Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH often suppresses a laugh when I'm being serious

187 replies

Anonin · 21/01/2024 21:05

Hello,

Maybe I'm overtired and touchy, but tonight I blew a fuse because DH suppressed a laugh when I tried to show him some martial arts movements that I learned as a kid, and not for the first time either. We've been married for more than a decade, and I've never been able to show him the movements in full, because the few times I did, he always laughed and then said that he suddenly thought of something funny which had nothing to do with me.

A few years back I was also very angry, because I was talking about something serious and personal, and he was suppressing a laugh all the way through, and, when I got angry, he said it wasn't me, he just thought of something funny. This happens times and again too, only sometimes I just let it go, but sometimes I was extremely vexed, depending on my mood.

I find this so childish. He made me feel ridiculous and regret confiding something I cherish with him. I believe him when he said that he wasn't making fun of me, but I'm furious that he cannot control himself to behave like a normal person would when others are being earnest. Particularly when I was talking passionately, this would be a moment that he often thought of "something funny". DH doesn't have friends, was bullied at school, and his siblings are all the same.

DH helped a lot with the baby, so I can't say he's a bad spouse, but tonight I feel so resentful that I almost wanted to book a plane ticket for me and my baby to my dad's place and leave him alone for a while.

AIBU? What would you do in my position?

OP posts:
StrongasSixpence · 22/01/2024 14:31

Then why take the piss out of OP for engaging with her cultural heritage?

janeintheframe · 22/01/2024 14:15

StrongasSixpence · 22/01/2024 13:38

Posts like this are explicitly racist. Mocking something you have zero clue about outside of a Carl Douglas song.

Yes Shaolin is kung-fu (or wushu). No its not something to therefore laugh at or be inherently comical. It's a cultural and spiritual tradition with a long history in China and other parts of the world. Important enough to Chinese culture that it was brutally suppressed during the Cultural Revolution.

There are many different schools, ways and traditions relating to different regions and masters. It's very normal to have particular teachings going down families and OP would have to have been very good to be invited to demonstrate at her school in China.

You don’t know my ethnicity and are barking up the wrong tree.

Geraldneedsasecondclassstamp · 22/01/2024 13:42

@Anonin

You're a good sport OP x

Bumblebeestiltskin · 22/01/2024 13:40

Potatohigh · 21/01/2024 22:04

A part of you?

I'm going to bow out now because I think in your Ernestness your missing lots of the context of how this is practiced. this completely screams of mu grandad had a gap year 60 years ago and we consider ourselves cultural experts 3 generations later despite us all having no connection with anyone else

Yes, absolutely this

StrongasSixpence · 22/01/2024 13:38

janeintheframe · 21/01/2024 21:56

Is shaolin , kung fu? Were you pulling fighter poses in the lounge?

Posts like this are explicitly racist. Mocking something you have zero clue about outside of a Carl Douglas song.

Yes Shaolin is kung-fu (or wushu). No its not something to therefore laugh at or be inherently comical. It's a cultural and spiritual tradition with a long history in China and other parts of the world. Important enough to Chinese culture that it was brutally suppressed during the Cultural Revolution.

There are many different schools, ways and traditions relating to different regions and masters. It's very normal to have particular teachings going down families and OP would have to have been very good to be invited to demonstrate at her school in China.

Anonin · 22/01/2024 13:33

@Ktime Perhaps, but at first I think it's just beside the point, since my post is about DH sniggering often when I talk about or do something I'm passionate about. The martial arts is just an example. That the majority of MN community going bonkers just bc of that example wasn't something I could have predicted 😁, but then we learn something new every day.

OP posts:
Ktime · 22/01/2024 13:27

Anonin · 22/01/2024 09:35

@NewbieSM I am ethnically Chinese growing up in Southeast Asia. I didn't explain eveeything in my posts (too long), but there aren't classes around here that teach these moves. When I was in SEA I did take extra classes, and bc the moves my dad taught me was considered unique, I was often asked to exhibit it at school. But I moved to Europe after high school, and just practiced it myself since.

