Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so guilty about wrap around care.

163 replies

Giantwaterbottle4 · 22/01/2024 10:14

I know I am probably not unreasonable but I just feel awful about my kids being in wrap around care. They are 5 and 3 and both have to go to breakfast club and after school club.
They don't get home until 5 and are out of the house by 7:30. I just feel like this is not how life should be and not how envisaged parenting!

Is this really the norm? Or am I failing them and have set them for exhaustion and burnout when they are so young.

It doesn't help that they both say they miss me, especially the younger one and that they don't want to go. Once they are there they both seem happy and have good days but they are always so tired when home

OP posts:
justanotherusername22 · 22/01/2024 19:10

C0keZer0 · 22/01/2024 10:54

It is what it is. Easy for others to say but I wouldn't have had children if I had to do this, I don't think it's fair. I appreciate circumstances change though. Any chance you can change your hours?

I feel the same.

ElaineMBenes · 22/01/2024 19:07

I don't know anyone whose child is in wraparound care morning and evening 5 days a week - it's actually not normal at all. Given there are 175 kids in the primary school and 26 places in the wraparound care, which only operates Mon to Thurs anyway, clearly it's not "normal". People tend to use it for a couple of days a week and juggle working hours and grandparents. We are in a relatively average mixed area. It's the middle class, better off parents here who mainly work long hours and use wraparound care. It's too expensive to be worthwhile on a minimum wage job!

Depends where you life and your school surely.....
Ours has far more than 26 places and as it's such a small school most people get a place if they need it.
It's also quite cheap so it's accessible to all.

ginforall · 22/01/2024 18:59

Please don't feel guilty about doing what you have to do and doing your best for your children, which I'm sure you are. I've spent ages feeling guilt for working full time, my DS is 11, knows no difference and is a happy sociable child. I'd recommend looking up Anna Mathur (both books and podcasts) who is a psychotherapist who does a lot of mum guilt. I have no reason to suggest her other than I have found her podcasts really useful for feeling better as a mum, doing my best.

FleetwoodMacAttack · 22/01/2024 18:21

Home by 5pm really isn’t that bad - lots of nurseries in London open til 6.30. House prices are so high and commute so long there’s often no other option.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/01/2024 18:00

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 16:57

I don't know anyone whose child is in wraparound care morning and evening 5 days a week - it's actually not normal at all. Given there are 175 kids in the primary school and 26 places in the wraparound care, which only operates Mon to Thurs anyway, clearly it's not "normal". People tend to use it for a couple of days a week and juggle working hours and grandparents. We are in a relatively average mixed area. It's the middle class, better off parents here who mainly work long hours and use wraparound care. It's too expensive to be worthwhile on a minimum wage job!

I imagine those who need full time wraparound care are simply less likely to go with a school that doesn't offer it full time, I know that I wouldn't. Though there's also childminders, nursery wraparound care for school age children etc so just because it isn't available for every child at the primary school wraparound, it doesn't necessarily mean that no one else uses it, it will just be elsewhere.

RazzleDazzleEm · 22/01/2024 17:08

Op if it is the "norm" does that make it better?
In the US new mums are expected to sit on special cushions to assist them back to work in a very short space of time after delivery and pump milk at their desks.

I would never go with norms like that, you need to look at your priorities and needs right now and what you want to do whilst thinking about what's best for them and if possible look at a compromise.

MarceyMc · 22/01/2024 17:01

I feel your pain OP, my little one does ASC twice a week and on each of those days every week I feel awful - we are lucky we have family that can help on 2 of the other days, but she's still not home with us, and one day a week when my partner is able to collect her. The guilty feeling is horrible but you aren't failing as a parent and some of the judgemental comments on this thread are just unhelpful. Until very recently I worked part time but a £700 a month hike on the mortgage, plus every other bill imaginable rising, royally fucked that upConfused

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 16:57

pointythings · 22/01/2024 13:22

You're still assuming that people put their children in wraparound care because of 'lifestyle choices' and it gives me the rage.

We put ours in wraparound care because we needed to heat, eat and keep a roof over our heads. We were stony bloody broke. I still remember the fear when the car made an odd noise ( and no, the car wasn't a luxury because no public transport).

You were lucky to be able to have a parent nit working. Most people are not.

