Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy sensible house, not dream house?

32 replies

Breadcakes · 22/01/2024 23:38

Looking to buy our first home and can't get my head around what's realistic/normal mortgage-wise. All the houses that would be ideal for us seem to be around £600-650k.

We have a £150k deposit. We could borrow a max of £480k and just about afford the monthly repayments. But that seems a ludicrously big mortgage?

Our options locally seem to be:

  1. Buy a small 2 bedroom house for around £450k that's not much bigger than the flat we're living in now, but has outdoor space which I'm desperate for, and an easily affordable mortgage. Keep saving for a few years and hope to afford bigger/forever/dream home eventually.

  2. Buy a bigger, 3 bedroom £600k+ home with more living space that fits our needs. A long-term home, potentially a family home. Max our borrowing and get what we need now. Drawback is higher monthly payments and less money to save.

A problem as old as time, but any advice welcome!

OP posts:
SD1978 · 23/01/2024 02:31

I'd go affordable and be able to maintain social interests. Potentially looking at houses with an opportunity to expand if children do become something you want. I would hate to have a house and never be able to set foot out of it as I couldn't afford to!

BoxOfCats · 23/01/2024 02:20

I went for the "affordable" option rather than dream home. Thank god I did, because 5 years later the interest rates skyrocketed, I had to change jobs due to redundancy, and then DP announced one day out of the blue that he was leaving me for another woman.

Luckily I was able to buy him out and keep the house, and I was very thankful I hadn't let my ex partner talk me into buying at the top of our budget.

UsualChaos · 23/01/2024 00:28

Breadcakes · 23/01/2024 00:19

Thanks, yeah I'm worried about more steep price hikes mainly. We have a few hobbies eg. gym, tennis club, cycling, that we'd each like to be able to afford to continue with.

I can't see me or DP's salaries increasing significantly at all in the future. We both have public sector careers and may get small yearly raises in line with inflation. We're undecided about kids at the moment, but would like to keep that door open.

Could you extend the house if you decided to have children? We built an extra bedroom and our neighbours did a loft conversion on their similar house.

Breadcakes · 23/01/2024 00:19

Thanks, yeah I'm worried about more steep price hikes mainly. We have a few hobbies eg. gym, tennis club, cycling, that we'd each like to be able to afford to continue with.

I can't see me or DP's salaries increasing significantly at all in the future. We both have public sector careers and may get small yearly raises in line with inflation. We're undecided about kids at the moment, but would like to keep that door open.

OP posts:
UsualChaos · 23/01/2024 00:03

We made a decent chunk of money selling our first house and relocated to the country where we could have used that chunk as a depsit and got a far bigger house. But it would have meant a big commitment, mortgage-wise. In the end we went sensible, and I did feel a bit wistful initially, but as the years have gone by I'm so glad we went for that option. It's meant more flexibility in so many ways, and now with the cost of everything being what it is, I'm doubly relieved.

Ponoka7 · 22/01/2024 23:59

I wouldn't buy the cheaper one with a view to moving again. You'll never be happy in it. I'd only go for the two bed if it was to guarantee still affording a certain lifestyle. You've got to see the positives in were you live, not hopefully being able to move. Could you afford children and the second house?

ACynicalDad · 22/01/2024 23:54

If you think your salaries will go up in the next few years and you can just afford it now I would buy the biggest you can afford. Moving is money down the drain, we stretched for what we have, but haven't had to move and it's now very comfortable. If, however, you think your salaries are near their limit and the chances of kids appearing in the next few years are low, then I'd be more inclined not to stretch yourself.