Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my life is always harder as a parent in this scenario?

508 replies

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:28

I think maybe I am but… here goes…

I parent our 17 month old alone. Ex pays but sees her as and when. Usually it’s for a day or day and night a week, she never goes to his as he just doesn’t have the right stuff for her there. I feel put upon massively, I am stressed on nursery run, dealing with online food orders, trying to clean around work, I never feel I have a moment to myself.

A good friend who I really trust said recently, very delicately, that when I moaned about these things as if it was only me because of being single, that others in the wider friendship group felt they couldn’t share how hard they find things when I’m around. I was surprised by this as I genuinely believe as a couple life with one child is pretty easy? I never consider anyone in a relationship with a child could find it harder than me, I imagine it being plain sailing. AIBU?!

OP posts:
bombardelli · 24/01/2024 22:12

Sorry your ex is a shit, it’s disgusting that men can get away with doing so little, but why are you moaning constantly to your friends?

Regardless of who has it worse constant moaning is enough to put anyone off.

Your problems are not more important just because they are yours.

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 22:11

Surely if it's a much easier way of bringing up children it would also have a great impact on the children as parents less stressed etc, someone needs to tell the govt this so they can start prompting it as a healthier way of life...

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 22:09

Ok so being a single parent is sooo much easier, don't need to negotiate with a partner, and get free time when they go to the other parent (if you're lucky), awesome! So why is it still stagmised in our society, and the minority family type?

Blondebrunette1 · 24/01/2024 22:00

I have four children and a husband so I can't compare having just one child but my husband and I don't stop and in fairness have a lot less than a day's worth of support & free time per week. I wouldn't be annoyed if you told me you have it harder than me but I'd think you were a bit ignorant if I'm honest. No one knows what life's like for others, people find different things difficult/easy, some children's needs are greater than others, financial situations vary. Too many variables to judge but we all do, I have friends who are single parents that have so much time for themselves, their new partners/hobbies etc, it's hard not to think they have it easier x

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 24/01/2024 19:16

I've never been a single parent OP but I can relate a bit as I had an extremely difficult child. Even with DH there. I became very exhausted and bitter. If a friend was complaining about a child being up teething or not eating i honestly felt like ridiculing them as their challenges were just silly and short term compared to what I dealt with every day. But I didn't of course I just nodded along sympathetically. My friend was single and despite all the shit she put up with she had a much more 'plain sailing' experience than me at that time and she knew it. Its all relative. But yes a happy couple with supportive family nearby on good income and with a healthy average baby don't know now lucky they are.

Terfarina · 24/01/2024 19:14

I am in a very happy marriage with a partner who has always done loads of childcare - realistically more than me.

I STILL found it easier being a single parent (5 years) because here are no debates - who is doing bedtime, school runs, how to deal with tricky teens etc.

I am relieved to see so many women echo my experience - that single parenting can be amazing and much easier than when coupled.

Particularly for single parents where the other parent regularly takes the child/ren so you get a sustained and regular period of time to yourself - very few marrieds have that.

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 19:03

Stephne2 · 24/01/2024 18:50

I think what you don’t realise when you’ve only been a single parent is that this mythical partner who takes anywhere near 50% of the load off you is as rare as hens teeth as is a partner who does not bring their own work or issues/disagreements over parenting etc. I’m lucky enough to be in a very happy marriage but DH is definitely not this mythical creature and it’s not all roses. Among my friends who don’t even have such a happy marriage , they still wouldn’t consider themselves to be in a bad marriage, abused etc, it’s just normal

Bringing up children is always going to be tough, but if you're with a partner that is actually making your life harder (ie It would be easier without them) I think it's time to evaluate the relationship.

Stephne2 · 24/01/2024 18:50

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 18:00

Maybe she didn't realise your relationship was in difficulty (sulky man child etc), I think most people would agree it's easier on your own than with bad relationship.

