Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so guilty about wrap around care.

163 replies

Giantwaterbottle4 · 22/01/2024 10:14

I know I am probably not unreasonable but I just feel awful about my kids being in wrap around care. They are 5 and 3 and both have to go to breakfast club and after school club.
They don't get home until 5 and are out of the house by 7:30. I just feel like this is not how life should be and not how envisaged parenting!

Is this really the norm? Or am I failing them and have set them for exhaustion and burnout when they are so young.

It doesn't help that they both say they miss me, especially the younger one and that they don't want to go. Once they are there they both seem happy and have good days but they are always so tired when home

OP posts:
Dantedisciple · 23/01/2024 08:14

Gettingbysomehow · 23/01/2024 07:14

I had to have wrap around care too because I was a single mum. I hated it. It wasn't how I wanted to bring up my child. I wanted a more traditional mum role being at home with my child until he was older but my exH just left and went abroad. I would have considered going onto benefits for a few years but it wouldn't pay the mortgage.
I still feel bad about it 40 years later. I feel my ex let his son down
I didn't have a child to hand him over to strangers.

You didn't let your son down. He was lucky to have you.

Capmagturk · 23/01/2024 08:13

Its this way for alot of children op, don't feel bad you need to work to provide for them. My children now don't need to go to wrap around care as they are older but they still moan about not wanting to go to school.

Flip it around and see the benefits too, they are seeing you working and providing for them and that will instill a work ethic in them. They are getting prepared for a future work life by learning to get up and out the house daily. They get to spend time with friends of various ages and wrap around care does alot of fun activities - arts and crafts, games that they will be having fun and developing their characters from (better than alot of kids just sat infront of a tv/device before or after school). The money you make allows you all to have a better lifestyle.

Its understandable they will be tired as they are still quite young but as they grow up they'll be less tired and their bedtimes will be later and you can spend more time with them.

ThisIsOk · 23/01/2024 08:06

I understand how you feel OP.

When I first went back to work after DS1 he was in childcare from 7am to 5pm three days a week. Some days he was asleep when I left and asleep when I got home. It was really hard and I felt such guilt. I worked as a nurse though so I was out the house for 14 hours with his dad doing all childcare drop-offs and collections.

After DS2 I dropped my hours so I only had to work two days a week (25 hours) which did help.

When my youngest started school I took on a really exciting new job role but it required me to work different hours which meant the children were in before and after school clubs from 7.30am to 5.30pm. It just wasn’t what I wanted ☹️

When I was a child me and my sister were always in wrap-around care and my parents had absolutely no choice, which we understood, but we really missed spending time with them. We’d spend on average about 3 hours a day with them (Mon-Fri) and it just didn’t seem enough.

My husband had experienced the same and so before even trying for children we had agreed that as much as possible we would avoid childcare and I would be at home with them if I could which is why we changed around with my hours so much when they were pre-school age.

Sadly I had to leave my job 8 months ago for ill-health reasons which meant we didn’t have to use wrap around care anymore and I have to say that it’s been really lovey being able to spend so much more time with my children who are 6 and 10 now as I see them for about 8 hours a day.

Every person is in different situations though and if I had the choice of staying in my current state of health and seeing my children so much or having my health problems disappear and use wrap-around care for work purposes then I would choose the latter.

All anyone can do is the best in their own circumstances and sadly mums are always judged more than fathers, in my opinion anyway.

It’s natural for you to feel the way you do but please don’t let yourself feel any guilt because you are doing what you need to do in order to look after your children and give them a good quality of life.

Candleabra · 23/01/2024 07:47

It was normal for me. No reduced hours, working from home etc. Everyone had a 9-5 job involving a commute so just had to get on with it. If there are other options now for you to explore then great, I’m glad there’s more flexibility now for working parents. But your kids will be fine if not.

pelargoniums · 23/01/2024 07:44

the kids are out the door at 07.30 and not back in until.5pm - at their age they are in bed by about 6.30 - thats just fact.
Bed at 6.30pm at age 5 sounds unusual, rather than factual. Even at age 3! At 3 my daughter went to bed at 7, so would have had two hours with me after a 5pm pickup; now, at 5, she’s asleep at 8pm – and up at 6am. What I wouldn't give to farm out the early mornings to strangers…!

Gettingbysomehow · 23/01/2024 07:14

I had to have wrap around care too because I was a single mum. I hated it. It wasn't how I wanted to bring up my child. I wanted a more traditional mum role being at home with my child until he was older but my exH just left and went abroad. I would have considered going onto benefits for a few years but it wouldn't pay the mortgage.
I still feel bad about it 40 years later. I feel my ex let his son down
I didn't have a child to hand him over to strangers.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 23/01/2024 06:27

MrsMurphyIWish · 22/01/2024 16:30

Teacher here and very normal amongst my colleagues. DH and I haven’t family so mine (12, 9) have been in wraparound since reception. DD no longer needs it and lets herself out and in. Do men feel guilty? Do they fuck and fuck all the judgemental arses too. I’ve bloody worked hard to be a professional and a mother is only part of my identity. I maybe selfish but I also don’t want to forgo and good quality of life by not working.

Some men do have that guilt. My DH doesn't mention it often a specific but it's there in other things he says. Such as "I wish we could have one of us home with her" or the days she's clinging to me crying cos she doesn't want to go in (rare but happens) "I wish I earned more" or "I'm trying to win the lottery". He feels it. He wants our child to be with us more. He does pick up but he calls me from the car the second his ETA goes up by a minute so we can work out if I could get there quicker, so she's not there longer.

He takes on as much of the financial load as he can so that I can work part time, which we decided on together because of how our jobs work. The second I found out I was pregnant he started doing more training/development at work to increase his income. He started saving and investing more. Everything he does is to give ya the family life we want, or as close to it as we can get it with financial restraints.

And on top of all that, his full time job that he works really hard at to support us, he supports my career too. Which I also worked really hard to get to where it is. And luckily I was senior enough when DD came along that part time won't harm it. I can still go on work trips because he will happily use his annual leave to be here for DD if needs be. He does the pick ups so I can take the meetings that our director loves to put in later. Whatever I need, he will cover it. So if he can't, I know he actually can't. Never won't.

Sorry you seem to only have experience of rubbish men. But there are good fathers and husbands out there that have the same feelings as mothers and wives. They just sometimes get communicated differently.

Giantwaterbottle4 · 22/01/2024 22:56

Wow thank you for all the replies, advice and opinions. I am sorry I am only just getting back, (ironically) have been at work then sorting the kids haha. I have read them all and it took a while and I truly appreciate the messages of support.

I do have a DH and he also works full time. His job is a little more flexible sometimes, it's a trade so can be away for a while then off for a little so he picks the kids up and drops off when he can.

I work because I have to, as others have mentioned and no it isn't for luxury/handbag or spending money it's for bills, house, car, food etc.

I think I will see if I can utilise some flexibility time with work better.

I sometimes can pick them up at 4 and every night we have dinner together and bath and bed, story. In the morning we have some time and every weekend. We also mange holidays with annual leave so they aren't in clubs etc then.

It really has been very reassuring reading most of these comments.

I do agree that it's sad that life is like this but I also think about all the awful situations people are in with their kids around the world who'd do anything for this life and try to remind myself. I also remind myself that kids my kids age used to be made go to work themselves! When I think about those things I wonder if this ideal world I imagine where parents spend the entire day with their kids and so whatever it is you're "supposed to" (think homeschooling instgram mums) ever existed!

OP posts:
Dantedisciple · 22/01/2024 22:19

MrsMurphyIWish · 22/01/2024 16:30

Teacher here and very normal amongst my colleagues. DH and I haven’t family so mine (12, 9) have been in wraparound since reception. DD no longer needs it and lets herself out and in. Do men feel guilty? Do they fuck and fuck all the judgemental arses too. I’ve bloody worked hard to be a professional and a mother is only part of my identity. I maybe selfish but I also don’t want to forgo and good quality of life by not working.

Many men feel guilty and inadequate if they can't put bread on the table or bring home the bacon. the patriarchy placed enormous demands on men too. As a teacher I would have expected you to know that.

blackpanth · 22/01/2024 21:29

Don't feel guilty. You are doing your best x

tiggergoesbounce · 22/01/2024 21:22

@pointythings

It's the one that gets thrown at working mums everywhere. The 'you aren't raising your own children', the 'you're farming them out to strangers'. And it's nonsense because as a parent, you still spend the majority of every single day with your children

You say that but its not true if in the OPs situation the kids are out the door at 07.30 and not back in until.5pm - at their age they are in bed by about 6.30 - thats just fact. I have never said that in derogatory way, its just fact. You can have a mum do more in an hour than another in 6hours.

That is what I object to - the fact that you are agreeing with the poster who posted the same old sneer

Its not a sneer, in this case its true for the working week

And a sneer is exactly what it is

Its not a sneer, its fact for the week they use wrap around care.

An implication that as a working mum, you're doing it for the 'luxuries', and that if you only cut your cloth, made sacrifices, you'd be able to be a SAHM. That is what needs to stop because it is NOT TRUE

Wow, i never said any of that or agreed with saying working mums do it for luxuries or anything about them making scarafices to be a SAHM - what on earth are you on about ??? i didn't say that

I clearly say its a balancing act. I say its an individual choice, i say it doesn't matter what anyone on this thread thinks it what the OP thinks that counts .

And of course there are some working parents out there who can't do breakfast or homework - people who work shifts are an obvious example

Yes as i highlighted because you are grouping working mums all the same listing off what they do as if there is a mum checklist- there isnt - i say they are no less for not being able to do those things

But you are supporting the contention that they are lesser parents because they do not stay at home

No i didnt- no one mentioned anything about staying at home - that didnt even enter my quotes at all !! So please stop adding your frustrations on to me. Only quote me on what i say.
I didnt even think the OP was talking about staying at home ???

That is what has to stop

No, it has to stop that you are jumping on me for things i haven't said.

If you have a more nuanced view then don't support or agree with people who judge working mothers - because the reality is a lot more nuanced than 'you aren't there for them'

Did you even read my post - i don't judge working mums - i made it clear that the OP should only care about how they felt about it are they not other people on here trying to tell them they are wrong or right when every circumstance is different. The OP says this is not how she envisaged parenting, so i asked about her - no sweeping statements, no judgments at all. You have it sooo wrong.

MissTrip82 · 22/01/2024 20:57

I’ve never had any of the ‘omg you’re abandoning your children for an iPhone’ types object when the entire team resuscitating their desperately ill child is made up of working parents whose children are being cared for by someone else, usually for long periods (there’s no two days a week 10-2 roles in these jobs). They seem to be able to control stupid comments then, and seem glad enough to see those selfish working parents (like their own working partners:………always interesting to see what people really think of the person whose paid work allows them to stay at home). So I wouldn’t worry about thoughtless comments like that.

If the current balance of your dual role as parents (caring for your child and financially supporting your child) isn’t working, is there any option for change?

