Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS parking dilemma

166 replies

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 21:11

Let me preface this that I am grateful to all the NHS workers for their hard work and dedication to their job.

I've wanted to start this thread as I've recently seen numerous debates about this on social media. Oftentimes someone's complaining that NHS workers are parking their cars on residential streets where parking is available at the trust. The post usually has a plethora of comments ranging from those agreeing it's a nuisance to those saying it's reasonable.

I have made a few observations myself, I am aware that they may make me sound like an AH but they seem the most logical to me.

  • if parking is available at the workplace then it should be used (whether free or not)
  • to address expensive parking, almost all workplaces don't offer free parking, doesn't matter what industry. A lot of workers aside from NHS, pay for parking and live.
  • to address antisocial hours, as above, there are other industries that won't necessarily have free parking and have to pay for it
  • the NHS offers good job stability in this day and age (always understaffed so not much chance of losing your job, they need you), fantastic pension, the pay isn't great but also not out of the norm, discounts for on site nurseries etc, overall don't the benefits outweigh the cost of parking?
  • to clarify, I do understand if there's no parking available then absolutely look for an alternative but I find it cheeky to use residential roads when there's ample parking available at some trusts.
  • I can see why people get frustrated with there being no space near their house because of people that work. Now before people say 'buy a house with a drive' it's sometimes not possible, some get house by council and are grateful for what they have, or some that own their house may not be able to afford one with a driveway. It's cheaper to pay for parking at your workplace thank buy a house with a driveway.

So, AITA for thinking that being an NHS worker doesn't exempt you from paying for parking and you should be more considerate to residents in the area?

I hope we can all have a discussion about your views.

OP posts:
TeenLifeMum · 21/01/2024 23:40

@Buniadot parking bands mean band 7 (me on 50k) pay the same as the execs on £100-200k. I’m glad the lower bands pay less but grouping all management together when salaries are so different is hardly fair. That said, I don’t mind paying but I dislike parking 20 minutes away. If my dc is ill I cannot get there with any speed… although, if they’re very very ill, I can walk upstairs and meet them in A&E 😂😬🙈

TeenLifeMum · 21/01/2024 23:36

@overthehill23 £15 a day in my trust 🙈 salary sacrifice for 2 days a week is better but still £28 a month. We had a multi-storey built in addition to 2 other car parks… but now we have built on the 2 staff car parks so reduced parking by 300… and they can’t understand why staff morale is so low. On 1 April parking charges will also increase. Yay. We all feel very valued. (We’re not in a part of the country where public transport is an option - only retired people use them so timings are not for commuters).

Zwicky · 21/01/2024 23:35

You've been lucky to not have to pay for parking at work, I wish that was the case across board and there were adequate car parks in workplaces. Doesn't change the fact that not everyone can afford to live in a house with a driveway, or they live close to the city centre because they work there and can walk to work. So they actually planned out how they would commute

A - I’m not “lucky”. I do pay for parking. Cheaper than public transport but I do pay. The parking isn’t “adequate” although I’m “lucky” enough to start at 7am so I do get a space.

B - I don’t have a house with a driveway. People park in my street too. Not sure why you think they don’t.

C - I couldn’t afford to live within about 5 miles of where I work. Towns are often quite expensive places to live. You can afford to live within walking distance of a hospital. Good for you.

D - I have planned how I commute. I drive.

EddieHowesShithousingMags · 21/01/2024 23:30

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 23:03

That's harsh, are there good transport links in the area? Regardless I can't see how they can justify this policy.

Reasonable links in that it’s a city centre hospital. But it serves a pretty rural community and many of the staff just don’t have the option of getting the bus or train. And tbh, after a 13 hour shift I want to get in my own car and drive straight to my own house and get into my own bed because in less than 11 hours I have to be back on shift. And when I go to work. I don’t want to get up an hour earlier to take the only bus which serves several other villages and takes 50+ minutes to do a 20 minute drive, only comes once an hour and takes me to the bus station in the centre of town which is still a 15 minute walk away.

If I can drive to and from work and park in your street then you can bet I will. I get it’s inconvenient for you. But that’s not my problem.

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 23:20

BungleandGeorge · 21/01/2024 23:17

It’s all irrelevant. If there no parking restrictions on the road anyone can park there. You don’t have any special privileges if you live on the road, you’re paying the same for the use of the road as the rest of the population. Perhaps get rid of your car or pay to park yourself?

I do pay, at work. And we're in the process of advocating for parking permits which I'm more than happy to pay for.

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 21/01/2024 23:17

It’s all irrelevant. If there no parking restrictions on the road anyone can park there. You don’t have any special privileges if you live on the road, you’re paying the same for the use of the road as the rest of the population. Perhaps get rid of your car or pay to park yourself?

