Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my life is always harder as a parent in this scenario?

508 replies

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:28

I think maybe I am but… here goes…

I parent our 17 month old alone. Ex pays but sees her as and when. Usually it’s for a day or day and night a week, she never goes to his as he just doesn’t have the right stuff for her there. I feel put upon massively, I am stressed on nursery run, dealing with online food orders, trying to clean around work, I never feel I have a moment to myself.

A good friend who I really trust said recently, very delicately, that when I moaned about these things as if it was only me because of being single, that others in the wider friendship group felt they couldn’t share how hard they find things when I’m around. I was surprised by this as I genuinely believe as a couple life with one child is pretty easy? I never consider anyone in a relationship with a child could find it harder than me, I imagine it being plain sailing. AIBU?!

OP posts:
PissedOff2020 · 23/01/2024 10:23

Too many variables here. Do you work full time or not? If your friends in two parents households all work full time, but you don’t, then they may be finding it just as hard. How many hours parents are working is a massive factor in how hard juggling life is.
As a mother who’s always worked full time, as has my husband, life is difficult to juggle. We have 4 children, on top of that the only family of a very ill 87 year old who lives a 40 minute drive away & constantly in and out or hospital. Trying to fit in hospital visits, shop, cook, clean, work, ferry kids to hobbies, spend time with the kids…. It’s relentless.

We all have stuff going on.

We don’t get nights off being parents, it’s constant. When the kids I’d sometimes feel envious of friends who got a night off a week, imagine a full nights sleep? Or a day to yourself and not being at work?

Parenting is just hard full stop. Like many have said, it’s not a competition and some kids are easier than others too!

Circe7 · 23/01/2024 10:06

Objectively there are negative effects on children (on average) of being from a single parent household. Poorer academic performance, more behavioural problems, more health issues, poorer career prospects etc. This does not, of course, apply to every child from a single parent family and there are a multitude of reasons these issues but it is very clear in the data. There are also obviously groups of children who are disadvantaged for all sorts of reasons including being in a household with an abusive parent, which is no doubt more damaging than living with a non-abusive single parent.

A whole thread on mumsnet which talks about how being a single parent is comparable to having a partner who gets home late from work (which it objectively isn’t in that children who have a parent who works late don’t have the same poorer life outcomes on average) or that it’s easier because you don’t have to negotiate about who does the washing up is unhelpful.

For every single parent who is feeling empowered at making every parenting decision herself there are probably three who are really struggling due to poverty, difficult ex, issues with the children or just exhaustion. I suspect the demographic on mumsnet tends towards the former.

Policy could address the disadvantage suffered by children from single parent families, much of which is related to poverty and lack of parental attention/time or poor maternal mental health but in many cases it does the opposite in the UK. It definitely won’t change most people have the attitudes on this thread (and this is on a site for mothers).

It’s probably just because OP was insensitive to her friends and people are defensive about being told their life is easy when it isn’t but it’s not necessary to make the opposite argument about how easy single parenting is to make your point.

KmcK87 · 23/01/2024 10:04

I’ve been a single parent with zero involvement from dad, no money, no contact and I’m now parenting as part of a couple. I would say overall single parenting is harder but parenting with a partner also brings difficulties. For instance, my partner works ALOT, 6 sometimes 7 days a week, but he does loads when he’s home. Sometimes we end up arguing through tiredness/ stress with the baby and that on top of dealing with a baby can be more difficult. Sometimes we disagree on how to parent as well, I liked being able to make all the decisions on my own.
Parenting is hard full stop.

Iwasafool · 23/01/2024 10:02

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:32

@STARCATCHER22 yes I know people have struggles, I’m usually very understanding. I suppose I just think how can it be harder than being alone.

My husband was in an accident at work that left him disabled. I sat in Consultants office when he was told he would never get better and was likely to be in a wheelchair within 10 years. Some days he screams with pain.

When we had that meeting I had a 10 day old baby on my lap and my 2 year old was with my mother. I had to go back to work fulltime when the baby was 8 months old so I had a fulltime job, a baby, a toddler and a disabled husband to care for.

So yes I think I probably had it harder than you but I just got on with it.

