Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel so guilty about wrap around care.

163 replies

Giantwaterbottle4 · 22/01/2024 10:14

I know I am probably not unreasonable but I just feel awful about my kids being in wrap around care. They are 5 and 3 and both have to go to breakfast club and after school club.
They don't get home until 5 and are out of the house by 7:30. I just feel like this is not how life should be and not how envisaged parenting!

Is this really the norm? Or am I failing them and have set them for exhaustion and burnout when they are so young.

It doesn't help that they both say they miss me, especially the younger one and that they don't want to go. Once they are there they both seem happy and have good days but they are always so tired when home

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
vivainsomnia · 16/02/2024 09:23

They will be fine. Mine were there until 5:30 at least and they honestly were fine. The club's were great and offered nothing different to what good parents offer, activity outside, fun in the park, meeting with friends, baking, cooking, sports, or indeed, relaxing in front of the TV, and even playing on the Xbox.

Funnily, the Xbox and TV were not popular and must kids preferred to be involved in the activities. Mine loved it.

Giantwaterbottle4 · 16/02/2024 09:16

Hi everyone, thanks again for the opinions and advice. I've thought so much about all this.

Some points, I don't have a career as such but it isn't a bad job (in the public sector) and the pay does increase for I think 5 years. Also has an ok pension.

I pretty much have to go back so part time (as I do now) isn't an opinion.

However I have worked it a bit better I think.
Come September both will be in school.

So their days will be leaving the house at 7:30 - home by about 4:20/4:30, latest 5 on v busy days.

They go to bed for about 7/7:30 sometimes the youngest is asleep at 6:30 ish. They tend to get up at 5/6 (for youngest) 6/630 for eldest so we have a fair bit of time in the evening.
I'm trying to put a positive spin on things and believe that they won't be negatively impacted.

And like so many have said, I don't really have a choice so what else can I do 🤷‍♀️😭

OP posts:
surreygirl1987 · 25/01/2024 17:12

Future earning potential and pension are more important considerations for a parent deciding whether or not to stay in the workforce.

Agreed. This was why I went from part time to full time, even though I actually 'earned' less when I did so. Playing the long game!

And yes, of course MH and childcare needs to factor in. But they loved nursery, and my MH was all the better for returning to work.

surreygirl1987 · 25/01/2024 17:10

But did staying at home cause the depression, or is it the case that people (of either sex) with fragile MH are more likely to opt out of the workplace?

I can't speak for others, but for me personally, being at home looking adter a baby was awful for my mental health. I was instantly better when I went back to work!

catelynjane · 24/01/2024 16:26

Urcheon · 24/01/2024 16:19

SAHMs statistically have poorer MH than WOHMs, with more reporting depression.

But did staying at home cause the depression, or is it the case that people (of either sex) with fragile MH are more likely to opt out of the workplace?

Urcheon · 24/01/2024 16:19

MrsMarzetti · 24/01/2024 15:31

Not everyone has a career, some just go to work and as OP hasn't told us which job she does. I am pretty sure your MH and the care of your offspring are far more important considerations, if not why bother having children in the first place?

SAHMs statistically have poorer MH than WOHMs, with more reporting depression.

MrsMarzetti · 24/01/2024 15:31

Usernamen · 22/01/2024 15:56

One shouldn’t only focus on incremental earnings in the present to determine whether to continue or abandon one’s career after children. Future earning potential and pension are more important considerations for a parent deciding whether or not to stay in the workforce.

Not everyone has a career, some just go to work and as OP hasn't told us which job she does. I am pretty sure your MH and the care of your offspring are far more important considerations, if not why bother having children in the first place?

Thinkbiglittleone · 24/01/2024 14:31

SnapdragonToadflax · 24/01/2024 00:33

Could someone please tell my 5 year old he should be asleep by 6.30pm? 😂 Tonight he was still wide awake and chatty at 8.30, I had to sing my entire repertoire of lullabies to get him to sleep.

Im one, and most my friends who have kids his age, My DS who is 6 would be shattered if he was still awake at 8.30pm, especially if he had to be out the house by 07.30 like the OP. He would be a disaster after a few days with school . He has one late night a week (8pm), but that's at the end of the week so doesn't really impact school as he gets to catch up at the weekend We also don't stay with him singing him to sleep, he just goes up at 6.30, ready for book and bed. But as others have said everyone is different and does what works for them, it's never "one size fits all for kids" in my experience.

OP you can only do what you can do, it does sound like it's not how you wanted it to be. It must be hard to feel guilty about it, knowing they don't want to go and there is no point people telling you not to feel the way you do.
I'm sure you have already thought of this but are there any ways you could minimise the days that they attend, maybe your partner starting later a day or 2 a week and you starting super early a day or 2 in time to finish and pick them up? They are socialising all day at school at that age, so they are still getting those skills in just being there, so maybe try a childminder, so the kids are at home and can have down time if they want.

SnapdragonToadflax · 24/01/2024 00:33

Could someone please tell my 5 year old he should be asleep by 6.30pm? 😂 Tonight he was still wide awake and chatty at 8.30, I had to sing my entire repertoire of lullabies to get him to sleep.

Stompythedinosaur · 23/01/2024 23:07

If you'd rather they were in a home type environment, than would a childminder work? Our childminder became a real part of our family, much loved by our dc and still has a close relationship now they are too big for childcare.

But, they will be fine. You aren't leaving them with strangers, you are leaving them with familiar adults they will build bonds with.

What is they alternative? My dc were sometimes tired after a long day, but that was clearly preferable to me losing my job and us losing our house or not affording food.

Runnerduck34 · 23/01/2024 23:03

Sounds very hard, It may becoming more of the norm but agree its a long day for small DC especially 5 days a week and not ideal , probably very tiring, and they do end up spending more time each week with other people than with either you or their dad.
On the plus side it could help them be socialable and more resilient -they may love it . Or they may struggle with it depends on the child and type of childcare.
Can you and DH negotiate a more flexible pattern so one of you can drop off later and start work later and the other one start work early and finish early so do an earlier pick up ? Or look at requesting a 4 day week. Salary sacrifice may not be that much once you take child care, tax , travel cost etc out of it.
Can either of you WFH at all to make days shorter?
Can you or DH look for a more flexible jobs to improve work life balance?
However feeling guilty isnt good for you, does their dad feel guilty? Mum guilt is awful all you can do is the best you can and no parent is perfect, you sound like a lovely mum.

Mamabear2424 · 23/01/2024 22:24

Is this every day? If so Id try and see if you can change things ?

converseandjeans · 23/01/2024 22:12

YABU to feel guilty if that's what you need to do.

Can either of you afford to drop a day a week? I don't see it as just the Mum's role. However it depends how much you need the money from you both working full time. I'd prioritise spending time with them over new car, holiday abroad etc. You never get those years back & can both go FT once they are a bit older.

I'm not being sexist. I just think it's a long day x 5 every week.

Giantwaterbottle4 · 23/01/2024 21:57

DryIce · 23/01/2024 09:19

Also parenting these days is very intensive - people like to extol the virtues of prior years where they headed out on their bikes with a gang of friends and just had to be home for dinner! For some reason this is presented as wholesome and lovely, not neglectful. But somehow the same concept in a school hall after 3.30 is shameful and guilt inducing

This is such an interesting and valid point! Thank you

OP posts:
Tessa92 · 23/01/2024 13:26

Well no I agree that that wouldn’t be ideal either - it was just the way things were I suppose. Let’s be honest there never will be an ideal solution and in many careers taking 10 or even 5 years out is certainly not an option. Unfortunately choices have to be made - for fathers as well as mothers- and we should of course continue to campaign for cheaper, high quality childcare.

tiggergoesbounce · 23/01/2024 11:37

If a kid is going to bed at 6:30, a SAHM isn’t spending the majority of the day with their school aged kid either – so why bother with the differentiation?

Why is this quoted at me ??? I never did mention SAHP ?? What on earth are you talking at me about ?

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/01/2024 09:29

Tessa92 · 23/01/2024 08:30

It has not been the norm for ever. When my children were young 30–35 years ago very few mothers worked full time. When I was a child very few mothers with children at home (up to 18 years) did. My mother did work once her youngest child went to school and I did the same - part time and flexibly.
i know times and economics have changed but I really wish that those with under 5s who don’t want to work didn’t have to. I would have been so sad to have missed those years with my children - even though it was boring at times and we had very little money.
This is where the idea of universal income would work so well.

Edited

I'm not sure that would be the ideal either. Women have fought so hard for equality, including within the workplace but we still aren't 100% there yet and if it was made optional for parents with under 5's to work, it would be largely women who would take that up. It would make it more difficult for women who did want to continue to work because companies would be looking at women of childbearing age and think why bother? they'll get pregnant and stop working for 5 years.

MojoMoon · 23/01/2024 09:25

DryIce · 23/01/2024 09:19

Also parenting these days is very intensive - people like to extol the virtues of prior years where they headed out on their bikes with a gang of friends and just had to be home for dinner! For some reason this is presented as wholesome and lovely, not neglectful. But somehow the same concept in a school hall after 3.30 is shameful and guilt inducing

This is very true

Rose tinted glasses somehow have mothers of the past dedicating 24 hours a day to nurturing their children AND kids being sent off the play independently from a young age.

Tbh after school care which involves interacting with a range of other children, arts/crafts, games, sports, imaginative play with a group, reading etc is providing a lot of stimulation and development for kids and keeps them off screens

DryIce · 23/01/2024 09:19

Also parenting these days is very intensive - people like to extol the virtues of prior years where they headed out on their bikes with a gang of friends and just had to be home for dinner! For some reason this is presented as wholesome and lovely, not neglectful. But somehow the same concept in a school hall after 3.30 is shameful and guilt inducing

vivainsomnia · 23/01/2024 09:17

This was my situation too as a single mum. My youngest also found it a bit harder. It continued until they started secondary school and could walk to school and come back on their own.

