Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think my life is always harder as a parent in this scenario?

508 replies

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:28

I think maybe I am but… here goes…

I parent our 17 month old alone. Ex pays but sees her as and when. Usually it’s for a day or day and night a week, she never goes to his as he just doesn’t have the right stuff for her there. I feel put upon massively, I am stressed on nursery run, dealing with online food orders, trying to clean around work, I never feel I have a moment to myself.

A good friend who I really trust said recently, very delicately, that when I moaned about these things as if it was only me because of being single, that others in the wider friendship group felt they couldn’t share how hard they find things when I’m around. I was surprised by this as I genuinely believe as a couple life with one child is pretty easy? I never consider anyone in a relationship with a child could find it harder than me, I imagine it being plain sailing. AIBU?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Flippingnora100 · 02/02/2024 19:08

I think whether you are being unreasonable depends on what it is about you that is making your friends feel like they can’t complain about their lives. If it’s a genuine sensitivity towards your situation, that’s one thing. If it’s your attitude/response when they try to talk about their own situations, that’s another. Maybe do some self-reflection around how you respond. If there’s anything dismissive about the way you respond, then you have your answer.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 28/01/2024 13:57

Realdeal1 · 28/01/2024 08:28

Isn't op just saying its harder being alone than when there are two full parents who are actively doing the parenting and sharing the load. I listen to my friends' issues, many of whom have partners but I do think you have someone to share it with whereas the buck stops with me. Most recently two extremely rich lawyers with two children. The mother is tired on maternity leave because she's carrying one baby plus her shopping. Husband was at work but generally a brilliant dad too. People cooing about how tough it must have been for her.

Secondly another raving about how she managed two nights/morning school run without husband who was away for work.

Of course, having a shit partner is different but when you have someone who is sharing the load, of course its easier

No. She said "always harder". She has also followed up that she very much thinks being part of a couple with one child is very easy and straightforward. And in some cases it might be. But not always. People have piled on because of the attitude of her life always being harder.

Pootle23 · 28/01/2024 08:38

You must be a real joy to be around not.

You can’t blame your couple friends because of your poor choice of partner to father your child.

He needs to grow up, little one needs some clothes and somewhere to sleep at his place, doesn’t need anything else so not sure why he can’t look after his child.

Lighrbulbmo · 28/01/2024 08:34

Many people post on here about their useless partners. Raising a child with a dead weight doesn’t make it easy. It’s harder.

Realdeal1 · 28/01/2024 08:28

Isn't op just saying its harder being alone than when there are two full parents who are actively doing the parenting and sharing the load. I listen to my friends' issues, many of whom have partners but I do think you have someone to share it with whereas the buck stops with me. Most recently two extremely rich lawyers with two children. The mother is tired on maternity leave because she's carrying one baby plus her shopping. Husband was at work but generally a brilliant dad too. People cooing about how tough it must have been for her.

Secondly another raving about how she managed two nights/morning school run without husband who was away for work.

Of course, having a shit partner is different but when you have someone who is sharing the load, of course its easier

OnTheBanks · 27/01/2024 14:46

Hankiesk · 22/01/2024 07:32

@STARCATCHER22 yes I know people have struggles, I’m usually very understanding. I suppose I just think how can it be harder than being alone.

In general it is harder being alone I would think. I am in a couple with 1 DC, having two sets of hands is great. But when my DH had a heart attack it was difficult to manage parenthood, work, and taking care of DH so I think there are ups and downs to most people's lives over the long haul.

Scotcheggsontoast · 27/01/2024 13:24

EmeraldA129 · 27/01/2024 09:12

That is exactly the point that everyone you are taking the piss out of is making. Glad you agree with them!

No not at all, I think we established quite early on that there are other factors that can change things like health issues, relationship issues, financial issues.

Of course no one can say being a single parent is the only issue that can make you're life hard! And trump's everything else. That's almost too obvious to say.

People are arguing that even if all those other things are equal, it's still harder to parent when you're in a healthy relationship, vs doing it on your own.

RosieAway · 27/01/2024 09:43

Case in point, I’m sick as a dog but as my DC’s piece of crap father (ex) hasn’t shown up, I have to somehow take to best friend’s birthday. Can barely move yet he’s told me to “find the strength?!?”. So yes it’s harder with that shit going on, but at least he’ll be around at some point to lighten the load. So actually, I’m claiming this as hardest - on your own, no support, with an abusive ex you can’t get out of the picture. Or, an abusive useless person in a couple.
It IS a feminist issue though, as the bar for men is ridiculously low, misogyny is rife and the entire system is patriarchal and skewed against women. Those who have support lovely partners often don’t realise how good they’ve got it. Perhaps that is the underlying issue here. When someone is going through it, it’s not appropriate to moan about the small stuff. Equally, I am always there to listen to my friends no matter what is happening as everything is relative

EmeraldA129 · 27/01/2024 09:12

Scotcheggsontoast · 27/01/2024 07:10

And I think the vote is that way because obviously it's not harder in ALL situations. Some people have health issues / other issues that will far outweigh the difficulties of single parenting.

That is exactly the point that everyone you are taking the piss out of is making. Glad you agree with them!

Scotcheggsontoast · 27/01/2024 07:21

It's actually sounds like it would be unfair on DC to get into another relationship,if doing so would make our lives so much harder.

Scotcheggsontoast · 27/01/2024 07:10

And I think the vote is that way because obviously it's not harder in ALL situations. Some people have health issues / other issues that will far outweigh the difficulties of single parenting.

Scotcheggsontoast · 27/01/2024 07:09

saffy2 · 26/01/2024 17:35

Come back when you’re in a relationship, and re read this thread and then you’ll see how ridiculous you sound.
i do empathise with single parents. Because I was one. And it is not easy, and I know that. Not
once have I said it’s easy. But you know that I haven’t once said it’s easy, you’re just deliberately misinterpreting what I’m saying, because you can’t begin to contemplate that maybe just maybe you could empathise with other people…which is the actual issue here. I am empathising with single parents, and I’m also empathising with parents in couples who find different things more difficult…you will not see AT ALL that your situation might not be the worst one available, and you won’t empathise with anyone else. Even though every single person on this thread has agreed that being a single parent isn’t easy.
when you have your hindsight you will feel a right idiot re reading your posts on here.
AND given the vote is dramatically agreeing that op IBU…I’m not alone in this thinking. Virtually nobody who voted has agreed that being a single parent is harder in all situations. But you can’t accept that while we agree being a single parent is difficult sometimes different situations are more difficult and difficult in different ways.

Edited

I don't think I will be reading this when I have a partner, as it sounds that being a single parent is way better so think I'll stay that way thanks! I'd only be willing to get into a relationship if on the balance of it they added positively to my life, enough to outweigh any of complications that come with being with another person.

Upandaway1000 · 26/01/2024 21:21

Scotcheggsontoast · 26/01/2024 16:51

It must be the best kept secret, coz whenever I tell anyone I'm a single parent they say oh sorry about that, and look a bit sad for me. If only they knew, we should promote it!

I'm waiting for the Daily Mail article "Single parents think they have it tough, have they ever tried parenting with a man in the house??" 😅

RaccoonOnTheSofa · 26/01/2024 19:15

saffy2 · 26/01/2024 17:35

Come back when you’re in a relationship, and re read this thread and then you’ll see how ridiculous you sound.
i do empathise with single parents. Because I was one. And it is not easy, and I know that. Not
once have I said it’s easy. But you know that I haven’t once said it’s easy, you’re just deliberately misinterpreting what I’m saying, because you can’t begin to contemplate that maybe just maybe you could empathise with other people…which is the actual issue here. I am empathising with single parents, and I’m also empathising with parents in couples who find different things more difficult…you will not see AT ALL that your situation might not be the worst one available, and you won’t empathise with anyone else. Even though every single person on this thread has agreed that being a single parent isn’t easy.
when you have your hindsight you will feel a right idiot re reading your posts on here.
AND given the vote is dramatically agreeing that op IBU…I’m not alone in this thinking. Virtually nobody who voted has agreed that being a single parent is harder in all situations. But you can’t accept that while we agree being a single parent is difficult sometimes different situations are more difficult and difficult in different ways.

Edited

I have solo parented and parented with a partner and solo parenting was way way harder for me. Is my partner perfect? No. Do I carry a majority of the mental and physical load? Yep. But having another pair of eyes so I could do xyz for two minutes has brought me a lot of mental relief to be honest.

