Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy sensible house, not dream house?

32 replies

Breadcakes · 22/01/2024 23:38

Looking to buy our first home and can't get my head around what's realistic/normal mortgage-wise. All the houses that would be ideal for us seem to be around £600-650k.

We have a £150k deposit. We could borrow a max of £480k and just about afford the monthly repayments. But that seems a ludicrously big mortgage?

Our options locally seem to be:

  1. Buy a small 2 bedroom house for around £450k that's not much bigger than the flat we're living in now, but has outdoor space which I'm desperate for, and an easily affordable mortgage. Keep saving for a few years and hope to afford bigger/forever/dream home eventually.

  2. Buy a bigger, 3 bedroom £600k+ home with more living space that fits our needs. A long-term home, potentially a family home. Max our borrowing and get what we need now. Drawback is higher monthly payments and less money to save.

A problem as old as time, but any advice welcome!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hoolahoophop · 23/01/2024 13:38

A couple of PP say small house, big life. But it depends on the life you want. A friend just spent every penny she has on a smallholding, with a big, big house. She will be paying it off for ever!

Her big life is growing her own veg, using logs from her wood to feed the fire, keeping chickens and having friends round for home cooked dinners. Not big holiday's, expensive hobbies or even eating out.

If you and DH are homebodies get the house, if you like to live outside of the home, get a smaller mortgage.

Devilshands · 23/01/2024 13:24

Can't see me or DP's salaries increasing significantly at all in the future. We both have public sector careers and may get small yearly raises in line with inflation.

In which case I'd get the affordable house. If mortgage rate sky rocket again and your salary doesn't increase much you're going to be buggered if you're already stretching yourself. No one needs that stress in their lives

purplecorkheart · 23/01/2024 13:03

Are you planning to buy new build for the bigger house or second-hand? Just remember that some second hand houses take lots of work etc. Can you absorb these costs if you go with a big mortgage for the bigger house.

Personally in the situation you describe I would go with the two bed option but one with the possibility to do an attic conversion.

Makeitmakesensetoday · 23/01/2024 12:53

BoxOfCats · 23/01/2024 02:20

I went for the "affordable" option rather than dream home. Thank god I did, because 5 years later the interest rates skyrocketed, I had to change jobs due to redundancy, and then DP announced one day out of the blue that he was leaving me for another woman.

Luckily I was able to buy him out and keep the house, and I was very thankful I hadn't let my ex partner talk me into buying at the top of our budget.

This

But I'd find a compromise, your current dilemma seems very all or nothing.

GreatGateauxsby · 23/01/2024 12:51

Personally I’d def go for no 2 IF salaries were going up

I can't see me or DP's salaries increasing significantly at all in the future. We both have public sector careers and may get small yearly raises in line with inflation. We're undecided about kids at the moment, but would like to keep that door open.

but given the situation I’d look for a poorer condition 3 bed if you could so improve as and when
or an unusual 2 bed that could be extended later on…

Nosleepforthismum · 23/01/2024 11:37

In your position, I’d go for a cheaper house that needed improvement. Put down £100k deposit, retain 50k for renovations. Sell house for a profit and buy £600k dream house with a lower and more affordable mortgage.

GasPanic · 23/01/2024 10:59

Suppose it depends what type of 2 bed.

I doubt whether you are going to get much outdoor space in your average new(ish) build 2 bed.

Postage stamp size bit of turf and enough concrete slabs to plonk a barbecue on is standard.

gardenfoundry · 23/01/2024 10:55

I'd go for the bigger home. Sod paying more in stamp duty when you move a second time!

Is an extension available for the cheaper house?

mynewusername2023 · 23/01/2024 10:52

We bought our house based on one income but it was 23 years ago. We're still in the same house (mortgage paid off) with no plans to move until retirement.

I'd go for a cheaper house that you could extend. That way you'll be able to enjoy your life and have some more security if something happens to one of your jobs. Also if you do decide to have children, could you afford the bigger house on one wage while on maternity leave?

Sunnydays0101 · 23/01/2024 10:40

I definitely wouldn’t over stretch yourselves. Are you hoping to have children in the future ? If so, you need to factor in maternity leaves, childcare costs, extra person in the house costs, etc.

Is there no in-between houses - a three bed maybe ?

If buying the bigger house means an end to your hobbies. Etc, do not do it.

SD25 · 23/01/2024 10:38

A mortgage that size is perfectly normal for people buying houses in that sort of price range and above. If you're not overly stretching yourself, and are happy doing whatever you need to do to pay the bills for the foreseeable, then go for the bigger house. Moving is expensive and circumstances change - it's easily possible that something happens that gets in the way of you doing that move further down the line and then you will be stuck where you are.

UsualChaos · 23/01/2024 10:36

FarmGirl78 · 23/01/2024 10:23

Mid way through a successful high-flying job I hit depression and moved back to my hometown to be nearer friends and family. I took an £13k pay cut and I chose happiness over status and wealth.

