Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS parking dilemma

166 replies

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 21:11

Let me preface this that I am grateful to all the NHS workers for their hard work and dedication to their job.

I've wanted to start this thread as I've recently seen numerous debates about this on social media. Oftentimes someone's complaining that NHS workers are parking their cars on residential streets where parking is available at the trust. The post usually has a plethora of comments ranging from those agreeing it's a nuisance to those saying it's reasonable.

I have made a few observations myself, I am aware that they may make me sound like an AH but they seem the most logical to me.

  • if parking is available at the workplace then it should be used (whether free or not)
  • to address expensive parking, almost all workplaces don't offer free parking, doesn't matter what industry. A lot of workers aside from NHS, pay for parking and live.
  • to address antisocial hours, as above, there are other industries that won't necessarily have free parking and have to pay for it
  • the NHS offers good job stability in this day and age (always understaffed so not much chance of losing your job, they need you), fantastic pension, the pay isn't great but also not out of the norm, discounts for on site nurseries etc, overall don't the benefits outweigh the cost of parking?
  • to clarify, I do understand if there's no parking available then absolutely look for an alternative but I find it cheeky to use residential roads when there's ample parking available at some trusts.
  • I can see why people get frustrated with there being no space near their house because of people that work. Now before people say 'buy a house with a drive' it's sometimes not possible, some get house by council and are grateful for what they have, or some that own their house may not be able to afford one with a driveway. It's cheaper to pay for parking at your workplace thank buy a house with a driveway.

So, AITA for thinking that being an NHS worker doesn't exempt you from paying for parking and you should be more considerate to residents in the area?

I hope we can all have a discussion about your views.

OP posts:
user1477391263 · 21/01/2024 22:29

The problem with people being allowed to park on residential streets is this: people understandably don’t want to live in traffic sewers, and avoid living in areas near schools….or hospitals… or daycare nurseries….or stations…or…. (“Well, surely you knew what it would be like, living near an XYZ? That’s why I chose an estate further out of town!”)

The system is therefore literally punishing people who live near facilities that they might like to use themselves, and rewarding those who live further away….which then encourages more sprawl and pushes everyone to drive more and more for their everyday needs.

Vicious circle.

To get out of this trap, British cities need to start off by doing something about parking, but the transition is likely to be painful, because it requires unpicking several decades of urban development.

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:28

annieloulou · 21/01/2024 21:59

I work in an NHS Trust, the staff parking charge relates to your salary banding. I am part time, low band, I pay less than £10 per month. The land used for car parking is privately owned. You need to be there by 9,00 am though to get a space.

All residential roads around are residents only, so staff can’t park there. The travel office can turn you down if you live close or are on a bus route or don’t have caring responsibilities, or don’t have to go off site for home visits etc.

I think this is a reasonable test though, taking into account personal circumstances and other transport options.

OP posts:
TeenLifeMum · 21/01/2024 22:27

I’m nhs and work at different sites. For off-site parking 2 days a week (I don’t qualify for on site), I pay £28 a month salary sacrifice. I also have a 20 minute walk from this parking location but it’s the closest I can get.

For 2 days at the other site, on site due to journey time being an hour, I pay £4.60 twice a week.

so it’s £64.80 per month for parking.

As I have to travel to different locations, so there’s occasions I’m paid for my 20 minute walk during my working hours, which seems madness but clearly not enough to give me on site parking.

Toddlerteaplease · 21/01/2024 22:26

In my trust, staff are not allowed to park in the visitors car park and pay. We do have P&R but there has been issues with the reliability of the buses and it adds extra time on to an already very long shift. So people do park on local roads. I live within walking distance fortunately, but all the roads are double parked.

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:26

Tinkerbyebye · 21/01/2024 21:54

YABVU big time

when I worked in a town I parked in free street parking and walked half a mile into town as I couldn’t afford to pay for the car park

I still do it if I go into town now whenever I can

there's a col crisis on and for some people it’s as bad as pay for parking or food

Thought I might be to some people.
Though I welcome different opinions.