I don't know anyone whose child is in wraparound care morning and evening 5 days a week - it's actually not normal at all. Given there are 175 kids in the primary school and 26 places in the wraparound care, which only operates Mon to Thurs anyway, clearly it's not "normal". People tend to use it for a couple of days a week and juggle working hours and grandparents. We are in a relatively average mixed area. It's the middle class, better off parents here who mainly work long hours and use wraparound care. It's too expensive to be worthwhile on a minimum wage job!

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 16:50

nokidshere · 22/01/2024 15:49

Guilt is a completely wasted emotion. It serves no purpose for you or them. You need to work, they need care, it's a perfectly normal situation. The best way to deal with it and to help with the guilt is to put it in perspective, and be upbeat and matter of fact about it. Your children will be fine.

There are 168 hours in a week. Your children are at school/care for 50 of those hours. If they sleep for 40, they still spend 78 with you. Don't spend a minute of that time feeling guilty about putting a roof over their heads and meals on the table.

Hopefully a 3 year old sleeps more than 5.7 hours a day.
Using a more realistic amount of 12 hours sleep a day that leaves 34 hours with parents

Somethingsnappy · 22/01/2024 16:45

Just to say OP, to you and anybody else reading this who feels guilty about wraparound care....

I've never had to use wraparound care, but that extra 1.5 hours in the morning and 1.5 hours in the evening is really not exactly quality time with my children. In the mornings, I barely see them, as they are getting dressed, eating breakfast etc, while I am preparing breakfast, sorting their bags etc. Also, I'm a little stressed getting them out the house on time, so I'm a bit grumpy. Then when they come home from school, they are all tired, so they either do their homework or watch some TV for an hour. It only really becomes quality time with them once dinner is ready and we all eat together, and then story time at bedtime etc.

I know I've simplified it all a bit, but my main message is that those periods of time shortly before and after school, are really not my favourite/most rewarding times with my children.

We all just do what we have to do. Guilt is a wasted emotion, unless you use it to make changes. If change is not possible, then ditch the guilt!

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 16:43

Urcheon · 22/01/2024 12:10

Yeah, because mothers who work do it for luxuries, whereas fathers who work do so to put food on the table. 🙄

I never said anything about mothers or fathers. I don't think the OP mentioned if they were male or female?

In fact many people do have lots of luxuries, it's not unreasonable to suggest prioritising time with preschool aged children over material things. Obviously not everyone has that choice but many do.

MrsMurphyIWish · 22/01/2024 16:36

Also laughing at “strangers” looking after children, like working parents just dump their kids with some random and not DBS checked, qualified staff 😂

MrsMurphyIWish · 22/01/2024 16:30

Teacher here and very normal amongst my colleagues. DH and I haven’t family so mine (12, 9) have been in wraparound since reception. DD no longer needs it and lets herself out and in. Do men feel guilty? Do they fuck and fuck all the judgemental arses too. I’ve bloody worked hard to be a professional and a mother is only part of my identity. I maybe selfish but I also don’t want to forgo and good quality of life by not working.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/01/2024 16:17

Bumpitybumper · 22/01/2024 15:06

Stating someone has 'nothing to feel guilty' about though is part of the problem. OP does feel guilty and you are basically dismissing this by saying it's unfounded when you have no idea regarding the origins of the guilt.

If it derived completely from external sources like the misogynistic societal standards you outline then yes of course, this can be discounted. If however the OP feels this way because the current setup doesn't align with what she feels is right for herself and her children then the guilt she is feeling is doing an important job. It is telling her that she perhaps needs to work towards changing something so that she is happier with the setup. We all need to be guided by our intrinsic values and not told by society (one way or the other) that the way we choose to parent is 'right' or 'wrong'.

Well, as I said before, I'm sure OP is more than capable of deciding herself which comments she does or doesn't find to be helpful.

pelargoniums · 22/01/2024 16:11

MrsMarzetti · 22/01/2024 15:43

Who says this is out of her control ? We all make our own choices. Maybe OP makes enough after childcare bill to pay other main bills the it's worth, if she only has £50 left after the childcare bill then it's not worth it and it is within her control to change it.

Surely it’s the family pot that only has the £50, childcare being a joint cost not a whimsical personal spend?