WalkingRunning · 22/01/2024 20:52

Women shouldn't automatically be assumed to be the default parent, but OP's concern is that the children are doing long days in wraparound every day after school, and likely through the holidays too. Without family support it's impossible. If you are single it's holiday club whenever you can't take leave and if you are a couple you end up splitting all your leave to lessen the holiday club bills. And then wraparound all term. Not cheap or we easy. We made it work by both working shifts around each other but that too is difficult

pointythings · 22/01/2024 20:51

@tiggergoesbounce you are agreeing with this statement:

Your children are spending the majority of their lives with strangers. You get them dressed and put them to bed, but their "life" is with other people who you don't know

It's the one that gets thrown at working mums everywhere. The 'you aren't raising your own children', the 'you're farming them out to strangers'. And it's nonsense because as a parent, you still spend the majority of every single day with your children. That is what I object to - the fact that you are agreeing with the poster who posted the same old sneer. And a sneer is exactly what it is; an implication that as a working mum, you're doing it for the 'luxuries', and that if you only cut your cloth, made sacrifices, you'd be able to be a SAHM. That is what needs to stop because it is NOT TRUE.

And of course there are some working parents out there who can't do breakfast or homework - people who work shifts are an obvious example. But you are supporting the contention that they are lesser parents because they do not stay at home. That is what has to stop. If you have a more nuanced view then don't support or agree with people who judge working mothers - because the reality is a lot more nuanced than 'you aren't there for them'.

ElaineMBenes · 22/01/2024 20:48

Ours costs £6.75 for an hour - definitely not cheap or accessible to all!

Ours is less than that for a whole session (two and a half hours) so it is accessible and in my area is used by a whole range of families, not just those that are wealthy.

JSMill · 22/01/2024 20:41

Why are people trying to make women feel bad when they are trying to do their best? Why do people love to do that to mums?? I was able to be a SAHM when the dcs were younger and I had years of crappy comments about my choices, from men and women. I have no idea if it was the right choice but it was the choice my husband and I made and was nobody's else's business.

tiggergoesbounce · 22/01/2024 20:39

it's not true though, is it?

@pointythings What isnt true ???

It's the horrible sneer that those of you who for some reason don't like working mums like to throw out to make us feel bad. So stop it
I think you must have @"ed" the wrong person. I absolutely dont "sneer", "dislike" or "make you feel bad" thats just ridiculous.

Every day, a working mum gets her children up and does breakfast with them. Every day, she picks them up, baths them, gives them dinner, does homework and reading with them and then the bedtime routine. Every day, she gets up if they need her in the night. Every weekend, she's with them

Well thats not always true. You seem to be grouping all working mums together and saying that those are all things that matter. What if a working mum can't do some of those things in your eyes does that make them less of a mum. My friend cant do breakfast or the school run, either side as shes out the door at 6am and not in until 7pm - it doesn't make her any less of a mum, it does mean she spends less time with her children though - thats just a fact.

And of course the same applies to dads

Yes it does.

Children of two working parents still spend the majority of their time with their parents

That depends on the jobs and the hours, so again a very sweeping statement - grouping working parents all the same, they are not circumstances for each individual are very different- as i say in my post.

Then there's the fact that the children aren't with 'people the parents don't know'.
They're with other adults with whom they have a relationship outside of the home - how is that different from 'it takes a village'

They are with people the parents have to trust, just the same as school.

So stop it with the sneering and the misrepresentation. It's not OK

I am not sneering, show me where i do. I say its a personal choice, a balancing act. I do not sneer at anyone !!!!.

@pointpointythings

pointythings · 22/01/2024 20:22

@tiggergoesbounce it's not true though, is it? It's the horrible sneer that those of you who for some reason don't like working mums like to throw out to make us feel bad. So stop it.

Every day, a working mum gets her children up and does breakfast with them. Every day, she picks them up, baths them, gives them dinner, does homework and reading with them and then the bedtime routine. Every day, she gets up if they need her in the night. Every weekend, she's with them.

And of course the same applies to dads. Children of two working parents still spend the majority of their time with their parents.

Then there's the fact that the children aren't with 'people the parents don't know'. They're with other adults with whom they have a relationship outside of the home - how is that different from 'it takes a village'?

So stop it with the sneering and the misrepresentation. It's not OK.

HangingOnJustAbout · 22/01/2024 20:19

What would you have to give up to spend more time with the dc? It's a balancing act and takes some thought to get right.