When they were in their late teens, I asked them to be totally honest with me and to tell me if they wished it had been different. Both of them looked horrified at the question and said that they had a lovely childhood, that they didn't mind going to wrap around care and holiday clubs, that it taught them self-discipline, they learned to make friends easy and ultimately, it allowed me to work FT, earn reasonable money that meant I was able to give them many opportunities and wonderful memories of great holidays.

Their words. Don't feel guilty.

MinionKevin · 23/01/2024 09:11

Things will improve, the children will stay up later and the summer will come and the evenings don’t feel so short.

I think what you need to do is sit with your husband and see if you can sort out that you do pick them up earlier one night a week. Even see if it is something you can work out with work that you have a slightly earlier finish one night.

Didimum · 23/01/2024 08:40

tiggergoesbounce · 22/01/2024 21:22

@pointythings

It's the one that gets thrown at working mums everywhere. The 'you aren't raising your own children', the 'you're farming them out to strangers'. And it's nonsense because as a parent, you still spend the majority of every single day with your children

You say that but its not true if in the OPs situation the kids are out the door at 07.30 and not back in until.5pm - at their age they are in bed by about 6.30 - thats just fact. I have never said that in derogatory way, its just fact. You can have a mum do more in an hour than another in 6hours.

That is what I object to - the fact that you are agreeing with the poster who posted the same old sneer

Its not a sneer, in this case its true for the working week

And a sneer is exactly what it is

Its not a sneer, its fact for the week they use wrap around care.

An implication that as a working mum, you're doing it for the 'luxuries', and that if you only cut your cloth, made sacrifices, you'd be able to be a SAHM. That is what needs to stop because it is NOT TRUE

Wow, i never said any of that or agreed with saying working mums do it for luxuries or anything about them making scarafices to be a SAHM - what on earth are you on about ??? i didn't say that

I clearly say its a balancing act. I say its an individual choice, i say it doesn't matter what anyone on this thread thinks it what the OP thinks that counts .

And of course there are some working parents out there who can't do breakfast or homework - people who work shifts are an obvious example

Yes as i highlighted because you are grouping working mums all the same listing off what they do as if there is a mum checklist- there isnt - i say they are no less for not being able to do those things

But you are supporting the contention that they are lesser parents because they do not stay at home

No i didnt- no one mentioned anything about staying at home - that didnt even enter my quotes at all !! So please stop adding your frustrations on to me. Only quote me on what i say.
I didnt even think the OP was talking about staying at home ???

That is what has to stop

No, it has to stop that you are jumping on me for things i haven't said.

If you have a more nuanced view then don't support or agree with people who judge working mothers - because the reality is a lot more nuanced than 'you aren't there for them'

Did you even read my post - i don't judge working mums - i made it clear that the OP should only care about how they felt about it are they not other people on here trying to tell them they are wrong or right when every circumstance is different. The OP says this is not how she envisaged parenting, so i asked about her - no sweeping statements, no judgments at all. You have it sooo wrong.

If a kid is going to bed at 6:30, a SAHM isn’t spending the majority of the day with their school aged kid either – so why bother with the differentiation?

This guilt is only so large at this point in time because society is in a transitional period of it becoming more common for both parents to be out at full-time work. We therefore don’t have decades behind us to say that something is ‘the norm’ to not let ‘guilt’ come into it, or to see the effect of what full-time hours of childcare have on a young person. Who knows, maybe they will be positive – they may end up more confident, socialised, resilient beings. Something moving from uncommon to common over time isn’t inherently bad.

What if homeschooling by your SAHM was once the societal norm and then one day out-of-home schools popped up? You can bet women would have been criticised for sending them to schools too. But formal schooling is the norm, therefore it’s fine, even though gasp you are allowing strangers to educate and care for your child for double gasp 6-6.5hrs a day.

Tessa92 · 23/01/2024 08:30

It has not been the norm for ever. When my children were young 30–35 years ago very few mothers worked full time. When I was a child very few mothers with children at home (up to 18 years) did. My mother did work once her youngest child went to school and I did the same - part time and flexibly.
i know times and economics have changed but I really wish that those with under 5s who don’t want to work didn’t have to. I would have been so sad to have missed those years with my children - even though it was boring at times and we had very little money.
This is where the idea of universal income would work so well.

Itsmychristmasdress · 23/01/2024 08:27

I work.in an ASC. I think it's child dependent there are some children we have who can't handle it and it makes me sad. Crying, not engaging with others etc. Others live it and have all their bestie around them. They are much loved by us and they love us all too!!

Notimeforaname · 23/01/2024 08:18

Unfortunately its normal. And very much needed in a lot of cases.

I worked in a nursery for a few years and it was shocking how much time these children spent with us. Many from 7.30am - 6.15pm when we closed.(always had complaints/requests about closing time and could we stay open it to work around work commitments.

For extra money I often brought some of the children home and babysit for the night while parents had other commitments and I'd I'd see their routine..almost 12 hours at creche, come home, few minutes to play, dinner, bath, story bed by 7.30/, mental
.
.

If kids are away from you that long because you have to keep a roof over their heads, feed them and cant afford to work less..fine. but if its just to have "me time' or extras that aren't actually needed, then I feel its unreasonable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread