Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so guilty about wrap around care.

163 replies

Giantwaterbottle4 · 22/01/2024 10:14

I know I am probably not unreasonable but I just feel awful about my kids being in wrap around care. They are 5 and 3 and both have to go to breakfast club and after school club.
They don't get home until 5 and are out of the house by 7:30. I just feel like this is not how life should be and not how envisaged parenting!

Is this really the norm? Or am I failing them and have set them for exhaustion and burnout when they are so young.

It doesn't help that they both say they miss me, especially the younger one and that they don't want to go. Once they are there they both seem happy and have good days but they are always so tired when home

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 22/01/2024 14:51

Bumpitybumper · 22/01/2024 14:37

Whilst this situation isn't unusual, I don't know how helpful it is to hear from those who have done similar and never felt any sense of guilt or unhappiness about the situation. The point is, OP clearly feels that the current setup isn't ideal for her or her children. It may well be a necessary evil but there is nothing wrong with her feeling angry about the lack of options available to her and families like her own. I believe we instinctively know as parents when we hit the right balance with these kinds of things and OP's feeling that the balance is wrong will probably be pretty accurate for her family.

I'm not saying that OP can or should change anything but I think downplaying how she feels and emphatically stating that her children won't be detrimented by the wraparound care is pretty disingenuous when none of us know the children in question. Some kids will thrive in these kinds of settings, some will survive them relatively unscathed and some will find them very difficult indeed.

Society often makes women feel guilty though because society says that mothers need to be the default parent. Like others have pointed out on this thread, there's a double standard when it comes to mothers working vs fathers working.

I don't think there's anything wrong at all with reassuring OP and telling her that she has nothing to feel guilty for because she really doesn't. I don't understand how that is potentially any less helpful than some other comments on the thread, especially ones which could do nothing but make OP feel even more guilty.

Ultimately, OP can decide for herself which comments she does or doesn't find helpful. Maybe she will appreciate the various comments.

kirinm · 22/01/2024 14:47

Bumpitybumper · 22/01/2024 14:37

Whilst this situation isn't unusual, I don't know how helpful it is to hear from those who have done similar and never felt any sense of guilt or unhappiness about the situation. The point is, OP clearly feels that the current setup isn't ideal for her or her children. It may well be a necessary evil but there is nothing wrong with her feeling angry about the lack of options available to her and families like her own. I believe we instinctively know as parents when we hit the right balance with these kinds of things and OP's feeling that the balance is wrong will probably be pretty accurate for her family.

I'm not saying that OP can or should change anything but I think downplaying how she feels and emphatically stating that her children won't be detrimented by the wraparound care is pretty disingenuous when none of us know the children in question. Some kids will thrive in these kinds of settings, some will survive them relatively unscathed and some will find them very difficult indeed.

Nonsense. The OP has asked if she's failing as a parent. A lot of parents are saying no she isn't because putting kids in nursery / after school clubs isn't something anyone should feel guilty about.

I'm not going to say you know what OP do continue feeling guilty but know that you're not a bad parent.

Waxwin9 · 22/01/2024 14:40

normal. Many have such long days in nursery as soon as the maternity finishes. Don't beat yourself up. It's pretty standard. They will survive.

Bumpitybumper · 22/01/2024 14:37

Whilst this situation isn't unusual, I don't know how helpful it is to hear from those who have done similar and never felt any sense of guilt or unhappiness about the situation. The point is, OP clearly feels that the current setup isn't ideal for her or her children. It may well be a necessary evil but there is nothing wrong with her feeling angry about the lack of options available to her and families like her own. I believe we instinctively know as parents when we hit the right balance with these kinds of things and OP's feeling that the balance is wrong will probably be pretty accurate for her family.

I'm not saying that OP can or should change anything but I think downplaying how she feels and emphatically stating that her children won't be detrimented by the wraparound care is pretty disingenuous when none of us know the children in question. Some kids will thrive in these kinds of settings, some will survive them relatively unscathed and some will find them very difficult indeed.

autumnnightsaredrawingin · 22/01/2024 14:34

Guilt is a wasted emotion OP, and you are clearly a good parent.

