Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my life is always harder as a parent in this scenario?

508 replies

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:28

I think maybe I am but… here goes…

I parent our 17 month old alone. Ex pays but sees her as and when. Usually it’s for a day or day and night a week, she never goes to his as he just doesn’t have the right stuff for her there. I feel put upon massively, I am stressed on nursery run, dealing with online food orders, trying to clean around work, I never feel I have a moment to myself.

A good friend who I really trust said recently, very delicately, that when I moaned about these things as if it was only me because of being single, that others in the wider friendship group felt they couldn’t share how hard they find things when I’m around. I was surprised by this as I genuinely believe as a couple life with one child is pretty easy? I never consider anyone in a relationship with a child could find it harder than me, I imagine it being plain sailing. AIBU?!

OP posts:
edissa · 22/01/2024 09:43

I've done both - I've been a single parent and I'm now parenting as part of a couple. Pros and cons to each scenario. I had challenges as a single parent that I don't have now as a couple, and equally, I have other challenges now that I didn't have as a single parent. 🤷‍♀️

Caszekey · 22/01/2024 09:41

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:32

@STARCATCHER22 yes I know people have struggles, I’m usually very understanding. I suppose I just think how can it be harder than being alone.

So o lu the person with the biggest complaint is allowed to moan?
I moan about the washing (three boys) and my mate goes omg yeah tell me about it (two girls). I don't snort and tell her she can't possibly understand my hard life because she only has to (generally clean) daughters and I have three (generally grubby) boys so how dare she speak to me of her problems!

ToMeToYouAndBack · 22/01/2024 09:41

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:32

@STARCATCHER22 yes I know people have struggles, I’m usually very understanding. I suppose I just think how can it be harder than being alone.

Living alone with a child is easier though surely? You only have yourself to think about. You aren't worrying what he is doing or trying to do stuff for them.

Stop looking at others and assuming they don't have problems

StragglyTinsel · 22/01/2024 09:41

Nonomono · 22/01/2024 09:20

Saying a single parent had it easier, or just as hard as a 2 parent family is so offensive though.

Surely you can see that someone in a 2 parent family, who chooses to remain in a 2 parent family, they obviously have it easier else they would just leave.

You can have a challenging relationship but still benefit from being in a 2 parent family, which is why so many people DP choose to stay with a partner they’re not happy with.

Most people do not choose to be a single parent.
To imply that they are lucky and have things easier than a 2 parent family is such a slap in the face.

Maybe we all benefit from appreciating the ways we are lucky.

I’m a single parent with a waste of space STBXH who only makes things harder. Focusing on how much harder things are for me than everyone else helps absolutely no one.

Yes I am frazzled running around and skint from paying nursery fees and everything else. I have a disability. I can’t afford a car. Etc etc.

But I have a good job that pays well and has potential for career progression. My children are healthy. I get the basic rate of CMS from STBXH (to the penny and no more). I can afford to heat my house, eat, pay for things I think are important. All of these are huge positives and not everyone has this.

my 3 year old sleeps well. This is a big thing. He didn’t always sleep well and I can remember the sleep deprivation. So when my friend was talking about her problems with her children who do not sleep well at the weekend, I listened. I sympathised. I recognised that she’s sharing something that is hard for her.

I didn’t sit there thinking ‘well you’ve got a nice partner who helps and you don’t have to go to work; my life of harder because I’m a single mum’. No. I didn’t even consider what level of sympathy the misery Olympic category merited (if any, because she’s married so isn’t allowed to complain).

If this OP’s friends are raising that they feel they can’t talk about their lives because she is dismissive and only interested in how hard things are for her, then she has a problem. Starting a thread seeking validation of her position that her life is just harder suggests she’s missed the point.

SleepingStandingUp · 22/01/2024 09:39

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:28

I think maybe I am but… here goes…

I parent our 17 month old alone. Ex pays but sees her as and when. Usually it’s for a day or day and night a week, she never goes to his as he just doesn’t have the right stuff for her there. I feel put upon massively, I am stressed on nursery run, dealing with online food orders, trying to clean around work, I never feel I have a moment to myself.

