costs, registering with HMRC, training etc. Maybe you need to live in the real world? You can't just walk in to a shop and start stacking shelves five minutes later, FFS.

Edited

@OCDmama no need to sell the kids, I don’t think extra mouths to feed retail for much anyhow? The point is if you have 3 kids to feed, clothe and transport, that’s a massive responsibility and not one that should be taken lightly. If your main breadwinner is on a contract (most can be ended at a weeks notice), I’d definitely consider this the type of job you would need good savings to do with a clear conscience. Contractors (as a PP mentioned) aren’t actually eligible for UC as they are not counted as full time, you aren’t FT unless you have a FT contract and have passed your probation period. Hope that’s clarified my comments for you. Certainly not holier than thou, just a long term freelancer who understands how sporadic temporary work can be.