Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to work more hours? (Universal Credit)

409 replies

Abneyandteal19 · 23/01/2024 00:00

Hi
Have never claimed benefits before except child benefit as we've always earns over threshold, situation now is....
3DC ages 4 (preschool) 6 and 8.

I work part time professional job management - but job share 15hrs PW. Income £14500

DH professional job in region of £60-65k has never been out of work until now. His contracts ended in Dec. Had a job lined up for Jan- company funding issues have meant they've delayed his start indefinitely. Of course he is desperately searching.

Done all calculations and looks like we are entitled to some UC, so filled in all forms. Have to agree to commitments, DH has to look for work log jobs applied for work coach etc...all fine no problem

But my commitments have come back with I must agree to look for more hours work. I am not sure I can do this... my job is job share split 40/60 so there are no more hours. I have my preschooler everyday I don't work.

Main point is we were just looking for a bit of help for a few months until DH starts and then gets paid for a new job. Chances are he will absolutely get one in next 3 months and then of course will will cease claiming anything and then me working part time will be totally fine again.

It's not that I don't want to work more just not that easy to find something for a few hours a week that will pay more than childcare will cost? Any thoughts/experience? So AIBU not to want to work more hours?

OP posts:
TerroristToddler · 23/01/2024 09:02

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 23/01/2024 08:51

FFS
OP is not trying to get out of work
She IS working. And she is also looking after 2 younger children. Her husband is working hard to find another high earning position and by the sound of it, he will have one soon. Potentially even before all the UC stuff is sorted.

If she went full time then she'd invariably get criticised for leaving her kids in someone else's care all day.

They're a family who have hit a stumbling block. It happened to a LOT of people during Covid. Only at that time UC just paid out without the work expectations.

Essentially some of this comes off as jealous that she lives the way we should be able to - part time to be there for children whilst the other parent works to pay the bills. Like it used to be, only it should be acceptable to be either parent now

Tbf..., her youngest is 4 and the others are in school. Soon all will be school age. We're not talking about leaving 3 babies in childcare at this point (which is expensive) - she's got school age kids.

Beezknees · 23/01/2024 09:00

YANBU to not want to do it but I think you'll have to do a bit of hoop jumping. I've been a claimant for 15 years and it's best to just do what they ask.

AgnesX · 23/01/2024 09:00

AreYouMeOrWhat · 23/01/2024 02:29

I'm no expert but why have you claimed UC rather than your husband claiming contributions-based ESA? That is 6m of payments so presumably meets your needs better.

Why would she claim ESA, does she have a condition of some kind. I may have missed an update.

shepherdsangeldelight · 23/01/2024 08:55

Sadly, you can't know how long it will take your DH to find another job. The job market is tough right now. So you looking for another job is a good idea anyway.

If you don't want to detract from his job hunting (which is really not all day every day ...), then why not look at evening or weekend jobs? Hospitality/retail don't take weeks to "onboard" people - you could be started pretty quickly, and if DH did find another job you could just walk away.

I found the UC checks soul destroying. I think you will struggle to prove you've made the requisite amount of effort to find another job if you haven't. If you want the money, you have to jump through the hoops.

PickledPurplePickle · 23/01/2024 08:55

YABU - the rules are there for a reason.

If you don't want to follow them, don't claim

Do you have any savings to tide you over?

NeedToChangeName · 23/01/2024 08:55

SmellyKat10 · 23/01/2024 00:37

Hm, I’m not entirely unsympathetic but on balance I do feel like this is pretty poor.

In principle, you CAN work. Your husband could watch the kids. You just don’t want to. That’s not what UC is there for.

Edited

I agree with @SmellyKat10

Benefits should be a safety net for those who need it. If your DH isn't currently working, then he's available to care for the children. Or, he could take temp work while he seeks a long term role

Dweetfidilove · 23/01/2024 08:55

I think the system is doing exactly what you expect it too, but with conditions.

The idea your husband need to be ‘available’ for opportunities is false, as people manage to get new jobs and change whole careers while working full-time jobs. If a recruiter wants him enough, they will schedule an agreed time for a chat / interview.

There’s also no guarantee of when he will get a job, so you may indeed need to increase your hours or he takes an interim job until he’s back on form. UC is going to be a shock to the system for a family accustomed to £80k, and especially one with so many expenses they have no safety net. It will help to get creative very quickly.

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/01/2024 08:53

Charlie2121 · 23/01/2024 00:35

So in your opinion fraud is OK provided it is less fraud than some other people commit.

That’s a bold take.

Indeed.

Fraud is fraud. The above comment screams tory mindset. Point the finger at the plebs but turn a blind eye when the middle class do it.

Spacecowboys · 23/01/2024 08:52

Babyroobs · 23/01/2024 08:43

Uc does not have to be paid back. It's not like the old tax credit system which is calculated over the years earnings. For a family like this, UC will pay far more in benefits than JSA which is around £85 a week.

Thanks for clearing that up, I’m obviously thinking of the old system. I think ops options are either to agree to look for work (with more hours)or for dh to apply for job seekers allowance, even though it is less money.

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 23/01/2024 08:51

FFS
OP is not trying to get out of work
She IS working. And she is also looking after 2 younger children. Her husband is working hard to find another high earning position and by the sound of it, he will have one soon. Potentially even before all the UC stuff is sorted.

If she went full time then she'd invariably get criticised for leaving her kids in someone else's care all day.

They're a family who have hit a stumbling block. It happened to a LOT of people during Covid. Only at that time UC just paid out without the work expectations.

Essentially some of this comes off as jealous that she lives the way we should be able to - part time to be there for children whilst the other parent works to pay the bills. Like it used to be, only it should be acceptable to be either parent now

roarrfeckingroar · 23/01/2024 08:50

I see the OP's point. She has a job that works well for their family so giving it up for a FT job doesn't make much sense, providing the husband does get a FT job soon.

They've clearly paid in as a family, I can't begrudge them a bit of support for a few months. It should be savings, but I would rather support a family like this in a tough situation than the perennially unemployed.

roarrfeckingroar · 23/01/2024 08:46

Drosera · 23/01/2024 01:16

We should be angry at the people raking it in at the top not people taking such small amounts (UC is terribly low) at the bottom.

But these high earners are the ones whose taxes help facilitate UC.

Exactly. And why should we be angry at those "raking it in" if they pay taxes?

Babyroobs · 23/01/2024 08:43

Spacecowboys · 23/01/2024 08:42

Would it not be better for your dh to claim contribution based job seekers allowance? If you claim universal credit and then dh secures another job earning 60k , won’t you have to pay back all the universal credit? I believe it is based on tax year earnings, not on a month by month basis? I’d look into it a bit more.

Uc does not have to be paid back. It's not like the old tax credit system which is calculated over the years earnings. For a family like this, UC will pay far more in benefits than JSA which is around £85 a week.

Babyroobs · 23/01/2024 08:42

I think the key thing is here how confident you are that he will get something else paying 60/ 70k within a few months ?

Spacecowboys · 23/01/2024 08:42

Would it not be better for your dh to claim contribution based job seekers allowance? If you claim universal credit and then dh secures another job earning 60k , won’t you have to pay back all the universal credit? I believe it is based on tax year earnings, not on a month by month basis? I’d look into it a bit more.

Babyroobs · 23/01/2024 08:41

AreYouMeOrWhat · 23/01/2024 02:29

I'm no expert but why have you claimed UC rather than your husband claiming contributions-based ESA? That is 6m of payments so presumably meets your needs better.

It would be JSA he claimed as he is not ill. But I'm guessing they are claiming UC instead because they have kids and Uc will pay them a lot more than just Contributions based JSA for the husband.

SecondUsername4me · 23/01/2024 08:35

Surely a household income of 80k combined means you have some savings to help towards the main bills for a couple of months?

But generally, yes, if there are two adults in the home capable of working, then they should be working. Why is it unreasonable to say that now one adult will be at home full time, The other adult shouldnt step in and plug the gap in finances by working full time?

hanschristmassolo · 23/01/2024 08:35

Why doesn't he look after the 4 year old whilst you work additional hours surely that's the logical answer

Mariposistaaa · 23/01/2024 08:30

coxesorangepippin · 23/01/2024 02:18

But if op applies and gets a full time job she'll only be on 30k per year, as opposed to the 60/70k her DH could earn?

Plus they'd have to pay for more nursery days?

Sp they survive off her 30k until he gets a job - he looks after the kids. When he gets a job, her 30k plus his 60+k will be enough to cover the extra nursery days. Kids can be in nursery FT and both parents work FT.

SENwoes · 23/01/2024 02:57

I do understand your logic but I cannot stress enough how punitive the UC system is and I would strongly discourage you from ‘just being honest with them’ and telling them your plan. There is no leeway for bargaining with them. You either accept your work commitments or you don’t. I’m afraid if you want to get any money from them you will need to be seen to be looking for more work. If it means you end up stacking shelves for a fortnight then so be it.

setsailsam · 23/01/2024 02:43

YABU

the benefit system is there for those who need it most, not those who choose not to work. I hope you get sanctioned for not following your claimant commitments

AreYouMeOrWhat · 23/01/2024 02:29

I'm no expert but why have you claimed UC rather than your husband claiming contributions-based ESA? That is 6m of payments so presumably meets your needs better.

chaosmaker · 23/01/2024 02:27

This thread is exactly why there should only be about 3 'benefits' and everyone should get UBI. It's a complete no brainer especially as tech is being foisted on everyone - think AI - and many traditional jobs will disappear to it anyway.

coxesorangepippin · 23/01/2024 02:18

But if op applies and gets a full time job she'll only be on 30k per year, as opposed to the 60/70k her DH could earn?

Plus they'd have to pay for more nursery days?

catotangent · 23/01/2024 02:17

Charlie2121 · 23/01/2024 00:25

Everything that is wrong with this country is encapsulated on this thread.

The majority of posters suggesting the OP commits fraud and takes money they are not due from other tax payers.

No wonder the country is in a mess if that’s the prevailing view on matters.

Agreed. I'm sure some people would like to work only 15 hours a week and be topped up by universal credit payments but you can see why that's not fair surely.