Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

10 year old won’t stop crying

236 replies

Mimikyuu · 21/01/2024 21:39

My 10 year old won’t stop crying because I’m going away for a few days. It’s gotten to a point now where I’m just annoyed by it and struggling to muster sympathy.

Any idea on how to calm this sort of anxiety? She’s been crying for a week and I leave next week for 3 days. She will be here with her dad and brother.

OP posts:
Geppili · 23/01/2024 03:38

Op, you are being shortsighted and hardhearted.

ClairDeLaLune · 23/01/2024 00:27

some of you are nuts

Fine, crack on and lie to your daughter, and she’ll never trust you again. It’s not us who are nuts.

CrazyHedgehogLover · 22/01/2024 20:15

I’m sorry OP but your being completely unreasonable, telling your child lies will not help with sensitivity or fears.. or even anxiety. If anything your going to cause her trust issues and problems more so if the one person she’s supposed to be able to count on and rely on is lying to her when serious situations crop up.

what if your sore after surgery? What if something goes wrong (not trying to scare you) and you have to stay in longer than a week? I was told I would be in hospital for a week when I was put down for surgery (NHS) and ended up being in there for nearly two weeks!? Can you trust you’ll definitely be home when you’ve said to her you will be?

it’s ok for you to say “some of us are nuts” you came on here asking for opinions and how best to deal with it.. you can’t expect everyone to agree with how you do things.

you should never lie to your children, is something was to happen or if she finds out that it was a lie, the trust will be broken. You may think that is insane and “not going to happen” but it does happen, my stepdaughter doesn’t get along well with her mum now and she’s 11 because of her mum telling her “white lies” so she wouldn’t get anxious etc.. she also didn’t like being away from her mum naturally, now she doesn’t trust a word she says.. quite sad really.

tell her about the surgery and be honest, suggest she come and visit you in hospital so she can see that your ok? FaceTime her and speak to her etc.. she is clearly worried and anxious, you lying to her will make this worse.

LuckySantangelo35 · 22/01/2024 16:59

Snowdogsmitten · 22/01/2024 13:11

“Just stay at home and miss your surgery. Put your daughter first.”

: Mumsnet.

Some people really seem to think this!

can you imagine how people would react if op said she was going away on a hen do or something like that!

catelynjane · 22/01/2024 16:59

Thinking I’m having surgery will absolutely cripple her with fear. I am not going to tell her

Can you 100% guarantee she's never going to find out about this? Nobody is going to accidentally mention it in conversation? She's not going to find any letters or paperwork or medication related to your recovery?

What happens if you have to stay in hospital longer than planned, or the surgery goes wrong and DH needs to come in and see you?

Chichimcgee · 22/01/2024 16:49

So you’re gonna ruin your relationship with your child by constantly lying to her about important things because she’ll be upset. Even though she’s already upset.
at the moment she’s 10 but this will come out and it will stay with her, she will always remember you lied to her.

TripleDaisySummer · 22/01/2024 16:13

Thinking I’m having surgery will absolutely cripple her with fear. I am not going to tell her, she thinks I’m going away for work and I’m trying to help her cope with that as best I can but I understandably am getting tired of the constant crying.

https://www.youngminds.org.uk/parent/parents-a-z-mental-health-guide/anxiety/
https://www.rileychildrens.org/connections/older-kids-and-separation-anxiety-how-it-happens-and-what-to-do

^^Would this be any help.

A weeks crying is extreme - you could try low level anxiety helping stuff - breathing apps - rescue remedy stuff- fidget toys - but at 10 I'd have though calm matter of fact with a few distractions thrown in and asking her Dad to run interference when your understandable frustration with her gets too much.

Supporting A Child With Anxiety | Tips and Advice

If your child or teenager is struggling with anxiety, we've got information about signs and treatment, and practical strategies you can do together.

https://www.youngminds.org.uk/parent/parents-a-z-mental-health-guide/anxiety

Quartz2208 · 22/01/2024 16:08

Mimikyuu · 22/01/2024 15:08

Fucking hell some of you are nuts 🤣

Even if I was going away for work, that’s still me going because I HAVE to not because I WANT to.

She’s a sensitive kid and needs some help managing her anxiety which is fine. It’s new territory for me as I was not a sensitive child and neither were my siblings so she’s like a little alien to me. A little alien who I live very much and funnily enough, know a lot better than strangers on the internet! Thinking I’m having surgery will absolutely cripple her with fear. I am not going to tell her, she thinks I’m going away for work and I’m trying to help her cope with that as best I can but I understandably am getting tired of the constant crying.