HowNice23 · 23/01/2024 10:00

Notwithstanding lone parenting is a ballache (I've been divorced for 7 years and current partner is a long distance relationship so essentially have managed my now teens for majority of the time) being in a couple can be stressful and lonely. Not everyone pulls their weight or wants to manage things the same way. Hopefully in time your child can stay with their dad for longer periods to give you some much needed respite.

Nicolaluu · 23/01/2024 09:59

You worded it badly it’s not pretty easy in a couple but I’ve been a single parent and after a big gap I now have a baby with my husband and it is significantly easier in a couple than on your own.. I think you need to talk to your friend though and reassure them that you can see they have difficulties too and are there for them to also vent. It’s not a competition and being friends is about being there for each other

justteanbiscuits · 23/01/2024 09:46

Are you that person that when someone else says they're finding x or y hard, you come back with how it's much harder for you??

Everyone has struggles.

SimonBolivar · 23/01/2024 09:37

i have the same dynamic with my very very close friend. She has 2 kids, and has them half the time. I have 3 kids and with my husband all the time. She had an argument with her teen at the week end and found solace talking to “an adult” who had sone distance to it. She told me and my other friend “you don’t know how hard it is all the time alone” withiut an adult to share

and that’s true

the issue I see in your case with your fiends is that you’re locked into a “comparison” of circumstances when what you need, each, is to listen to what’s going on for each, and see how you can help support. Your friends may have tensions with their partners and quarrels with how and when to do things that drains too…

really listening to each other experience, without judgement is tough. But it’s worth it. As is telling your story without comparison to what you imagine other people life to be.

those in couples will have to negotiate the how the when and the what with the other parent daily. That drains also, but in a different manner

we are linked - not ranked

JadziaD · 23/01/2024 09:35

Also, I think OP that you need to realise that whether or not someone else's life is objectively easier or harder than yours, doesn't mean they don't have the right to express that disatisfaction or stress. And it sounds like that's what's been happening - your friends don't feel comfortable telling you when things are hard for them.

It's like the competitive tiredness thing - I have zero time for working parents who pooh pooh non parents in the office if they complain they're tired. It's such bollocks. Just because you don't have a baby, doesn't mean you can't be tired, whether or not you are AS tired is irrelevant, you're still feeling it.

HarrietStyles · 23/01/2024 09:35

How would you feel if another single Mum said to you:

”It must be plain sailing for you, your ex contributes financially and he has your child one day a week. I don’t get any money from my ex and he never sees our 3 kids. It’s much harder being me and your life looks easy to me.”

That’s how your friends will feel about you.

There are always people who have life easier and harder than you, regardless of their relationship status. Friends listen to each others troubles and offer empathy and support, regardless of whether you deem their troubles easier than your own.

JadziaD · 23/01/2024 09:32

sorry, haven't read the whole thread but I have a friend who is a single mother by choice. And about 6 months in, she told me that listening to her NCT buddies she is 100% certain that her life is easier than theirs!

Obviously, not the case across the board. But no, being single is NOT always harder.

NerrSnerr · 23/01/2024 09:23

The thing that sticks out to me is why doesn't your ex have stuff to care for his child at his own house so he can have proper, regular access and give you the opportunity to have a break?

Allyliz · 23/01/2024 09:20

I had 2 children with a man who thought that good parenting involved going to work at 8am after getting himself up, coming home at 5 to shower and change and then going out to pubs and activity clubs till close to midnight. Add to this the fact that he was very tight with money and resented spending time with his children...I didn't tell people as I was married and everyone assumed I was OK. He's been gone for many years now thank god but being in a dysfunctional couple can be just as hard as being a single mum

Ozzbozz20 · 23/01/2024 09:17

I’ have a partner but we have 3 children, two being under 3, my partner works M-F out before we wake up and when he gets home he’s knackered but does still pull his weight reasonably. That means I am parenting two young children alone for 12 hours a day 5 days a week. Add onto that I work nights twice a week, neither younger child sleeps, and I still have to manage the household, cooking, cleaning, laundry. It’s bloody hard hard work! Yes being a solo parent of course is challenging but doesn’t mean couple parents have it plain sailing!

BusyMummyWrites01 · 23/01/2024 09:17

Agree with most of the posters here - that you have a skewed perception.

I have two teens on the spectrum, one with significant MH issues, but am happily married. We both find it excruciatingly hard and at times have wondered whether our marriage would last or whether, by divorcing, it would free one of us to have something akin to normal. Both my kids will eventually go to university (although we suspect one will live at home for most of that time), so its not a SEN scenario, but we do not anticipate one of them ‘leaving home’ [or, thus, ‘Parenting’ to be over ever].

Even amongst my friends with NT kids, struggling with two working parents, elderly/sick parents, cost of living concerns, health concerns as they age (breast cancer, etc) and the usual puberty/exam/post covid stuff has been extraordinarily stressful.

Parenting is hard. Doing it alone is hard. Doing it with someone else and sharing the joint but additional burdens that brings is hard.

Anyone who claims it’s easy (over an 18-21year period) is either deluded or lying. But what keeps us going is that we love our kids and the stress is balanced (mostly) by the love and the fun moments they bring, their successes and watching them grow into young adults both because of AND in spite of us. That, and wine.

Stephne2 · 23/01/2024 09:15

thebestinterest · 23/01/2024 00:35

Yes, it’s hard even in a two parent home but I’m certain it’s a lot harder parenting alone.

e.g, I do get breaks throughout the day, everyday. DH will take our 17mon old on walks to the park (which usually lasts 1.5-2.5 hours depending on what he has going on), he’ll also watch her in the am after breakfast for about 1.5hrs, and then again at night before bed, where he’ll play blocks and sing and tire her out with dancing. I also get about 30min for a bath. In addition to this, he brings her to library hour occasionally.

your friend is being unreasonable because no matter what anyone else has going on, they can still share their experiences!

If someone is getting that much input from their DH then obviously it’s going to be easier than being a single parent but in my experience the majority of fathers don’t have the time or inclination to do as much your DH. Not that they don’t care but if they’re busy earning money to support their family they’re often tired and then a good portion just don’t fall that far along the spectrum of being inclined to do as much as your DH. Not to mention those that are positively unhelpful (you’ll still see these fathers plastered over FB or in public looking like the most involved loving fathers in the world despite the reality behind closed doors being very different ) These aren’t just isolated cases, this is very very common. When I was single parent I was amused and slightly perplexed that so many of my married friends actually admitted they were jealous of me. It wasn’t until I was brining up a child in a relationship that I totally understood. When you are in a good relationship it is easier but it still rare to have someone as involved as your DH

Hoolahoophop · 23/01/2024 09:13

The struggles are different. My DH works long hours so I do the majority of the childcare, cooking, homework etc. I do the breakfast rush, the bedtime routine etc. But if I need him to just be there while I pop to the shops so I don't have to take DC then I can at least on the days he WFH.

On the other hand I have an extra person I have to plan around, when is he WFH, when is he in the office, who is eating at what time each night.

Then there is always the compromise, when we do have a moment because DC is asleep we have to agree on what to put on the TV, or what to do, or go our separate ways to do what we want to, but not too often or what's the point of being a couple. So the free time is never truly your own.

Then there are always the small differences in parenting, again, compromise to ensure that the kids are getting the same message, talking to ensure you are on the same page.

I would not want to be a single parent, I love my family as it is. But I wouldn't say it is easier. When DH is away it doesn't feel any harder, just difference.

The big advantage of parenting as a couple who work well together is emotional support. When DC is ill we are both there to share the worry etc.

And I'm sorry to say that at late primary I still find the involvement very, very full on. Driving to clubs, supervising homework, cooking, keeping clothes washed, keeping on top of the endless diary of school requirements.

Its fun though.

Phoenixfire1988 · 23/01/2024 09:06

Inneedofadvice12 · 23/01/2024 00:55

Currently on holiday with husband of 3 years and daughter who’s 14 and our son who’s 1.
first night here and my husband decided to stay out till 0530 the next day with his friend and came home a mess after taking ketamine. I was furious as I am in Asia with my kids on a family holiday and he left us to ourselves.
Another night my son wasn’t happy about being out during the evening and I was poorly with a uti, and I’m currently pregnant.
I told my husband that the 1 year old needed to back to the room abs he decided not to come but to stay drinking with his pal. Despite me being poorly.
last night we went to a rooftop bar for dinner, my son had been up the night before with a temperature so wasn’t himself. The venue was extremely loud with a dj playing and just not a family place so after food I took my son away to chill while they carried on drinking and then we got a taxi after about an hour. In this time I’m walking around with my son in a stroller to keep him happy and relaxed. In the taxi during a standard conversation my husband snaps and says ‘what the fuck is wrong with you today, you’re moody!’ I was in shock and didn’t even argue back. He embarrassed me and when we got out the taxi I asked him what was wrong but he was still snapping at me. I told him I was going back to the room and he shouted ‘chow, go on, fuck off!!!’ Everyone in the lobby of the hotel could hear so I was super embarrassed. He then decided to stay out again until 0400 the next day.
this is so out of character for him as at home he’s actually boring and never does anything.
what should I do? I feel really disappointed and upset and that he isn’t prioritising me, the kids of helping me at all.

You need to tell him to sort his sh!t out immediately instead of sitting there all meek and taking his b0llocks remind him this is supposed to be a FAMILY holiday and all he's done is leave you with the kids while he gets w@nkered he might be having the time of his life but he's ruining it for everyone else and if it carrys on he's going to be going home single and he can be a selfish pr!ck all he wants then .
You seriously need to be firm with this one not let him walk all over you while making a huge tit out of himself the only embarrassing thing is not standing up for yourself and allowing him to bully you , YOU are not the embarrassment here he is

Imisssleep2 · 23/01/2024 08:58

Everyone's situation is different and to say a couple raising one child have it easy is very narrow minded of you.

Until recently myself and my partner, we are together, raise our 3year old together. We care for him along with working full time, my partner 37.5hrs a week, myself a minimum of 42.5hrs a week (I worked Flexi hours), it was hard at times, really hard, when stressed with work, toddler tantrums, life admin to sort, shopping to do etc. there was no time for me to have any time to myself at all.

3yo is now at school mornings Mon to Friday, and we have a new born, so it's no easier, I Def couldn't manage two alone, but your not looking after 2, just one.

To be so "poor me" without considering other people's situations, doesn't make you a great friend/listener, it's not a competition, we all have different struggles at different times, it's what we have to do as parents.

Blueflower1612 · 23/01/2024 08:54

As a single parent where the father is not involved, I can appreciate you saying how hard life is. However I think you are being inconsiderate to think that your friends don’t have problems too just because they have two parents and they should be able to talk about whatever is concerning them. You should listen to them and allow them to talk because that’s what a good friend does. It isn’t a competition about whose life is the hardest.

Ifeelsolow247 · 23/01/2024 08:54

I parent three children alone, one of those is severely disabled.
Most of the time I cope fine, but there are days when I would give anything just to have someone to share the load with, a shoulder to cry on etc etc.
It's that feeling of being alone that hurts more than anything during the tough times.

That said, I am in a better position than I was a few years back when I was trapped with a highly abusive partner/ father of my children.
I am so thankful that I finally found the courage to break free, and in all honesty I would be perfectly happy to spend the rest of my life alone as my son's carer.

ImCamembertTheBigCheese · 23/01/2024 08:45

I'd say that you friend is gently telling you to read the room.

ChangeAgain2 · 23/01/2024 08:45

You're making huge assumptions. You're assuming that their partners are actually doing something other than adding to their workload. You only need to read a few posts on MN to see that, for some women, a lot in my circle, the distribution of labour in the household is unfair. They are living in the 1950s, doing all the childcare and housework while also working full time. Unfortunately, having a partner doesn't mean you have a partnership.

123sunshine · 23/01/2024 08:41

Having been married with 2 children, then divorced and sole parented for 5 years then remarried, I would say there are some things that are easier in a relationship with kids and some that are easier being single parent. I think the toughest thing I found as a single parent was the sheer among of time in my own company, it’s lonely and isolating. Kids went to bed when young by 7:30-8 the the whole evening spans ahead of you by yourself. Likewise when they go to their dads there is sound solo time. Even when had kids at weekends it always felt like everyone is with their families at weekends, so loneliness was the toughest thing. However being in a relationship with kids either with the children’s bio parent or step parent also brings other challenges. So on balance no one way with easier or harder. Also a lot depends on the factors of the personalities involved.

Sals22 · 23/01/2024 08:26

I’ve done it both ways, I honestly found it easier as a single parent, there was only myself and the babies to look after, I didn’t have to worry about sharing expenses, worry if we/he was coming home to a bomb sight, no schedules to align, not worrying I wasn’t putting enough effort into my relationship, I throughly enjoyed it.