Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH's secrets and lies

238 replies

UnicornAndSparkles · 21/01/2024 21:42

I'll preface this with the fact that DH is generally a wonderful husband and father. He in incredibly loving and patient and generous and will always go out of his way to be a real 50/50 partner, be that with early starts, sharing the parental load as best we can (he'll always get up early with the kids for instance, and does most of the nursery drop offs and pick ups despite working full time). We've been married for almost 15 years and he is my absolute rock.

But. He has lied to me, on multiple occasions, about finances. At first it was to cover up a drinking problem, which I obviously knew he had, but he wasn't ready to admit to. With a lot of support from myself and others he has overcome and is now 4yrs sober. Something I am hugely proud of him for. But that drinking problem got him into significant debt which he didn't reveal to me. When he got sober he came clean and told me of the loan and credit card debt, totalling around 10k, all repayable within 2y he said. 2y came and went and I presumed it was paid. It's now 2y on and I find out it's not repaid and there's still around 10k to repay so there must have been significantly more at the outset. His company has recently gone bust and he hasn't been paid a salary for around 6m. He initially kept this from me for 2 months, contributing to the family finances as he usually would but only now I find out it was through a credit card. Obviously this was unsustainable and we he revealed the issue we started paying all the bills from our savings, which are almost depleted. I earn money too but not as much as he does, and my salary isn't enough to cover the mortgage and childcare costs. He put off finding a new job as he was sure the money would come in. It didn't and he has admitted he should have got a new job months ago rather than only starting to look now, when we have little savings left to fall back on. He's also revealed that he's been living in his overdraft for 3y. Again, something he kept from me.

He was on a 90k salary, which to me is a huge amount, but is so bad with money that he couldn't budget his spendings. He lives a champagne lifestyle, which I presumed was because he could, but it's become apparent that he couldn't afford half of it. I, on the other hand, would rather save than spend. It gives me far more of a thrill to see savings mounting up and shop in the likes of new look than it does to buy fancy things and not have any savings. Of course I enjoyed the holidays and all the rest of the things DH was spending money on, but only because I thought he could afford it and it was never overly lavish. My salary is far below his and I obviously had a very naive view of what 90k can afford, as it's clearly not the lifestyle we've enjoyed. He's always been this way, his family joke he was always awful with money. But the issue is the lies he's told me, the fact that he's kept the loan amount and credit card bills and overdraft secret from me, whilst the debt mounts up and up. We've always said we share finances and so it came as a shock that he wasn't being open and honest with me. He says he was embarrassed about the whole thing but now I don't feel I can trust him with money and am questionning whether he really does earn £90k or that's an exaggeration, whether the total debt is bigger than the 20k he's admitted to (he initially said it was 8-10k), whether there are more credit cards with payments due. It really worries me as we share a mortgage and have two children.

The crux is I asked him to prove he was being honest with me about the level of debt he now admits to. I've asked to see bank statements showing the figures and the repayment plan. But he won't show me. AIBU? We are very close to having to ask my grandfather to help us with money when our savings run out as until he starts getting paid again my salary cannot cover all of the outgoings (grandfather is in a position to help, financially, and has offered to do so as he is aware that we are living off our savings). Or we default on the mortgage. I cannot believe we're in this situation. I feel cross that he hasn't been honest with me and cross that he didn't up sticks and get a paying job sooner when he realised the company was going bust, but I can't turn back the clock and he recognises he's been a fool. But am I being unreasonable to not be able to trust him with the finances and to want to see the debt in black and white? Or is he unreasonable not to show me the level of debt he (and realistically "we" as we are a partnership) owe?

OP posts:
silentpool · 23/01/2024 11:11

I had a husband like this and he always hid things, racked up debt etc. It was a terrible way to live, always waiting for the next shoe to drop. Find a way to leave before your financial future is destroyed.

TreetopsSun · 23/01/2024 11:01

In fairness to the OP, as someone who’s been there, she will be in an utter shock. I think lots of women confronted with betrayal go into crisis mode and fix things, because they are worried about children and their DH. The thought of all this and on top separating is just too messy and too much, so you focus on fixing, especially with a partner saying they are so sorry and want to change. She will probably feel embarrassed (how did I not realise this, and what will other people say) and also utterly scared (will lose the house etc).

OP if you are going to stay my advice would still be to go and speak to a solicitor (I wish I had) and just find out what the position would be if you separate. You also want to try and improve yours situation if you need to leave (so increase income). Tell people - you need support.

