Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he’s choosing to be homeless and it’s right that he doesn’t get a housing association property?

288 replies

Casparr · 21/01/2024 18:28

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-68033982

Man works 50hrs a week. At minimum wage that’s 27k and about £1900 take-home each month. He sleeps at friends’ houses or his ex-partner’s, presumably for free. Why can’t he just get a room in a house share (under £600 a month in Glasgow) and save up a deposit for a flat?

Daniel Thomson

I'm working but homeless and bottom of the housing list

A working father finds himself "sofa surfing" amid social housing shortages in Scotland's biggest city.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-68033982

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 20:00

Question for you all. If you were the ex would you be happy with him taking the kid to the HMO?

Iwasafool · 21/01/2024 20:00

Casparr · 21/01/2024 19:06

I'm not really sure the point of these articles anymore

Same. As an able-bodied young man with full-time employment and no dependents, it’s right that he’s at the bottom of the housing list. I don’t know what the BBC is trying to demonstrate or why anyone would be shocked or surprised.

What has being a man got to do with it? Would a woman get more sympathy?

Stressedafff · 21/01/2024 19:59

Private renting is nigh on impossible
Landlords want a deposit, a homeowner guarantor earning over £45k per year
These HMO’s are also often used by the councils for homeless people, some with personal issues.
Why are people more annoyed that someone maybe does not want to live in a HMO, paying £800 for one room and shared facilities, than the fact the government have refused to build affordable housing and allowed greedy private landlords and their mortgage providers to terrorise the rental market and make even having a home absolutely impossible

Britinme · 21/01/2024 19:58

My 45 year old autistic son is currently unemployed, homeless and sleeping in the back of his van. He's in the south-east. He was in a flat but his landlord is selling up and evicted him. His former flat was the cheapest in the area (I checked) and comparable places are 25-30% more. He's behind on his council tax, has no credit score, and can't even find a room in a house share because of a) no job and b) no credit. Can he get on the list for council housing? Can he heck as like. He's staying cheerful at the moment, and haunting the public library to apply for jobs and charge his phone. He gets UC and PIP and if he could get a room in a shared house could just about afford that. The housing situation is just dire. I don't live in the UK and he wouldn't be allowed to come and live with me for anything more than a holiday.

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 19:58

IT WAS AVAILABLE TO EVERYONE WHETHER THEY COULD AFFORD THE ALTERNATIVES OR NOT

StrawberryShortbread2001 · 21/01/2024 19:57

Nonomono · 21/01/2024 19:07

YABVU

You obviously live a very privileged lifestyle and have no clue how difficult it is for some people.

This man is working 50 hours a week and cannot find affordable housing.
There are thousands of people like him in his situation.

When I was looking for homes to rent it was very difficult trying to save up the money to get a deposit and then most landlords didn’t want to know as they wanted someone with a much higher income or 2 incomes.

Would you rather he gave up his job and just rely on benefits?

And where would that get him? He won't be housed because he's on benefits.

StrawberryShortbread2001 · 21/01/2024 19:56

BubbleBubbleBubbleBubblePop · 21/01/2024 19:06

If you "don't know Glasgow well", then don't comment. Do you know how hard it is in Glasgow for a non student to get a houseshare at a decent rent? I do. Very, very, very hard. So many people are competing for spaces.

This man works and contributes towards society. I think he should be high up on the list of people who should get a council property - he is after all, paying towards them off his taxes.

What a sad state of affairs. And what a nasty post this is.

But there's so many other people who are contributing who have children or people who aren't but are vulnerable (disabled, unwell).

soupfiend · 21/01/2024 19:55

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 19:54

@soupfiend This is your post from page 3

I largely agree with what you've been saying except that in my view, there is the money to embark on a mass building of social housing and that housing should be for people who cant afford or cant access (for all sorts of reasons) the private rental market and ownership

Just like in the 50s

There is no political will for it, thats all

It WASNT like that in the 50s It was available to anyone who wanted it

Yes it was. Where have I said it wasnt?

soupfiend · 21/01/2024 19:54

Just looking on spareroom.com in the city centre, there are 55 rooms if you specify professionals, which seems to weed out student only accommodation. They hover around the 700pcm mark

They include bills, he wouldnt have council tax to pay in an HMO

Not great, but doable. He can save for a deposit if he is not currently paying rent because he is sofa surfing.