No, it’s not ideal. But it is very necessary and very normal in the society we live in. Plenty of kids are in childcare longer than these hours. Unfortunately, without family help (those who have it are SO lucky!) or without being able to work flexibly or not at all, it’s become the norm.

Do the kids have dinner with you when they get home?

coatonthewashingline · 22/01/2024 14:26

Mine are a bit older now, but we used childminders and/or in home care at this stage. Whether it’s ok depends on child and nature of wrap around. Our school had mixed age care, and IMO it was not one bit good for the little ones, for
more than a couple of days each week. They got too tired, and disruptive and overwrought.
For many years we had a TA from school bring the children home, take them to activities etc. It was no more expensive than clubs times three, snd so
much gentler for both us and them.

pelargoniums · 22/01/2024 14:19

DD4 spent the weekend making a birthday-love-thank-you (who knows) card for her favourite teacher at the wraparound provision. If I turn up too early she asks to stay to finish her snack and play some more; she’s frequently requested to stay to the very end of the session (impossible as her baby brother needs to eat and would danger nap if I picked her up later). (Her wraparound looks enormously fun tbh: free play, make their own sandwiches, access to a hoarder’s paradise of colouring in and crafting materials, open access to the playground and garden, some TV time. At home it’s more like “I’ll be with you in a minute, I just need to make tea.”)

She loved and adored her nursery key worker – and is always thrilled to see nursery staff out and about in town; in turn they always stop to say hello and see how she’s doing. You could say this means I’ve completely outsourced nurturing her Hmm or you could say she’s developed multiple meaningful interactions and relationships with people outside of her immediate family, because she’s confident and secure, and this will stand her in good stead as she goes out into the world – which starts in reception, where they have to navigate their own path in new surroundings and learn all this STUFF and new motor skills and it’s exhausting; how much easier is it if they’re able to rub along with strangers and build relationships?

ElaineMBenes · 22/01/2024 14:15

Yeah, because mothers who work do it for luxuries, whereas fathers who work do so to put food on the table. 🙄

I was JUST about to say this.
I can't believe we still have to challenge this ridiculous view.

Psychoticbreak · 22/01/2024 14:11

Dont beat yourself up. I am a lone parent who has same hours. It has to be done to provide for your kids end of really.

Blondeshavemorefun · 22/01/2024 14:10

I assume in child care as You work.

You provide a roof over their heads and food in their tummies plus clothes toys etx

And sure lots of love and cuddles as well

Don't feel Guilty

Not sure why the childcare costs ?

Could you use a cm so a home from home and can chill /relax more after school /pre school

Or look at costs of a nanny. If you use a nwoc Costa are a little cheaper - then in own home

But you picking them up at 5 is a good time. Many children are in childcare til 630/7 whether nurseries or nannies etx

You still have time each evening to do tea /homework /play/read /bath /bedtime

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/01/2024 14:08

ColleenDonaghy · 22/01/2024 13:36

It was a choice for us at the time - when I went back to work we could have survived on DH's salary (or a little more generously on mine as I was the slightly higher earner), although that would be a lot tougher now with increased mortgage payments thanks to higher interest rates.

I absolutely made a choice.

It wasn't about "lifestyle choices" like activities and weekend trips, it was about my choice of lifestyle to continue the career I'd worked for for a decade, and use the 4 years UG, 1 year PG and 9 years professional study I'd done.

We expect our girls to work hard in school and get a decent education after that but then they turn 30, have a baby and all of a sudden it's the judgmental head tilt if they don't want to give that up.

Choice here too. DS isn't school age yet so no wraparound care and we likely won't need to use it full time due to flexibility options.

I had a shorter maternity leave than usual and DS goes to nursery full time. I enjoy my career and there was no way I was giving it up.

DryIce · 22/01/2024 14:02

I think the fact you're so worried about this shows you're a great aren't who thinks a lot about what's best for her children.

If you want practical solutions, I flexed a few days to start early and then I get them from school. Would that work?

But if its just guilt - as a child I was often picked up by a nanny, but I envied the children staying at afterschool club with all our friends it seemed so much fun. My parents worked full time- but I loved the holiday clubs and activities. And , yes, the holidays and luxuries that maybe came with it.

My husbands (busy) mum was home every day after school, but mainly got on with things and left them watching tv/entertaining themselves. He isn't unhappy about jt, but doesn't see it as necessarily any better than afterschool care

Someone else is absolutely not "raising your children" - you are there mornings, evenings, nighttime, holidays, weekends. They will absolutely know you are their mum.

LavenderHaze19 · 22/01/2024 13:51

I don’t really think many people have a totally ideal set-up.

My kids go to wraparound, so they spend most of their lives with strangers, but they do always have two parents around at bedtime - one each to read them a story, talk about their days and any worries or problems they have, etc.

One of my best friends is a SAHM - her kids are collected from school at 3/don’t go to nursery, but she says bedtimes are absolute pandemonium - her husband’s never there because he’s got to work (much harder to draw boundaries at work when your family’s survival depends on your performance) and each of their children is just desperate for a bit of 121 time with a parent.

As I said upthread, there’s very little in life that hasn’t got both advantages and disadvantages.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 22/01/2024 13:51

bobomomo · 22/01/2024 13:15

@Crunchymum

I stayed home with mine until youngest was 6 then worked pt so finished in time for the school run. This meant financial sacrifices, and careful planning eg food. We certainly didn't live the lifestyles I read about today like paid for activities each weekend, take aways, trips out etc but it was right for me - my dd has asd and seizures so options for out of school care were almost non existent

We wouldn't survive without both wages. I would LOVE to stay home with DD. I'd also love to stay home and still let her go to nursery a couple of mornings/days a week because she loves it and gets a lot from it. I'd also love for both of us to be able to do something we love rather than what pays the bills AND be at home with DD making lovely family memories every day.

But even with the careful planning and cutting right back etc. We can't afford to live without my wage. We have done all of that careful planning and cut backs etc and I'm able to work PT so she's in nursery three days rather than five. But it's not a choice of "work or SAHM". It's a choice of work or we don't pay the mortgage or have the heating on.

I'm glad you were able to afford to make that choice. Most people can't.

DontSetYourselfOnFireToKeepOthersWarm · 22/01/2024 13:51

Urcheon · 22/01/2024 13:00

Hear, hear. It’s a deeply ordinary situation.

It is the fact that it is deeply ordinary that makes it shitty.

CroccyWoccy · 22/01/2024 13:45

EDIT - this was a reply to @kirinm

Yep I often get told off if I turn up early!

I also wonder how much time parents who pick their children up from school at 3:30 are spending on quality 1-1 interaction with them, v.s. stuff they could have done at ASC anyway (playing with friends, running around, playing with toys) or watching TV?

I speak for myself but when I worked less than 5 days a week in the time after school often I'd end up on a playdate, chatting with the parent while the kids played with each other. Or my DC playing in their room while I made dinner. Or them nagging me to turn the TV or play on the Ipad. We didn't spend oodles of time on wholesome parent-child activities!

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 22/01/2024 13:45

C0keZer0 · 22/01/2024 10:54

It is what it is. Easy for others to say but I wouldn't have had children if I had to do this, I don't think it's fair. I appreciate circumstances change though. Any chance you can change your hours?

I'm lucky that I can be flexible enough that I should be able to do normal school drop off and pick up, but if it had been 5 years ago, I absolutely wouldn't have had that flexibility, nor would I have been able to afford to drop hours. A lot of jobs don't offer that flexibility and with today's prices being so much higher than they were 5 years ago, many people may have thought they could afford part time, had kids, and now can't.

Financial should obviously be a part of the decision as to whether you can have children. But the world changes and so you can plan all you want but its not guaranteed.

Perhapsanorhertimewouldbebetter · 22/01/2024 13:39

It's far from ideal, for you or them, however I'm fairly confident that you're not alone in having to live this way.