But not telling her is crippling her with fear because she senses something is going on that she doesn’t know about. She needs to trust that you are the person she can trust to tell the truth and that you will be honest with her. Not telling her will ultimately be worst.

show her the princess of wales, explain it is not serious because at the moment she is not where she needs to be.

@Howbizarre22 it is likely her fear is because what she is being td doesn’t fit with what she knows, that she realises something isn’t right and that they are hiding things from her and she is scared of what that is.

whiteshutters · 22/01/2024 15:31

It's a few days@Howbizarre22

Howbizarre22 · 22/01/2024 15:15

It sounds more than her being sensitive tbh more like terrible anxiety. I would be keeping an open mind as to why she is so terribly afraid of you leaving her with her dad & brother, I wouldn’t be so dismissive of that. The level of her distress is not normal she’s either a significant anxiety problem which needs address or a legitimate fear of something you don’t see. 10 days of crying is not just being a bit ‘sensitive’ is it. Personally I’m not sure I could leave her until I’d got to the bottom of it though I do appreciate you have your own needs and life to live.

Mimikyuu · 22/01/2024 15:08

Fucking hell some of you are nuts 🤣

Even if I was going away for work, that’s still me going because I HAVE to not because I WANT to.

She’s a sensitive kid and needs some help managing her anxiety which is fine. It’s new territory for me as I was not a sensitive child and neither were my siblings so she’s like a little alien to me. A little alien who I live very much and funnily enough, know a lot better than strangers on the internet! Thinking I’m having surgery will absolutely cripple her with fear. I am not going to tell her, she thinks I’m going away for work and I’m trying to help her cope with that as best I can but I understandably am getting tired of the constant crying.

OP posts:
Snowdogsmitten · 22/01/2024 13:11

“Just stay at home and miss your surgery. Put your daughter first.”

: Mumsnet.

Quartz2208 · 22/01/2024 13:07

@Mimikyuu you may not have discussed it around her but she is 10 and not stupid, she recognises and is picking up on someth8ng going on and it is causing her anxiety. The link between the c section that did and the work and going out that didn’t is the anxiety one suspects in you and your husband and the uncertainty.

they can instinctively pick up on lies even if they aren’t aware of it and the stress/anxiety cues in you. My child prone to anxiety finds me being anxious one of his worst triggers and also needs me to tell him the truth and trust him.

if you don’t tell her now what is happening and she finds out (as she invariably will) that you lied it is going to make it worse.

and yes she was anxious about the c section so that meant you decided not to tell her - but has that worked out for you. Maybe the link isn’t the surgery but your anxiety and the fact that she is clearly aware she is left out.

as for pandering surely lying about thr reason is pandering far more than telling the truth

Esgaroth · 22/01/2024 12:44

When one of us goes away, the other parent usually does something fun and special with the kids. Nothing spectacular, just stay up late with popcorn and watch a film or go out for ice-cream or go to explore a different park/pool from the ones we normally go to.

It takes the focus away from 'time without Mummy' and puts it on 'special time with Daddy' (or the other way round). Our more sensitive child does still usually get tearful, especially at bedtime, but she sees the positives too.

Caffeinedetox · 22/01/2024 12:42

I can't believe the people telling the OP to just stay at home!!! Yes that'll definitely help the next time mum has to go away. Jesus it beggars belief that some people would pander to a 10 year old child and let them be in charge of what the adults in the household do. And we wonder why we are raising a generation of kids who don't obey rule or listen to authority.

I would sit down with her, explain to her why you're going away (obviously in 10 year old language so as not to scare her), tell her she'll be absolutely fine with her dad and brother(s) and that you'll do something nice when you get back.

Hounddug · 22/01/2024 12:29

I think she’s needs a non alarming explanation as to why you are going .

At the mo she thinks you are going because you want to rather than have too

FarmGirl78 · 22/01/2024 11:51

elgreco · 21/01/2024 22:45

Ask if she'd like to stay with granny or friend. If she stops crying, you have a husband or son problem.

Give over!! Issue with husband or son isn't the only reason children might want to stay somewhere else when their Mum is away!! If you'd have asked me this at the same age I'd have MUCH preferred to stay with my Auntie or Grandparents. Staying with Dad and Brother meant same house, parent rules, being outnumbered by 'smelly boys', whereas time at Grandparents would have meant getting to stay in my 'other bedroom' at their house, later bedtimes, Grandparent rules, being spoiled and being the only one there to get attention lavished on.

Comedycook · 22/01/2024 11:50

Some very mean responses here..and you sound pretty unsympathetic too op.

I actually think this is a bit worrying. My dd is very close to me and I know would miss me if I went away but she wouldn't be in this sort of state and crying a lot.

I also don't understand why you have lied to her and said you're going away for work. She's old enough to understand you need to go to hospital

MzHz · 22/01/2024 11:48

idonthaveyourwellies · 21/01/2024 22:41

It's very telling that OP doesn't respond to most of these messages. My Mother was very much the same. My sister is the same too

Your child is crying, asking you not to go. So you can A: take her with you, B: ask a friend or a relative she's comfortable with if she can stay or C: you just don't go.

You ask what you can do to calm the anxieties? You talk to your child and come up with a solution

Its really that simple

So you can A: take her with you, B: ask a friend or a relative she's comfortable with if she can stay or C: you just don't go.

or D, you reassure her that you’re going because you have to, that she will be fine and that unless something else is going on that she’s not telling you, that she’s overreacting and she’ll be fine, and you GO.

Assuming no other mitigating factors, we have to teach our children to be resilient

this is akin to manipulation and needs to be nipped in the bud tbh. Imagine how the DH is feeling? Rejected I’d expect.

ReadytoFly · 22/01/2024 11:47

Why should she stay at home? Don't be ridiculous, parents need to go away and this might be work related anyway. She's leaving her DD with her DF and DB. She'll be fine! Children need to know that parents leave and come back and they need to know that they can't control the actions of others around them, particularly responsible adults, through crying etc. It works be unhealthy for the OP not to go unless there are some significant extenuating circumstances she hasn't mentioned.

BagsaMunroe · 22/01/2024 11:47

I agree with @tealweasel

Kids are more switched on than you think. I'm sure she knows there is a secret and that's why she's anxious.

Unless going away for work is the norm for you, you're on a hiding to nothing.
She knows it's a lie.

I find it hard to believe you are hiding an operation from a child of 10.
Soon she'll have to cope with her own bodily changes at puberty so hiding health issues and your op is plain daft.

It's not helping her mature or build any resilience.

BagsaMunroe · 22/01/2024 11:43

I know the reason is likely that my husband is a bit stricter than I am and makes her keep on top of her room etc where as I’m a little more lax. That’s why she doesn’t like it when I’m not around.

So- you talk to her dad and ask him to be a bit more relaxed while you're away.

On the other hand maybe you indulge her too much and she's growing up a bit precious?

tealweasel · 22/01/2024 11:43

Take it from a child whose parents hid health stuff from them and who now has crippling anxiety as a result (because I always assume that everyone is secretly dying but is lying to me about it), trying to keep the surgery under wraps is only likely to make this worse in the long run.

You've told her you're away for work when actually you're having surgery (obviously you haven't provided details of what for, which is absolutely fine, but let's assume it carries at least some risk of complications as most surgeries do). She has reason to feel some anxiety about what's happening and I wouldn't be surprised if she's picked up on this, even subliminally. For my money you'd be better off being honest about what's happening and helping her to understand and to develop techniques to manage her anxiety, rather than ignoring her feelings and pretending she should have no reason to be concerned.

BagsaMunroe · 22/01/2024 11:41

Oh come on @Mimikyuu

At 10, she's old enough to know about an operation. She's not a baby.

You're protecting her and just condoning the 'snowflake' behaviour.
It's not going to help her.
She will probably guess it's not 'just work' and know everyone is lying.

Is it good to lie?

No.

You should explain simply what's going on (she may even need surgery herself one day.)

Give her some 'responsibility' to help her grow up while you're away- some cooking, or helping out in the house.

Treat her like a 'big girl' not a baby.

And arrange for some phone calls as and when your op allows.

whiteshutters · 22/01/2024 11:38

I remember a midwife telling me when I had my first child that they know how to yank your chains from day one. I'm not sure about a little baby but a 10 year old? She will be going to secondary school soon. Is she going to cry about that too? Maybe you have been guilty of babying her too much? Tell her what is going on.