Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year old won’t stop crying

236 replies

Mimikyuu · 21/01/2024 21:39

My 10 year old won’t stop crying because I’m going away for a few days. It’s gotten to a point now where I’m just annoyed by it and struggling to muster sympathy.

Any idea on how to calm this sort of anxiety? She’s been crying for a week and I leave next week for 3 days. She will be here with her dad and brother.

OP posts:
Adrieeeeenne · 22/01/2024 07:38

I have a 9(almost 10) yo DD who is also very clingy, and she also gets fussy/upset if I going away/out (although it is getting less as she gets older). I know how draining it can be to manage the whole thing (all done with love of course!). I had an overnight stay in hospital recently and I did say that’s where I was going (although was very casual about the whole thing, no big deal etc.) and she navigated it better than I expected (thankfully!). I have no magic advice but wanted to lend my voice to the responses who don’t see this as ‘abnormal’ or a sign of abuse - some kids are just like this and you all have to get through together until they’ve grown out of it. My silver bullet is usually to say she can sleep on my side of the bed, always works for us. Good luck at hospital! X

PiersPlowman11 · 22/01/2024 07:26

@Futb0l

Well, in my case from the age of five I was expected to walk the 3/4 mile to and from school myself. In the mornings, mum was taking care of baby sis and in the afternoon, she was with friends.

At the weekend, whenever the weather was fine I was expected to play outside and not return until mealtimes. Dad had his hobbies and mum had her friends. We did go out together and have holidays, but their parenting was so inconsistent.

As for how the parenting affected sis and me, I had recurring nightmares, sucked my thumb until I was 12 and my sister developed bulimia. Both of us had our confidence shattered.

No way would I recommend latchkey parenting!

Newchapterbeckons · 22/01/2024 07:21

Futb0l · 22/01/2024 07:10

Latchkey kids were certainly a thing when I was growing up, and while I was one myself and enjoyed my freedom, I feel on reflection what the term really meant was “negligent parenting”.

It depends on age! Age appropriate levels of independence are a good thing. You should be able to leave a 10 or 11 year old at home to pop out for half an hour, for example. You should be able to pop away for work for a few days and leave a 10 year old with dad - they should be busy with school and friends and hobbies and not clinging to mum.

I agree latchkey was really a phrase for children that were left to their own devices, and whilst independence should be encouraged- basic parenting and nurturing should continue and often doesn’t for these children.

Seagrassbasket · 22/01/2024 07:12

In all honesty I really would tell her what’s going on. In the unlikely event of complications/needing to stay in longer she will feel very betrayed that she wasn’t told.

Futb0l · 22/01/2024 07:10

Latchkey kids were certainly a thing when I was growing up, and while I was one myself and enjoyed my freedom, I feel on reflection what the term really meant was “negligent parenting”.

It depends on age! Age appropriate levels of independence are a good thing. You should be able to leave a 10 or 11 year old at home to pop out for half an hour, for example. You should be able to pop away for work for a few days and leave a 10 year old with dad - they should be busy with school and friends and hobbies and not clinging to mum.

3luckystars · 22/01/2024 07:07

It’s the build up to it, she will be fine when you are gone. I’m sorry I’m not more help but maybe leave her looking after something you really value (so she will know you will be coming back) and make plans for calling her every night.
Also tell her you will bring her something back.
Its wearing alright but I think it’s building up to it causes the stress and once you are gone, it will stop.

all the best with the operation

Futb0l · 22/01/2024 07:07

Honestly I think you have to go back to basics and not give this a lot of response. If she gets a lot of attention for this she"ll keep doing it.

Acknowledge the feelings but don't validate them - its not a reasonable reaction for a 10 year old to cry constantly about 3 days with dad while mums away, and there is nothing for her to worry about.

Just be brisk and cheery, ask her what she wants for food while your away and tell her dad will get it in. When i go away i always tell the kids to look after Dad and make sure he behaves, they find this hilarious.

MrsHughesPinny · 22/01/2024 07:06

@PiersPlowman11 I think parenting was just really different in the 80s (when I was growing up). Parents weren’t really expected to interact with kids as intensively as they are now or consider their opinions. None of my friends’ parents did either, even if they had a SAHM, we were always in and out of various houses. Parents were ‘in charge’ and we did as we were told, I suppose, but then also had a lot more freedom to grow in confidence.

Obviously there were truly neglectful parents and I’m sorry if you experienced that.

I’ve always been thankful for my Mum forcing me to do things independently because I was really shy as a kid. If she hadn’t forced it there’s no way I’d have moved to Singapore for a job with a two year old which kickstarted the career I have now! 😂

PiersPlowman11 · 22/01/2024 06:59

@MrsHughesPinny
Latchkey kids were certainly a thing when I was growing up, and while I was one myself and enjoyed my freedom, I feel on reflection what the term really meant was “negligent parenting”.

So many parents didn’t give a fig what we did as long as we stayed out of their hair and didn’t bring trouble to the home.

I sometimes wish I had parents instead of sharing my childhood with two adults.

But I digress…

applepiesain · 22/01/2024 06:56

Personally I would tell her about the surgery, I can't see why you wouldn't.

I understand that separation anxiety could cause this, but that's different to thinking that she doesn't want to stay with her dad because he's a bit stricter.
You come across here as irritated by her behaviour. Try and take a step back and realise that while it's normal to often find things other people do annoying, it isn't helpful in solving deeper issues to just quickly dismiss them as something else. They will just be pushed under the surface and re-emerge as something else undesirable .

MrsHughesPinny · 22/01/2024 06:49

@PiersPlowman11 She did plenty for us growing up, especially considering she was on her own. But there was balance. She went out alone, we went out together, we travelled alone, we travelled together. It made us all very independent.

ZsaZsaTheCat · 22/01/2024 06:44

Mimikyuu · 21/01/2024 22:45

Jesus Christ I only posted an hour ago I’ve been busy!

Im having surgery so no she can’t come with me. I’ve not told her about the surgery as she would freak out even more. Her relationship with her dad and brother is fine she’s just very clingy to me.

I think you should tell her about the surgery and explain it all - then she will understand why you need to go away. You cannot shield kids from difficult situations forever and they will never learn resilience.

coldbrightmorning · 22/01/2024 06:44

worrywilma · 21/01/2024 22:52

Fucking hell. what has the world come to, when's mum asks a parenting forum for advice on her anxious daughter, next news, people are insinuating her husband and/or son are perverts!

And before I get piled on, yes I'm aware of the signs of sexual abuse. I live it.

Because posters have said they were the same and the y were being abused? Perfectly reasonable suggestion to make.

WonderingWanda · 22/01/2024 06:44

Is it very unusual for you to go away for work? She must be finding it a bit strange. don't understand why you wouldn't tell her you were going to hospital, honestly, if something went wrong and you died she would spend her whole life being confused about it.

PiersPlowman11 · 22/01/2024 06:43

@MrsHughesPinny

”She always said Kids have to learn their parents are people with needs and wants too and that the world doesn’t revolve around us.”

Tough love, eh? Pity such people don’t apply their own ethos to themselves.

MrsHughesPinny · 22/01/2024 06:39

You know your daughter and family best. Separation anxiety is one of those things that has to be handled before it gets suffocating. If you don’t think she’d cope with knowing why, that’s fine. You need to worry about YOU at the moment. She has her other parent looking after her.

My Mum did the same. She always said Kids have to learn their parents are people with needs and wants too and that the world doesn’t revolve around us. We travelled to relatives in Sweden by ourselves twice a year starting at 8, 10 and 12. We were latch key kids, all of us have travelled and lived all over the world, moving for job and educational opportunities and have massively benefited from it.

catelynjane · 22/01/2024 06:39

You shouldn't be lying to her - it's only going to cause more problems in the future when it happens again and she doesn't know if she can trust you or not.

I was clingy to my mum at that age as well - I got on fine with my dad, it's just he was a bit more strict and I didn't like it Grin

Mimikyuu · 22/01/2024 06:39

I’m not telling her about the surgery. She doesn’t know as there has been no opportunity where it’s been discussed for her to overhear anything.

I know the reason is likely that my husband is a bit stricter than I am and makes her keep on top of her room etc where as I’m a little more lax. That’s why she doesn’t like it when I’m not around.

And I do go out, to the pp who said I reminded her of her mum who never went out. I go out regularly and I also work full time.

OP posts:
Littlemisscapable · 22/01/2024 06:38

Shes 10. She knows perfectly well something isn't right and has probably picked up that you are going to hospital but doesn't understand why and hasn't got the maturity to make sense of this. Just be honest with her. Get a calendar..highlight the days you will be away and explain when you will call/ if she can visit. You are being really unreasonable and you are the parent regardless of medical problems. Have more empathy. You are making her anxiety much more unnecessarily.

Bestyearever2024 · 22/01/2024 06:34

I think this is relatively extreme for a 10 year old who has a good relationship with her Dad and brother

After your op, I think you should organise some counselling for her, to help her learn strategies to cope with fear

quisensoucie · 22/01/2024 06:31

Once this is over, you need to do some independence training
That level of clingyness and emotion in the absence of a physical/nd/abuse/school issues, is completely unnecessary

Zanatdy · 22/01/2024 06:29

I’m sure OP knows her own DD better than strangers on MN in whether she should tell her about the surgery. I think next time maybe give one day notice as it’s clearly distressing. Do you go for nights out etc / time away? Maybe an idea to get her more used to it. Sure she will be ok. I hope you’re surgery goes well OP

YukoandHiro · 22/01/2024 06:02

Agree with those saying she senses you're lying to her.

I think it's always better to tell the truth even when the truth is scary (surgery). By not telling her you're actually making it a much bigger deal than it is

PiersPlowman11 · 22/01/2024 06:02

@DogLover24
Yeah, I reckon the daughter is the eldest and she’s twigged that she’s about to be shunted even further down the pecking order.

Just because a nipper’s needs are more immediate, it doesn’t mean the other kids no longer need Mummy’s affection.

Be kind to your daughter, OP, or you’ll lose her as an adult.

SparePartz · 22/01/2024 06:00

Stop lying to her.

She's probably picked up that something is wrong and nobody is telling her the truth.

Explain in age appropriate language that you need the surgery, and what the benefits will be.

This! My 11 year old definitely picks up on stuff we think we didn't mention in front of them. She's probably overheard you're going into hospital and as you're not being honest with her it's assuming you won't come out. Sit her down, apologise and have an honest conversation with her.