A good friend who I really trust said recently, very delicately, that when I moaned about these things as if it was only me because of being single, that others in the wider friendship group felt they couldn’t share how hard they find things when I’m around. I was surprised by this as I genuinely believe as a couple life with one child is pretty easy? I never consider anyone in a relationship with a child could find it harder than me, I imagine it being plain sailing. AIBU?!

Is me doing the washing when DH entertains the kids harder than you trying to do the washing with a kid hanging onto your leg? Probably not.
But that doesn't mean there aren't other things which aren't harder, or even just hard too. It isn't too trumps.

You don't have a parent undermining you, refusing to help with the kids but making a shit ton of mess, you might have easier dynamics with family or at work, or with money. But also, as I said it isn't about top trumps. Sometimes life's just hard.

We have three, good DH but I'm permanently exhausted. If I wanted to moan about being tired in your friendship group would you counter it with how much more tired you are because you're a single parent? If I moaned about being fed up of the constant clothes washing, would you tell me how much harder you have it?

You might say no but your friends comments suggest otherwise.

How often are your gripes labelled as "because I'M single" so there's a hard line your friend's can't pass?

TawnyT · 22/01/2024 09:39

Also, just to add. I'm sorry you're parenting alone and finding it tough. From what little you've said it sounds like you have a good group of friends that are trying to be considerate of your feeling about being a single parent by downplaying their own struggles. I hope you can foster that friendship group and gain support from them. Things will get easier as DC gets older, stick in there and look after yourself as best you can. You're raising a whole human being in your own! It's a wonderful thing but it's a mammoth task to do alone, you're doing great.

OMGitsnotgood · 22/01/2024 09:38

I worked with a single parent who had the same view as you, that people parenting in couples had it so much easier that she just dismissed any issues I was having - so I just stopped talking to her about them.

Of course, having an extra pair of hands and someone to share practicalities with does make a difference and from that perspective it is easier. And I can appreciate that all the responsibility falls to you so it can be stressful.

But as a couple, you also have twice the washing; twice the food prep; two lots of time talking about each others days etc. All normal family stuff and nothing to complain about at all - but there are demands on a couple's time that you don't have. Any issues with the children aren't halved because there are two of you, although any associated practicalities can be shared and
you always have someone to talk to so the stress can be reduced.

Also you might not know their home circumstances. i had friends whose husbands worked very long hours or worked away, so they were effectively single parents during the week, and weekends were spent trying to catch up with jobs and squeeze in a weeks worth of family time.

Well done for starting this thread and for listening to what people are saying. I don't doubt that your life is tough as a single parent, I'm glad I never experienced it, so hats off to you. But I have experienced a colleague's daily moans and dismissal of any of my issues as I am lucky enough to be in a couple.... so I do get where your friends are coming from too.

applepiesain · 22/01/2024 09:37

Far too many variables within family set ups to think this way.

We tend to discard the myriad of possible difficulties in other set ups and focus on our own individual difficulties, not realising that sometimes, by not having something we inevitably can't have the problems that often can be associated with it.

Eg. I don't have help or input from relatives.
What I immediately see around me is helpful grandparents and involved aunts and uncles all playing a role in bringing up the children. Woe is me that I and my kids don't have this.
What I don't see is the judging moaning grandparents who are less than enthusiastic about helping and lose patience with the kids as a consequence, or the irresponsible uncles who didn't think they'd bother with a car seat, or thought they could leave the kid with a mate while they popped to the shops.

You don't have a partner, fine. Obviously there are difficulties with this, but you've also eliminated all the possible detriments that go along with having one.
Don't compare your situation to the imaginary "perfect family" that very rarely, if ever, exists.

teatimeplease · 22/01/2024 09:34

Anyone can find being a parent hard regardless of who's around them. It's not a competition of who has it harder! You can all have it hard at the same time/different times/for different reasons.

TawnyT · 22/01/2024 09:31

Hi OP. Lots of comments saying life with a useless man is harder than single parenting.

But just wanted to chime in with some of the things I've found difficult with a good man, that a single parent may not have had to deal with. Navigating differences in parenting styles (while sleep deprived and cranky), managing eachothers mis-matched physical intimacy needs, managing eachothers mental health, factoring in another person's calendar and persinal finances, deciding on what to spend money on as a household, dealing with in-laws, finding time to do things as a couple, finding time to do things on our own

All this to say you're right that some aspects are easier, but some of it is harder too. We all have different parenting experiences and each is difficult in its own way. Like PP suggested, it's probably worth practicing a little more listening, ask other parents what's going on for them and try really hard just to listen and sympathise and not chime in with your own complaints until the conversation turns to you. (As an aside, I actually find this really hard to do in general myself and I'm currently reading the book 'How to make friends and influence people' that discusses how to make the conversation about the other person and not yourself, worth a read of you can manage it, I'm listening to the audio book version as its easier to fit in around time with DC/work)

SpringleDingle · 22/01/2024 09:30

I've been a couple with a small baby and am now a single parent to 1 kid following my divorce. It was easier for me to be a single parent. My exH was no help whatsoever - all he did was make jobs harder, pile on the guilt and add to my workload.

It sounds as if you have a very one sided view of life in a couple. There are many reasons that a couple with a kid can be having a very hard time of things!

Passingthethyme · 22/01/2024 09:29

Have you not seen all the threads on here with fathers who do nothing? I don't doubt being a single parent is hard if you have a great partner, I imagine it's a different story when you have a bad one

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 22/01/2024 09:28

Nonomono · 22/01/2024 09:20

Saying a single parent had it easier, or just as hard as a 2 parent family is so offensive though.

Surely you can see that someone in a 2 parent family, who chooses to remain in a 2 parent family, they obviously have it easier else they would just leave.

You can have a challenging relationship but still benefit from being in a 2 parent family, which is why so many people DP choose to stay with a partner they’re not happy with.

Most people do not choose to be a single parent.
To imply that they are lucky and have things easier than a 2 parent family is such a slap in the face.

It can be easier or it can be harder. My married friend has it easier as a married couple than she would have if she was single but that still doesn't negate the fact that I as a single parent have advantages that mean my life is easier than hers as a married couple.

It isn't as black and white as you are making it out to be

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 22/01/2024 09:27

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:32

@STARCATCHER22 yes I know people have struggles, I’m usually very understanding. I suppose I just think how can it be harder than being alone.

It seems being alone in this is something you find really hard and those feelings are valid, it is hard, but that doesn't mean that someone in a relationship will find things easier. I have a lot to deal with, disability, , abusive ex, children with SEN, could go on and have had friends say they feel their problems dont compare and I always say that if they're finding things hard they are hard and I mean it and want to be there for them. My struggles don't negate theirs. My pain doesn't lessen someone else's.

My first barley slept, for 12 months I was surviving on sleeping no more than 40 minutes at a time, macimum 6 hours a day, this was with Stbxh pre everything going to shit. He helped a bit, would it have been harder without him, I doubt it because of how he started treating me. I found that period harder then I do now being a disabled single mum to 3 primary school children with SEN. Im not saying those things to compare to what you're going through. If you are finding things hard they are hard, but the fact your friends aren't doing it on their own doesn't mean that they can't be struggling.

anywherehollie · 22/01/2024 09:24

I was a lone parent for 7 years and then I met my now husband who (more than) pulls his weight with the kids. It's a million times easier with him around. That's just my experience though.

Nonomono · 22/01/2024 09:20

regenerate · 22/01/2024 08:40

so now it’s a two parent family with a nanny

i was quoting your specific point about two parents

and having parented as a couple and as a single parent… i find it infinitely easier as a single parent

what is your experience of either?

Saying a single parent had it easier, or just as hard as a 2 parent family is so offensive though.

Surely you can see that someone in a 2 parent family, who chooses to remain in a 2 parent family, they obviously have it easier else they would just leave.

You can have a challenging relationship but still benefit from being in a 2 parent family, which is why so many people DP choose to stay with a partner they’re not happy with.

Most people do not choose to be a single parent.
To imply that they are lucky and have things easier than a 2 parent family is such a slap in the face.

Mariposistaaa · 22/01/2024 09:19

Suffering competitions are really damned annoying OP. You need to rein in your moaning around your friends or they will get fed up. It’s like the classic ‘I’m tired’ ‘ohhhh what right have YOU got to be tired’ that we have to put up with with a colleague at work

Workawayxx · 22/01/2024 09:18

I’ve parented v small dc single and in a relationship (2 different dc) and think there are easier and harder bits to both and it depends very much on the relationship and the partner. Many many don’t pull their weight but still make demands so it’s like having extra housework/washing etc without the person covering much. They may still expect you to be default childcare leaving you feeling resentful that they get to swan off on “important errands” while you’re left juggling home and child. all that while they still expect to have input on what you eat, how to deal with child etc etc. of course in many relationships it is easier (I’m not doubting how hard it is for you at all and have been there) but it totally depends on the situation.

financially may be easier depending on partners salary and how good they are with finances. I’m probably worse off with tiny dc in nursery and partner than when I was single as get no UC now and nursery fees are expensive.

I would just try and remember it’s not a race to the bottom and it might help you to feel better about your situation if you listened to some friends issues and try and focus on sone positives of your position.

jannier · 22/01/2024 09:18

Are you someone who if someone said they are ill instantly say yes you had that but worse and list your ailments? Because that seems to be your empathy level with parenting

Diamondcurtains · 22/01/2024 09:18

I have a husband but in the early days I did 99% of the parenting. Just because there’s a partner doesn’t mean most if the parenting doesn’t fall on one parent.

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 09:17

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:38

Thanks. I’ve definitely got in my head that anyone in a couple has masses of support etc and I feel I’ve got a huge gap in my life.

Lots of people are in bad relationships with partners who make things harder not easier. Plus there could be many aspects that are difficult. No doubt the average single parent has it harder though.

You are coming across as open minded on this thread though - maybe the issue is with your friend. She might be imagining your life is easier than hers in some aspects, who knows.

Londonrach1 · 22/01/2024 09:12

Parenting is hard end of story. I think a single parent potentially has it easier as you can do things your way. So your job is easier than your poor friend who has to think about another person wants and needs...how that make you feel op... Yabu. As I said at the beginning parenting is hard and making a sweeping statement like you did and I typed doesn't help. Everything struggles in different ways.

MuggleMe · 22/01/2024 09:09

My DH has a chronic illness and my eldest DD has ASD and MH issues, and bickers relentlessly with my younger DD. I still think you probably have it harder as I have the emotional support and DH does what he can, but you don't have the monopoly on hard times.

If their only child doesn't sleep, or is constantly sick, or showing signs of additional needs, or miserable at nursery, they need to be able to chat about it.

Roadtripwithkids999 · 22/01/2024 09:07

I think OP has tried to divide people by starting this thread over who has the worst life.

I nearly fell into it to say well my life is x,y,z and is also hard. But everyone's life is hard in different ways. It's not a race to the bottom, no need to compare, no need to be jealous, no need to think you are better because you are struggling so you must be a better/stronger person.

Just be bloody nice to each other and if someone needs a vent or a shoulder, lend it.

RaccoonOnTheSofa · 22/01/2024 09:02

EweCee · 22/01/2024 08:33

Parenting is hard. I am in a couple and we work well together as parents and I'm grateful for that. However, I have a BIG job, my child does a LOT of activities (professional gigs etc), my DH is self employed so it is always full on - 24/7, 7 days a week. And we get NO outside support at all. So I look at my single parent sibling who gets my mother on hand all the time for all after school and holiday (and cleaning, cooking, animal care etc etc) and every 2nd weekend child free to go on dates with her partner and weekends away etc - and I think, yes it's tough being sole decision maker as a single parent but you get WAAAY more free time/ adult time than I ever do.

What’s a “BIG job”?