It's unfortunate I cited the martial arts example, right? I did bc it was the most recent example. Some kind users told me to delete the post, but I'll just let it be, I'm used to be laughed at 😄.

DH always apologised profusely, and he does help a lot around the house and with the baby, but sometimes he just ticked me off.

This should have been in your Op.

A white person going to SE Asia to learn martial arts is going to bring up memories of Karate Kid and Kill Bill for people. Entirely different if you’re from the region.

Anonin · 22/01/2024 13:24

financialcareerstuff · 22/01/2024 10:37

Some of the ignorance around more authentic martial arts, and the tradition of them being passed orally through generations, is stunning, and yes, I think the mockery definitely has a racist tinge.

The best equivalent I can think of that people might understand is having specific recipes passed on through generations, for example in Italy. When your great gran spent time in the kitchen with your gran, teaching her as a child. then next generation, then next....Even if you only cook one or two of these dishes occasionally, they are a powerful connection to family, and it matters..... especially if your family moved country, and it is a way of staying connected to the authentic traditions of previous generations.

Having people deride this, and say you should learn to cook properly by going down to the local Dominos pizza joint is ridiculous.

@financialcareerstuff Thanks, excellent example. I couldn't have said it better myself.
Also thanks to others who give reasonable answers. Sorry I can't reply one by one and can only hit the thanks button.

As for the mocking ones, it's very amusing reading them and learning a bit more about our society 😄.

OP posts:
NotQuiteNorma · 22/01/2024 11:39

Could it be Henry, the mild mannered janitor? Could be!!

janeintheframe · 22/01/2024 11:39

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 10:06

Most Scots are quite proud of being Scottish. Imagine that every time you wanted to talk about aspects of being Scottish, your husband started sniggering.
Or another example, imagine you played the bagpipes to a high standard and had learned from ancestors now deceased. You now want to tell your child about this aspect of your heritage but your husband keeps sniggering.

People are deliberately misunderstanding the OP and that is racist.

I don’t agree with you at all. Talking about bagpipes and laughing, not ok. Someone gets the bagpipes out and gives a rendition in their living room, and the other person laughs, highly likely it’s a bit squeaky and comical. Even if you once played to a high standard as a kid.

some things just are funny. My husband is Scottish, if he got the bag pipes out as he used to play as a kid there is every chance I’d laugh.

i very much doubt her husband is a racist. But she can clarify that.

FarmGirl78 · 22/01/2024 11:36

You've said that in addition to this he also made you angry "a few years back". If the last thing he to make you angry was a few years ago I think most people on the planet who are in a relationship would gladly trade places with you.

ADoggyDogWorld · 22/01/2024 11:22

EmmaEmerald · 22/01/2024 11:07

“The fact that this also holds ethnic and cultural significance due to your heritage changes things”

actually even if you remove this factor

the post says “my husband repeatedly laughs when I tell him about things that are important to me”. Which is awful.

decent people don’t even need the added context. Tbh I pulled it out because someone said “cultural appropriation” which is my biggest eye roll.

I am British btw but a lot of people don’t accept that on account of my skin colour.

Edited

Such a good post.

People will ignore in favour of poking fun at a woman who is mocked when she tries to talk to her husband about things that are important to her.

Carry on poking fun, people, if you don't care that your racism is showing.

EmmaEmerald · 22/01/2024 11:07

“The fact that this also holds ethnic and cultural significance due to your heritage changes things”

actually even if you remove this factor

the post says “my husband repeatedly laughs when I tell him about things that are important to me”. Which is awful.

decent people don’t even need the added context. Tbh I pulled it out because someone said “cultural appropriation” which is my biggest eye roll.

I am British btw but a lot of people don’t accept that on account of my skin colour.

Fitandfree · 22/01/2024 11:07

I find it hard to be serious when I perceive people to be overly ernest or passionate OP. Expecting your DH to sit and watch your martial art, in the living room is asking for a snigger. You sound very intense and ernest - I suspect that is what makes him chuckle rather than the content of your academic work. I wouldn't drag out my dissertation and expect someone, with no knowledge of my field, to put up with me passionately discussing it. I'd expect them to glaze over very quickly. It sounds like he's trying to pay attention, but it's too much. There's no reason you can't pass on your skills to your DC, just don't try to force it on your DH. In defence of PP your OP did you no favours, and didn't explain the skill level of your DGF and DF. I doubt your DH is deliberately trying to belittle you. Does he suffer from social anxiety?

NewbieSM · 22/01/2024 10:38

Apologies @Anonin I was wrong in my earlier post so I'm sorry for that.

The fact that this also holds ethnic and cultural significance due to your heritage changes things. Your husband laughing at you while you practice is shitty and demeaning. And it's also racist. Just like a lot of the posts on here.

I think your initial post weren't clear and you would have got different responses had we all understood better.

Not all racism is hate and violence, the most insidious kind is the casual "joking" kind where you are made to feel small and stupid. Like a pet.

From another Chinese woman x

financialcareerstuff · 22/01/2024 10:37

Some of the ignorance around more authentic martial arts, and the tradition of them being passed orally through generations, is stunning, and yes, I think the mockery definitely has a racist tinge.

The best equivalent I can think of that people might understand is having specific recipes passed on through generations, for example in Italy. When your great gran spent time in the kitchen with your gran, teaching her as a child. then next generation, then next....Even if you only cook one or two of these dishes occasionally, they are a powerful connection to family, and it matters..... especially if your family moved country, and it is a way of staying connected to the authentic traditions of previous generations.

Having people deride this, and say you should learn to cook properly by going down to the local Dominos pizza joint is ridiculous.

baldpenguine · 22/01/2024 10:34

WhichEllie · 22/01/2024 00:31

Oh ffs. Clearly the 12 year olds and the illiterates are out in force on MN today.

@Anonin , if you want real responses ask MN to delete this thread and then post a new one. Don’t mention the martial arts example. Use the example of him mocking/laughing at your doctoral dissertation and perhaps another one or two examples relating to him mocking you when you try to raise serious topics. You’ll receive MUCH more relevant replies.

Personally I wouldn’t be with someone that had no respect for me. I suspect he doesn’t respect women in general and he will model that lack of respect towards you to your child throughout their childhood.

Oh come on 😂😂😂

If my DH decided to start giving it large in the lounge with some moves his grandad taught him as a child, I'd piss myself

How do you even compliment someone showing you that

It's giving 7 year old performance in the lounge vibes.

Some things are meant to be laughed at.

Redlarge · 22/01/2024 10:20

LightDrizzle · 21/01/2024 22:16

I think it’s unfortunate you led with the martial arts example. I think I would struggle not to giggle. However him smirking when you are taking about other things, like your doctoral thesis does sound very off.

Does he show interest and admiration of your (non martial arts) interests and achievements at other times? Getting a doctorate is a fabulous achievement and it sounds like a topic that would be of common interest, not something really impenetrable and arcane.

This. Hes trying to belittle your interests and achievements. Its to make you feel like a silly little girl.

Redlarge · 22/01/2024 10:18

My ex used to smirk when i was talking to him about interests/work or anything that was important to me.
He was a complete (and still is) narcissist with a god complex.

Geraldneedsasecondclassstamp · 22/01/2024 10:17

@ShoePalaver

Are you Scottish? Most Scottish people have a good dose of self-depreciation about them.

If you bust out the childhood talent show skills all po-faced, expect a few giggles. OP can lighten up and have fun with it. Laugh along instead of trying to win her husband over with continued serious displays of kung-fu. People are more interested in things if they are approached in a lighthearted manner.