I bought a 2 bed terraced. My parents were horrified I was living in such a lowly house and offered me a cash gift/bribe to buy a house on a well respected estate in town instead. I turned it down, and explained I could actually have afforded a 4 bed detached on their even more prestigious new build estate.

I'm very happy in wonky old terraced. Its cute, its cosy, my heating bills are still only about £70 a month, and I've managed to significantly over pay my mortgage. I now have more in savings than I'd need to pay it off. I've cut my hours to 4 days at week and I'm looking at maybe cut to 3 days. I still earn less than national average.

IMO why on earth would you spend money that you can choose to do other lovely things with, to buy a house that you don't actually need?? Just because it's society's idea of "ideal". Nope. Ideal to me is being able to enjoy the whole of my life, not just the retirement bit. Live is for living, don't waste it working and paying bills if you don't need to.

💯
Small house, big life.
I made a similar choice, despite having the sort of job that you'd associate with a far fancier house. No regrets.

Saz12 · 23/01/2024 10:34

Dont buy with a view to moving "soon" if you dont have to. Moving costs, time etc is costly. HOWEVER being overextended is a nightmare - if you wanted children, could you afford the mortgage in the bigger house? Which hobbies would you have to drop? Could you tighten your spending up without too much misery? What about unexpected bills, illness, etc?

FarmGirl78 · 23/01/2024 10:23

Mid way through a successful high-flying job I hit depression and moved back to my hometown to be nearer friends and family. I took an £13k pay cut and I chose happiness over status and wealth.

I bought a 2 bed terraced. My parents were horrified I was living in such a lowly house and offered me a cash gift/bribe to buy a house on a well respected estate in town instead. I turned it down, and explained I could actually have afforded a 4 bed detached on their even more prestigious new build estate.

I'm very happy in wonky old terraced. Its cute, its cosy, my heating bills are still only about £70 a month, and I've managed to significantly over pay my mortgage. I now have more in savings than I'd need to pay it off. I've cut my hours to 4 days at week and I'm looking at maybe cut to 3 days. I still earn less than national average.

IMO why on earth would you spend money that you can choose to do other lovely things with, to buy a house that you don't actually need?? Just because it's society's idea of "ideal". Nope. Ideal to me is being able to enjoy the whole of my life, not just the retirement bit. Live is for living, don't waste it working and paying bills if you don't need to.

IamRoyFuckingKent · 23/01/2024 08:35

I'd buy the bigger one. We did and don't regret it, 15 years later.

Tatumm · 23/01/2024 08:34

A cheaper house with scope to extend outwards and or into the loft is probably what I would go for.

Roselilly36 · 23/01/2024 08:34

We went for the dream house, it was a stretch, but so worth it, we lived there for 18years, and downsized a couple of years ago. Moving is very costly and stressful, avoid moving if you can. we don’t have any regrets.

NewYearResolutions · 23/01/2024 08:34

I will go for the bigger one. It cost a lot to move house. Don't see it as your forever home. You might move up again.

shivawn · 23/01/2024 08:31

We had a similar deposit and got a 465k mortgage for our dream house, 6 bedrooms, a long tree lined drive hiding it from the road and massive gardens. We've only just bought and I'm still in awe that it's ours. We had previously bought a small house for 145k and lived there for 7 years but it became far too small once we had children, I don't regret starting with the smaller house because it gave us loads of financial freedom to travel and socialise when we were younger and even if we decided to go big and max out our budget we never could have afforded anything like our current house back then.

Holy moly though, 600k+ for a 3 bed would be hard to swallow. I guess you're in a very expensive area.

UnimaginableWindBird · 23/01/2024 08:22

Can you buy a cheaper house with the potential to extend it into something bigger? We bought a cheap two bedroom end terrace with a garden and got a two storey extension which has given us three double bedrooms and a generous kitchen/diner which is something we could absolutely not have afforded in our area without having done it ourselves.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 23/01/2024 08:14

I’d buy the biggest and best house you can get now. Moving is so costly and such a bloody faff, I’d hate to move knowing by I’d need to move again soon. I’ve got a huge mortgage, that went up loads. But I’ve also got a gorgeous house , big enough for everyone, near to school and work etc. so it’s totally worth it.

Passingthethyme · 23/01/2024 08:11

Whatever you do, don't overextend yourself. Get the biggest house buy only if you can still afford it if interstate rates go up, someone is out of work for a few months etc. It's not worth the stress

ConsuelaHammock · 23/01/2024 08:09

Don’t overstretch yourself for a mortgage! Buy a house you can comfortably afford.

Bangbangchittychitty · 23/01/2024 03:05

If you are a young couple go for the bigger house

FrozenGhost · 23/01/2024 02:55

I went for the sensible and I somewhat regret it. A few years later we can easily afford the repayments. And while it's nice to have extra money, we don't really need it and aren't really using it for anything important. Prices have gone up so the dream house seems like it was a bargain back then. We would have a lot more wealth as a family if we owned the other place.