I'm sure you're well aware that some people bring up their kids in rented accommodation with support from the government and few luxuries. Anyone can do it but it is not a lifestyle many would choose unless they valued maximising time with their dc above all else.

If you don't like the way things are what can you do? We both went part time, staggered start and end times so dc never needed childcare. It meant a smaller home, minimal holidays and no luxuries. It also meant slower career progression and a smaller pension. We were fine with that and could still lead what we considered a comfortable life, that may not be the case for some though.

tiggergoesbounce · 22/01/2024 20:17

Your children are spending the majority of their lives with strangers. You get them dressed and put them to bed, but their "life" is with other people who you don't know

I think this is the reality, but you know that.
Your kids, of course, will cope and get used to it. And yes i think it has become a lot more of the norm for kids. There are some who like it and some who hate it and cry after 2 years of going.

But the only thing that matter really is, do you think you are failing them. You say this isn't what you envisaged parenting to be, what did you envisage it to be ?

Are you happy with the set up ?

Everyones circumstances are different and every child is different, so no one can tell you if you are right or wrong, they give an opinion based on their lives, or what they percieve yours may look like. But without knowing the ins and outs - its just sweeping statements and opinion.

It's a balancing act of what's important to you and what's essential.

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/01/2024 19:59

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 19:52

Well yes but places aren't available for most children. it's still the case that only a minority do wraparound care 5 days a week both mornings and evenings. Saying it's normal is like saying it's normal to earn 100k.

If the demand is there, it will be available for those who need it. I imagine that demand will largely vary by area.

Plenty of people have said it's normal on this thread, clearly it is hardly unusual.

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 19:57

ElaineMBenes · 22/01/2024 19:07

I don't know anyone whose child is in wraparound care morning and evening 5 days a week - it's actually not normal at all. Given there are 175 kids in the primary school and 26 places in the wraparound care, which only operates Mon to Thurs anyway, clearly it's not "normal". People tend to use it for a couple of days a week and juggle working hours and grandparents. We are in a relatively average mixed area. It's the middle class, better off parents here who mainly work long hours and use wraparound care. It's too expensive to be worthwhile on a minimum wage job!

Depends where you life and your school surely.....
Ours has far more than 26 places and as it's such a small school most people get a place if they need it.
It's also quite cheap so it's accessible to all.

In richer areas there will no doubt be more demand for wraparound care, yes. The point I am trying to make it that it is not normal for parents who are genuinely struggling to make ends meet to be using wraparound care 5 days a week.

It tends to be used mainly by better off parents and even then most don't use it 5 days a week.

Ours costs £6.75 for an hour - definitely not cheap or accessible to all!

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 19:52

SouthLondonMum22 · 22/01/2024 18:00

I imagine those who need full time wraparound care are simply less likely to go with a school that doesn't offer it full time, I know that I wouldn't. Though there's also childminders, nursery wraparound care for school age children etc so just because it isn't available for every child at the primary school wraparound, it doesn't necessarily mean that no one else uses it, it will just be elsewhere.

Well yes but places aren't available for most children. it's still the case that only a minority do wraparound care 5 days a week both mornings and evenings. Saying it's normal is like saying it's normal to earn 100k.

surreygirl1987 · 22/01/2024 19:49

My kids are 3 and 5 as well, and in exactly the same wraparound care boat. It's actually shorter hours than they did when they were at nursery. I just try to make up for it by spending loads of quality time with them on weekends and am with them all through the school holidays rather than using the holiday clubs that lots of parents have to use.

catelynjane · 22/01/2024 19:19

I think it's becoming increasingly normal.

I don't think you should feel guilty for having to work, but equally if there was a way to reduce the amount of time spent in childcare, I would do it.

I was in full-time childcare from a baby - yes, it was normal and I coped just fine but honestly, it wasn't ideal for anyone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread