Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my life is always harder as a parent in this scenario?

508 replies

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:28

I think maybe I am but… here goes…

I parent our 17 month old alone. Ex pays but sees her as and when. Usually it’s for a day or day and night a week, she never goes to his as he just doesn’t have the right stuff for her there. I feel put upon massively, I am stressed on nursery run, dealing with online food orders, trying to clean around work, I never feel I have a moment to myself.

A good friend who I really trust said recently, very delicately, that when I moaned about these things as if it was only me because of being single, that others in the wider friendship group felt they couldn’t share how hard they find things when I’m around. I was surprised by this as I genuinely believe as a couple life with one child is pretty easy? I never consider anyone in a relationship with a child could find it harder than me, I imagine it being plain sailing. AIBU?!

OP posts:
Mumkins42 · 23/01/2024 17:36

I think it's all about the language you're using. As a massive generalisation, I believe single parent life is much harder. But, your post comes across a little wo is me and completely ignorant of the struggles other people have. Even if your struggles are greater on the whole - people don't respond well to this approach in life.

Ourlittletalks · 23/01/2024 17:18

OP, I’m a single mum of one child. Her dad doesn’t help out at all, and I know several single mums who have absolutely no help (financial or otherwise) from their children’s father. Your life sounds quite cushy to me, having someone else take over responsibilities for an entire day or day and night each week.

I work full time, I’m 26 weeks pregnant with baby number 2, I pay all my own bills, rent, etc. however, I remember when my brother and his wife had their first child. They were a couple and they struggled so much that someone in the family would have to take their child every weekend to give them a break. They found it more difficult as a couple with one child than I did as a single mum with one child.

I think your attitude is unreasonable. Yes, as a single parent you will have different struggles and will have a more difficult time parenting just because of financial issues, childcare issues, etc. but that doesn’t mean that your life is at all times more difficult than the others around you. It’s not a competition.

Janeypr24 · 23/01/2024 17:14

I think the important thing to remember is that parenting, and life, is not a competition. No one has the monopoly on how hard things are. Even if you feel other friends on the surface have it easier than you - they still need to be able to express their frustrations in their own lives, however trivial you may feel they are. My husband and I separated when my kids were 9 and 4. But one of the things I realised I had after that was a freedom my couple friends did not have. I didn’t have him questioning my parenting or life decisions - I wasn’t rowing with him about petty stuff as a lot of my friends were - and I really liked that. Your child is young and that is hard. But your friends will appreciate it if you are a happy listening ear - not a judgemental mate who thinks they’ve got it easy.

Topsy44 · 23/01/2024 16:45

I totally agree with AnethystSparkles. Being a. single parent with no support it is all on you and that is exhausting,

Mariposa99 · 23/01/2024 16:35

“Plain sailing”, as if.

AmethystSparkles · 23/01/2024 16:26

Well all other things being equal, of course it’s much harder being a single parent. Granted, one of the couple may be ill etc, but as a single parent with no support you’re constantly stressed because it’s just you and if you’re ill you’re buggered. Social support is a huge factor in longevity.

Also, most single parents have actually been part of a couple, and obviously not happily hence the separation. So they actually have experience of both situations.

GirlsAndPenguins · 23/01/2024 16:05

I just can’t deal with this thread 😂😂
I’m not saying being a single parent is easy, I’m sure it’s extremely hard. But having children is extremely hard! Working parents, even with support still have to run around sorting childcare, work, uniforms, packed lunches. My husband is extremely supportive…I still feel like death though ☠️🤦🏼‍♀️
To be honest I’m part time and even my days off are no walk in the park so I know that being a stay at home parent is no picnic either! Xx

saoirse31 · 23/01/2024 15:58

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:32

@STARCATCHER22 yes I know people have struggles, I’m usually very understanding. I suppose I just think how can it be harder than being alone.

For many Id say parenting alone is far easier, you dont have to deal with for example abusive spouse etc

user1495054098 · 23/01/2024 15:49

My husband moved out when my daughter was 13 months and my son was 4. I actually found my life easier after that as I didn't have to deal with him as well as the kids!

webs1991 · 23/01/2024 15:48

Hi there some times it is hard to see pat out own lives and struggles because we can’t see from anyone else’s perspective but you do sound a bit self absorbed and maybe reflect and even just listen more to your friends as it does sound maybe as though I’d your friend is having a hard time or time to chat through their problems it might be you are the kind of person who interest if listens tried to relate by sharing a similar story but sometimes people don’t want to hear your similar story or struggle they just want to be heard and validated (I do this to and I have become now aware of it). I’m in a happy relationship and the days we both have our one child as in the date we are both off work al together I actually find HARDER than when it’s just me and my son and the reasons are just silly things like of my partner is off I will get annoyed if he doesn’t so something to share the load even though he can be doing a billion other things, or most times I usually make all the plans and if he’s off I’d like him to make a plan for what we do but he’s he happy just lounging aroind so when we waste the day I get a bit annoyed but nothing major or even things like lunch if you are just making for you and wee one it just seems easier and quicker to do that than figure out lunch and tidying up around your partner etc tbh that’s not even real stuff I can’t really think but it’s just different from being alone basically because when it’s just you and wee one you’re in your own rhythm kinda thing. Ultimately we’ve all got our own struggles and pressures we can put on ourselves as well so I don’t think really anyone or very many people any way have it plain sailing.

MoreDollies · 23/01/2024 14:51

I think you're being brave and naive to ask.

I say this because you are making a judgement on the ease of something in a very binary way, when life really isn't like that. And you're risking the friendships you do have with that judgemental approach

A single parent with a massive support network might have it much 'easier' than a couple with no support network. Or any of the multiple issues that any individual could face, as an individual or as part of a couple.

Besides which, 'easy' is relative.
Unless you walk in their shoes, you have no real way of quantifying and qualifying how 'easy' some people might find their situation.

Everyone being a parent doesn't mean we are all on the same journey. We're not all in the same boat. And because our children are also all unique, we not even in the same storm as each other. And how 'easy' we find it will also depend on our individual resilience and support network too.

You may be wise to stop comparing your circumstances with others, it's not a competition and your friends should be able to tell you their woes without worrying if you're secretly assuming they should get over it because your life is way worse...

Yummers8 · 23/01/2024 14:37

Being part of a couple can be hard work in itself sometimes for so many reasons.
You sound quite self absorbed.
But then you don’t have to consider other people’s feelings as part of the fabric of your everyday existence do you?
I think you’ll be happier with your life if you can be more empathetic.
And sort out your baby’s father to be more useful. He can get the equipment he needs quite cheaply at a charity shop.
Then perhaps you can stop being the victim and enjoy the child that you chose to have.

Daisies12 · 23/01/2024 14:20

YABU. It's not a competition. A lot of people, single or couple, have issues. Surely friends should be sympathetic and help each other.

chloe1656 · 23/01/2024 14:18

Am in a couple - we have 2 children, I do all the things you do except with two children. My husband works a lot, I work. - we haven’t had a night off since our youngest was born 14m ago….

absolutely have you moan but don’t think you have the hardest life and no-one else struggles - trust me it’s not “plain sailing” for us couples either.

and absolutely trust me when I say there are still others out there who have it a lot worse!

Wherearethewaves · 23/01/2024 14:13

The grass isn't always greener on the other side- my partner is at times a brilliant dad, but has serious mental health issues, last year he had 3 major crisis episodes of being suicidal, and a number of bad times in between, he was not able to work for over 4 months and as self employed no income during that time. I spent most of the year wondering if he would have hurt himself when I got home that day, if he would be alive, how I would tell our children if he was not, how I would support their grief through the rest of their lives, how I can best support our kids through the times that he's in crisis, do I take them away from someone who's a great dad to them when he's well, to protect them for when he's unwell, having worked part time to bring up the kids how do I bridge the financial hole to keep us afloat? In those times every spare minute I have is spent on the phone to medical services for him, the school support team for the kids, carers support, psychologist appointments, days spent in minor injuries or hospital when he's hurt himself, trying to catch up on work hours missed etc, and on top of that I'm running the house and family solo, not able to plan support becasue I never know what's going to happen that day. In my case it would certainly be easier to be a single parent with an ex that contributed financially and had the kids a day a week. From the outside you'd never know, you'd see us walk down the street on a good day and think what a normal, happy, lucky family we were. Things are not always as they seem. But I still appreciate that my friends have tough times. I'm still there for them when they need me. I share what I have and give what time or support I can, I listen when they're having a hard time. Maybe it's not about comparisons of whether things are harder for you, or for your friends, maybe it's about them being there for you when you need them, and you being there for them when they need help.

bonzaitree · 23/01/2024 14:08

OP are you one upping people?

They will just be having a general moan and then you say “well I don’t have any support …..”

Maybe work on your listening skills and let them vent without bringing the conversation straight back to you.

Ilovesmesomefriedchicken · 23/01/2024 13:56

to be completely honest you & your friends don’t seem very supportive to eachother. It shouldn’t matter “who has it hardest”, you should all be able to talk about & support eachother when any of you are having a difficult time. I don’t see why it needs to be a competition as to who technically has it hardest. All circumstances faces issues & problems, they’re just different. Nobody should ever minimize what somebody else is struggling with, since we all have different coping abilities across a wide range of things. What one finds difficult or stressful another might thrive & vice versa. If you & your friends can’t support eachother without it being a competition then it’s toxic & not a nice healthy friendship.