Cathbrownlow · 23/01/2024 11:01

I have to add, that I agree with the poster above. There is never an end, there is never a moving away from it because an addict is who he is. The OP is stuck in the lie/ get discovered/ promise never to do it again / lie etc etc cycle forever until she leaves, and by default this means her children are stuck in the cycle too. The consequences also get more and more dire. 1k in debt becomes 2k, becomes no home to live in...

Snowdogsmitten · 23/01/2024 09:50

I mean, all power to you for wanting to forge ahead with this relationship, but I could never, ever, ever get over someone lying to me on that scale. Lying over and over. £110,000 in debt… it is utterly unthinkable.

That is a life destroying amount that will hang over your heads likely until the end. What a life…

I’d be gone I’m afraid. I would be leaving the relationship for my children, not staying for them. Before that man destroyed all of our futures.

Who wants to have to parent their husband that much? All respect and all love would be gone.

CheekyHobson · 22/01/2024 20:27

He deserves one last chance and I have said in no uncertain terms that he will be out if he messes up.

I hope you're serious about this because I can guarantee you that in a few weeks or months, the backsliding and the minimising and the justifying and the claims that he's "proven he can be responsible" or that he's "changed and is never going back to the way he was" etc etc will start along with requests for a little loosening of the purse strings.

My financially irresponsible ex said and did all the same kind of things as yours is currently doing when I discovered his multi-year, $200K+ financial lies.

I didn't want to be a financial jailer to a liar and addict so I left him. Within a year I could tell he was sliding back into his old habits and now, years on, I can see he hasn't changed at all.

Your financial future is at serious risk here, make no mistake.

He's not a rock, he's a millstone.

TitusMoan · 22/01/2024 20:11

LeGinge · 22/01/2024 16:05

I'm sorry if this is genuine but to me it reads like an AI generated thread.

rubbish

This is exactly how the discovery of an addiction plays out (sadly)

Report it if you like

Aquamarine1029 · 22/01/2024 19:46

UnicornAndSparkles · 22/01/2024 19:18

Yes, we're taking legal action against the company, which is essentially going bust so I don't know if we'll see any of that. I've had proof of that and have known about the situation for months. What I didn't know about was the gambling, which seems to have escalated on account of him not being paid.

The gambling escalated because your husband is an addict. He will always be an addict and he will continue to gamble or he will find something else to replace it.

Evilspiritgin · 22/01/2024 19:41

Just wanted to add that StepChange are really good, they will sort out with you, the best way of tackling this , be it making himself bankrupt or something else.

i don’t make anything near what your husband does but they helped me clear £28000 of debts in 4 years, I knew I had debts but didn’t realise the full amount, if he’s been putting in his “monthly wage” to pay bills , he will have racked up the debt quite quickly

BrainInAJar · 22/01/2024 19:28

Don't stay with him because of the children; leave him because of the children.

UnicornAndSparkles · 22/01/2024 19:18

Yes, we're taking legal action against the company, which is essentially going bust so I don't know if we'll see any of that. I've had proof of that and have known about the situation for months. What I didn't know about was the gambling, which seems to have escalated on account of him not being paid.

OP posts:
JollyMollyPolly · 22/01/2024 19:16

OP, I can't advise on your husband's addiction, and your decision to stay is very much yours to make, rightly or wrongly. I do however strongly suggest you go to the MSE debt forum and put together a SOA (statement of affairs). This level of debt will be very difficult to clear unless his monthly payments are manageable and they will give the best advice on the way forward.

Mirabai · 22/01/2024 18:07

Regarding the house/mortgage - you can block a remortgage at the land registry but the only way to ringfence your half of the value I know of is to divorce.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 22/01/2024 17:59

I'm so sorry for you, OP. You sound really lost and bewildered. I wish, wish, wish that my Mum had had access to a place like Mumsnet all those years ago because she was second-guessing her decisions.

One tip... make absolutely certain that your husband has no replacement bank cards hidden away or due to arrive by post - to your home or elsewhere. My father made a big performance of 'handing over' his bank cards knowing that the new ones had been safely squirrelled away. His 'need' to gamble overrode every decency, every concern for his wife and young children. His wants mattered more. That is the mind of a gambler and that is the mind of your husband.

I think he's realised that if he wants to stay in the family home he has to agree to whatever you say but, be under no illusions, he will be thinking of ways to thwart your attempts to stop him gambling. That is absolutely at odds with his addiction which will be working harder, much harder than you can, to get him back to it - and it will win because it is what he wants.

Only when he has hit rock bottom and there is no more leeway for him to gamble, when there is every reason to genuinely choose recovery and find his way back to his family, is there hope. He is not there; he is not nearly there.

I realise that reading these posts is jolting for you and make very unpleasant reading. There's no way around that because this is a serious subject and I guarantee that you do not know everything or even nearly everything... how could you? Your husband left you in the dark about the extent of his gambling. This is who he is. He has shown you. You want to believe the best of him because you love him but, he is not the man you believe he is and, if he were honest and able to look at himself with any clarity, he would agree with that.

I will offer that your husband may be a 'nice guy' underneath but think of him as a zombie for now. He has no mind of his own, he is an addict and until he stops being an addict, he will continue to lie and cheat and take from his family.

Never mind what he says, look at what he does.

What you do next really, really matters.

Get support from your family, they will want to help you. Let them do that. They have nothing to gain but the best for you and your children, to make sure that you and they are safe. The best thing that could happen to your husband is that he hits rock bottom, hard and fast. That can't happen whilst he's living with you and your children in the family home, it really can't.

I'm sorry for what I'm writing to you, I don't know you, but I'm earnest about your situation because I was the child of a gambler. Our lives were blighted by him, we had so little money and my Mum worried herself sick all the time. That is what is on the horizon for your children if you focus too far on your husband and his needs. He is an adult. Your children need you so, so much.

Please call out for support, but not from him. He is elsewhere and you cannot reach him right now, maybe never again. An addict services themselves first. Always first.

Your children, your house and your family money... protect those at ALL costs. Flowers

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 22/01/2024 17:46

You need legal advice.

Quite simply, you have to protect you, your kids and your home as s priority.

While I wouldn't stay with him,wouldn't trust a single word he says and would resent the babysitting - you have said you want to stay with him, and a divorce still might be the best thing for you and your children.

Not necessarily never see him again and severe all ties but still a divorce.

Get legal advice and listen to it.

cheddercherry · 22/01/2024 17:32

In that case shore up the house and yes I’d put it in your sole name. You’re now the one gambling on him (and in his own family’s words he’s always been this way so the odds aren’t in favour of him suddenly changing - remember you caught him out, he didn’t come clean and even when he did it wasn’t the actual truth) so you’ll need to make sure for the kids sake you’re well protected.

Ellie56 · 22/01/2024 17:27

Is there anything else I can do? Please don't tell me to leave him as I have decided to give him a second chance. He's an addict but he's a good person and I hope he can overcome this. He's taking steps to get help. He deserves one last chance and I have said in no uncertain terms that he will be out if he messes up.

@UnicornAndSparkles

It's not really a second chance though is it? From all your other posts, it sounds like you've given him multiple chances over the years.

You are now in debt to the tune of £110k. And he didn't tell you about that. You had to find out for yourself. Four years ago it was only £10k. What will it be next year? Because as PP say the gambling won't suddenly stop. He's in too deep for that. He will find ways to get money and will continue to lie and put you and your children at risk. This is who he is.

Go back and reread the posts by the posters who really understand these things, who work with addicts, or have lived through similar themselves.

I do hope for your children's sake you don't live to regret giving him a so called "second chance".

sterli2323 · 22/01/2024 16:45

UnicornAndSparkles · 22/01/2024 15:37

Thank you for all the advice.

We've had multiple discussions. He's accepted full responsibility. All the debt is in his name (thankfully, but we share a mortgage so it does impact me and I'm alive to this). He's contacted Step Change and I've seen the initial information he's shared on his account and the call log on his phone confirming he had a 32 min call with them today. He's also shown me that he's contacted Gam Care.

He's given me his cards including the joint account card that we pay our mortgage and all bills from. He has access to nothing. I will give him the money he needs, like a child. I can't believe it's come to this but it's necessary. I'm encouraging him to tell his immediate family to garner their support. He's told his sister thus far and she is alive to the fact that we both need support.

He's basically begged me to stay and has told me he will prioritise our relationship and that of our children. He has agreed to all of my terms, blocking all gambling sites, handing over all cards, allowing me to see his search history on the computer, his laptop and phone whenever I ask. He did this willingly, but I told him in no uncertain terms that if he didn't I'd be packing his bags today and he'd be out.

I need financial advice as to what to do about the mortgage we share. I don't know if it's sensible to have it in my sole name now. I don't want to come across as money grabbing but in the circumstances I can't trust that he won't remortgage without my knowledge. Obviously my priority is our kids and their security. I haven't broached this with him but he was shocked when I asked if he'd remortgaged the house or taken anything out in my name, saying he never would. And he hasn't. But I'm alive to the fact that he is an addict and so there is always the possibility. Everything at the moment is through credit cards and unsecured personal loans in his name. I have checked my Experian and there's nothing untoward. His is obviously ruinous.

Is there anything else I can do? Please don't tell me to leave him as I have decided to give him a second chance. He's an addict but he's a good person and I hope he can overcome this. He's taking steps to get help. He deserves one last chance and I have said in no uncertain terms that he will be out if he messes up.

StepCgange are good but they are funded by the creditors and are known for recommending IVA's when there are other solutions. I would post on MSE where there are many knowledgeable posters and lots of information on dealing with debt whilst protecting assets. Debt-free wannabe — MoneySavingExpert Forum
Regarding the mortgage you can put a restriction on at land registry which would stop him remortging with a different provider or borrowing against the house.

Debt-free wannabe

Mutual support and help for those on their journey to becoming debt-free.

https://forums.moneysavingexpert.com/categories/debt-free-wannabe

Mirabai · 22/01/2024 16:39

tuvamoodyson · 22/01/2024 16:27

Has he even had a job for the last six months??

Well that’s my question, I wonder if he’s been fired.

adultchildofalcoholicparents · 22/01/2024 16:33

Please don't tell me to leave him as I have decided to give him a second chance.

You've made your decision and I respect that you're selecting hope over the experience and tribulations of others who've lived through similar revelations and circumstances.

Please return and ask for support and advice if this goes awry for you. Posters here would understand.

tuvamoodyson · 22/01/2024 16:27

Alwaysalwayscold · 22/01/2024 15:43

Have you asked for proof that he's not lying about his job not paying him for 6 months?

Has he even had a job for the last six months??

ttattooedlady · 22/01/2024 16:12

Again I don't want to be miss downer and I do hope that he continues his commitment to change and follows through with all that he has said. However, a friend of mine mine put up with this for years and years. Her dh told her he wasn't getting paid at work due to some issue or other. Every month he was apparently working for free. She believed this at first but it's a very common lie people tell. First it was gambling then alcohol then she discovered drugs and debts to dealers. Someone burgled her house with her and the dc in bed and it turned out this was related to her dh. Eventually she found out he was waking up during the night while her and their dc slept to gamble and take drugs. She like you stayed and listened to the promises but unfortunately in the end she had to leave as she was unable to stay and keep a roof over her dc heads. She has never recovered financially and had to move house and disrupt her whole life. She took charge and he even went to rehab but it was never enough and he would find money despite her controlling all their finances. Very sad.

LeGinge · 22/01/2024 16:05

I'm sorry if this is genuine but to me it reads like an AI generated thread.

Aquamarine1029 · 22/01/2024 16:00

I see you've decided to give him a second chance, (actually it's about the fourth or fifth chance you've given him but I've lost count), and I hope you're ready for it. Micromanaging a grown man as though he's an infant is not something I would ever do. How utterly soul destroying.

Right now, he is Mr. Agreeable, accepting all of your terms and conditions because he's desperate to save his own arse and keep his happy life. I guarantee you, Mr. Agreeable won't be around for long. His addictions are soon going to be pounding at his door, and the monkey on his back will refuse to be ignored. He's an addict and a pathological liar. That's just who he is. Also, there is far more to come that you don't know about. There always is.

Don't forget that it's 100% ok to throw in the towel, anytime you want to, and refuse to live like this any longer. He's the one who ruined everything, not you.

hellsBells246 · 22/01/2024 15:57

Sorry, I should have RTFT.

You sound very sensible and switched on. Only you can decide if this marriage will be sustainable. Take care. I hope you have RL support? 💐

hellsBells246 · 22/01/2024 15:54

Bloody hell. He's not a wonderful partner at all.

He's brought you to the edge of bankruptcy! You could lose your house! And he has lied to you again and again and again - and he STILL won't shoe you his bank statements, so the debt is much worse than you fear.

I'd seriously be thinking about leaving him over this.

I'd separate all my bank accounts from him and i'd never trust him with money again. I'd never ever give him any of my money.

I'd accept money for you and the dc from your family, but ensure the money is ringfenced so your lying H can't touch it.

He will bring you all down with him.