OP posts:
CatherinedeBourgh · 21/01/2024 22:26

When I had to work anti-social hours in another industry (anything after 8pm counted) the company paid for me to get a taxi to and from home.

NHS workers have the same entitlement to any member of the public to park in public roads, if people want them not to they should make the alternative easier and cheaper so that they choose not to exercise that right.

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:25

quiteathome · 21/01/2024 21:54

So quite often it is because we are not allowed to park on site.

Thank you, it seems counterintuitive to have staff car parks where staff can't actually park.

OP posts:
user1477391263 · 21/01/2024 22:24

British cities are a mess.

As in other Anglo countries (such as the US, Oz, NZ, Canada), Britain has the cultural preference for private cars, driving, detached houses with gardens and low-level low-density buildings, and a cultural aversion to public transport, walking/biking, higher building heights and densities, apartment living etc.

But unlike the other Anglo countries, the UK does not have much space per person to build all the roads and parking needed, and does have a lot of old, pretty town centers which it has never wanted to tear down to build huge urban car parks and great big multi-lane ring roads.

So the UK is stuck right in the middle - everyone is hopelessly dependent on cars, and yet there is nowhere to park or drive them. Hence, clogged roads, potholes and parking wars.

reflecting2023 · 21/01/2024 22:23

OP what is your problem, really? If you think nhs perks are so great apply for a job. But for goodness sake stop whinging,

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:21

rwalker · 21/01/2024 21:51

The area near our hospital is now residents only they actually asked the council for it
park due to hospital staff parking like complete dicks
of course any taxed insured car can park anywhere
but they were over hanging drives parking on junction corners and generally parking inconsiderately

I'm also waiting for a reply from council re parking permits, it's mostly workers from town that cause the issue here but same principle applies.

OP posts:
Pussycat22 · 21/01/2024 22:20

Give it ten years and there won't be an NHS to bash. Then watch em throw a tantrum!!!

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:19

CheesecakeandCrackers · 21/01/2024 21:50

I live a 15 min walk from hospital so have a lot of cars on our road from staff who don't want to use the free park and ride which is a further 15 min walk away. I can't get excited about people parking on the road generally but we have started a request to make our road permit parking only in an attempt to limit the nightmare of people blocking us in. If we have a holiday booked we have to leave our car on the road the night before as we've been so badly blocked in at times. Usually people overhang a bit so we can get out but then not back in. It's all hospital staff or residents on our road so it's frustrating that they can't park more thoughtfully which would mean the road could remain zoneless which has advantages for everyone. I have tried not to complain about it over the past 10 years as other roads get blocked much worse with hospital parking but as they gradually increased restrictions our road has become the parking place of choice. I think its fine to charge staff for parking too where patients also pay, I'd like all parking to be free but think that's unrealistic. My own office decided to move to a new location without parking so I pay £22 a day to park within a 15 min walk from my office now.

I agree with everything you've put here, I'm waiting on a reply from our council re parking permits for our road as well.

OP posts:
SunshineAutumnday · 21/01/2024 22:18

Our trust wil not allow staff to use the hospital parking.

So we PAY for residents parking £15 per shift, I then pay for resident parking where I live £190 per year. After a day shift I can NEVER park in my road and end up with 10 minute walk.

So, no. I'm not exempt from parking.

QueenBean22 · 21/01/2024 22:17

NHS worker here and pay for parking, £28 a month. We are not guaranteed a space, when we do get a space at home time it can take around 30 minutes to get off the hospital site. For these reasons I’m considering handing back my staff permit and parking in a residential street close by.

MonkeyPuddle · 21/01/2024 22:17

I used a private day nursery 20 mins walk, 5 min drive. No NHS on-site nursery. No priority. I fact I had to see my abusive ex more often due to my shift times before I switched jobs.

Zwicky · 21/01/2024 22:16

YABU. You can’t have a system where anybody can park on public roads unless they are NHS scum. NHS staff don’t have to shove over to be nice so other people have more space on the public roads. Unless there is also a scheme where NHS staff don’t have to pay tax then I’ll be using the services just like anyone else.

