Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to work more hours? (Universal Credit)

409 replies

Abneyandteal19 · 23/01/2024 00:00

Hi
Have never claimed benefits before except child benefit as we've always earns over threshold, situation now is....
3DC ages 4 (preschool) 6 and 8.

I work part time professional job management - but job share 15hrs PW. Income £14500

DH professional job in region of £60-65k has never been out of work until now. His contracts ended in Dec. Had a job lined up for Jan- company funding issues have meant they've delayed his start indefinitely. Of course he is desperately searching.

Done all calculations and looks like we are entitled to some UC, so filled in all forms. Have to agree to commitments, DH has to look for work log jobs applied for work coach etc...all fine no problem

But my commitments have come back with I must agree to look for more hours work. I am not sure I can do this... my job is job share split 40/60 so there are no more hours. I have my preschooler everyday I don't work.

Main point is we were just looking for a bit of help for a few months until DH starts and then gets paid for a new job. Chances are he will absolutely get one in next 3 months and then of course will will cease claiming anything and then me working part time will be totally fine again.

It's not that I don't want to work more just not that easy to find something for a few hours a week that will pay more than childcare will cost? Any thoughts/experience? So AIBU not to want to work more hours?

OP posts:
justasking111 · 23/01/2024 12:06

Friends and I took on evening work. ASDA deliveries, bar work, shelf stacking at times because of young children. Working nights won't interfere with @Abneyandteal19 job hunting in fact as an employer would have impressed me.

Abney is getting a hard time if her husband sees this as a sabbatical bar sending off résumés.

Hankunamatata · 23/01/2024 11:55

You want the benefits you jump through the hoops.
They don't know dh is definitely getting a job. If you need more hours pick up some weekend work or evening work via agency.
When we were in this position (though dh didn't earn anywhere near 60k) We had to make ends meet. Dh started doing takeaway delivery as then he was free during the day for interviews and I went and did bar work on a weekend (having never worked bar in my life)

historiccastles · 23/01/2024 11:50

@Abneyandteal19 I'm an academic who has done a lot of work on the welfare system and I have on occasion been a UC claimant.

There is a misconception that the welfare state is about paying in and therefore being entitled to a bit of help when you need it. It isn't. It hasn't been since the number of people it needs to support began massively exceeding the number of people paying in. So the amount you've paid in taxes/NI historically and how long you plan to be on it is not relevant to how they'll calculate your entitlement or what they will expect of you.

UC is not really designed to be a short term gap fill. It takes time to get your first payment, though you can get an advance. If you can manage any other way, then I would try to manage that way.

If you can't manage any other way then you need to play ball and apply for jobs. When I was on UC in between jobs, my job coach was pretty light touch. She wasn't concerned that I'd have any difficulty finding a job and as long as I was logging a few applications every day, she left me alone. But if you find and are offered more hours, you will be expected to take it and your husband will have to take on the childcare.

shepherdsangeldelight · 23/01/2024 11:49

WithACatLikeTread · 23/01/2024 11:33

They can't be that flexible if they have children to pick up etc. Plus they might say this job is 16 hours but give you seven or none. I don't really get this "I had it difficult so therefore you should have the same problems" attitude. It takes time also to find these jobs. UC can help them feed the children in the meanwhile.

They currently have 2 parents available to pick children up etc.
So, yes, they can be very flexible until the point where one of them actually starts a new job.

Obviously this is area dependent but retail/hospitality round here are taking people in within a couple of weeks of applying. They are also taking on people who can't be fully flexible e.g. students around study commitments. Plus OP's story (she works part time in her main job but wants some extra hours) is totally plausible and doesn't scream that she will leave straight away.

The main thing is that neither OP or her DH is actually even looking for this type of job, so they have no idea how easy or not it would be to get one.

Oliotya · 23/01/2024 11:44

WithACatLikeTread · 23/01/2024 11:33

They can't be that flexible if they have children to pick up etc. Plus they might say this job is 16 hours but give you seven or none. I don't really get this "I had it difficult so therefore you should have the same problems" attitude. It takes time also to find these jobs. UC can help them feed the children in the meanwhile.

