Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH's secrets and lies

238 replies

UnicornAndSparkles · 21/01/2024 21:42

I'll preface this with the fact that DH is generally a wonderful husband and father. He in incredibly loving and patient and generous and will always go out of his way to be a real 50/50 partner, be that with early starts, sharing the parental load as best we can (he'll always get up early with the kids for instance, and does most of the nursery drop offs and pick ups despite working full time). We've been married for almost 15 years and he is my absolute rock.

But. He has lied to me, on multiple occasions, about finances. At first it was to cover up a drinking problem, which I obviously knew he had, but he wasn't ready to admit to. With a lot of support from myself and others he has overcome and is now 4yrs sober. Something I am hugely proud of him for. But that drinking problem got him into significant debt which he didn't reveal to me. When he got sober he came clean and told me of the loan and credit card debt, totalling around 10k, all repayable within 2y he said. 2y came and went and I presumed it was paid. It's now 2y on and I find out it's not repaid and there's still around 10k to repay so there must have been significantly more at the outset. His company has recently gone bust and he hasn't been paid a salary for around 6m. He initially kept this from me for 2 months, contributing to the family finances as he usually would but only now I find out it was through a credit card. Obviously this was unsustainable and we he revealed the issue we started paying all the bills from our savings, which are almost depleted. I earn money too but not as much as he does, and my salary isn't enough to cover the mortgage and childcare costs. He put off finding a new job as he was sure the money would come in. It didn't and he has admitted he should have got a new job months ago rather than only starting to look now, when we have little savings left to fall back on. He's also revealed that he's been living in his overdraft for 3y. Again, something he kept from me.

He was on a 90k salary, which to me is a huge amount, but is so bad with money that he couldn't budget his spendings. He lives a champagne lifestyle, which I presumed was because he could, but it's become apparent that he couldn't afford half of it. I, on the other hand, would rather save than spend. It gives me far more of a thrill to see savings mounting up and shop in the likes of new look than it does to buy fancy things and not have any savings. Of course I enjoyed the holidays and all the rest of the things DH was spending money on, but only because I thought he could afford it and it was never overly lavish. My salary is far below his and I obviously had a very naive view of what 90k can afford, as it's clearly not the lifestyle we've enjoyed. He's always been this way, his family joke he was always awful with money. But the issue is the lies he's told me, the fact that he's kept the loan amount and credit card bills and overdraft secret from me, whilst the debt mounts up and up. We've always said we share finances and so it came as a shock that he wasn't being open and honest with me. He says he was embarrassed about the whole thing but now I don't feel I can trust him with money and am questionning whether he really does earn £90k or that's an exaggeration, whether the total debt is bigger than the 20k he's admitted to (he initially said it was 8-10k), whether there are more credit cards with payments due. It really worries me as we share a mortgage and have two children.

The crux is I asked him to prove he was being honest with me about the level of debt he now admits to. I've asked to see bank statements showing the figures and the repayment plan. But he won't show me. AIBU? We are very close to having to ask my grandfather to help us with money when our savings run out as until he starts getting paid again my salary cannot cover all of the outgoings (grandfather is in a position to help, financially, and has offered to do so as he is aware that we are living off our savings). Or we default on the mortgage. I cannot believe we're in this situation. I feel cross that he hasn't been honest with me and cross that he didn't up sticks and get a paying job sooner when he realised the company was going bust, but I can't turn back the clock and he recognises he's been a fool. But am I being unreasonable to not be able to trust him with the finances and to want to see the debt in black and white? Or is he unreasonable not to show me the level of debt he (and realistically "we" as we are a partnership) owe?

OP posts:
Jioyt · 22/01/2024 00:39

OP, I'm sorry you're going through this. I disagree with those suggesting you leave your husband.

It's terrible that he lied, and it's a shock to discover he couldn't afford the lifestyle he led you to believe you could. BUT he is still your husband, and from what you have said, a loving and supportive one.

If it were me, I would opt for a tough conversation and encourage him to come clean. He absolutely needs to show you ALL the bank statements.

The next step would be to seek help with finding out how you can get all the debt repaid. Whether or not it's "his" debt is irrelevant. You're ALL being impacted, so it's best to look at this as a family problem rather than a husband problem.

People do stupid things. Hopefully, this is the last time he'll do this. As annoying and heartbreaking as it is, you can both overcome.

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 22/01/2024 00:34

The debt is a massive problem and I think you should get specialist help with it.

He also needs to get addiction counselling. He is simply just jumping from one addiction to the best and you can be guaranteed that without intervention there's another one coming next or he'll return to the alcohol.

I would be very tempted to leave him to it.

SwordToFlamethrower · 22/01/2024 00:17

Deal breaker. Pure and simple. He won't show you his finances and he expects your grandfather to bail him out?

Bin. Or you'll go down with him!

TreetopsSun · 22/01/2024 00:12

OP I’ve been where you are. I did exactly the same as you (took over all the finances that was the advice of the psychiatrist I made him see when his secret debt of 50k came out). A couple of years later, I took my eye off, and then 4 years later found he had incurred another 17k of debt.

You will live in a constant state of low level trauma worrying when the next “surprise” will come. I stayed for a variety of reasons (mainly I had 2 small children and was working part-time). It will grind you down and you will resent him.

5 years later (so 10 from when the 40k debt came out) he has in incurred no big debts; however, regularly overspends and has no money at the end of the month. I don’t respect him. I’ve managed to push my career on, I earn double what he does now. I think I need 2 more years before I can cover the mortgage and children’s expenses and then I will go.

If I had my time again I would have left when the first debt came out, moved in with my parents and divorced him. I was so shell shocked though and just went into survival mode.

I would be taking your Grandfather’s help to get out (either stay with family or rental).

Ponoka7 · 22/01/2024 00:07

Bankruptcy can stop you from getting jobs, especially at his level. He's an addict. He replaced one addiction with another and will again. He needs help with addiction. Some people can't get rid of addiction, so they channel it into becoming workaholics, or exercise etc. This isn't just going to go away. It sounds as though he's always lived in a fantasy world. I agree that you should talk things over with a debt charity once he's got his job offer. Personally he'd be doing anything, even warehouse work if an offer doesn't come through, or be told to get out.

Pottlee · 22/01/2024 00:04

Oh OP, sorry no advice, but just want to say I feel for you. Sounds as though you’ve got a tough road ahead, but also sounds like you’re a good person who will help your husband get the help he needs - if only he can be honest with you. I hope you and your family come through this the other side, I really do. I admire you for wanting to work through this, as I don’t feel like you come across as a doormat, and I do wonder if any of the LTB posters would actually jump straight to that themselves in the same situation - I doubt it. Good luck, I wish you the best.

Noseybookworm · 22/01/2024 00:02

I'm incredulous that you would describe a man who has continually lied and hidden things from you as 'your rock'! And he is still refusing to show you all his financial records which suggests that he has still not been completely truthful with you. I'm not sure what advice you're looking for here OP but I would do everything I could to protect myself and my children and definitely not be borrowing money from your Grandfather. You need debt advice immediately. Get in touch with Citizens Advice as a first step.

Clarinetiu · 21/01/2024 23:59

was he gambling crypto. I got myself in a bit of a situation with that.

however you need to look at the facts 90 plus commission. Let’s say it’s 65 percent on target bonus.

Probably nets 5k a month. Not going to scratch 110k that’s why you need to look at other options

R41nb0wR0se · 21/01/2024 23:58

I think you and DH really need to talk to a debt advice charity. I really hope it works out for you.
I have known people get out of debt of 1.5 times their annual salary. It's not easy, and takes time, but is doable.
It may be worth trying to get a payment holiday on the mortgage to give an opportunity to pay off any very high interest debt that can't be moved to a cheaper deal. Now that you've stopped him spending, you will need to map out the debt he has, see whether it's possible to move any of it to lower cost forms of credit etc, although this may be challenging to find.
Presumably you've cut up his card for the joint account?
Like I said above, definitely get some independent debt advice from a charity. You may also find marriage counselling helpful, and he really needs to seek help with his gambling addiction.

UnicornAndSparkles · 21/01/2024 23:53

He's massively buried his head in the sand. We had the house on the market 18m ago and were looking at bigger houses 100k+ more than ours. He kept pushing to look at even bigger ones and I was saying I don't see how we'd meet the mortgage repayments. Obviously he thought he'd win big and be able to afford it. What an idiot. He knows he's been a total and utter idiot and that it's the lies that are the bigger issue. I've told him I don't trust him not to do it again, hence me being in control of all his personal finances. Like a child.

OP posts:
Clarinetiu · 21/01/2024 23:52

You aren’t getting a mortgage with 110k of unsecured debt.

i seriously doubt anyone would be about to pay off that level of debt with that level of income.

That’s why bankruptcy is something to seriously look at.

UnicornAndSparkles · 21/01/2024 23:50

Won't getting him to go bankrupt significantly worsen our chances of ever getting joint credit aka a new mortgage if we sell up years down the line? The job he's looking to get is a similar salary but comes with commission that could go straight towards reducing the debt. I probably need financial advice on this but obviously can't afford to pay for it.

OP posts:
Clarinetiu · 21/01/2024 23:48

There is something you can do.

he has to go bankrupt. The sooner the better if he’s on 90k he is never going to get under neath from 110k.

whilst bankrupt he will never get credit and that will simplify the management of the situation for the next few years

UnicornAndSparkles · 21/01/2024 23:41

I'm so glad I posted tonight. I've been so naive.

I did an Experian report on him. Obviously he wasn't telling me the whole truth. He's £110k in debt. I did one on myself and it confirmed there's nothing in my name or our joint names. I checked and he hasn't remortgaged the house. All the debt is his and his alone. I went to confront him and he immediately confirmed what I'd found and showed me websites showing what is a serious gambling addiction. I questioned everything he told me and added it all up. He had no choice to accept it, I'd found out for myself. He started off trying to repay the alcohol debt, lost money and then tried to repay that loss. Over and over. And now £110k is gone. It's all there is black and white. The money wasn't spent on fancy things, it was gambling and then more gambelling when the initial win didn't come. What a mess.

He's handed over control of all his incoming finances to me and when he gets a new job will have our joint account as the payee and I'll be giving him money to spend and will have control of all debt repayments. Again these are his to repay and nothing is in my name or our joint names but he clearly cannot be trusted to be responsible for repayment. All of my earnings will continue to go into my sole bank account and I will transfer the percentage I pay towards our outgoings, as I have done for the past 15y. Nothing changes for my finances but I have total control over his. He offered this as he's clearly worried about me leaving with the kids. As he bloody should be.

He's blocked all the gambelling sites from his phone and laptop and home computer and I'll be checking intermittently. I feel like I'm living with a teenage boy now.

I told him if we didn't have kids he'd be out the door tonight.

I genuinely didn't think I could hit this rock bottom with a decent man. What a idiot.

I don't know what else I can do other than the above if I'm going to stay with him. He knows this is the last chance. I love him but genuinely if it wasn't for the kids I'd tell him to leave as I cannot trust him. But I do love him. This is the only issue in our marriage, and I accept it's a huge one. Hopefully having full control over finances will help regain some of this but it'll be a long process.

What else can I do?

OP posts:
Menomeno · 21/01/2024 23:25

rustlerwaiter · 21/01/2024 22:59

Your first point I agree with, the second not so much. It's not just bailing the OP's husband out, it's bailing the family out. While getting the finances at least on an even keel is doable why make it harder for everyone by not taking the help being offered.

What if Op’s grandfather gives them tens of thousands of pounds, but the debt is much worse than he’s admitting to and they lose the house anyway? GF would be throwing his money away. It’s madness to borrow a penny with no idea of how much the debt is.

2jacqi · 21/01/2024 23:23

@UnicornAndSparkles you need to take charge of all the finances from hereon in. he needs to give you access to all accounts. (I take it that it was his own business which has gone belly up?) can you take on extra hours at all. when do the children start school. when you get access to all the accounts, remove his cards and change all the passwords so only you can deal with the money. doesnt matter whose money it is. he has not cheated and some people are just useless and bury their heads in the sand. contact the credit card companies and make an arrangement now. dont hesitate or you could be made bankrupt because it also sounds like he will be owing inland revenue too. accept family help if necessary with the proviso that you will repay it when you get back on your feet. also, i am not sure how it works but you might be able to get a mortgage holiday

MrsTerryPratchett · 21/01/2024 23:17

Have you heard the expression, 'dry drunk'? Because that's what he is.

The substance isn't there but the behaviour all still is.

TheSilentSister · 21/01/2024 23:13

Save your GF's generous offer for yourself and your kids, not your feckless DH!
Honestly, if you let him bail you out, your DH won't learn. He's gone from one addiction to another and lying to boot.
You need some time apart (even a night or two) from him to reflect and see things as they are, without DH trying to manipulate you.
He's been burying his head in the sand and you would be too if you accepted your GF's offer of help.

WineIsMyMainVice · 21/01/2024 23:07

Could you see if your mortgage company can give you a ‘mortgage holiday’ for a few months? Just in the short term….

yanbu to want to see all the details and paperwork etc. that’s the least you deserve.

good luck op

HalloumiGeller · 21/01/2024 23:05

This man is not an "absolute rock" at all. He's irresponsible and deceitful, I'd be fuming if my DP had done this! We are very open about our finances and will happily show each other our bank accounts! He's not telling you the full truth, hence why he won't show you his bank statements.

rustlerwaiter · 21/01/2024 22:59

Mirabai · 21/01/2024 22:28

He’s as addicted to spending money and lying as he was to drinking alcohol.

OP you need to step up and get much tougher.

First you have to see those bank accounts. And you have to take charge of finances from now on.

Second you are not borrowing money from your gf. If your gf bails DH out here will never learn his lesson.

You can’t make any decisions until you know the extent of the debt. But if necessary, sell your house and downsize.

He’s the opposite of a rock OP, he’s a crevasse.

Your first point I agree with, the second not so much. It's not just bailing the OP's husband out, it's bailing the family out. While getting the finances at least on an even keel is doable why make it harder for everyone by not taking the help being offered.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 21/01/2024 22:54

There is absolutely more lies to come out if he's still being shifty about it.

His excuse of being embarrassed doesn't was because he's told you some of it so what embarrassment is left - he's deliberately hiding more from you.

Insist to see the extent in black and white and buff up your financial savviness because it's you that's going to have to make a plan to get out of debt if you're going to stay together.

adultchildofalcoholicparents · 21/01/2024 22:49

I speak from not entirely dissimilar experience of family members.

DH is generally a wonderful husband and father. He in incredibly loving and patient and generous and will always go out of his way to be a real 50/50 partner

He will ruin you and your family. No matter what the self-exculpation, chronic lies and deceit do not make a "wonderful" anyone. You cannot begin to deal with life properly when only one of you is willing to be part of a team and face reality.

Februaryfit2024 · 21/01/2024 22:47

You need to see his credit file.

Is his tax up to date with the dissolved business?

Don’t pay if any debts until you know the true picture and have it in front of you.

bluebird3 · 21/01/2024 22:44

IHS · 21/01/2024 22:05

You urgently need to get to the bottom of the finances and give him an ultimatum that he hands over all financial responsibility to you. You can issue him a weekly living allowance and the rest goes on family requirements and on reducing the debt. If he refuses, then start making plans to divorce.

I agree with this. I could probably forgive the spending addiction and lying IF he agreed to hand over all control of finances, agreed and stuck to a debt reduction plan and had total honesty going forward. However even that might be a stretch depending on the level of debt. If he's £30, 40, 50k+ in debt I'm not sure I could forgive that. It's just pure and simple stealing at that point from both you and your children.