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 23:17

MolkosTeenageAngst · 21/01/2024 23:01

If parking is an issue on a street residents should campaign for the council to make it permit only. If that’s not the case then anybody is reasonable to park there for any reason, house prices will reflect the fact the houses don’t include parking. If free residential parking is available within walking distance of course most people aren’t going to pay to park in an expensive private car park. I wouldn’t want to pay parking at work, I’m a teacher and parking in all of my workplaces has always been free. Paying to park at work is also an unfair system where those on low wages end up having to pay a far bigger chunk of their salary to park vs those on high salaries, if you’re a porter or cleaner or canteen worker on little more than minimum wage paying parking fees every day is going to be far more significant than if you’re a top level consultant on a 6 figure salary.

One PP mentioned that their parking charges are based on their salary band, possibly a good solution?
We are in the process of trying to introduce permits, it does take time unfortunately.

OP posts:
Buniadot · 21/01/2024 23:15

overthehill23 · 21/01/2024 22:59

I think if paying for parking it should be the same all over the NHS. I see a person above says there trust is £1.50 a day or £20 a month fair. At my trust if you can't get a parking permit- massive list only about 50% I would say have one. It's £10 a day which is a lot

Absolutely correct, one institution and so many different rules and policies. One PP mentioned theyd face disciplinary action for parking on site.

OP posts:
Buniadot · 21/01/2024 23:13

@MyGooseisTotallyLoose I seem to be very fortunate that there are good parking options wherever I go, the only time I'd stay in a residential road is visiting family but yet again that is with a paid for visitor permit.

OP posts:
Buniadot · 21/01/2024 23:10

@Saschka I'm glad the enforcement is working well, if a bit too eager from your example, it's really a shame that there's still too many cars. At my previous rental we had a limit of 2 cars per household which seemed to work well. Seems the parking situation everywhere is just not moving with the times.

OP posts:
Buniadot · 21/01/2024 23:06

Itsbeginingtolookalotlikexmas · 21/01/2024 22:45

I am NHS staff and park on the road. We have a car park but I’d need to pay and it never has spots. I drive out a few times a day so even if I got to the clinic early I’d still lose my spot when I left to go on a visit. The street I park on has drives and I never block a drive or park inconsiderately, however, the local residents hate us. We hide our NHS badges when we park. I’ve been shouted at a few times.

That's antisocial behaviour and you absolutely shouldn't get the abuse. I think my trust is a unicorn trust looking as all comments so far. Employers should also cover your expenses (ie parking) when travelling between sites.

OP posts:
Buniadot · 21/01/2024 23:04

innerdesign · 21/01/2024 22:38

@Buniadot Never said NHS specific are the problem.

You might want to check your thread title and OP...

Probably should have made myself clearer. For that I do apologise, I think it's a problem across many industries. The thread was inspired by posts about NHS workers in particular.

OP posts:
Buniadot · 21/01/2024 23:03

EddieHowesShithousingMags · 21/01/2024 22:37

We’re not allowed to park on-site at our city centre hospital. Being caught parking on site means potential disciplinary action. So that’s nice.

That's harsh, are there good transport links in the area? Regardless I can't see how they can justify this policy.

OP posts:
MolkosTeenageAngst · 21/01/2024 23:01

If parking is an issue on a street residents should campaign for the council to make it permit only. If that’s not the case then anybody is reasonable to park there for any reason, house prices will reflect the fact the houses don’t include parking. If free residential parking is available within walking distance of course most people aren’t going to pay to park in an expensive private car park. I wouldn’t want to pay parking at work, I’m a teacher and parking in all of my workplaces has always been free. Paying to park at work is also an unfair system where those on low wages end up having to pay a far bigger chunk of their salary to park vs those on high salaries, if you’re a porter or cleaner or canteen worker on little more than minimum wage paying parking fees every day is going to be far more significant than if you’re a top level consultant on a 6 figure salary.

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 23:00

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 21/01/2024 22:34

Hopelessly naive, but I genuinely think that all parking should be free.

The Trafford Centre manage it. Brent Cross manage it. Yet somehow when I park in town it's £8 for 3 hours?!

Liverpool Women's Hospital used to be £2 on exit, so affordable even if they were there for days. Now it's a 'normal' hourly rate. Why can't it be standardised across all sites to be like this?

Aintree hospital had free parking during Covid. Now it's back to normal.

(some of that possibly irrelevant but just wanted to say that it should ALL be free!)

Brent Cross has fantastic parking, I agree. And in an ideal world I'd love free parking everywhere. It's a shame that's not possible.