150 hours a week spare, of course they can find flexible work between them. You can't opt out of working altogether because it's not a 9-5 paying what you want. Even if he only gets 7 hours a week, that's 7 more than none.

Hmmmmaybe · 23/01/2024 11:41

@TweetypiePez they haven’t “fallen in hard times” - her husband took a risk for a contract position - that would
have paid more - and the entirely foreseeable outcome od that risk has happened.

that is a shame for the op personally. It is not what the welfare state is set up to support.

I could earn more as a contractor but I have a less paid position because it’s permanent.

zendeveloper · 23/01/2024 11:37

Abneyandteal19 · 23/01/2024 11:07

I think it may have been misleading to say contractor.
End of 2022 DH took a job which was 12 months with possibility to extend. This was billed as a longer probation period and what they offer all new starters to see how things go, all the way through he passed all assessment got good appraisals etc and they intimated the contract would be extended/made permanent. Then with a month to go they pulled the plug and said it wasn't financially viable to keep him on.

To me this is very different to a 'contractor' working a few months here and a few months there.

I am now talking about him looking for contract jobs as they are more likely to come up quickly and want an immediate start etc. so he will be earning money quicker whilst continuing to look for permanent. And also seeing if his job offer he had in Jan comes through.

To say why we had kids in this 'precarious' position. Nothing about our position was precarious. When we had kids I was teaching and DH was civil service. He then took a leap to try to further his career which ultimately did work for a year and then it didnt...

Thanks for all your constructive advice. I'll leave it there for now.

OP, this is a contractor position, many contractors would work for years for the same client - not necessarily a few months here and there. And it all sounds quite mad to me that a contractor with a contract that was not extended wants to claim welfare in between contracts.

I had several contracts that fell through like that, sometimes at the last moment - you turn up at the office on your first day, but the manager has changed and the new one doesn't want you anymore - that's it, home you go. Had a few contracts that were terminated with 24h notice as the project no longer was needed. Had quite a few invoices that were eventually never paid so the last month was working for free. This is the risk you're taking for a higher reward.

If your DH earns 65K as a contractor, a permanent equivalent would be 35-40K, right?

TweetypiePez · 23/01/2024 11:37

Hi OP

Some people are utterly deluded. They cannot fathom that any of us could fall on hard times. Life is not fair and some of us have far more difficulties than others, through not fault of our own.

Sadly, the post-war consensus of a safety net has been eroded at an alarming rate and state support is now almost wholly punitive. This is partly down to the government and media waging a war on anyone who needs state support. However, state support hasn’t been at sustenance levels for decades. It is not a life style choice unless you want to starve to death. The general public have been duped into thinking people on benefits are living a great life and receiving easy money. This is categorically untrue.

The government would much prefer you take a minimum wage job regardless of whether or not it limits your DH’s ability to look for a far better paid job. This short-sightedness is plain to see across government and policy. Our government doesn’t do long-term. Some of the rules around UC are utterly nonsensical and make life harder for claimants to better themselves in the medium to longer-term. But no one cares because anyone needing state support has been incorrectly labelled ‘a scrounger’. As I am sure you’ll now appreciate, that simply isn’t the case.

I would accept your commitments for now and do whatever is asked of you. It takes 5 weeks to set up UC and receive your first payment anyway. If your husband can find work in the next 3 months I think you’ll be fine. If he is still struggling after 3 months then you can reassess your options. Good luck.

jessycake · 23/01/2024 11:34

Just go throught the motions , there are plenty of politicions , their mates , Academys , companies , utilities fleecing the system . They often get a knighthood . Keep the job that works for you for a few months then review.

WithACatLikeTread · 23/01/2024 11:33

Oliotya · 23/01/2024 11:24

It is that easy, especially with only 15 hours a week accounted for between two of them, they can be flexible. Might not be the sort of work he'd like, but it's there.