Might be cheaper further out of Glasgow, not sure where he works

VisiblyNot25 · 21/01/2024 19:54

You sound unbelievably judgemental. It says in the article his brother was also homeless so he clearly doesn’t have the family safety net mang of us take for granted.

The state of housing should be constantly at the top of the news agenda, in my opinion. It’s a national disgrace & i imagine the aim of articles like this is to try & humanise the problem.

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 19:54

@soupfiend This is your post from page 3

I largely agree with what you've been saying except that in my view, there is the money to embark on a mass building of social housing and that housing should be for people who cant afford or cant access (for all sorts of reasons) the private rental market and ownership

Just like in the 50s

There is no political will for it, thats all

It WASNT like that in the 50s It was available to anyone who wanted it

Shadowsindarkplaces · 21/01/2024 19:54

Don't know the situation in that area but down south you may be able to afford rent but landlords want min 6 months in advance, guarantors, and accept higher 'bids' for even the lowest standard rent of room/ share/ bedsit/ flats.

soupfiend · 21/01/2024 19:51

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 19:45

@soupfiend social housing was council housing back then and was available to anyone who wanted it

Yes thats right. Where did I say it wasnt?

soupfiend · 21/01/2024 19:50

ladyvimes · 21/01/2024 19:42

Surely the point is that someone working 50hours a week should be able to afford to rent at least a one bed flat but rentals and house prices are so ridiculously high that for many this is impossible. I live in a naice area where lots of houses are currently being built. Barely, if any of this will be affordable housing. Council house waiting lists are 9yrs + here. I honestly don’t know how some people manage.

Even 'affordable' housing isnt really affordable, the prices are incredible, you pay the mortgage bit, then you pay rent on the rest and then on top of that you pay service charge for the rental bit.

Expensive.

StrawberryShortbread2001 · 21/01/2024 19:50

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 21/01/2024 18:46

He does have a dependant. Rents are incredibly expensive now. A two bed flat ( so he can have his daughter stay) can be completely out of reach for people working full time jobs. 1k+ rent plus bills, ct, commuting costs and food plus maintenance. The sums just don’t add up. We should definitely be investing in social housing rather than propping up high rents via uc.

He doesn't need a 2 bed. He can either have his Dd's bed in his room or he sleeps in the sitting room and she has the bedroom.

AgnesX · 21/01/2024 19:48

50 hours a week at NMW is a lot of hours and a pathetic wage.

That all said, it's his choice and even in Glasgow his options will be limited.

BobbyBiscuits · 21/01/2024 19:48

Do you have something against him personally? Is he your ex? If not why do you care?

StrawberryShortbread2001 · 21/01/2024 19:45

The council wouldn't help my niece when she was homeless. She had been in a mother and baby foster placement due to a mental breakdown. Her baby was subsequently taken from her which made her homeless. She was a 20yo young woman, seriously mentally unwell, she'd previously been a LAC herself. According to the council she wasn't vulnerable.

My friend's husband has recently died and they were made homeless by her landlord, luckily she has been put in a homeless hostel. It's one room for her and her 2 DC 16 and 18. If it wasn't for the 16yo being at college they would have been on the streets.

So while I agree there should be secure and safe housing for all, in the current climate there are so many people more in need than him.

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 19:45

@soupfiend social housing was council housing back then and was available to anyone who wanted it

alpenguin · 21/01/2024 19:44

NotMyFirstChoiceofName · 21/01/2024 19:02

Someone who takes home £1,900 / month should able to rent a small place in Glasgow. I suspect we are not getting the full story here.

Should but the reality is it’s like a rental frenzy in Glasgow and landlords are looking for ridiculous rents and deposits and references and guarantors. I know of a very well off woman who studied a year in Glasgow and nobody would rent to her due to lack of references, so she ended up in halls of residence with people the same age as her grandchildren.

Places advertised are often taken by the time you call to find out about them. The situation in Glasgow is awful.

AS for flat share - the same issues exist.

I’m not saying there aren’t other reasons in his instance but it’s extremely difficult in Glasgow right now trying to find affordable housing.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 21/01/2024 19:44

socialdilemmawhattodo · 21/01/2024 19:19

I agree with you. I had no idea about the UC top ups for rent until a colleague's young adult son got his equally young adult g/f pregnant a few years ago. They at the time moved into a flat in a not very nice town in the SE. He was a student at uni, she had been but dropped out. Universal credit was paying them approx £900 per month for housing. I was horrified - that comes directly from taxpayers. His mum was also shocked - single parents, we both worked in steady but low paid jobs. So his family and hers helped out with temporary accommodation for a time but when the baby came they moved into this privately owned and rented flat. (No criticism of the landlord - they are allowed to own and rent out property). 2 young adults - aged 18-20 who have contributed nothing to society. He couldnt be bothered to wear a condom and the tax payer funds over £10k pa. And that wasn't the whole claim. They are no longer together. This has to be stopped. I do not wish to fund this. And what is the cost per house to build on an estate where hopefully the brownfield site is already owned by council or govt? It must be less even looking at a 10-year payback.

I’d agree with you I own so no real skin in the game but colleagues I work with are single parents working full time getting UC to pay high rental costs. It makes no sense to me for the taxpayer to pay 12k a year to a private landlord for 18 years+ Surely they could build houses/ flats for less and they would have an asset.

Casparr · 21/01/2024 19:44

Nonomono · 21/01/2024 19:27

Exactly!

OP obviously has no idea what it’s like in the real world and can probably borrow from the bank of mummy and daddy whenever she feels like it.

Not true at all, I‘ve lived independently since I was sixteen. I’ve lived in some dreadful house-shares with some dreadful people, and stay there saving up for a decade until I had enough to buy a tiny one-bed flat. It never crossed my mind to go on a housing list, as a healthy and single young adult.

In my view, housing association and council properties are for those who need them, not those who’d like to pay less rent.

OP posts:
soupfiend · 21/01/2024 19:44

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 19:35

Luckily authors like John Boughton are about to stop you trying to rewrite history

John Boughton (author of Municipal Dreams The Rise and Fall of Council Housing) on the welfarisation of council housing.

//www.insidehousing.co.uk/insight/the-rise-and-fall-of-council-housing-56139

Inthe 1980s, residualisation may have been a partly unintended consequence of housing policies pursued with varying ideological intent

Since 2010, and more so since the return of single-party Conservative government in 2015, we’ve seen something further: welfarisation – ‘a conception of social housing as a very small, highly residualised sector catering only for the very poorest, and those with additional social “vulnerabilities”, on a short-term “ambulance” basis

I have no idea what history you think Im re writing. What a bizarre and quite aggressive post.

Gillypie23 · 21/01/2024 19:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ohdojustfuckoff · 21/01/2024 19:42

OK, presuming that the renting situation isn't particularly different to here.
I know a few Landlords of HMOs, they'll let someone view, they'll say they have kids, but the kids won't be staying. Next thing they know, kid is staying at weekends. There are either complaints, or they are aware that a child is there and it's murky with their insurances, or they just feel uncomfortable- and responsible. At that point, they give notice- but the persons joined the council list and it takes months and months, and months! To get them out. So this is probably why he isn't in a HMO.

Privately renting a flat? Yes an option, but he needs fairly good credit, and pass affordability. Then he also needs to seem like the best candidate from the LLs perspective.
LLs might prefer a couple,
LLs might prefer a "professional"
LLs might prefer someone without a child
LLs may just prefer someone who makes 10k more a year.
LLs may prefer someone who's turned up with a 6 month deposit- as has been referenced on MN a few times, people have had to do it because its so tough to get chosen.
In some areas of the country there are up to 50 people showing interest in any private rental that comes up.

There is talk of us having a housing crisis for a reason.