I think what you don’t realise when you’ve only been a single parent is that this mythical partner who takes anywhere near 50% of the load off you is as rare as hens teeth as is a partner who does not bring their own work or issues/disagreements over parenting etc. I’m lucky enough to be in a very happy marriage but DH is definitely not this mythical creature and it’s not all roses. Among my friends who don’t even have such a happy marriage , they still wouldn’t consider themselves to be in a bad marriage, abused etc, it’s just normal

Tigernoodles81 · 24/01/2024 18:19

I'm married and my husband does about 10% of childcare, school runs, club taxis etc. I work full time from home in a senior role. It's really hard and exhausting. Parenting in general is exhausting whether you are coupled up or not.

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 18:00

T1Dmama · 24/01/2024 15:59

Have to say this sort of attitude really pisses me off,
I have a friend, who like you always moaned about ‘how hard it was for her’ .. how I didn’t understand because I had a husband … I pointed out that he was rarely home as he worked away and I did everything alone…. (She has the support of various family)..
she went as far as only holidaying with other single mums, ‘because they understood’…
Im now also single and have to say I find it MUCH easier! I can simply please myself and my child without having to consider a man’s wants, I’m not constantly trying to keep 2 ppl happy… It’s hard work having child(ren) plus a sulky man child.

Maybe she didn't realise your relationship was in difficulty (sulky man child etc), I think most people would agree it's easier on your own than with bad relationship.

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 17:59

T1Dmama · 24/01/2024 15:59

Have to say this sort of attitude really pisses me off,
I have a friend, who like you always moaned about ‘how hard it was for her’ .. how I didn’t understand because I had a husband … I pointed out that he was rarely home as he worked away and I did everything alone…. (She has the support of various family)..
she went as far as only holidaying with other single mums, ‘because they understood’…
Im now also single and have to say I find it MUCH easier! I can simply please myself and my child without having to consider a man’s wants, I’m not constantly trying to keep 2 ppl happy… It’s hard work having child(ren) plus a sulky man child.

Maybe she didn't realise your relationship was in difficulty (sulky man child etc), I think most people would agree it's easier on your own than with bad relationship.

T1Dmama · 24/01/2024 15:59

Have to say this sort of attitude really pisses me off,
I have a friend, who like you always moaned about ‘how hard it was for her’ .. how I didn’t understand because I had a husband … I pointed out that he was rarely home as he worked away and I did everything alone…. (She has the support of various family)..
she went as far as only holidaying with other single mums, ‘because they understood’…
Im now also single and have to say I find it MUCH easier! I can simply please myself and my child without having to consider a man’s wants, I’m not constantly trying to keep 2 ppl happy… It’s hard work having child(ren) plus a sulky man child.

regenerate · 24/01/2024 15:42

I can't stand it when people say 'he works so much I'm practically a single mum' it's not comparable

I did find it more stressful having a workaholic husband / co parent than being a single parent

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 24/01/2024 15:24

I think it's always

  • best is supportive and caring relationship
  • 2nd best is single (especially if family and friends offer you help as they know you're single)
  • worst is being in horrible upsetting stressful relationship.

I can't stand it when people say 'he works so much I'm practically a single mum' it's not comparable

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 15:22

Also when people have two weeks on their own with kids and they think they know what it's like! And decide it's easier. The grind of doing EVERYTHING on your own for YEARS is what makes it harder.

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 15:21

saffy2 · 24/01/2024 09:15

Autonomy in all those things I listed is something you’re taking for granted. I did too. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to spend money because I knew all the ins and outs and knew what was spare. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to say yeah stay up late tonight without then having to explain that choice to someone. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to make toast for dinner for myself because I couldn’t be bothered to cook and there was no one else to think about. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to be able to go for a meal out with my child and have it be cheap because I’m only paying for 1 adult meal and 1 kids meal. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to be able to make decisions for me and my child without having to consider a single other thing or person in those decisions, such as my family love 300 miles away. I can’t now just up and go and see them…because it’s not just my time, it’s not just my kids, it’s not just my money. Instead, there has to be a discussion, a plan, a check on does he have holidays to take, does he want to come, can we afford the petrol, is he ok with me going without him and taking the kids.
none of these things are because we have a bad relationship, or he doesn’t pull his weight or I view him as another child. This is all just purely because he is another adult in our family that I HAVE to consider at all times. I didn’t have that before. And that made it easier. Everything. Easier.

That's true! I do really enjoy having that autonomy.

But also think it could be a case of it being 'easier' like at work you might say it's easier just to do everything myself, whereas actually if you can delegate well, and to a trusted team, it is easier to share the load.

It would probably be 'easier' to not have any friends either as you don't need to remember birthdays, listen to their problems, arrange meet ups, but doesn't mean it's preferable or in the long run more enjoyable.

BMWM340 · 24/01/2024 10:33

I'll give you another viewpoint, from a couple.

I have a young DD. In the last few years I have battled a very aggressive cancer, resulting in long hospital admissions and being in an induced coma.
Due to all my surgeries and chemo I have 2 chronic life threading heart conditions.
I still manage to work nearly full time, as does my husband. But when I'm in hospital / sick, he is pretty much a single parent.

When I'm home we share the load, none of us are default parents.

But us as a couple are also at the moment trying to work through his infidelity, my current health conditions, finances and much much more.

If I was a single parent I'd be entitled to much (MUCH) more financial help. We don't get anything due to earning too much, despite finances being extremely tight.

I haven't even scratched the surface, and I don't need to, it's not a race to the bottom. But you are incredibly naive to think that single parents will ALWAYS have it worse off, or 'what could be worse when you're a single parent.'

Not saying it's tough for you, but there are a multitude of things that make things hard. Not just solo parenting.

thecatsthecats · 24/01/2024 09:28

saffy2 · 24/01/2024 09:15

Autonomy in all those things I listed is something you’re taking for granted. I did too. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to spend money because I knew all the ins and outs and knew what was spare. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to say yeah stay up late tonight without then having to explain that choice to someone. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to make toast for dinner for myself because I couldn’t be bothered to cook and there was no one else to think about. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to be able to go for a meal out with my child and have it be cheap because I’m only paying for 1 adult meal and 1 kids meal. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to be able to make decisions for me and my child without having to consider a single other thing or person in those decisions, such as my family love 300 miles away. I can’t now just up and go and see them…because it’s not just my time, it’s not just my kids, it’s not just my money. Instead, there has to be a discussion, a plan, a check on does he have holidays to take, does he want to come, can we afford the petrol, is he ok with me going without him and taking the kids.
none of these things are because we have a bad relationship, or he doesn’t pull his weight or I view him as another child. This is all just purely because he is another adult in our family that I HAVE to consider at all times. I didn’t have that before. And that made it easier. Everything. Easier.

I get you on this, even though I'm happily married!

I had a holiday alone and my word, it was beautiful. Simply leaving the house without worrying about ANYONE'S needs or desires or capacities was blissful.

We've got a baby now, and every so often I (unfairly) think "this would be easier without you". Which is untrue - he does so very much. But at the end of the day, he's another person with needs and views to incorporate alongside a baby.

saffy2 · 24/01/2024 09:15

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 09:01

Do the positive things he adds to your life outweigh the added difficulties of having him in it?

Autonomy in all those things I listed is something you’re taking for granted. I did too. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to spend money because I knew all the ins and outs and knew what was spare. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to say yeah stay up late tonight without then having to explain that choice to someone. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to make toast for dinner for myself because I couldn’t be bothered to cook and there was no one else to think about. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to be able to go for a meal out with my child and have it be cheap because I’m only paying for 1 adult meal and 1 kids meal. I didn’t realise how amazing it was to be able to make decisions for me and my child without having to consider a single other thing or person in those decisions, such as my family love 300 miles away. I can’t now just up and go and see them…because it’s not just my time, it’s not just my kids, it’s not just my money. Instead, there has to be a discussion, a plan, a check on does he have holidays to take, does he want to come, can we afford the petrol, is he ok with me going without him and taking the kids.
none of these things are because we have a bad relationship, or he doesn’t pull his weight or I view him as another child. This is all just purely because he is another adult in our family that I HAVE to consider at all times. I didn’t have that before. And that made it easier. Everything. Easier.

saffy2 · 24/01/2024 09:09

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 09:01

Do the positive things he adds to your life outweigh the added difficulties of having him in it?

That’s irrelevant. The post is not about can we see the positive in our situations. The post is about is it easier as a single parent or as a couple. Positivity in a life doesn’t make it easy. I haven’t broken up with him because I want to be with him, even though it is harder in many ways. I found life infinitely easier on my own but I still want to be with him. That’s why in these situations, when faced with friends moaning about their own lives I wouldn’t say, well actually it’s harder in a couple. Exactly as ops friends are finding they can’t speak to her. The point is, people choose to be in couples for many reasons, that doesn’t mean it’s an easier option. For me, it is not the easier option, it is the more difficult option. Every single thing is harder, organisation, negotiation, parenting, alone time, discussions, finances. Literally everything. No that’s not all lessened because he runs the hoover round 😂 but even if it was, it doesn’t detract from the fact that having a second adult around doesn’t automatically make life easier for a lot of people.
and as for the second opinion thing you’ve said, I gave an example above of where as a single parent I truly believed people in couples had that support, and then I was in a similar situation and still had to decide on my own because like many many many fathers in a couple situation, he was at work when that situation happened and so I still had to make a decision on my own about what to do, while also making a decision on what to do with my 8 year old. Because being in a couple doesn’t magically mean there are always two parents available.

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 09:01

saffy2 · 24/01/2024 08:56

But I’m living it and have lived the other life and am telling you you’re wrong. Our relationship is fine, we have a very good relationship, he pulls his weight and he is a good dad and a good partner in life. It was still easier being on my own for the various reasons I’ve listed.
i have no relationship issues, and I do not have a partner who does nothing around the house, even though he is out at work for 11 hours per day. And still, my life was vastly easier when it was just me. The same as when he goes away for work, everything is easier. Literally every single thing.

Do the positive things he adds to your life outweigh the added difficulties of having him in it?

Saymyname28 · 24/01/2024 08:57

My life became substantially easier after I left exH to be a single parent.

saffy2 · 24/01/2024 08:56

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 08:45

That's true you don't need to negotiate things and so that element is easier. Although also no one to ask a second opinion of, work things out with too..

Yes more washing to do if there are more people. But while you're doing the more washing maybe the other partner is cooking the dinner or taking the bins out, or doing bedtime?

I think if it's harder with two parents that must be because there are relationship issues on top.

But I’m living it and have lived the other life and am telling you you’re wrong. Our relationship is fine, we have a very good relationship, he pulls his weight and he is a good dad and a good partner in life. It was still easier being on my own for the various reasons I’ve listed.
i have no relationship issues, and I do not have a partner who does nothing around the house, even though he is out at work for 11 hours per day. And still, my life was vastly easier when it was just me. The same as when he goes away for work, everything is easier. Literally every single thing.

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 08:52

regenerate · 24/01/2024 07:28

@Scotcheggsontoast what is your situation?

Had a useless DH and chucked him out. Yes things felt a lot easier once he was gone (especially initially), but I also realised all the little things he did do that I took for granted. He also had MH and alcohol issues and didn't work though so that's the main thing that was adding the stress rather than the bickering over what time bedtime should be / what the child should eat for dinner.

Scotcheggsontoast · 24/01/2024 08:45

saffy2 · 24/01/2024 07:28

And nobody is actually saying that parenting in a couple is the same type of hardness as being a single parent. It is different. But it doesnt mean that it is easy. It is still hard, and in my
experience harder. It is different hard, for sure. It
is not that I cant pop to the shops at 8pm if I need to, but it is that I can’t decide for myself that bedtime is x, or this school is the right school, or this weekend we will do
this or even, this is the cheese we will buy. I can’t just bung on some washing and it’s all done, because there is more washing in the washing basket etc etc.
it is not the same, and it is not the same type of difficult. But it is still difficult. And for many women for different reasons it is more difficult.
i also spent 8 years on my own…I find having someone always there incredibly irritating, we struggle a lot with physical space because I need my own physical space a lot. And you don’t get that when you live with another adult 🙈😂 I also like silence…again you don’t get that when you live with another adult!! Another example of how hard it is, different hard but still very hard.

That's true you don't need to negotiate things and so that element is easier. Although also no one to ask a second opinion of, work things out with too..

Yes more washing to do if there are more people. But while you're doing the more washing maybe the other partner is cooking the dinner or taking the bins out, or doing bedtime?

I think if it's harder with two parents that must be because there are relationship issues on top.

Swipe left for the next trending thread