They can't be that flexible if they have children to pick up etc. Plus they might say this job is 16 hours but give you seven or none. I don't really get this "I had it difficult so therefore you should have the same problems" attitude. It takes time also to find these jobs. UC can help them feed the children in the meanwhile.

BarbieDangerous · 23/01/2024 11:31

I’m confused. Instead of getting an extra PT job, why doesn’t your husband get a PT job alongisde applying for roles that fit in with his career? Would that not make more sense?

OCDmama · 23/01/2024 11:26

@LegoDeathTrap

Aye but we're not talking about othe people's situation are we?

We're talking about this one and what's best for this family.

AnneValentine · 23/01/2024 11:26

Abneyandteal19 · 23/01/2024 00:42

Hi all and thanks for replying,
@ButWhatAboutTheBees thank you for getting what I am saying...just need help for a couple of months to get back on our feet and in my mind that is exactly what benefits were designed for. I would say we would be on this for a max of 4 months potentially out of our whole working lives.
I've worked for 18years 12 of which were full time and Dh has worked for 20years entirely full time.

I accept I could get a zero hours job in retail etc but surely by the time I'd applied interviewed, onboarded, completed training etc it would be pointless and a waste of everyone's time?
Of course if for some reason DH was still unsuccessful in a few months I'd rethink but in that event it would be much better for me to look for a FT job in my field which would pay so much better!

No @YireosDodeAver my husband is not useless at all he couldn't have predicted what happened and is trying really hard. If he had to look after our 4 year old while I did extra work at the moment he would miss out on job hunting time. Eg today a recruiter called him at 11 to set up a call with a company at 12:30- so if I was doing a 4hr retail shift he would have had to turn this down which seems madness!

I absolutely do not want to fleece the system I just can't get why benefits are not a stop gap for a bad situation- I thought that's exactly what they were for?! I think I'll just be honest with them if they call and go from there.

The idea is you should both be looking. If he gets a job great but if you not you should be working as he can do childcare.

OCDmama · 23/01/2024 11:25

@Redruby2020 that's not the case here though is it? What's the point in bringing that scenario up? How about looking at this specific situation? Why should OP disadvantage herself because of other people's problems?

I say this as someone who grew up with a single mum. It was really hard but she didn't sit their wishing the hard stuff on everyone else just because things were difficult for us.

Oliotya · 23/01/2024 11:24

WithACatLikeTread · 23/01/2024 11:17

People talking about getting jobs as if it is that easy. It really isn't at the moment.

It is that easy, especially with only 15 hours a week accounted for between two of them, they can be flexible. Might not be the sort of work he'd like, but it's there.

LegoDeathTrap · 23/01/2024 11:21

ShitChristamasPresents · 23/01/2024 10:24

And for those posters saying “you’re only part time, get more hours” etc. Three children is a lot of work and no, the OP isn’t doing more than 15 hours paid work but I bet she’s not sitting around painting her nails and flicking through Netflix. Good grief. This race to the bottom is insane.

It’s ok to ask for help temporarily. It’s not in the childrens best interests to suddenly have to do pre/school, childminder, after school clubs etc just for a month or two. Some children would be ok. Lots at that age really need a parent to be with them before and after school. The OP isn’t suggesting a new lifestyle choice based on UC. She’d be in trouble if she was - especially with a mortgage to pay.

Also, for all those “how do you not have more savings!” posters - have some grace here. Covid was tough. £80k sounds like a lot until you have three children, a mortgage and all the everyday costs of living. Again, it’s not a race to the bottom.

OP, I agree that CAB might be a helpful place to call. And if it is just an extra hour work you need, that should be pretty easy to get?

Hope your husband finds a new job really soon.

Many of us have children in addition to a job, and without a husband sitting at home, without the £60K salary for the past few years, and without state help. So please.

WithACatLikeTread · 23/01/2024 11:17

People talking about getting jobs as if it is that easy. It really isn't at the moment.