Christ, sit me down and insist I watch with straight face and somber respect while you shuffle and jump about the living room? I will piss myself laughing. Have some fun with it, get husband and toddler up to join in, laugh along with them, and everyone will have some fun.

You don't have to panic because OP has revealed she's Chinese. This thread would have the same responses if a Scottish woman said they'd given their husband a display of their childhood highland dancing classes.

financialcareerstuff · 22/01/2024 10:15

OP, I hope you are still reading and might reply.

I think you are right - you framed this wrong and unfortunately it's somewhat reproduced what you are getting upset about. As you'll know, a lot of people, with no linked cultural heritage, reckon they can do some martial arts, wiggle their legs around a bit, and look ridiculous- you even see this comical scene reproduced in films.....so I think that's what most people were imagining.

I think your post should probably have read... "my DH laughs at me when I share things that feel sacred or meaningful, including those related to my cultural identity. It really upsets me."

I think the responses would have been very different.

That's not ok. And to me, it sounds like your DH has an issue. If it's consistently your Chinese heritage that he laughs about, perhaps there is some fundamental disrespect there (even if he has shared heritage, some people may want to distance themselves from this). Or, it could be that he has built up an unconscious defense against certain kinds of intimacy- he doesn't even know he's doing it, but he has to disconnect himself and does so by laughing. The other theme I see is that your two examples are around your specialness/skill.,,, does that discomfit him and he feels a need to undermine anything that might contribute build your self esteem... or he can't take the idea of a woman who has skills he doesn't have?

From any angle, I think it's concerning....

MasterBeth · 22/01/2024 10:13

Jibo · 22/01/2024 08:51

OP is your husband British and are you from a different culture?

I do think we have a strong cultural habit in the UK of not taking ourselves/things in general seriously. You sound very earnest and many Brits find earnestness either cringey/awkward or amusing. And we tend to use humour/laughter to cover awkwardness as well.

Yes. I was just going to post something like this.

"Taking ourselves too seriously" is a cultural no-no. At its best, it's a good protection against pretension. At its worst, it's why we ended up with someone as unserious as Boris Johnson as PM.

(And, as others have pointed out, pointing out the earnestness of other cultures or races is a particularly unsavoury trait, if done disrespectfully.)

Deathbyathousandcats · 22/01/2024 10:07

Sounds like he's uncomfortable with serious topics. It probably stems from childhood bullying or an abusive parent. Laughing when uncomfortable is what toddlers do. He obviously has not progressed beyond that developmental stage.

Here come the armchair MN therapists, right on cue

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 10:07

TheDandyLion · 22/01/2024 09:55

I'd probably try to hide a laugh too. It sounds a bit like when kids try to show off a dance routine or put on a show for their parents in the living room.

If he's laughing when you are trying to have a serious conversation or when you're expressing your frustration or anger at something and you're expecting him to show support, then I would be annoyed if he laughed at that.

But that's exactly what it is? It's there in the very first post! Why can people not understand what they are reading, it's so strange

ShoePalaver · 22/01/2024 10:06

Geraldneedsasecondclassstamp · 22/01/2024 10:01

@EmmaEmerald

I thought it was clear from OP posts

so posters are fine with singing Hong Kong Phooey at her. The racism is meant to be all good fun. Nice.

OP has only just declared that she is Chinese. And for a bit of balance here, I'm Scottish but if I whipped out the highland dance moves I remember from when I was a child my husband would also rightly piss himself and we'd have a laugh about it.

Most Scots are quite proud of being Scottish. Imagine that every time you wanted to talk about aspects of being Scottish, your husband started sniggering.
Or another example, imagine you played the bagpipes to a high standard and had learned from ancestors now deceased. You now want to tell your child about this aspect of your heritage but your husband keeps sniggering.

People are deliberately misunderstanding the OP and that is racist.

Swipe left for the next trending thread