Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH's secrets and lies

238 replies

UnicornAndSparkles · 21/01/2024 21:42

I'll preface this with the fact that DH is generally a wonderful husband and father. He in incredibly loving and patient and generous and will always go out of his way to be a real 50/50 partner, be that with early starts, sharing the parental load as best we can (he'll always get up early with the kids for instance, and does most of the nursery drop offs and pick ups despite working full time). We've been married for almost 15 years and he is my absolute rock.

But. He has lied to me, on multiple occasions, about finances. At first it was to cover up a drinking problem, which I obviously knew he had, but he wasn't ready to admit to. With a lot of support from myself and others he has overcome and is now 4yrs sober. Something I am hugely proud of him for. But that drinking problem got him into significant debt which he didn't reveal to me. When he got sober he came clean and told me of the loan and credit card debt, totalling around 10k, all repayable within 2y he said. 2y came and went and I presumed it was paid. It's now 2y on and I find out it's not repaid and there's still around 10k to repay so there must have been significantly more at the outset. His company has recently gone bust and he hasn't been paid a salary for around 6m. He initially kept this from me for 2 months, contributing to the family finances as he usually would but only now I find out it was through a credit card. Obviously this was unsustainable and we he revealed the issue we started paying all the bills from our savings, which are almost depleted. I earn money too but not as much as he does, and my salary isn't enough to cover the mortgage and childcare costs. He put off finding a new job as he was sure the money would come in. It didn't and he has admitted he should have got a new job months ago rather than only starting to look now, when we have little savings left to fall back on. He's also revealed that he's been living in his overdraft for 3y. Again, something he kept from me.

He was on a 90k salary, which to me is a huge amount, but is so bad with money that he couldn't budget his spendings. He lives a champagne lifestyle, which I presumed was because he could, but it's become apparent that he couldn't afford half of it. I, on the other hand, would rather save than spend. It gives me far more of a thrill to see savings mounting up and shop in the likes of new look than it does to buy fancy things and not have any savings. Of course I enjoyed the holidays and all the rest of the things DH was spending money on, but only because I thought he could afford it and it was never overly lavish. My salary is far below his and I obviously had a very naive view of what 90k can afford, as it's clearly not the lifestyle we've enjoyed. He's always been this way, his family joke he was always awful with money. But the issue is the lies he's told me, the fact that he's kept the loan amount and credit card bills and overdraft secret from me, whilst the debt mounts up and up. We've always said we share finances and so it came as a shock that he wasn't being open and honest with me. He says he was embarrassed about the whole thing but now I don't feel I can trust him with money and am questionning whether he really does earn £90k or that's an exaggeration, whether the total debt is bigger than the 20k he's admitted to (he initially said it was 8-10k), whether there are more credit cards with payments due. It really worries me as we share a mortgage and have two children.

The crux is I asked him to prove he was being honest with me about the level of debt he now admits to. I've asked to see bank statements showing the figures and the repayment plan. But he won't show me. AIBU? We are very close to having to ask my grandfather to help us with money when our savings run out as until he starts getting paid again my salary cannot cover all of the outgoings (grandfather is in a position to help, financially, and has offered to do so as he is aware that we are living off our savings). Or we default on the mortgage. I cannot believe we're in this situation. I feel cross that he hasn't been honest with me and cross that he didn't up sticks and get a paying job sooner when he realised the company was going bust, but I can't turn back the clock and he recognises he's been a fool. But am I being unreasonable to not be able to trust him with the finances and to want to see the debt in black and white? Or is he unreasonable not to show me the level of debt he (and realistically "we" as we are a partnership) owe?

OP posts:
NameChange210 · 22/01/2024 15:50

It sounds like he's accepted his actions which is a good first step.

My STBXH did exactly the same. He was apologetic for a few months but then slowly slipped back into old habits and I ran a credit check on him a few months later and found he'd taken out more credit cards I knew nothing about.
I'm not saying to leave him, but please remember you caught him out rather than him admitting everything to you. He is well versed in lying and hiding things from you. They don't do it on purpose to hurt you, but people who are like this with money rarely manage to change overnight so please protect yourself. Take care x

Mirabai · 22/01/2024 15:46

Good to hear that all the right noises have been made.

However this is only the first step OP and the easiest one. The real nitty gritty will be committing to a 12 step programme and actually sticking to it.

Wanting to and actually treating an addiction are 2 different things.

You will not know for some time whether he is sincere and even if he is whether he will fall off the wagon. It be white knuckle for a considerable time yet.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 22/01/2024 15:45

He didn't come to you to tell you about this, he left you to find out about it and lied repeatedly. You believe him that he's 'taking steps' now?

You can still love him but that doesn't mean that you have to be tied to him financially. If he had anything about him - having realised that he's created this mess - he'd be grateful for you to protect yourself and your children, insulate you and them from his mess but, he's there, like another child waiting to be taken care of.

You will never stop looking over your shoulder, living on 'hope'. Addicts are liars and your husband has proven this to you, again and again.

You've made your decision and I wish you well. I hope you're not posting back here in a year or so, wishing that you'd made another choice. Be well and be careful. Protect yourself and your children from him.

TreetopsSun · 22/01/2024 15:43

@SpidersAreShitheads your views were spot on and as mentioned above this was what I was advised to do by a leading psychiatrist in addiction - take control of all the money and monitor bank accounts. It does mean you become a mother to a badly behaved child. It drains you totally, you live on edge. I ended up having to open up post that came. My DH would lie about payments going out of account (he spent loads of money on computer games and so would buy vouchers at the supermarket and say it was groceries). I then had to demand receipts.

I think some posters have nailed it on the head here, you can’t make him change. He may say things but the fact he won’t show you bank statements/isnt presenting you with a plan (he’s gone to something like AA, he’s taken a temp job to get some money in, he’s selling his valuables to pay off debt).is a massive problem. He needs to want to change.

I alway think what will it take my DH to change, I think when I leave that will have no impact (it will be my fault “he tried to change and it wasn’t good enough for me”). Im not sure bankruptcy would help either (debts would be written off) and start again. Maybe i will be surprised and me leaving will do it - and then as I say we would have all been better off if I’ve done in the first place.

Alwaysalwayscold · 22/01/2024 15:43

Have you asked for proof that he's not lying about his job not paying him for 6 months?

UnicornAndSparkles · 22/01/2024 15:37

Thank you for all the advice.

We've had multiple discussions. He's accepted full responsibility. All the debt is in his name (thankfully, but we share a mortgage so it does impact me and I'm alive to this). He's contacted Step Change and I've seen the initial information he's shared on his account and the call log on his phone confirming he had a 32 min call with them today. He's also shown me that he's contacted Gam Care.

He's given me his cards including the joint account card that we pay our mortgage and all bills from. He has access to nothing. I will give him the money he needs, like a child. I can't believe it's come to this but it's necessary. I'm encouraging him to tell his immediate family to garner their support. He's told his sister thus far and she is alive to the fact that we both need support.

He's basically begged me to stay and has told me he will prioritise our relationship and that of our children. He has agreed to all of my terms, blocking all gambling sites, handing over all cards, allowing me to see his search history on the computer, his laptop and phone whenever I ask. He did this willingly, but I told him in no uncertain terms that if he didn't I'd be packing his bags today and he'd be out.

I need financial advice as to what to do about the mortgage we share. I don't know if it's sensible to have it in my sole name now. I don't want to come across as money grabbing but in the circumstances I can't trust that he won't remortgage without my knowledge. Obviously my priority is our kids and their security. I haven't broached this with him but he was shocked when I asked if he'd remortgaged the house or taken anything out in my name, saying he never would. And he hasn't. But I'm alive to the fact that he is an addict and so there is always the possibility. Everything at the moment is through credit cards and unsecured personal loans in his name. I have checked my Experian and there's nothing untoward. His is obviously ruinous.

Is there anything else I can do? Please don't tell me to leave him as I have decided to give him a second chance. He's an addict but he's a good person and I hope he can overcome this. He's taking steps to get help. He deserves one last chance and I have said in no uncertain terms that he will be out if he messes up.

OP posts:
Mirabai · 22/01/2024 15:16

My personal line would be to take immediate action to separate and protect finances & that of my kids with a divorce. In terms of the emotional relationship it may be possible to continue IF he manages to get himself sorted out and stick to it long term. It’s not something I would pursue, but some women want to.

LAMPS1 · 22/01/2024 15:12

OP, please don’t accept money from your family or anybody else to bail him out. You will be throwing their money away and will feel forever guilty about that.

This is a terrible situation for you but it’s only just starting and will get worse so the best thing you can do is separate yourself from him legally and financially as soon as you can ( even though you feel you can’t stop loving him) Then, you need to down-size and become completely financially independent. It will be hard but it’s all for your own protection.
Only then can you accept financial help from your grandfather as it will be safeguarded for you and the children and your DH won’t ever have access to it.

Addicts always find a way to continue and to lie. They only ever drip feed tiny bits of the truth at a time. There’s always more you don’t know about.
You trust they have unburdened it all and that you are completely in charge of finances but while you are slogging away at work and trying to stay within your tiny budget he will be growing more debt elsewhere for you to be responsible for if you remain married to him.

If you can realise that one fact now, (even though you can’t stop loving him) you will help save yourself more heartache down the line and might have a chance to save yourself and the children from utter despair. At least you and the children will have a roof over your heads.

SpidersAreShitheads · 22/01/2024 15:06

TitusMoan · 22/01/2024 14:49

@SpidersAreShitheads said OP will have to treat him like a child and monitor everything for a very long time

With respect, because I’m sure you mean well, this is terrible advice. Futile.

I think maybe my meaning didn’t come across terribly well.

My point was with the level of deceit there is, that’s the only way to make sure he’s not lying again. And checking up to this degree is not really desirable, practical, realistic, or sustainable.

In no way was I suggesting this as a recommended course of action. I was pointing out the futility of staying with him.

pikkumyy77 · 22/01/2024 14:57

F

TitusMoan · 22/01/2024 14:49

@SpidersAreShitheads said OP will have to treat him like a child and monitor everything for a very long time

With respect, because I’m sure you mean well, this is terrible advice. Futile.

TitusMoan · 22/01/2024 14:45

Can I echo what ttattooedlady said. You cannot manage his addiction. You cannot fix him. You will also drive yourself mad trying. Get legal advice, go to StepChange, go to Gamcare and treat the whole situation as if he will never be able to stop. If he eventually does sort himself out, all well and good, but in the meantime you need to assume that he never will. That is the only way of proceeding.

Addicts lie and lie and lie. You would be wrong to think that now you’ve found out about his gambling that it will stop. You have just got more lies coming your way.

LakieLady · 22/01/2024 14:18

So sorry your "D"H is putting you and your kids through this.

You've had great advice upthread, I hope you're able to take it.

FWIW, it would be a deal breaker for me.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 22/01/2024 14:11

CharmedCult · 21/01/2024 21:50

He's lying about his salary and he's lying about his debt.

You'd be insane to borrow from your grandfather to pay off his debts.

You should focus all of your energy on extricating yourself from any financial connection to him. Get the house sold and downsize, preferably alone.

Tell your grandad to keep his money for now, divorce your husband and enjoy any money gifted to you from your grandad without this utter leech bleeding you dry.

Couldn’t agree more with this. Don’t get into debt to bail him out. He needs to feel the consequences of his actions, until he does he’ll keep doing it.

adultchildofalcoholicparents · 22/01/2024 14:00

He has a job he just isn't getting paid as the company is going bust (I know)

OP, I can only support every PP who knows that this is a version of the very common script played out by everyone who lives with an addiction when they're scrabbling round for something to say in the moment. You might be surprised at how far some of them are prepared to take this (wasting money on legal advice) before being compelled to tell the truth and even then muddying the story.

I understand that you and your children love him. Keep that love, but separate you and the children from the chaos of him and his (live) addiction. Your children need a roof over their heads, financial stability, and a parent who is fully present for them.

Ellie56 · 22/01/2024 13:58

@UnicornAndSparkles

Please, please take on board what @CantDealwithChristmas and @ttattooedlady have said and put yourself and your children first.

Don't let your children's childhood be blighted by addiction and the fallout from it.

ttattooedlady · 22/01/2024 13:40

I don't want to add to your worry or stress op and I'm sure some people will disagree with me on here, but I work with people in a therapeutic capacity and it's very very rare that people with an addiction at this level are able to stop because their partner or family take charge or block them from whatever or monitor them. In my experience it's very rare that people with this level of addiction are in fact able to stop at all. As sad as that is. More often they move from one addiction to another. It is possible to change and people do of course but it's rare. The fact that your dh is still being dishonest and it's you who is (rightly so) organising the change makes it all the more likely that he is not going to change. Addiction is an evil beast.
I have seen this situation play out many times and I can't remember the last time it worked out for the best. 9 times out of 10 it ends up ruining lives. Partners end up taking the majority of debt on divorce, the person with the addiction takes money out in their partners name, they remortgage the home, borrow from dodgy sources and so on. I have seen partners never recover from the debt and devastation left when they are finally forced to end the relationship. Never being able to retire or live comfortably, savings gone and left paying off debt accumulated by their ex for the rest of their lives.

I understand you love him of course but do you love yourself enough to not put yourself through this for the rest of your life.

CantDealwithChristmas · 22/01/2024 12:25

I would also like to add something else. I don't wish to frighten you OP.

Despite what some well-meaning PPs have said, please don't block his cards. In the 12 step recovery rooms I have met examples of gambling addicts whose other halves did this. Some of them, in desperation, borrowed money from dodgy individuals to fund their addiction instead. I don't think I need to spell it out. That kind of thing can get a man and his family into hot water pretty quickly.

It may sound mad to you and me but addicts are not sane individuals when in the throes of their addictions. Yes you love him. But you need to put yourself and your kids FIRST in all and any situations with addicts. Because situations can develop in unforeseen and unpleasant ways. You are not in charge here. The addiction is.

Chichimcgee · 22/01/2024 12:19

I’m so sorry you’re going through this.
I honestly think he should declare bankruptcy and you need to see bank statements and everything. Tell him to put everything on the table or it’s over.
People don’t work for 6 months for no pay, he needs to lay it all out so you can see it all, that’s the only chance you have for a fresh start.
Put the mortgage and everything into your name and tell him to get help for his addictions.
I was an addict, alcohol, drugs, gambling. I’m 14 years sober and what I’ve learned is I can’t trust myself. You need to decide whether he’s treated like a child who gets pocket money or whether to leave because he’s going to end up in a situation again and bring you down with him.

mommatoone · 22/01/2024 12:18

Bloody hell OP what a mess he has left you in. I would suggest getting all your information together ALL of it from him if he can be honest enough to do so!. There are various organisations that can offer you free debt advice. I have used Stepchange before. I don't think for one minute your grandfather should be bailing your husband out. His mess , he needs to sort it. And I'm sorry, but I agree with PP, he clearly has an addictive personality and I would be worried about what comes next! . Good luck x

CantDealwithChristmas · 22/01/2024 12:17

I'm so sorry to read this OP. Gambling addiction is incredibly hard to break.

Like substance addictions, recovery cannot begin unless the addict accepts they have hit rock bottom and wants to change. If your OH is not at this point, then all the wise words from PPs about website controls, StepChange etc will do absolutely no good. He will still find a way to gamble.

The ball is in his court unfortunately. Only he can decide to change. Ideally he would go to GA and start working a 12 step programme. Plus therapy.

gently encourage him but ultimately only he can choose to seek help for his addiction. Please recognise that he still might not be telling you the whole truth, he might just have told you some of the truth as you got his back up against a wall. Addicts often do this. He may not be ready to stop yet.

Encourage and support him but at the same time my suggestion would be to start preparing for a life on your own and use your grandfather's money to this end. Living with an addict will never end well. You cannot change them. Only they can change.

itsmylife7 · 22/01/2024 12:11

I just knew it would be gambling, after he quit alcohol.

An adict will always be an adict to SOMETHING.

His family said ' he's always been like that "

There's your answer OP he'll never change because that's who he is.

Mirabai · 22/01/2024 12:02

The problem is that for every man who reformed his gambling addiction and repaid his debt you’ve got any number who didn’t; whose partner clung on in love and hope, while they got deeper in debt, into lies, into stress, until the partner is forced to cut their losses and jump clear. Just ask the women who lost their homes.

SpidersAreShitheads · 22/01/2024 12:01

Namenotimportant85 · 22/01/2024 11:46

I’m not sure if this has already been mentioned as I’ve not read every comment. My husband used to be a gambler and got into a fair bit of debt, and like you it was the lies that got me more then anything. But credit to him he turned it around and I hope your husband can do the same.
if he hasn’t already get him to register on gamstop, that will then block him from using any gambling sites and get him to speak to his bank as they can also block his card from gambling. Would be a good idea to get some debt advice and possibly some counselling/therapy.

The problem with this is - as I mentioned above - that unlicensed casinos aren’t part of GAMSTOP and there’s thousands of these unlicensed sites on Google. It’s not illegal to play on unlicensed sites either so they’re readily accessible.

Also, blocking a bank card doesn’t stop the person from using Skrill, Neteller or other payment wallets.

Blovking the bank card and registering with GAMSTOP is a really good start but there are plenty of ways round it if he relapses. And that’s why this is so tricky - OP will have to treat him like a child and monitor everything for a very long time as he has lied repeatedly and still hasn’t come totally clean about his finances.

Namenotimportant85 · 22/01/2024 11:46

I’m not sure if this has already been mentioned as I’ve not read every comment. My husband used to be a gambler and got into a fair bit of debt, and like you it was the lies that got me more then anything. But credit to him he turned it around and I hope your husband can do the same.
if he hasn’t already get him to register on gamstop, that will then block him from using any gambling sites and get him to speak to his bank as they can also block his card from gambling. Would be a good idea to get some debt advice and possibly some counselling/therapy.