Oliotya · 23/01/2024 11:14

So he's not worked for nearly 2 months now? Sorry but 15 hours a week between 2 of you isn't enough. Universal credit should be a safety net for when people can't work, not for when they'd rather not. It's nonsense that he needs to be available 24/7 for recruitment, most people aren't unemployed when finding a new job. Between the two of you, you can absolutely manage to work more hours. Why couldn't he work evenings and weekends for example?

Hmmmmaybe · 23/01/2024 11:12

12 months is clearly a contract position and involved risks

he took a risk - fair play - but it’s beyond entitled to expect the welfare state to cushion you from that risk.

but even beyond that - your position is that you think the welfare state should subsidize your husband not working so he can interview for high paying jobs.

Abneyandteal19 · 23/01/2024 11:07

I think it may have been misleading to say contractor.
End of 2022 DH took a job which was 12 months with possibility to extend. This was billed as a longer probation period and what they offer all new starters to see how things go, all the way through he passed all assessment got good appraisals etc and they intimated the contract would be extended/made permanent. Then with a month to go they pulled the plug and said it wasn't financially viable to keep him on.

To me this is very different to a 'contractor' working a few months here and a few months there.

I am now talking about him looking for contract jobs as they are more likely to come up quickly and want an immediate start etc. so he will be earning money quicker whilst continuing to look for permanent. And also seeing if his job offer he had in Jan comes through.

To say why we had kids in this 'precarious' position. Nothing about our position was precarious. When we had kids I was teaching and DH was civil service. He then took a leap to try to further his career which ultimately did work for a year and then it didnt...

Thanks for all your constructive advice. I'll leave it there for now.

OP posts:
NonPlayerCharacter · 23/01/2024 11:04

OP, if your job is so flexible, surely you could take the kids for half a day or so if your husband gets a last minute call or interview, and work your hours around it? Even if it does mean parking them in front of the TV for a bit, as a one off that won't do any harm.

Bromptotoo · 23/01/2024 11:03

lookwhatyoudidthere · 23/01/2024 10:57

Why on earth would anyone choose to have three children in such precarious circumstances. We stuck with one because of childcare costs (after our first we were aware these were the same as a mortgage payment). People are constantly beefing about immigrants being on benefits, it’s not them you’ve got to worry about, it’s the entitled attitude of modern parents.

What on earth are you on about?

The OP's DH was in well paid work continuously until December. The rug was pulled from under him with further work. OP works around her kids - as one does.

This family are a classic example of where the 2 child rule punishes and impoverishes people who never intended to be in this situation. As advisers you see this regularly whether through this sort of misfortune, sudden disabling illness or where the bloke has scarpered with another woman.

Hyacinth1000 · 23/01/2024 11:02

From reading the thread I think these are the best suggestions. Obviously the OP can’t give up the job she has as its ideal for the long term.

  1. apply for a mortgage payment holiday, it’s exactly what they are designed for.

  2. check with work to see if they have any extra hours available temporarily

  3. look for an extra job on evenings or weekends, one that you could keep for a few months after your DH returns to work to recoup any savings you use during this period. This would negate your feelings about only doing a job a short while.

whatkatydid2014 · 23/01/2024 11:02

Why on earth is the answer of majority of posters here that a professional worker that would be on £45k full time should go and look for bar work or shop work on minimum wage as their first stop to fill a gap in family finances?

OP were I in your shoes I’d start by looking for roles in my industry on similar FT salaries that were FT or 50% plus and apply to them. If you are right and OH gets a job soon then you can stop looking. If not you’ve hopefully lined up something that will get you back to far closer your original family earnings and OH can look for a part time role (or if all kids are in school and you can make it work he could look for a full time one). It isn’t a requirement that you apply for every job in existence to claim universal credit (particularly when you’ve just started claiming and you already earn equivalent of something like 24 or 25 hours a week on minimum wage).

Schleep · 23/01/2024 11:02

Can someone please explain why two perfectly able bodied adults, one of whom is not working at all and the other is working just 15 hours a week, shouldn't find temporary part time work to supplement their household income?