Everyone’s situations are different. Some people on here will have found single/solo parenting harder and some will have found it easier. We cannot speak to anyone else’s experiences. I have ADHD and associated issues and dc has ADHD and I solo parented alone with no family or support whatsoever. I might tell someone with 4 kids I had it harder. They would probably laugh in my face and say I’m ridiculous but we just have different crosses to bear.

People need to stop telling others they’re wrong in this instance. Life is so personal and we all deal with different issues and we all cope differently.

It’s not a race to the bottom. Maybe if everyone stopped arguing and actually listened to each other and supported each other, maybe we’d all find parenting a wee bit easier.

Adviceplease18 · 26/01/2024 17:48

Of course lots of single parents have experienced both, most (not all) were in a relationship at some point.

saffy2 · 26/01/2024 17:35

Scotcheggsontoast · 26/01/2024 16:51

It must be the best kept secret, coz whenever I tell anyone I'm a single parent they say oh sorry about that, and look a bit sad for me. If only they knew, we should promote it!

Come back when you’re in a relationship, and re read this thread and then you’ll see how ridiculous you sound.
i do empathise with single parents. Because I was one. And it is not easy, and I know that. Not
once have I said it’s easy. But you know that I haven’t once said it’s easy, you’re just deliberately misinterpreting what I’m saying, because you can’t begin to contemplate that maybe just maybe you could empathise with other people…which is the actual issue here. I am empathising with single parents, and I’m also empathising with parents in couples who find different things more difficult…you will not see AT ALL that your situation might not be the worst one available, and you won’t empathise with anyone else. Even though every single person on this thread has agreed that being a single parent isn’t easy.
when you have your hindsight you will feel a right idiot re reading your posts on here.
AND given the vote is dramatically agreeing that op IBU…I’m not alone in this thinking. Virtually nobody who voted has agreed that being a single parent is harder in all situations. But you can’t accept that while we agree being a single parent is difficult sometimes different situations are more difficult and difficult in different ways.

Scotcheggsontoast · 26/01/2024 16:51

It must be the best kept secret, coz whenever I tell anyone I'm a single parent they say oh sorry about that, and look a bit sad for me. If only they knew, we should promote it!

Scotcheggsontoast · 26/01/2024 16:50

Well this has just made me infinitely grateful to be a single parent. Sorry all you guys in relationships it sounds awful! Off to have a stress free dinner with my little one, eat what we want, go to bed early, then a nice child free day while his dad has him tomorrow :-D

saffy2 · 26/01/2024 14:07

I think also what I’m not explaining well is that hindsight is a very important part of what I’m saying here. And hindsight is something that single parents do not yet have. I didn’t either when I was a single parent.

Exasperado · 26/01/2024 13:23

I would take single parenting a healthy, typically developing child alone any day of the week over some other alternative situations! Like being in a couple where the partner is financially, physically or verbally abusive. Where it is all left to me and I am unsupported. I'd take it being in a couple with a child who was seriously ill....there are so many scenarios where it would be preferable to be a single parent who has financial support from the other parent and also gets regular help/breaks from parenting, even if that's only one day a week.

My situation is that I am in a couple and my partner is supportive in every way. But a few years after giving birth I discovered I had a heritable condition that pregnancy made erupt and I have struggled with my health since. I have also passed it onto my 2 youngest children, who were born 16 months apart. The youngest is disabled and has developmental dealys/autism. Needs loads of practical care. The middle one was fine until teens but is now suffering in so many ways herself with both her disability and her MH and needs constant support and supervision. Our oldest died when he was a day old. I've never been able to return to work, so my husband has worked all hours while I do all the house and childcare/nursing care while he's gone, and we double up when he's home. We've never had regular support from anyone, we don't get breaks. We are knackered and overwhelmed as often as we are enjoying our kids!
Saying all that I get it is hard to be a single parent and I'd never say it wasn't. It is hard to parent at times for most people, for many different reasons. I'd never consider myself to be the only one with problems or even think I could be the only one it is hard for. I just don't get that mindset, even amongst all my own chaos 🤔😂 It's not a competition. Just don't judge until you've walked in someone else's shoes is my motto.. And listen to your friends vent without judging if they do you the honour of listening to you vent too!

saffy2 · 26/01/2024 12:47

Upandaway1000 · 26/01/2024 12:20

And yet, you still chose that life so there must be many significant factors which make that work for you. Its kind like if I take a well paid and really stressful job, yes my life was "easier" before in a low paid job but I still chose the job for the financial benefits/long term view etc. Most single parents are forced into that situation because of abuse/poor treatment/infidelity, its bizarre to see that painted as "easy".

Again people are not reading what I’m saying. I’ve literally said it wasn’t easy. I WAS IN THAT POSITION. I’ve experienced both sides in multiple ways. And it was EASIER for me in MANY ways, NOT ALL, on my own than it is to be in a couple.
Christ.

IpsyUpsyDaisyDoos · 26/01/2024 12:44

Upandaway1000 · 26/01/2024 12:20

And yet, you still chose that life so there must be many significant factors which make that work for you. Its kind like if I take a well paid and really stressful job, yes my life was "easier" before in a low paid job but I still chose the job for the financial benefits/long term view etc. Most single parents are forced into that situation because of abuse/poor treatment/infidelity, its bizarre to see that painted as "easy".

No-one is painting it as easy. Just saying that it doesn't have the monopoly on hardship. Get a grip.

RaccoonOnTheSofa · 26/01/2024 12:37

This thread has become batshit.

I think what it does prove though is that no two situations are comparable and you never know what’s going on in someone else’s life, and maybe we ALL need to listen to others when they want to talk - even if we’ve already made our mind up that they have nothing to whinge about.

Upandaway1000 · 26/01/2024 12:20

saffy2 · 26/01/2024 11:24

I think the point most people are missing on here is that those of us making the comparison are in the position to do so because we have been in a couple and then been a single
parent and in my situation, then also been in a couple after being a single parent. Not one person has only been a single parent, or only been in a couple. Which is why it’s laughable that people are kicking off so much when this is our experience. It doesnt matter what any of you think, I am telling you that my life was easier in countless aspects when I was a single parent. Especially to only 1 child. It wasn’t easy, and
nobody is saying it is, but it was easier in many respects than it is now. It doesnt matter whether you agree, I am telling you facts from my experience. And I’ve backed it up with the reasons why that is my experience. The people arguing with me do not have my experience and have not necessarily had both sides the way I have. I’ve had a bad relationship and 1 child, a single parent with 1 child, a good relationship with my 1 child, a good relationship with my 1 child and our child together, a good relationship with my 1 child, our child together and pregnant with our second child together. OuT of all of
those scenarios I found it infinitely easier to be on my own with 1 child.
and I haven’t once mentioned having time without my child…that’s not one of the things I found easier. I also don’t (and still don’t) have family support, we have no family nearby or Close enough even to see regularly. When I was on my own I was completely on my own. I still found it easier than any of the other scenarios for the reasons I have given, all which when you’re a single parent you completely take for granted, as I did.

And yet, you still chose that life so there must be many significant factors which make that work for you. Its kind like if I take a well paid and really stressful job, yes my life was "easier" before in a low paid job but I still chose the job for the financial benefits/long term view etc. Most single parents are forced into that situation because of abuse/poor treatment/infidelity, its bizarre to see that painted as "easy".

saffy2 · 26/01/2024 11:24

I think the point most people are missing on here is that those of us making the comparison are in the position to do so because we have been in a couple and then been a single
parent and in my situation, then also been in a couple after being a single parent. Not one person has only been a single parent, or only been in a couple. Which is why it’s laughable that people are kicking off so much when this is our experience. It doesnt matter what any of you think, I am telling you that my life was easier in countless aspects when I was a single parent. Especially to only 1 child. It wasn’t easy, and
nobody is saying it is, but it was easier in many respects than it is now. It doesnt matter whether you agree, I am telling you facts from my experience. And I’ve backed it up with the reasons why that is my experience. The people arguing with me do not have my experience and have not necessarily had both sides the way I have. I’ve had a bad relationship and 1 child, a single parent with 1 child, a good relationship with my 1 child, a good relationship with my 1 child and our child together, a good relationship with my 1 child, our child together and pregnant with our second child together. OuT of all of
those scenarios I found it infinitely easier to be on my own with 1 child.
and I haven’t once mentioned having time without my child…that’s not one of the things I found easier. I also don’t (and still don’t) have family support, we have no family nearby or Close enough even to see regularly. When I was on my own I was completely on my own. I still found it easier than any of the other scenarios for the reasons I have given, all which when you’re a single parent you completely take for granted, as I did.