I work in my local hospital but it’s inaccessible to me by public transport as it is outside of a small town and I live outside of an even smaller town nearby, so it’s a bus to my town, a bus between towns and then a third bus to the hospital. It is with 3 separate bus companies so not doable with a travel card and the timetables don’t join up. It’s around about 90mins on the bus and I would arrive 2 hours after my start time at the earliest. I wouldn’t be able to get home until the next day - too late to catch the bus back again. It would cost more in a week in bus fares than I spend in a month in petrol. My friend in my nearest city works in a big teaching hospital with a tram stop and a shuttle bus. The shuttle bus doesn’t work for shift patterns. You can’t park overnight at the tram park and ride so you can’t use the tram on a night shift. Public transport needs to work before you ban NHS staff from the roads.

It’s not normal in the private sector for businesses with parking to charge staff. It is normal for people working in city centres to have to pay for parking if they choose to drive in but this also applies to city centre hospitals with no parking. Realistically you can’t magic up car parks in the middle of cities for NHS staff but the difficulties of shift work should be recognised. If you are expected to start or finish at a time when you can’t access the hospital on public transport and also can’t park then their should be some help (mini buses/ taxis) because the ballache and the expense of it contributes to lack of retention in acute trusts,

Los of people live near places where people park. People live near high streets, schools, religious buildings, train stations etc. Other people are part of life.

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:15

innerdesign · 21/01/2024 21:45

@Buniadot fantastic pension, the pay isn't great but also not out of the norm, discounts for on site nurseries etc, overall don't the benefits outweigh the cost of parking?

YATA just for this. On site nurseries? Maybe on Grey's Anatomy, not in any NHS hospital I've ever heard of. Also the pension isn't fantastic any more.

There is limited staff parking at both hospitals I work between. As PP said, this is taken up by 7am by the dayshift nurses arriving. I start at 8.45. One site is urban so I pay a council car park. The other site is a town so I park on a residential street. The residents don't like it, but I pay my road tax and park legally, so tough. I live near a train station. Commuters park in our street to get the train. I survive. Also, if there was paid parking at the site with residential (free) parking, I wouldn't pay for it - why would you, when you could walk another five minutes and save the cash?

Maybe the trust near me is an anomaly then as there is an onsite nursery with staff's kids getting priority and discounts.

OP posts:
MonkeyPuddle · 21/01/2024 22:14

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 21/01/2024 21:57

Sounds a bargain

At my place of work you can pay £10 a day to park on site or £7 at a nearby public car park that offers a discount providing you arrive and leave at the right times. Everywhere else is more expensive.

Not NHS private sector in a provincial city.

Yours and my ideas of a bargain are different. At the time I worked for the trust I was a single parent, band 5, no unsociable, £750 a month nursery bill. I could barely afford to
get to work. Let alone use the parking. I brought home £1800 pm and parked in the surrounding streets to get to work.

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:13

Mangoandbroccoli · 21/01/2024 21:44

Here's a crazy idea, OP... how about when someone parks on the public bit of road that happens to be outside your house you don't 'make observations'? You don't judge, you don't speculate, you don't curtain twitch and you don't stir up hate on SM. Instead, you recognise that whatever they are doing there and for whatever reason they are parking there has absolutely nothing to do with their entitlement to use a completely public and legal bit of road and you just get on with your day Smile

No time for curtain twitching when you're working two jobs, pay for parking at them, yet can't find a space near your house because someone else doesn't want to pay for parking at their job 🤷🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
OakleyStreetisnotinChelsea · 21/01/2024 22:12

So often the NHS staff car parks are not big enough.

Or you might work somewhere with multiple sites with different rules in each. I work across all our sites so there is one with a free car park, one with a staff car park that needs a permit but is open with no barrier so it gets full of visitors and 2 with permit and barrier.

Now imagine being based at the one with permit but no barrier. A couple of times a year you need to attend training at the other sites. Your permit means you can park in any of the other sites. But you don't have a swipe for their barriers. So you can park in the streets or pay to park in visitors. But you already pay for your permit so you don't want to pay again. Or you might be based at the one with a free car park and not have a permit but also a couple of times a year need to attend training elsewhere. One of the permit sites is really tricky to park anywhere other than on site but on site gets full. Pain in the bum. Needs a multistory really but 1. Funding and 2. Where does everybody park while it is being built?

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:12

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

It's ridiculous that something that was working for staff and patients has been turned into expensive private car parks

OP posts:
Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:09

After reading the comments so far, I can see that I am mostly considered TA, I can live with that.
There were some good points raised.

Lots raised that there are no other options, I can sympathise for the most part, still doesn't mean it's not frustrating that you've been at work all day, paid to park at work, and then get home to find no space within a few roads of your house. As someone suggested, you don't have a right to park right outside, and that's fine and expected on let's say a terraced road, but it's not unreasonable to want to find a space.

@Flavabobble it's not much policing as common courtesy, re paying for parking at a workplace, I've only had one workplace not charge for parking, and that's because it was on an industrial estate in the middle of nowhere. I can agree that there shouldn't be charges but since there are, it's something that's part of getting to work.

@AnnaMagnani I'm sorry to hear that, is that still for a paid parking permit? Is there no pay and display available regardless of the permits? I know each trust works differently.

@Raincloudsonasunnyday from my experience (which may be very different to yours) train stations have car parks that are used by those commuting, and for the majority of London there are plenty of buses getting you to tube stations and depending on area there are plenty stations within walking distance. So they should all show consideration, I don't think NHS workers should be exempt from that though. When it comes to school drop offs and pick ups, people park for that for 30mins mostly, not a whole shift.

@Finbrek I guess that depends on the area and what public transport is available. Driving a car to work is not a luxury, but if it's also not unreasonable to pay for parking. You do it wherever you go and don't question is, so why is it different for work (in any industry).

@Saschka my local trust has 5 massive (sizes of a field each) staff car parks and 1 patient pay and display one. 1 overflow car park as well. A lot of the times they are empty, but as @AnnaMagnani mentioned this could be due to permits. As for the parking permit, I have raised it to the council and am waiting for a reply. I know it's a lose lose but it does get irritating after a while.

@lemonsqueezyeasy I very much would, it's strange that the 5 mile rule was created in an area where you can really get to and from work in a timely manner. In London it would absolutely make sense, in a rural area not so much.

@reflecting2023 yes, and? I wanted to hear other people's opinions on this. I'm personally not affected by my local trust as not walking distance, but by people that work in town. If you don't want to participate in the discussion you don't have to.

@kweeble thank you, I'm luckily not affected by my local trust, thread was inspired by many posts that I've seen. I am affected by people who work in the local town centre though. As you said, all these schemes should be encouraged and should run with corresponding shift times, many have said that shuttle buses run 9-5, which seems silly considering the majority of workers don't work that.

@olympicsrock when travelling between sites in work hours shouldn't all expenses associated with that be paid back? Ie you pay the initial parking because you do have to go to work, but if work sends you somewhere else then they should pay.

OP posts:
sltgal · 21/01/2024 22:08

I pay for the privilege of a parking permit at the hospital I work at but often can’t get a space if have been out on community visits and return to the hospital. My car has to be dumped wherever is legal or I would be late for patients waiting in outpatient clinics.

Onemorefortheroad · 21/01/2024 22:07

@innerdesign you can where I can work...
and 🙄 at the SNP comment, I wasn't even thinking politics, just stating facts.

WhollyGlorious · 21/01/2024 22:04

YABU. I don’t work for the NHS and park on a residential street the two days I go to work via train. As I’m allowed to do. I don’t park on permit streets as I’m not allowed as I don’t have a permit.

So long as it’s legal, anyone can park anywhere and no one has a right to be annoyed about it. If parking near your house is THAT important to you, make life changes so you can have a drive, or not live near a major workplace.