OP posts:
Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:59

@innerdesign to each their own

OP posts:
overthehill23 · 21/01/2024 22:59

I think if paying for parking it should be the same all over the NHS. I see a person above says there trust is £1.50 a day or £20 a month fair. At my trust if you can't get a parking permit- massive list only about 50% I would say have one. It's £10 a day which is a lot

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:57

TeenLifeMum · 21/01/2024 22:30

@Buniadot so my main base has 2500 employees and 400 parking spaces. It’s done on where you live etc. technically I shouldn’t be given any parking as I can walk to work. It’s a 45 minute walk and I often have to go to meetings at other locations so a 45 minute walk really isn’t a good use of my work time.

I’m not sure we massively mind paying, but often we’re simply not allowed to park on site.

Thank you for the insight, I do think that individual circumstances should be a factor in permit decisions (ie you have to travel during work, so need your car to do that, or some don't have public transport available for shift times, out of hours permits etc)

Overall it's strange that hospitals and town centres without parking haven't rethought the parking structures. You only really see multi storey car parks next to shopping centres but should ideally have more independent ones.

OP posts:
daffodilandtulip · 21/01/2024 22:56

It's much the same as those complaining about the school/church/railway that was likely there before they moved in.

If it's legal, it's legal.

GreatGateauxsby · 21/01/2024 22:55

missmollygreen · 21/01/2024 21:13

Yes, YATA
Anyone can park on public roads.
BUT.... staff parking in hospitals should be free

Agreed.

The parking costs at my hospital piss me off and I make 6 figures and am "only" visiting 2 X per week on a short term basis.

I can't even imagine how hacked off I'd be if I was working long shifts, dealing with the moronic general public and making £30/40k a year

Medstudent12 · 21/01/2024 22:54

And just to add I never park inconsiderately. I never park over drives or block kerbs, I just park further away. As I don't want to annoy people but also if you park inconsiderately then you might get car keyed!

Maybe the OP should think about how I felt finishing as a 26 year old A&E doctor and having to walk to my car in early hours of morning in unsafe residential areas as I was not eligible for hospital parking. What else should we do? Not drive and get a taxi 30 miles home at 3am.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 21/01/2024 22:54

Cincinnatus · 21/01/2024 21:14

If they can legally park on a residential street then they have every right to do that. They can park where they like as long as it’s legal.
Doesn’t really matter about how the residents feel about it.

I’m not saying it’s right or wrong as I don’t really care either way.

Absolutely. @Buniadot can you say you never ever park anywhere not your home or commercial/paid for parking?

BatteryPowerGnat · 21/01/2024 22:52

Many NHS staff work shifts/unsociable hours when public transport might not be running.
Some staff are on call - they remain at home during this time but when they are called in it could be 4am. No choice but to drive or pay for a taxi (which won't be reimbursed).

Saschka · 21/01/2024 22:52

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:42

I do and I have, also working unsociable hours.
Parking on my road isn't cause by my local trust, but by people working in town. The whole point was that most people have to pay for parking when they go to work. And those that use residential streets (from any industry) instead of available car parks are inconsiderate.

You asked what my problem was, I guess it's the fact that I go to work and pay for parking instead of being a nuisance to residents to then get home and not be able to park in a reasonable distance because of others who don't extend the courtesy.

We have residents parking and shit-hot enforcement (they towed my car despite me having a permit). And you can still never park on our road, unless you are sitting poised at 9am for people to leave for work.

There are just too many cars for the number of spaces.

Buniadot · 21/01/2024 22:50

user1477391263 · 21/01/2024 22:29

The problem with people being allowed to park on residential streets is this: people understandably don’t want to live in traffic sewers, and avoid living in areas near schools….or hospitals… or daycare nurseries….or stations…or…. (“Well, surely you knew what it would be like, living near an XYZ? That’s why I chose an estate further out of town!”)

The system is therefore literally punishing people who live near facilities that they might like to use themselves, and rewarding those who live further away….which then encourages more sprawl and pushes everyone to drive more and more for their everyday needs.

Vicious circle.

To get out of this trap, British cities need to start off by doing something about parking, but the transition is likely to be painful, because it requires unpicking several decades of urban development.

Edited

You are completely right, when buying our house we took into consideration the fact that 3 out of 4 of us can walk to work (I pay for parking at job #1 and walk to job #2), nursery is within walking distance, we have one car in a household of 4 driving adults and car share as to not cause inconvenience to our neighbours. If everyone thought a bit about others and actually planned ahead a bit there would be less of an issue.

You are correct though in terms of councils doing more to help. Multi storey car parks are the norm in Europe, they should be here as well.

OP posts: