Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Judgy comments about C-section

105 replies

heyduggee12345 · 22/01/2024 20:06

Did anybody else experience judgemental comments from friends/family when they told them that you'd opted for a c section?

I had many complications with my first birth which was to be quite honest traumatic and ended up in an EMCS. I guess I could try for a VBAC but I'm terrified it will end in another emergency.

I don't think I am being unreasonable for wanting/hoping for a more calm experience this time. But family & friends have been so judgy when I've mentioned.

It's making me question my decision and I'm having to justify myself everytime when people are asking the reasons why. Even the midwife told me today the consultant will likely try to push me for a VBAC.

Why is this?

OP posts:
HalebiHabibti · 22/01/2024 22:32

Queen Elizabeth II was born by c-section. This is my favourite c-section-related fact :)

My mum said her c-section was the best out of her 3 births as it was nice and calm. Do what works for you OP 💐

AuntPru · 22/01/2024 22:32

Oh and if, God forbid, anyone starts with the women have been doing it thousands of years, it's natural crap, then I'd just gently point out that infant mortality being sky high is also natural, so meh.

AuntPru · 22/01/2024 22:28

Oh god. People really do seem to forget that pregnant women are actually capable of independent thought! I'd be fucking furious if anyone felt they needed to check if I was doing what was best for my baby!

FWIW I had two medically indicated ELCS. It was not what I wanted but my big headed buggers didn't realise they were supposed to get head down. The experience itself was lovely, both times. Beyond weird to walk into a room pregnant and not even labouring and then out with a baby. The only judgement I've ever had has been online, where women (aaaaaalways women🤦🏼‍♀️) felt the need to point out that vaginal breech delivery is an option. Yeah I know, but not with a big baby with an insanely big head, footling breech and head extended backwards. Oh, hmm, maybe you do know your own situation best after all.

maisiedaisy64 · 22/01/2024 22:27

@DewinDwl that is an excellent response.

I’m due my 2nd in May, and definitely leaning towards a planned CS after an EMCS and sepsis for me and DD1. I’m
not telling anyone just yet, bar one supportive group of friends.

A lot of people seem to have experienced the judgement and I am definitely expecting that from one side of the family. Does anyone have any good statements to shut them down? My body my choice probably won’t cut it with some
of them!!

TigerJoy · 22/01/2024 22:18

Holy crap, I'm sorry.

I'm pregnant - and disabled - and both my sister (vaginal births) and SIL (C sections) both said "I hope you'll be having a C section" or words to that effect....

Ignore the deeply unhelpful people making judgey comments.

Don't bring it up from now on, and if people ask, just say "i'll follow the advice of the consultant" and change the subject.

BiscuitLover3678 · 22/01/2024 22:17

Mine were the opposite and surprised I’d go for a vbac. Midwives all trying very hard not to give me opinions either way (which was good although meant I went back and forth a lot).

AdoraBell · 22/01/2024 22:17

Just ask the friends and family why they want you risk to repeat the trauma, and why do they want to control your choices? With the medical staff keep pushing for the C-section if that’s what you want.

StaunchMomma · 22/01/2024 22:14

Those asking/judging won't have been through a traumatic birth or it's aftermath, will they?

I'd be reminding them of that.

BorisIsACuntWaffle · 22/01/2024 22:06

I think it does depend where you are.
1x emcs and then no mention of a choice for second just assumed that I'd have a vbac.

My friend in same situation but next town and a different trust was booked for a planed Cs for her second.

CuttingMeOpenthenHealingMeFine · 22/01/2024 22:03

I’ve had two elective c-sections. People can be total arseholes about it which I just don’t get as it’s not like it affects them in any way, shape or form. I’ve had two healthy babies and never felt a contraction and I am fine with that. Just ignore them OP.

crumpet · 22/01/2024 21:54

Fuck’em. Although it would be wiser not to talk about it too much prior to the event. The world and his wife always has a view. Keep your own counsel and do what is best for you and your baby.

Gowlett · 22/01/2024 21:53

Literally nobody has ever mentioned my C-Section.
Except DH when he urged me to “keep up” while out walking the baby a few weeks after birth. Fucking prick.

Whoknowsohyoudo · 22/01/2024 21:50

I had the opposite problem. I wanted a vbac but was told my hospital didn't perform them because they were not equipped to deal with the dangers of uterine rupture etc, so was automatically scheduled for another csection. First csection was easy, second was a nightmare, but I made it through them with two healthy children. Don't listen to anyone but yourself. I absolutely didn't want another csection but the idea of my baby possibly dying because of vbac complications settled that debate quickly. The nurses told me stories of women showing up with "the poor child half hanging out" because they refused the recommended csection, and waited until it was too late to do anything but deliver vaginally before going to the hospital. Quite selfish and dangerous IMO

ThreePointOneFourOneFiveNine · 22/01/2024 21:25

I've had two elective caesareans due to my own disability. In the anti-natal classes for my first, after an in depth description of labour, the midwife asked us all in turn to say how we felt about it. Most were saying things like nervous, I said "glad I'm not doing it", which earned me a horrified look from the midwife 😂

It's none of anyone else's business, and it is perfectly acceptable to tell them so. It's extremely rude of people to be giving their opinions, so don't feel you have to be polite in replying.

ProperOuting · 22/01/2024 21:25

How weird to hear midwives are trying to talking firstime ECS mother's into vaginal births. For my second birth, it became very clear that they were far more keen to opt for a managed c section than a natural birth, and even though I gave birth vaginally with my first they were keen to illuminate all risk before they agreed I could try for one again (I was low risk anyway, but induced with first so not sure if that's why).

I mean, everyone's experiences are different but the only planned c section mum I've talked to in depth really rated it over her first natural birth.

I must admit I did a lot of birth story swapping in the first two years after my first. I was carrying around a lot of trauma. I had a natural birth but 48 hours of induced labour that could very easily have ended in emergency c section though so was always mindful that it's definitely 'a real birth'. I may have expressed some sympathy at having to have a c section after drawn out labours but I hope no one is offended by that because I just thought they'd then have surgery recovery on top of everything else. Glad to see some people say their recovery was quick and easy.

I'm really hoping the same goes for you and it's a calm, well managed birth.

Superfrog3 · 22/01/2024 21:18

Whatever you chose will never be right for others. Do what is right for you and your baby.

I had an emcs with my 1st, traumatic and horrific.

2nd chose vbac got told I was an idiot, why are you doing that, it will never work, you always fail at giving birth. It ended up in a failed induction csection, then I got told you so, too posh to push, you just can't do it.

3rd baby elective csection and I got aren't you worried about the risks, your body just can't do birth/ handle birth and everyone telling me how they just did 2 pushes and out because to some people motherhood just comes naturally 🙄

I got annoyed told them they had baggy fanny's and that's why their kids fell out... Convo ended 😂

Thefaceofboe · 22/01/2024 21:16

I feel you. My MIL was very judgey about my c-section even though I had complete placenta praevia and couldn’t give birth vaginally even if I wanted to. She wanted me to ask for a second and third opinion as a vaginal birth is the only way women should want to give birth. Pregnant again and will be having a c-section this time round but will be keeping it to myself.

HillyHoney · 22/01/2024 21:16

I am honestly astonished that anyone would comment on it to you 😳

I had a crash section and then an elective a few years later, and I would have been deeply unimpressed at anyone who'd made any kind of negative comment about it, whether family, friend or random person in a cafe. For the life of me I don't know why people can't keep their opinions to themselves!

Glittering1 · 22/01/2024 21:12

Yes I've had comments. My sister said to my mother " oh I would give birth for Glittering1 as she's so soft and I dont think she will handle labour". Upon hearing I had an emcs she said "oh thank god she had a section, she wouldn't have been able for a normal delivery ". My DD was 10lbs 14oz.

My SIL also loved to boast about all her "natural" births.

My mother couldn't understand why I couldn't walk up three flights of stairs in my apartment after birth of my DD. Apparently the stitches she got after her vaginal birth were far worse than my major surgery.

Lots of other stupid comments that basically translated that c sections were easy and not a proper way to give birth.