Zanatdy · 22/01/2024 13:39

It’s absolutely fine, mine did too and they are teens now (one at Uni) and absolutely well adjusted normal kids with no sense of anger they went to the Afterschool club so I could put a roof over their head. It’s only for a part of their childhood, don’t feel guilt

ColleenDonaghy · 22/01/2024 13:36

pointythings · 22/01/2024 13:22

You're still assuming that people put their children in wraparound care because of 'lifestyle choices' and it gives me the rage.

We put ours in wraparound care because we needed to heat, eat and keep a roof over our heads. We were stony bloody broke. I still remember the fear when the car made an odd noise ( and no, the car wasn't a luxury because no public transport).

You were lucky to be able to have a parent nit working. Most people are not.

It was a choice for us at the time - when I went back to work we could have survived on DH's salary (or a little more generously on mine as I was the slightly higher earner), although that would be a lot tougher now with increased mortgage payments thanks to higher interest rates.

I absolutely made a choice.

It wasn't about "lifestyle choices" like activities and weekend trips, it was about my choice of lifestyle to continue the career I'd worked for for a decade, and use the 4 years UG, 1 year PG and 9 years professional study I'd done.

We expect our girls to work hard in school and get a decent education after that but then they turn 30, have a baby and all of a sudden it's the judgmental head tilt if they don't want to give that up.

kirinm · 22/01/2024 13:22

CroccyWoccy · 22/01/2024 13:08

Mine are in wraparound 5 days a week until 6pm.

They have really built their friendship groups at after school club, it’s given them so much more unstructured time with their peers than they would have otherwise and those friendships have flourished, including with children it would be hard to arrange regular play dates with. They get lots of outdoor time to run around.

They still take part in clubs arranged by school (sports, chess, book club, archery) and they do swimming, scouts and music lessons too.

I try to devote some time with them every night to read or play a game and we always have dinner together.

We try to have relaxed weekends and devote as much time as possible to family time.

I don’t feel guilty.

I agree with this. The ASC involves children of different ages and so my DD has a friend in year 5 / year 3 etc and she loves that. Even though she's in the same class as a lot of the ASC crowd, they're like a little gang after school. She often tells her dad to go away and come back again so she has more time to play.

pointythings · 22/01/2024 13:22

bobomomo · 22/01/2024 13:15

@Crunchymum

I stayed home with mine until youngest was 6 then worked pt so finished in time for the school run. This meant financial sacrifices, and careful planning eg food. We certainly didn't live the lifestyles I read about today like paid for activities each weekend, take aways, trips out etc but it was right for me - my dd has asd and seizures so options for out of school care were almost non existent

You're still assuming that people put their children in wraparound care because of 'lifestyle choices' and it gives me the rage.

We put ours in wraparound care because we needed to heat, eat and keep a roof over our heads. We were stony bloody broke. I still remember the fear when the car made an odd noise ( and no, the car wasn't a luxury because no public transport).

You were lucky to be able to have a parent nit working. Most people are not.

DocOck · 22/01/2024 13:19

A lot of people are in the same situation. It's no different to my DS being at pre-school at the moment, he's there from 8-5.30 most days because I have to work, and I have no guilt as most days he'd rather be there than with me as all his friends are there.

bobomomo · 22/01/2024 13:15

@Crunchymum

I stayed home with mine until youngest was 6 then worked pt so finished in time for the school run. This meant financial sacrifices, and careful planning eg food. We certainly didn't live the lifestyles I read about today like paid for activities each weekend, take aways, trips out etc but it was right for me - my dd has asd and seizures so options for out of school care were almost non existent

Jxtina86 · 22/01/2024 13:15

DD did 8-6 from 11 months old at nursery, 4 days a week. She's now at school doing 7.45 till 5.45 3 days a week plus an additional day of breakfast club. I try to get there for 5pm as much as possible so we have a little extra time at home before bed.

The staff are lovely, there's other kids from her class that go, she knows some of the older kids now as well which I think is great as she's more aware of school life outside of the reception bubble.

I get the guilt and in an ideal world we wouldn't have the need for wraparound care but the world is not ideal unfortunately (not saying that's right, it's just how it is!)

That said I was surprised that out of the 5 local schools, only 3 offered full wraparound care. Our closest school had nothing which meant we didn't even apply.