And perhaps £50 is worth it. It’s quite odd to decide a price on her behalf after her half of the childcare bill. £50 could be a bill, the difference between yellow sticker own brand beans and nice ones; it could be the self worth and sanity in working; it could represent staying in the workforce to contribute to a pension and put oneself in the running for future promotions and payrises; it could be buffer savings because being up £50 is better than an even £0. There are lots of reasons to work even if the family is only or barely breaking even after childcare.

Usernamen · 22/01/2024 15:56

MrsMarzetti · 22/01/2024 15:43

Who says this is out of her control ? We all make our own choices. Maybe OP makes enough after childcare bill to pay other main bills the it's worth, if she only has £50 left after the childcare bill then it's not worth it and it is within her control to change it.

One shouldn’t only focus on incremental earnings in the present to determine whether to continue or abandon one’s career after children. Future earning potential and pension are more important considerations for a parent deciding whether or not to stay in the workforce.

nokidshere · 22/01/2024 15:49

Guilt is a completely wasted emotion. It serves no purpose for you or them. You need to work, they need care, it's a perfectly normal situation. The best way to deal with it and to help with the guilt is to put it in perspective, and be upbeat and matter of fact about it. Your children will be fine.

There are 168 hours in a week. Your children are at school/care for 50 of those hours. If they sleep for 40, they still spend 78 with you. Don't spend a minute of that time feeling guilty about putting a roof over their heads and meals on the table.

MrsMarzetti · 22/01/2024 15:43

Dantedisciple · 22/01/2024 10:38

Don't feel guilty about things that are out of your control.

With luck you will have robust children who will cope with the fairly demanding regime that modern living demands.

Who says this is out of her control ? We all make our own choices. Maybe OP makes enough after childcare bill to pay other main bills the it's worth, if she only has £50 left after the childcare bill then it's not worth it and it is within her control to change it.

Usernamen · 22/01/2024 15:22

Assuming OP and her partner utilise their annual leave to spend time with their children, and the children are not in childcare at the weekend nor past 5pm during the week, I don’t see how they could possibly be spending more time with “strangers” than their parents. The maths doesn’t add up.

So I agree with PP, that really was a shitty comment.

Usernamen · 22/01/2024 15:17

If your hours are rigid, could your DH drop a day or two, or compress his hours?

Sanch1 · 22/01/2024 15:14

All 3 of mine are in childcare/school 730-5. Needs must to go to work and put a roof over their heads. They are all happy, confident and robust young people!

MinionKevin · 22/01/2024 15:13

I assume you don’t have a choice and that’s why it’s the way it is?
If you can’t change it you can’t change it.

Are you in a position to drop some hours at all, or compress your hours, adding time other days so you can say pick them up on a Friday?

Bumpitybumper · 22/01/2024 15:06

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/01/2024 14:51

Society often makes women feel guilty though because society says that mothers need to be the default parent. Like others have pointed out on this thread, there's a double standard when it comes to mothers working vs fathers working.

I don't think there's anything wrong at all with reassuring OP and telling her that she has nothing to feel guilty for because she really doesn't. I don't understand how that is potentially any less helpful than some other comments on the thread, especially ones which could do nothing but make OP feel even more guilty.

Ultimately, OP can decide for herself which comments she does or doesn't find helpful. Maybe she will appreciate the various comments.

Stating someone has 'nothing to feel guilty' about though is part of the problem. OP does feel guilty and you are basically dismissing this by saying it's unfounded when you have no idea regarding the origins of the guilt.

If it derived completely from external sources like the misogynistic societal standards you outline then yes of course, this can be discounted. If however the OP feels this way because the current setup doesn't align with what she feels is right for herself and her children then the guilt she is feeling is doing an important job. It is telling her that she perhaps needs to work towards changing something so that she is happier with the setup. We all need to be guided by our intrinsic values and not told by society (one way or the other) that the way we choose to parent is 'right' or 'wrong'.

whenismyturn · 22/01/2024 15:02

You shouldn’t feel bad it’s not your fault that modern life is set up this way and people have to work and put dc in childcare, there should be more support for families so they don’t have to but sadly there isn’t. You’re only doing your best Flowers

stargirl1701 · 22/01/2024 14:58

I would be prepared to do this with a childminder but not a breakfast club/after school club.