Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think he’s choosing to be homeless and it’s right that he doesn’t get a housing association property?

288 replies

Casparr · 21/01/2024 18:28

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-68033982

Man works 50hrs a week. At minimum wage that’s 27k and about £1900 take-home each month. He sleeps at friends’ houses or his ex-partner’s, presumably for free. Why can’t he just get a room in a house share (under £600 a month in Glasgow) and save up a deposit for a flat?

Daniel Thomson

I'm working but homeless and bottom of the housing list

A working father finds himself "sofa surfing" amid social housing shortages in Scotland's biggest city.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-glasgow-west-68033982

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Timetodownsize · 21/01/2024 20:25

To reiterate what others have said - the rental market in Glasgow is extremely difficult. Increasing bureaucracy and restrictions mean many private landlords are leaving the sector meaning more people are chasing a diminishing pool of rental properties.

soupfiend · 21/01/2024 20:24

Iwasafool · 21/01/2024 20:03

I don't think the 50s was the same everywhere. In my city my parents couldn't get a council property in the 50s. They had me and my sibling in cots in their room at my grans house. Gran slept on a sofa and aunt and uncle shared the other bedroom. They were told they weren't a priority as they had a roof over their heads.

Edited

Possibly, but the point is that the government of the day recognised the need for good quality housing, with agreed standards, (long gone) for anyone that didnt want to engage with ownership or private rentals or couldnt

That part of the market is now non existent, a solely private market has failed.

Also, something that has long been forgotten is that my parents got a mortgage through the council, they couldnt get a bank to lend them a mortgage. We dont do that any more, is that something that should be brought back....

SnowflakeSparkles · 21/01/2024 20:23

Travis1 · 21/01/2024 20:15

How do you look at this article and see him as the problem?

just for funzies I’ve worked out a mini budget based on this ‘amazing’ £27k salary and a 1 bed flat in East Kilbride and never having his child overnight since according to Op he doesn’t need to bother.

£1821 pay

£270 CMS
£500 rent
£116 ctax
£100 gas/elec
£20 broadband
£13 tv licence
£35 car insurance (benefit of the doubt his car insurance is roughly same as mine)
£270 fuel(assuming one tank of fuel a week gets him to work and back and a 4 week month)
£10 sim only phone
£200 food(assuming a 4 week month)

so on a 4 week month he’ll have approx £300 left assuming he has no debts or anything to pay. 5 week month not even £200.

This flat is also unfurnished so he needs to find furnishing. this doesn’t account for clothing, hair cuts, spending time with his child, Christmas gifts, if anything goes wrong with the car or anything needed replaced in the flat.

its fucking depressing.

That's really true and depressing.

Also consider that these days £200 for a food budget may not be adequate, especially once prices go up in April.

SnowflakeSparkles · 21/01/2024 20:22

and even if his financial circumstances were perfect, PPs are right that he likely wouldn't meet affordability checks.

Crikeyalmighty · 21/01/2024 20:21

we rent nice family homes and have done for 20 years - we have a very long perfect track record, quite high income , absolutely fine credit referencing -but are older so can't get mortgages - but we do keep a lovely home-
we are late 50s/early 60s- even we have twice in the last 8 years been asked for a guarantor- not quite sure who they would suggest!! My 84 year old FIL ?? We just told them to shove it and went elsewhere

SnowflakeSparkles · 21/01/2024 20:21

Casparr · 21/01/2024 18:38

Okay. But do you think he shouldn’t be at the bottom of the housing list, as an able-bodied, relatively young man without dependents?

He does have a dependent.

What about the mother of the child who is obligated to have him in her house despite them not being together because there is no suitable place for her father to facilitate a relationship.

He has parental responsibility, he should be adequately housed to meet that responsibility even if he is not the resident parent. The fair and reasonable way to balance split families is to ensure only one household can claim child related benefits, not to not even give the NRP a home in the first place.

Flatulence · 21/01/2024 20:20

I read this story, and my initial reaction was the same.
You can rent a 1 bed within walking distance of the city centre for £750pcm, giving him the best part of a grand for bills etc. And while I know he has a daughter (meaning an HMO really wouldn't be suitable) there's nothing stopping him sleeping in the lounge of a 1 bed flat and giving her the bedroom.
It's not ideal but it's possible.
HOWEVER, we don't know his full circumstances. I can only assume he has issues such a debt to resolve which affect how much money he actually has each month. It may be also that he is struggling to get a deposit together, or is struggling to pass the affordability checks by letting agents. We just don't know. And to a certain extent it doesn't matter because his story shines a light on how - even if you're in work and working lots of hours - it's not enough for many people to live on.
Rents have gone through the roof (as have mortgages, but the rises there are nothing like as massive as rent increases) and being a single adult is really tough financially - unless you're on a very good salary. There's very few socially rented properties available either, leaving people who are potentially vulnerable or struggling at the mercy of private landlords - some of whom are best described as "slumlords", profiteering from people's misfortune.
It is crazy that 27k, while not a pittance, is barely enough to live on if you're a single adult wanting to live on your own.
I hope he gets himself sorted soon.

Casparr · 21/01/2024 20:20

Crikeyalmighty · 21/01/2024 20:15

This is an incredibly complex issue and the problem is the government have now got it that people are bitching at each other - why should they get social housing, why shouldn't I get a 2 bedder, why should they be higher on the list than me, why are approved asylum seekers seemingly given places- some of the things you read are total fallacy's- designed to push an agenda. The fact is since the 80s the government sold off vastamounts of social housing at ludicrously low rates- and have failed to build enough social housing of all kinds in areas where there is work and facilities. There was a reliance on the private sector but it has all gone wrong as for various reasons landlords are selling up and those that aren't now are in a position to pick and choose and charge whatever they feel like- which is above the rate covered by UC allowances virtually everywhere apart from the cheapest areas- as others have said it's common to ask for guarantors or several months up front and the computerised approval scoring means it's quite strict affordability criteria- even if you have a perfect record- that's why when I see posters saying for people in bad relationships to just leave and rent somewhere- it really isn't that straightforward these days in most areas-

Completely agree! There isn’t enough housing to go around for an ever-increasing population.

OP posts:
Livelovebehappy · 21/01/2024 20:17

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 20:00

Question for you all. If you were the ex would you be happy with him taking the kid to the HMO?

Tbh, far better than sofa surfing or living on the streets. Not ideal obviously, but as he appears to have an ok relationship with his ex, maybe she can facilitate him spending a day a week at hers to see his dc. Meanwhile he can live in his HMO and try and improve his job/salary, or save a bit for a deposit on a private rental.

tachetastic · 21/01/2024 20:17

Iwasafool · 21/01/2024 20:05

Well why do people keep on about a man being homeless, I don't think it makes any difference. It is a terrible situation for any adult to be in.

I think it's possibly because he's a man.

If the article had been about a woman, and people had repeatedly talked about the appalling situation of homeless women that would also have been understandable.

Travis1 · 21/01/2024 20:15

How do you look at this article and see him as the problem?

just for funzies I’ve worked out a mini budget based on this ‘amazing’ £27k salary and a 1 bed flat in East Kilbride and never having his child overnight since according to Op he doesn’t need to bother.

£1821 pay

£270 CMS
£500 rent
£116 ctax
£100 gas/elec
£20 broadband
£13 tv licence
£35 car insurance (benefit of the doubt his car insurance is roughly same as mine)
£270 fuel(assuming one tank of fuel a week gets him to work and back and a 4 week month)
£10 sim only phone
£200 food(assuming a 4 week month)

so on a 4 week month he’ll have approx £300 left assuming he has no debts or anything to pay. 5 week month not even £200.

This flat is also unfurnished so he needs to find furnishing. this doesn’t account for clothing, hair cuts, spending time with his child, Christmas gifts, if anything goes wrong with the car or anything needed replaced in the flat.

its fucking depressing.

Crikeyalmighty · 21/01/2024 20:15

This is an incredibly complex issue and the problem is the government have now got it that people are bitching at each other - why should they get social housing, why shouldn't I get a 2 bedder, why should they be higher on the list than me, why are approved asylum seekers seemingly given places- some of the things you read are total fallacy's- designed to push an agenda. The fact is since the 80s the government sold off vastamounts of social housing at ludicrously low rates- and have failed to build enough social housing of all kinds in areas where there is work and facilities. There was a reliance on the private sector but it has all gone wrong as for various reasons landlords are selling up and those that aren't now are in a position to pick and choose and charge whatever they feel like- which is above the rate covered by UC allowances virtually everywhere apart from the cheapest areas- as others have said it's common to ask for guarantors or several months up front and the computerised approval scoring means it's quite strict affordability criteria- even if you have a perfect record- that's why when I see posters saying for people in bad relationships to just leave and rent somewhere- it really isn't that straightforward these days in most areas-

windyweather2024 · 21/01/2024 20:13

Actual Glaswegian here. Flats are in short supply: landlords selling up because of red tape and eviction laws, massive increase in international and rest of UK student recruitment without enough accommodation, less disposable income/high prices. Flats go within hours of going on the market and need a large deposit, references etc which presumably he doesn't have.

Flatshares often want students (no council tax) or don't want a single man of his age. There's fewer spare rooms, my colleague and I had both to stop renting out ours because the bureaucracy made it impossible.

A lot of the cheaper rentals are on housing estates miles from the city centre with poor public transport especially at night when I guess he'd be finishing.

So the SNP can add housing to their long list of devolved responsibilities to blame Westminster for...

FrippEnos · 21/01/2024 20:10

kinkalli · 21/01/2024 20:00

I agree with you, OP. Something doesn't add up! How can a single man, working 50h a week not find shared accommodation? Even in London this would be possible.

Finding them isn't the issue, as has been explained on here many times, getting to stay in one for many of those reasons is what is difficult.

Casparr · 21/01/2024 20:09

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 20:00

Question for you all. If you were the ex would you be happy with him taking the kid to the HMO?

There are hundreds of thousands of people living in house-shares. I’d bet 95% of them aren’t there because they love communal living. They’re there because it’s what they can afford.

OP posts:
akantar · 21/01/2024 20:07

kinkalli · 21/01/2024 20:00

I agree with you, OP. Something doesn't add up! How can a single man, working 50h a week not find shared accommodation? Even in London this would be possible.

Landlords wanting guarantors. The family next to me between them earn much more than this man and had problems getting a landlord to take them without a guarantor.

PepperIsHere · 21/01/2024 20:07

What a mean post.

Everyone has a human right to shelter. Just because it's become so monetised doesn't make it in any way acceptable for anyone to be homeless.

Of course someone working full-time should be able to afford a home.

Stop buying into Tory claptrap and try to muster a little humanity.

Kpo58 · 21/01/2024 20:06

Dissimilitude · 21/01/2024 19:34

We simply refuse to build enough houses, and every time there's development of any kind, people fall over themselves to object to it for a million different reasons.

We're not a serious country etc.

To be fair many of the objections are reasonable. Building 2000 homes on a floodplain without adding schools/doctors/shops/public transport/etc where none of them are actually affordable for locals (unless it's a microscopic sized home with an unusable tiny back garden) isn't really what the country needs.

Flats near public transport/other amenities with a decent amount of greenery around them could be very good, but noone apparently likes doing maintenance to places like this.

akantar · 21/01/2024 20:05

Newchapterbeckons · 21/01/2024 19:22

I am not sure why he can’t be a lodger and save slowly. This is how the rest of us managed. I feel like these stories are just for headlines. He is a healthy young man, I am sure he will be fine.

Most people who take a lodger want a woman. Very few for young men.

Iwasafool · 21/01/2024 20:05

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 20:02

NO. Since 1998 there have been three tenants in the flat below me. All male No single women because the system always assumes a woman will find a boyfriend to move in with

(i moved in as part of a couple Still am)

Well why do people keep on about a man being homeless, I don't think it makes any difference. It is a terrible situation for any adult to be in.

Iwasafool · 21/01/2024 20:03

soupfiend · 21/01/2024 19:55

Yes it was. Where have I said it wasnt?

I don't think the 50s was the same everywhere. In my city my parents couldn't get a council property in the 50s. They had me and my sibling in cots in their room at my grans house. Gran slept on a sofa and aunt and uncle shared the other bedroom. They were told they weren't a priority as they had a roof over their heads.

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 20:02

Iwasafool · 21/01/2024 20:00

What has being a man got to do with it? Would a woman get more sympathy?

NO. Since 1998 there have been three tenants in the flat below me. All male No single women because the system always assumes a woman will find a boyfriend to move in with

(i moved in as part of a couple Still am)

Stressedafff · 21/01/2024 20:01

JenniferBooth · 21/01/2024 20:00

Question for you all. If you were the ex would you be happy with him taking the kid to the HMO?

Absolutely not. I don’t get why people are so hell bent on people living in HMO’s. I wouldn’t live with strangers and I sure as hell wouldn’t want my kid in a house with a load of them

kinkalli · 21/01/2024 20:00

I agree with you, OP. Something doesn't add up! How can a single man, working 50h a week not find shared accommodation? Even in London this would be possible.

Swipe left for the next trending thread