EarlGreywithLemon · 22/01/2024 21:11

I’d add - I think I’m right that the NICE guidelines have changed recently to make it easier to have an ELCS - essentially you are entitled to one if you want one, and if a consultant says no, you can request another who will do it. But others who have looked into it recently will no doubt come along and give more accurate information.

Yonjovi · 22/01/2024 21:11

Oh god sorry OP that you're experiencing this. I had similar comments with my pregnancy during covid lockdown. I had a rare complication which meant that had I opted for a vaginal birth I would have been induced early, unable to have an epidural because of low blood platelets, higher risk of haemorrhaging, and they would not be able to use forceps or suction to get the baby out just incase he'd inherited my condition and the use of such implements could cause the baby to have internal bleeding. Oh and I would be alone during the early stages of labour because of lock down/covid rules. Some friends, my in laws and the consultant made alot of judgemental comments about me choosing to have an elective c section and in the end I completely disengaged with them - it made my pregnancy a lonely experience. There was a lot of "you can do it if you try, you'll be fine", and a total lack of understanding about my choice, which had seemed the obvious choice to me, but it made me doubt myself. I stuck to my guns, had the c sec, it was a really positive experience. I felt like I'd lost control in my pregnancy with the unexpected diagnosis of a rare medical condition & the c sec gave me some control back. Ultimately it was the right decision, despite being told it was very rare for my baby to inherit my condition (very low blood platelets), he did which meant he spent a few days in neo natal care with an emergency blood transfusion, with some follow up ultrasounds on his brain to check for bleeding - thankfully all OK now - he's a very healthy little boy. Had I listened to others, my sons outcome may not have been so positive and put us both at more risk.
Trust your gut. You don't need to justify your choice to anyone else. Disengage with them if you need to. You are the best person to advocate what's best for your baby. Do what you want. You've got this!

Parkerpenny · 22/01/2024 21:09

Planned section due to placenta previa. It was a positive experience and I hardly remember the recovery. My foo foo remained intact while my mummy pals sat on rubber rings. I was so sad at first to learn I couldn't give birth 'naturally' but it was a good experience. Over a decade ago now.

EarlGreywithLemon · 22/01/2024 21:07

I had an elective after a difficult vaginal birth - failed ventouse, forceps, third degree tear, episiotomy, lost 2.9 litres of blood (suspected start of placental abruption). There was probably some nerve damage and bruising as well which meant my bladder didn’t “wake up” so I left hospital with a catheter, leg bag and no one could tell me if it would recover (it did). My pelvic floor was so wrecked that my back just gave in and I spent three months doing physio to get better.

The ELCS was great. Yes, it hurt afterwards, but the recovery was smooth and a lot, lot quicker than from the vaginal birth. I hardly remember that I had one now.

All consultants and midwives I saw were supportive of an elective. (I was seen by several consultants because of another, unrelated minor health issue that they kept under observation). Only one registrar tried to question me, and the consultant waved her away before I’d even had a chance to open my mouth. One consultant even brought my C section date earlier saying “we do not want you going into labour after what happened last time”.

As for friends and family, very few of my friends had straightforward births and a few had electives for their second as well. My mother had an elective for her only child (me). My grandmother had catastrophic birth injuries when my mother was born which marred the rest of her life and she was never able to carry another baby. So there were no snide comments.

But if anyone had tried, they would have got extremely short shrift from me, plus a detailed and gory description of exactly how my vaginal birth went.

Stick to your guns OP, and pay no attention to judgey people!!

Newsenmum · 22/01/2024 21:05

emergency cs from a vbac is actually worse. Most women who choose a vbac do because they really want a vaginal birth experience. You’re doing what’s right for you.

AWanderingMinstrel · 22/01/2024 21:04

Do what is best for you! Had an EMCS with DC1, after 48 hours of induction not working and they got stuck, meconium etc. In the country I was in , it was standard to go for VBAC even after CS, so other DC 2and 3 were VBAC even with induction again, and DC4 came on their own . By far the most difficulty for me after was the CS because it’s major surgery- but I did feel judged about DC1- but healthy baby and mum is the most important.