Riverlee · 23/01/2024 13:41

There was a similar thread on Munster recently. Someone summed up the responses. If I recall,

Singles have it easier
Singles have it harder

Couples have it easier
Couples have it harder

If you are a single parent with family around, who can help with babysitting, school runs etc, you could have it easier than a couple who dh commutes and is out most of the day, and then is too tired to help in the evening, without any family support.

It probably took a lot for your friend to say this to you. I mean this kindly, but do you monopolise the conversation (probably unconsciously) about your struggles?

Stephne2 · 23/01/2024 13:33

BluesBird19764 · 23/01/2024 10:56

I watched single parent friends get tons of support from family, other friends who were much more likely to step in and give that person a break as opposed to me as part of a couple. I had no parents/family who took DC over night where as single parents could arrange for ex to take the weekend leaving them free for nights out/lie ins. Every situation is different, every one struggle’s sometimes. Kids grow up and we all have to get on with it.

This is very true, my family are great but definitely, since now in a happy marriage the support/dynamic has changed totally. They don’t feel they have to ring, visit, invite me over or give my children any additional input, pay for travel or meals for me (not that have got any more money now 🤣) fair enough as they’ve got their own lives to deal with but has made me realise how much they and other people did go out their way to try and help because I was a single parent

Babyboomtastic · 23/01/2024 13:31

There are so many different factors that contribute to making it harder/easier, being a single parent is just one. For example

+1
Single parent
Multiple children
Financial difficulties
Disabled child
Disabled parent
Other stresses in life
The other parent being useless or working away
Caring responsibilities for other family members

saffy2 · 23/01/2024 13:13

One of the hardest things I’ve found is differences in parenting. Each having a different stance on how things should be done, what should be said, how a situation should be handled, what pocket money should entail, what independence a child should have, chores the child should have, bedtime, bath time, timings, hobbies. Literally everything can be disagreed on when you have two different people trying to parent from the same space.
when you’re on your own you do things your way and that’s it. That’s not my situation now. Now my situation is I say for example, right bedtime needs to be at 7pm because xyz and he says, 7 really that seems early, I’d say 7.30. And then it’s not a given, there has to be a discussion there has to be an agreement. It can’t just be my way and it can’t just be his way. And so instead, often it takes awhile to get to a point of right this is what we will do with this. And often neither of us feel happy or that we are doing it the way we think is right.
i miss having total autonomy over my own parenting. I took it for granted when I was a single parent. I too often yearned for support, one time my son was struggling to breathe and I was sat crying and thinking if only I had another adult here to tell me, take him to the hospital that’s the right thing. Now I’m in a couple, and the only time since we began living together that I’ve had to make a decision like that he was at work and wasn’t even here. So I still had no support for that situation. It’s not as you think it is op. And not because he isn’t pulling his weight, or he’s a crap parent. But because everyone likes to do things their own way, and everyone has jobs. And 3 peoples dishes/cooking/laundry is more than yours and a child’s.

saffy2 · 23/01/2024 13:03

I now have two. But I was a single parent for 8 years with my first. I found it infinitely easier to be a single parent with 1 child than in a couple with 1 child, or in a couple and pregnant, or in a couple with 2 children (I have a large age gap so not like two small children). Im currently pregnant with my third.
literally everything in my life was easier when I was on my own. Parenting with someone else in the house is really really really difficult, housework, organisation etc literally every single thing is harder with two adults.

Yoga817 · 23/01/2024 12:56

I had a friend that constantly went on about how difficult their life was due to being a single parent to the point where she sounded angry with me for being single and alleging that I ‘had it so much easier then her’. She had a nanny and was paid significant amounts of money by her ex. I had terrible health problems at the time and was trying to juggle full time work, paying a mortgage whilst having a chronic health condition, so my life was certainly not easy. I also did not know if I would ever have children. If I ever wanted to talk about my struggles I would constantly get slapped down by her hard life. Suffice to say she is no longer my friend.

Crishell · 23/01/2024 12:51

I suppose my life is quite 'plain sailing' compared to others around me who have much bigger problems. I have one child, a husband who pulls his weight, work part time.
As a result I often feel awkward if I need to have a moan about something.

It's a shame really, because I don't have a perfect life. I have quite severe health anxiety actually but I wouldn't dare talk about that in front of someone who was struggling to put food on the table.

Should you only be allowed to moan about the big stuff?

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/01/2024 12:48

All things being equal then yes of course its far harder being a lone parent than for a couple.

But there are lots variables....disabled child, abusive relationship etc..